The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2007, 04-03 Study Session AGENDA CI'f1' Oh SPUKA..YE V_4,LLFY C'ITY COUNCII. V4'URKSIIT.ET tiTLTnY SF;SS[vY 7'aesday. April 3,2007 6:00 p.m. CI'TY FIALL COUNCIL CllAMBERS 11707 East Spragac Avcaue, Fint i'lonr (Ptesse Tara Ofl'.411 E:lertmaic Devlces During tbe LNiecHng) I)ISCiISS1UN I.T.AUti[2 SUQIECT/ACTIVITY GOAI. Dt. I3ClilI1 BCItlCI, Supcrintcndont PropcKal to l`:lose Nrntt L:lemtnutry School Uiscussiunllnformation Dr. Mnrk Andcrsun, Aswciatc SuFxsinte-ndrnl(''0 minutes) 2. Roger 1ohnxm, (nternnfionnl Prescntation and 1_'pdate on I'I'A DiscussicmJlntQtnultion Trndc A[liancc Excxutivc DirccWr (2Q minutcs) 3. lcrty Brady, Jail Commuader Upd,ite nn Spoksnc County Jail Discussianllnformnt.ion ('20 minutcs) 4. kcn Thompson (20 mintilrs) Prk,poscJ Amended 2007 Budget Discu~tiori/Infurmation S. Cary• Qriskcll (15 minuces ) Ameadmcnt t4 Animal Contrnl Ordinancc Discussionllnformnl ion 6. Cnry Driskrll (15 minuteti 1 Etevised Lo$U Ocdittiincr Discus;in1i`In1~0rnIatir►n f. Cnuncilmcmhcr [)enc:nny I:oundational C'«ncepts,'N1anaggcd Imptemcntation Discussionllnformatiun (15 minutes) Plan, Dissolved Urygcn'I'MUL fur the Spokana Rivcc 8. Mayor W iiliite .Advurce Agendn Additiatu Discussicm/Informsiion 9 lnformnliorl C)nlti: -/e dvemie 1'ayh►ruti, Fnojcct rt,lill nor be discus5ed) 10. 1ta+ur W'ilhite ('ouncil C'hrck in IaisLiutiic,Winf6rma[iun 11. i):tvrNtercier City Manas;cr Coinri7cnU Dis-cus~ioir7nf~irrriation AllJOURN ,Vute: Gn{crs otherwtso aoted abovc, tberc witl be no public commcnts at Cuancil Study Seaslom Ilawevcr, Couacil alxYys resenvs the rig6t to requeat laturmadon lrom tha public aad stntf ax upproprinta Uttring mettings hclsl 6y tho Ci!}' of Spoknnc Vnlley Cvuncil, thc Cuustcil resctves 4ic rigtil to tpkc "actinn" on any item listeif or suEsfequently nddcd tv thc agenda. The tcrm "action' means to daliberatn, diseuss, revitw. cQmqiclcr, evaluate, cu make a rollrctivc positive or ncgntivc decisiaa MOTtCE: 1,Wcvidunls plewing t, anauf tha rtuaing wt,o requtre special assiaanoe roscrnmmal*r physirat, fcsrin& r,r otha impairtnmrts. Dlczc cnnfan the City C1ak sl (Sl?9) 921-1000 n sonn +a pms's6k io tlu: arranrrrrr_nr rttrcr be r,:ade lr ~si n •i~rn~.t. 1(in~ i i a~!s I~C E CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY Request for Council Action ` . . Meeting Date: 04-03-07 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent ❑ old business ❑ new business ❑ public hearing ❑ information Z admin. report ❑ pending legislation AGENDA ITEM TITLE : Spokane School District No. 81 Presentation BACKGROUND: Dr. Brian Benzel, School Superintendent, and Dr. Mark E. Anderson, Associate Superintendent, have been invited to discuss the proposal to close Pratt Elementary School. STAFF CONTACT: ' ATTACHMENTS PowerPoint ; School Closure and Consolidation Study ' 1 5~xkd ~ PONIL Fratt Elementar,yo Closure Stu4 H1gI1 llghtS ~ i~ hfarch 21, 2007 FaCtS... • Since 1998 the schaol ai;irict has lcst approximately 1,800 alementary age stucfenfs. • Triis dec/ine has averaged 225 alementary students per year. • 1. 800 fewer students repr+esent the populaUon of four elementary schools. , • A projecfed enroilment decMe of 350 siudenfs for the 2007-2008 school yaar represents a loss of 'r8venue totaling 31.6 million. ~ ~ . i More Facts,.. . •_.continus ihrough 2010 •iuiecfions indicatp thet ws wiN nof see elemer,t~ enrollmsnt reboundJng to 19 any time in the next 10 ysar.s I - • There are a signrficant numb~r ctassrooms currently evailable in smaJl gmups al elementary schaols thrnughout the Drstrict. i ilJ~_LSchool District Siie Closures: 1972 to 1982 Irvr'ng Cmerson .-::ield Bancmft ~'otum6ra Nave.nnale ~ ~-'amilton Garland r ~Alcott Loma Vista Stadrum Davis Comstock Whittier , Study Criteria _•~sure continued sfudent access to a full range of ality educational programs. _ ;nsider geographr'c focation, neighborhoo, , dEmographics, tri pctentral constra;r • Impact the fewe$r attendance area changes, and studer►is. i: • Ensure decisions to adjusl school attendance areas are sustainabte for the near future. Areas of Analysis - _ _..i..i.~• • Enro!lmeni pm/eGWns % trends • Crty/COUnty hDUSrI►gda►elopment 8rri '.SpE'CTaI GY' L1Tlqt/@ pNUgTB("• s nc.~; ! • FEc_hd£f Sc/100/ /8119t;ni~h + • Transportetlorr8 Ca~..' 'i Age. era. coWitiar - - = - _ - - - i ~ • Marnlenance and ongoir►g operaUanal cos-s t • Vrab►lity for Iwg-range Caprtsf Projects rm~ . ~ • E('r►cienr use ofprck.~ry owned t'), _ 3 ;dems Nernblen ~Arfingtorr Hafines ; ludubat Hutton BatGoe fndfan Trail 3ancru~f 1s.7~rr~n Rac_ BWruss tlaby Sne,-~ Brown9 Udg-irwow Ste% ~ 8ry9At Uf1L1?I!} H8igt113 W8`.: ~ (i00Q8t ~.l/7N~UOty ~'TI+ ph~ Fl7iC11 Log517 M14, ~ ' Frdnf:fln LongfylJcaw W11-V Gerfleld Medison , Filtt?fS U~' Newest Schoo' °rolAtypi4al 3ubstantial Moder; :;r7ccigl Prograr►;s Faeirr 7; ~,oJlmenf in Educattbnr- 1sf of Provic'ing Servic-~-. Capacity and lmpect • Currenf Enrollmyn! • CurrBnt P::pufatort Lens+ry 'j • Nousing Gere+'opments • impact of Cbsure or+ Adjacent Schoots and 4 I ' , coM' ~ ' . ~ Ejeo2elltar~' ~ pra ~ jMp,a4C# pfClosur~ ' ~ ~ L ~ attendance Area C urrent p'ratt ~ r '4 i! • - F..--- . jr. ~ ~ S~ ys F- Lo~~~-~~~' ' ~ "~'i~ ~'M ,S~' " ~ ' ~ ` si; >;-~y~ 7s S '~'y. y .tr.: ' - ~ - ~ „ _ ~ ~ K• G• M~iv, ~ci3ttce A~a ~hen~~S ~rotaosec~ ~4~1 e i t~ t ~ y i ~s+ap'f." ~ ¢ .r ct e s~+ ~w • ~ ~ Z t ~~~iw. 1 ffi M~ s ~ •,,.at./r ~ • wn . _i / + W af ~ ~.M ~ t-LM+It l1 . ~ ip~~' ~.,!.~q Y s~_•-- flkl.~ {Y~ F q ,z ► gJ:a~-o'lmf ~s 'i ' , : w+ ,T zIt. "R t A 7t rM ~ l : 1- ~ : Ni.'.► •A~ i•.n.~ ~ ge l.~ 11 Q "...t. ~ ~ 1~ M ~ ' • - . ~ ~ r , N • .a ~ 'rr- ti _ ents gQ t4 School? w~,~« witl the stud - v tO t~i'`7 ~18 r'BfT~ Ste:4f'rs ~ ~n tn f ~ .Q1'5~ ,,Vtti '20 ro Dou";h 1'l'9sJ v&litt9. (c-ut79riifY 2 :•hjd8rtSy ftvrn St ta the il$,, f-tati'~~ o o ~+r~?Sa Stu+~~nES Wi11 go to Sw rtt' tu S {t tiroodwhora~Avos, r ~,~~'A`~ YattFy « C u n Rd s~51 f0 ~~Fm't@n tit'~tlta - ~n~nity 0~ucta~s) a~a ±~'ti: ~ SUh ave ~ ~ ~ ~pr,t#nuirxg ar►th :he ~n=~ t~Pn n''c.'~'~i uO ~ ~~ts wro:~~ t~ Stu_+r3r~~ h at a:t~ Ava . the~a ,t~ CtOendy 36 s;uosnts) ,ernTan ' #~•.~rn Gsmafian Rd, eastK~ fifh~e 3rea .}-h ~ a,~~ ~r~th 4f S:n Av a.~~ a~~ anC t~~''u ~t s~n ,.t~;~;►~s • a~ ~,n ~ti~rrj uP der~ts ~u;d ~ ~ tL mEvA 5tu Spw{It af A(GU~ntly t5'~ st"'~dRrMl. ~Y~il ra. ei'n '',~ir -~tw tamities tf;at ct~cwce tri ro ` LCU~"7t1y Z~ S4~t5' _ rlYhat will happen to the facility? ~i;u~~+ :?I'7~f .iu~}?~~ ~ .7t o~d~•y~ p.'~al~,'~;5 ~'i~ , ~ 3L ~~~.;r;~ 1 0 ~ :1 Mo;hball the factlrty unfit s:ich Irme es rf i5 '3QUrre(J fpf USG =s a'.Oee,1 school' far,*,tie Ca~+!,el Frcgram cN na&Jed as a ~ ner3hbor~rOOGi sc~`roGr D~,CE 3y3rn ANow Some porllOns af fhB feCrllry -n`~e mo-Jul3r -;assrvam unRs whrch are nof heated by ths csnf'8I bOIr'P.( 5ystem m particular - fa be utiiized Dy 3 vane!y of neighbarfiood pragrams includlrrg `Weed and Ssad ' How much will be saved? aersqnn8l SaOnys Bvildtng Ssvtngs S 50.000 Sub-Tata! $520,000 ~ Transpor,at*n Cust. Net Recurring Savings S450,000 7 ~-'~ujci:~(:~~ r~ir~~►~. :.~:'~I~,~.; ~ Projec.►ed 5-year Savings S2.775 ~ r•,;,._ c.. «;C~ Feasibility C/osure ol Prau clemencri ft rS fA8St,71a fo ~QS9 Pta!t L erea boundanes YSh&nc,30 SChD0i3 fo aCGon'rmOdatB ilts Pta7 sfud6nts ~~►j5 tECOmmQnLIatiOn JS ArUj9CieU fo S?v9 $450.000 ';GTE. ClCSUre uf Pt'afi wiN not nre-:fude al(-ddy Kmder,,_ Relocedon of Assessment Cenier ~tf iS 1eoSrbf9 tD /nlac;9;e f/xo Acs3S5mF.nt C/snf8t to th8 Pre7 , lac,lrty. ar)r1 !o base op+?ratrons ol chal unrt st !ne jacation • mts remmrriendatr„n rs projoc7eti fi sevs $1C,5,Os5 petyeer luOTt AddItional suTp-wt -tarvic-es -arp,c-orams mid ba ioceted _ c_!s . =r ,l _ _ I •r . . . . ~~uro ~t ~ran avaiiaqle 1 n ~ ~ryf;1~ 1i~ Y~ -1r, f i:f11J - 5tudy V.,. _~~'i".~9'~i' ` • ' ' ~ . . . c v ~ r{w~J t • ~ J So-s SpoKme P~jb-ic c o t'_t'r."E'll f-ll CC School Closure and Consolidation Study ~ Pratt Elementary - February 28, 2007 ~ ~ - Table of Confients Overvi ew 1 Pu rpose of Study 2 Taskforce Members 2 Schoo! posure History 3 ~ Recent Trends 3 Part I - Verification Study Criteria f~ Areas of Analysis 6 Verification Methodology > Additional Considerations 15 Conclusfon iG Part II - Impacfi of Pratt Gosure Attendance Area Modifications 17 Equftable Educational Programs 20 5taff Redistribution 20 I Technolagy Redistribuqon 21 Transportation Costs 21 Optlons for Reuse nf Pratt Facllity 22 Projected Savings from Prat.t clnsurc Part III - Assessment Center Relocation General Information 21 I Cost of Relocation 24 Part N - Summary ~ Flscal Impact 25 Impact on Student Capacity 27 Feasibility 28 ~ _ ~ Overview Un January 24, 2007 Superintendcnt Brian I3enze) made a preliminary rccommrndation tu the SpokAnc Public Schools I3oerd af Directors regarding the clagurc of Pratt Flcmentary School. Siudent enroltment has becn doclining district-wide t'or many years duc to a varicty of factors. in lighi uf this declining onnollmcnt, the School district's annual rcvcnuc has also bccn decreasing. Couplod with significant under-funding in BasiC Educatian programs by the State oF Washington, this has creatEd an anticipatcd $10.5 million budget shortfall for the 2007-08 budget year. The Districl desires to (imit Qtu impact to teaching and Icaming progmms, and to maintain a sa!'e, high-quality cduuitinnal rnvironment while aGhicving a balanced budgei. Reducing the currcnt number of e[ementary school facilities will rzduce ongoing apetating avethcad , and is a key component in die effort to preserve grograms. The reduction will, however, cause us tu redrgw -suroe schooi attcndance boundnries. The Superinteiident's preliminary recommendation was bnsed on the fact that Prait cumently has the smallest student enmllment of any clrmcntary school in the district; and is thercfnrc the elernentary schonl with the higliest cost per studetri srrvrd. This determinntion came nbout, in purt, thraugh the work undcrta}:en in the 2003 Schaol Utilizaiion Study, which has previously Gcen shared with the Citi•u,ns Advisary Committee (CAC), as well a.ti thmugh more recent 'f evaluatians :und enrollment projections. 11 Includes.l within the SuperintendenYs preliminary tccommendatinn was a call for an inter- dcpartmentai taskforce of disUict sttiffto invrstigatc the impact to surmunding schools and special prograzns, pruvide specific new attcndance zone recommendations for the Pratl students, nnd rqurt anticipated district savings with the closure of Pratt Elemcntury. Fstimating the initial cost, and ongoing savings, of nlvcating the district's special cducation assessment staff from their present (easrd locntion on Cast '1'rent (Tttic Ccnter), to the [lratt site, was alsa ta bc documented within this report. This report was ro be provided to the 13oard of Directots at their 1=ebruary 28, 2007 mceting. I'he'I"askfome investignting the recammendation of'clusing I'rait Etementary School wtis comprised of repmsec►tatives frvm Z'eaching snd L.rarning Sc:rvices, 5tudent Services. }luman Resources, Hacility Serviers, Safety and Security, Transpcirtaiioa. nnd Nuc3gat and Acutianting. Thc task forcc was askrd to uggrcgaie the existing data, discuss the chal{enges, prvpose solutions, end cummunicato the Gndings in regard tu this closune rzcommendation, as well su the relocation of approximately 230 studrnts fmm the Prau nttcndanc.c zonc: to oiher district faciGties. 'Che "['nskforce studying the Superintendent's prcliminary rmcamniendation his fnllowed the approach established during the 2003 School UtiliTntion Study, in order to independently verify the validity of the SuperintendcnYs recommendation. This process, and the outcomc, will also bc . documented within the bndy uf this study. It shauld be noted thet evcry memher of the committee was conscious thnt the reuommcnd.itions that wauld cutite out of this study Nvould huve a direct impact to studettts, stafF, parenL~, guardians, and the surruunding community. Spccial diligencc and effort has been taken to maximine the safety, security, aiid rrlucatinnal needs of the students, while mittimizing disruption to familie; aisd canimunitici. Pagc ! i'urposc of Study - Ttte purpose of the Schuol Closure and Consalidation Study is to: • Align the number of clementnry school facilities with uur current and projcctcd ncar- term enroltment. • Reduce the school district's general fund opernting exJxnses in order tu protect edurational programs from further reductions. • Keduce the number of leased fncilitics the Uistrict is utiliring, [herrb,y rcalucing overall opcrnting expenditures. ~ • Maintliin safe and appropriate tc:aching nnd lutrning cnvironmenu f'or studcnts and staff_ • Minimizc the impact of a school closurc on surrounding schools, thmilies, and communitics. • Determine whethcr there would be any facilitics availablc; for usc as temporary hausing (a.k.a. "whoo) schQOl") while u faciliry is replaced or mUdernized, during the implcmentetion uf Phcisc il of the district's 25-Ycsr Capitnl lmprovement Plan. • Provide specific delails regarding the prnpascd closure af Pratt Elementary School; to include investigation of the impact tu Surrounding sc:houls and specia) programs, reCVmmendation of specific new attendance nrces. ;md a report of nnticipnted ciistrict savings with the c:losure uf Pralt. Taskforcc Members .IiiF►n Mannix 1_xccu1i6c Director, I-:icilitics nttd I'lunning Nail SuUivan - L'xecuti,,e Uircctor, Finunce and Budget Mikz Ainswarth - Exu:utivc Dimctor, Student Suppott Serviccs 1ason Conley - Directar, Safety, Su:urity, Kisk Manngemcnt and Transpertation Craig Numatn - Supervisnr of Finuncial and Arri{N t iral tiervices Kcvin Momson - "Ceclinical Scrvices Spccialist Rhonda McLcllan - Transpurtation 1_iaison Uthcrs making a contribution to thc study in specitic arcati: [3arb WriE;ht - Associate Supc:xintendent, I luman Resourccs , Ken Brown - I:recutive Director, Tec.hnology and Informaiinn Services ~ ~ Yn};c 2 ~ i ~ ~ Schoal Closurc History While it hns tx-en many years since Spoknne F'ublic Schools has closed an active school building, historicafty ctosures have occurred on a rcgular basis. Between 1970 xnd taday the District has ctused 14 schants (see chart bClaw). Those closure decisions wcre based on enrollment and demagraphic needs and projectians, the wndition uf the structure and infcastructurc. Futd the changing nee& of educafional pm~,u-atn delivcry. Demographic and cnmtlmcnt paitertts change over time, as dnes the quality of fucilitics as bui{dings age, get replaced, or are reaovaled. Thcreforc, this type of study shauld be undcrtaken on a regular ITasis, to cnsure cffecuve use of tar dollars in oFxraiing our school facilitirs. Tuble 1- Scltanl C.losures bet►veerr 1972 cmd Prrsenl Location Closeti LocAtioo Closed (rving 1972 Whittier 1972 i Field - 1972 LDavis ~ 1974 ~ Columbia 1972 ~ Fmerson ~ 1981 Hamilton ~ 1972 ~ Dancroft ' 1981 ~ Alcntt 1972 i[avermalc1-1981 ~ , i Stadium ~ 1972 ( darland 1982 Camstnck ~ 1972 Loma V ista 1982 (Sacvice_ "SI'S Fittt IOo Ycnn" M hutory ofSpotuna Publit Sctux?is) • NU7'E I: These lorations bave since bocn reutilized for athcr progranis, or returncd into scrvice at a taier date. NOTG 2: 'I'his locat.ion is lcascd to thc Guild Schoaf. ~ Recent Trcads Elementary stvdent enroliment hes dEclined significantly in thc past decade, yet ttie nucnber uf rlrmcntary schuols has remained the same. Since 1998 the schoQt district tws iost 1,778 elcmcntary age siudrnts, wiiich equaics io thc student papuLiiion of four elementary schools. "l'he Uctober 1998 rnmllment counts showcd that Spakanc Yublic Schuals had a totaI of 16,534 ITC elcmentnry nge (grades K thmugh 6) students. As oF Cctvber 2006 t)ie numher t-pf clemcntary age students had drnppx;d to 14,756 FTE. This decline has averaged 222.25 stvdenLs per year. Tuble Z- EnroJlment Decllac sfnee 1998 I ~ 1988 1998 ZQQO 2001 2002 2003 2004 1 2003 2008 I K 1,185 1,109 1,048 1.044 1.07/8 1,097 1,094 1,129 1.130 1 2,573 2,493 2,398 2,258 2,233 2,314 2.319 2.308 2,370 2 2,725 2,508 2.425 2.324 2,248 2,196 2,285 2.242 2,297 3 2,605 2.679 2.530 2,429 2.351 2,177 2.200 2,236 2,248 4 2,558 2.578 2,616 2,450 2.422 2,383 2,209 2,798 2,292 S 2,437 2.529 2,571 2.613 2.415 2,362 2,330 2,159 2,191 6 2,453 2,403 2,484 2,563 2,603 2,408 2,388 2.288 2,229 I TOTAL ~ K-6 18,534 18,297 16,070 15.681 15,349 14,914 14,604 I 14,699 14,758 Chg fmm PriorYear i~::"~ r~.2:7~ t43~,j Total Luss 1.778 fS.n,r<c BudFa C. AcCIL•u::tin, •!U Yuu Gnnllmrn! Fn>jcclion_ ids1 f'aec 3 ` ~ F~Here amc d ata, depictcd in graphic fi,rmut. A{I tigures up thraugh the 2006-07 school year arn actual. Figures ZRcr that puint are prujcctcd. C.'Irart I Flrnrenlary Enrollnren! Prnjection T urAu. K-8 18 7so m .1. I 0 3ao I . U.fl'1 t55~~ _ a 15.5D0 i . u •ca ~ 15.000 • 14 f71•., N,~01 t~.Itt ~-4w~_~--t. 1 4. i 50 1t101~. • TOT/VL K~ 146 14 5CD ? l4i9 t 49D '203 2001 25102 2003 2064 2M 5000 30lf7 BIOQ 2D0O 2010 2011 2012 2013 :Ot 4 ?P t! 2riI9 : D f! (Source: I3uQget & Accounnng - h:lem [rirollment Chaet Nist and {'mj.xls) :1lthaugh the cnrollmcnt at the elementnry level appears to have tumcd around tind is pmjected ti) wntinuc rising slawly, the same r.an not bc said of the overull K-12 cnrollment picturc. (_7tar[ 11 - K-! ' L'nrvllrricnr ! 'ct:lrire x~~.~~ ~~CS ~JGI UJW UJD9 :.-LM OOC7~~1 DM~~1 J'~) ~ I 7R4) I 0 1Ns'i J/ ~ ~ A7f) li.1Y tl Y I ~ 1 D00I FMOCLAL YEAN 1-his loss oFenmlIment also hns u dinsct 6scal impact. lt is estimated that the District will lose $ I.6 milliun For the upcoming 2007-08 school year due to the continuing K-12 enmllment dcc:linC, and the pmjec:ted loss of an xciditiona! 350 students in the caming yeur. The tatx) enrollment loss district-wide over the pxst decade has resulted in a net loss of S 10.7 million to ttie school district. "I'uh.le 3- Revenue Luss Due !v F,irroIlmea! Dicliite Fiscal Enrollment CHAN{3E Cumulat(ve Basic Ed BEA Losa Year TT~) (K-12) FTE Losa AllocaUon 98-99 30,519 3,784.11 - 99-00 30,420 (98) (98) 3,932.45 (387,268) 00-01 30,183 (237) (336) 3,872.62 (918,663) 01-02 29,874 (309) (546) 4,141.68 (1,279.779) 02-03 29,636 (238) (784) 4,144.65 (986.427) 03-04 29,428 (208) (992) 4,204.69 (874,576) 04-05 29,045 383) (1,375) 4,294.54 (1,644,809) 05-06 28,549 496) (1,871) 4,450.26 (2,207,329) 06-07 28,389 (160) (2,031) 4,699.95 (751,992) 07-08 (esL) 28,039 (350) (2,381) 4,69995 (1,644,983) (10,754,104) I,S,jur,c. f3udgct cC Accounung - Cost of }=nmtlmcnt t~cLIlI7C TK•~~~ O7-oS %I)) Enrollment projc%:tions for thc tom.srcablc futurr am based upan a ten yeac history uf actusl student enrollment, recent history of City and Counry livw birth raLes, recent histary of cahort survivHal rates, and weighted cohort survival projcctians for futuro years. This projection has proven to bo relatively accurace for a five yenr periud into the futurc, and less so beyond that point. Tuhle •J - T err 1'et7r Enro(lntenl 1'rnjcclinn 2007 2048 2009 2010 2811 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 1,082 1.089 1.140 1.154 1154 1,168 1,159 1.168 1.172 1.174 1.175 2.394 2.293 2,309 2,418 2,445 2 447 2.455 2.467 2.472 2,484 2.488 2,324 2,348 2,248 2.284 2.359 2,398 . 2,407 2,110 2,424 2,436 2,270 2,297 2,320 2,222 2,238 2,341 2,370 2,371 2.379 2,381 2.396 2,263 2,285 2,312 2,336 2,236 2,252 2,357 2.385 ~T 2,384 2.387 2,265 2.237 2.258 2,285 2,309 2,211 2,226 2.329 2.358 2.3~9 2,367 2,178 2.253 2.224 2,246 2.272 2298 2.198 2.214 2.316 2.344 I 2,348 14,776 14,801 14,811 14,922 15,023 15,192 15,164 151330 151493 15,561 15,604 (5uur.= Hu:lgcs 3c Accaunting - 16 1'cnr l:nrc>Ilnicnt Pruicctiu+i. xls) As uin be scvn from camparing Tables 2 and a(abave), the clemcntFUy cnrallment is noc projected to reach thc 1998 high af 16,534 F1"E any time in the next ten years. Tliis mrans that cven thaugh the ovcratl kindergarten through hvelfth grade enrollmerrt is projected to flatten out in 2010, und should tr:gin lo incroasc overall thercaRer, the elementary enrollment wil) not retum to previaus Icvels fur yuitc somr time. Pagc> ~ _ ~ i I Part I - Verificatic,n Study Critrria "Ihe following critcria werc utiliz.ed by the 'taskforce in reviewing all pertinent dala and infortnaiion, and in making all spccific recammendations: • Utilize tlie facility study and schcxol boundary revicw proccss first established in 2003 to ensure a thorouglt and cohesive methadology, and remain true tn the proc.ess established and revicwed with the Citizens Advisory Committec at that time. • Gnsure cantinueci student access tu a full range of quality educatianal program5. • Consider gcographic location, historic signi(ic."cc, cwrent and futuce neighborhoacl Jrmographics, transportation is.uce, ana other potential cctinstraints. • ImpACt the fewest number of schools. and schmil aitend.ince are::s. • Minimizc impact to students, families, and c:ummunitics. ~ • Ensur4 c1c,~i~ionti fr) ;idjlt~j uhocl :.ItCl~ti_III~~ 11-wUiltl:3Ttc. Jfc ,U~lA1f1:lh1< 60f the ftc11 ; fl1tUCl' Areas of Anal}'sis Specific areas analyzed ns purt of Qic study included, but werc uot limitcd to: • Current use of spxes in our elementary schcxsls: tu ensure effective and efticient usc ot' progrum space. • Lnrullmcnt projecticans and trends, and what thcy ptirtend for die next tliree to eight yeurs. • Housinb develnpments and planned hr,w;ing units in the C;ity of 5pokane and regions of Spokane Cuunty thnt would patcntially impact 5pokanc Pubfic Schools enrollmcnt. • Spcc:ial or unique programs, and the spacc needs mid most desirable lucations for thesc prngrams. • Feeder schuul rclationships, nnd how uny changes tu currcnt attendarice arras N3ould impact or atTcct fccdcr school rclationships. • Tmpact to ttansportatioa eosts: both inereased costs andlor incrensed n;venue derived from busing studeats to a different schoal, outside their c:urrent uttendanr.c arca. • Age, era, size and acreage of the facility, ancl how these fACiors campAre ngainst similar factors far other etementary schools, and how they cumpare against established District I PAgC 6 ~ I standards such as thc Elemcntmy Eclucaiional5pecificatians and Best Practices Mnnual for Sc:hool Construction that were established aftcr passagc af i}te: 2003 Bond lssuc. • Maintenance and vngoing operationu) costs f'or each elementary school facility, and whcther any particular facility is signi6c;antly more costly le maintain and operate. • Viability far long-ranga Capital Projects impmvemeniLs, both in terms of the feasibility for a particu[ar facility to be uLilized as the basis for a modernization projcci, and in terms ofthe school site's desirability fur such a modcrnization or replacement projcct, and nlsu in terms of wheiher the site and structure could be utilized as a`wherl school' during a futum pha.se ofthc District's 25-Ycar Sch+,wl Improvcmrnt Plan. • Efficient use of property owned by the DistricK, to include roducing or climinaiing ttic use of as azaay lensed facilities us practical. • lmpact to angoing operating co;ts, with a spu;ific intent to reduce ongoing unnual operating costs in the General Hund, and with thc understnnding that it may require a nne- timc outiay o}'Capital fuod dollars to nccumplish. VcriCcation Metbodology Thc Taskforcc txUtan its analysis by looking at all c~duc:atianal proEx:rtirs in thc District's inventory except secondary schools. This appmuch pravided thirty-eight (38) faciliiies far our consideration, the vast majority of them are ncighbonc(xA elementary schools. The list, in alphabetical order, is as follaws: Adcim.s HUmhlen :tifullurr Rrwd Arlirrgton Hulme_s Prrm I Audubnn fluttorr Regu! Balbva Indtrm Trai1 RidgevieK• Bu►rcrojt Jeffersun Ravsevelt Nemi,ss l.ihby Slrrrirhln Browne Lidgerwood .Steven.s I flrycmt Lincoln Heights Wesiview aoper l.imvcMd Whitmm, F'inrh Logan Wi!lard f'ranklrn Lungfellow ii'ilsun Gurfielc! Maclison if'cxortridgc Grvnt Maran Prairie 'Fhe Taskforce njembers tlien began Applying a variciy of filtets designed to quickly etiminate tfic best artd mosl viabEe facilities tium consideration, and reduce the number truty leing considerod to a more manngeable totxl. Thc filters utiliucl were verv similnr ta those used in thc 2003 Schoal lltilization Study, and many of thrm wcrc idcntical. f'nge 7 Filter One ~ l-he first tilier applieLi tc, Uie list ul lli i►'ty-i:ight facilitic: w ati that Lhe %er} nc«c~,l si:lwo ls in our II uiventory are larger, mon modem, more functianal, nnd conform to the District's elementnr}, Educntianul Specifications and F3est Practices for Schoal Consiruction. Tliey sre therefore more viable for the long-term. These facilities, due to thcir larger stvdent capncity and Sustainable dcsign, arc aiso able to be operated in a mare cost effective fushion. Due to the state-of-the-art heating, ventilatiun, and air-conditioning systems (HVAC) installcd in these facilities, their use of nalurallighting, und the use oi luw-VOC (Volatile Organic Cumpound) products, they are more aomfortable tti occupy. -17ic flexihlc t+nd adapiable design companents utilized in ttiese buildings, along with the fect that thcy have scpuratc gymnasiums und cafctcria/inulti-purpose roams, also meuns that they wil) bctter meet the needs of cducatiunal program delivery fot a louger pcriod of dme_ Given these circumstanres thcse facilities were deemed to be the most c;apablC of ineeting the neecis c.~f the Uistrict, and therefare should not be considcred far closure. "Chis filter remuves the foUowing schools Gom consideraiian: I 2003 Bvncl 1998 Bund 1991 Bottd ~ L.idger►vand Nrou•ne Hvmbletr Lrncoln Ileighls l.ngan Pidy;et-ie«, 1988 (.apital Ste►'eru ,lforun I'rnlrie i Thirty (30) facilities rcmgin under co~»sideration. i ~ Filter Two "Ilie second filter appfied is similar to the first in tliat our pmtotypica) elementnry schools arr thc ncxt ncwcsl group oi' facilitics, havc many of the same amenitics and functional spaccti, and provida similar pmgram support as our most ia:ccnt facilitics. l'he main drawback of this goup uf facilities has been the minimal amount uf fresh uutsiclc air txing introduced into the faciliry due to their design immediately follawing the mid-70's world- wide encrgy crisis. 'I-his is curre:ntly being corrected, and six of the fourteen prototypical schoals lzave ulready becn brought up to current ASHRE (Amrric:in Scxicty of !{eating and Refrigeration F..ngincers) guidefines for fresh ouvide sir. -I'he balance ofttie prototyFical elementnry scliuuls will hc; ulxiated with the passagz oi'tlic ncxt Phase af the 25-Ye:ir School Impravement Progrnm. In addition to the updatcs to the f-NAC systems, these facilitics arc also receiving new roofs, flooring updates, and other improvemcnts thut will alluw lhcm to function as top-notch schoul buildings for many ycars to come. 1-his filter removes the following schools from consideration: Regal rwrstrucver/ i» 1982, up{late-d in 2005 II Wandridge cnnstrurled in 19821 Xno.+ewlr cunsrrucred 1r1 198/ 9teridan consmicted in 1981, updated in ZpO,t iVhilmcvl constructed in 1981 P~~r R Arlirlktart curutrurlcd ui 1980, upclrued in 2004 l3en:lss constructed in 1980, updoted in 2005 Carfield constructed in 1980 k'illard constructed in 1980, rqxlated in 2004 Arxfubon constructed in 197 9 Coaper constructed in 1979 Grmrt constructed rn 1979, rrluluted irt 200 -5 Holme.c constructed in 1979 I.cmsfellow constructed in 1974 Sixtccn (16) facilitirs retnain under consideration. Fiiter I'hrce This filter was Applied to scru:n out any schoul thut had substantial additions or modcrni•ratiun of (arge areas of thc facility. Tho ratianal is similsr to those used in filters one and twa, in thnt a fecility w•ith a significar►t porfien ofthe buiiding that has reccntly been added ar modemired would also be better nbiv to meet the needs of staffand students, and would be more viablc for lang-lcrm use and more cost effcctive than facilities that havc not received similar updates. In addition, tliis filtcr seeks to hunor docisians madc in previous bond issues where public input has directed the DLSirict to invr.st taxpayer dnllars in thesi particular schools. This flter remaves the following sc6ools from cansidcration: ?Lfullrm Rornrl original constructlan in 1456, »ruJar addition in 1978 W'ilsoir origtnul conutruction irt 1926. major odditinn in 1999 Puurtcen (14) facilities remain undcr considcration. fLItcr 1=our I1te fourth filter is spcc:ific tu spexisl program facilities. Tbe Taskfon:c believes that our spacial program facilitic$ should be considered sepatately, as their necds nre dil7crcnt nnd uniquc as compared ta neighlwrtiood olrmcntary u:hools. Thesc special program facilities will ncit provide the desired financial gain due to the uniyve needs and reyuirements of thc speciHl Prograizis located therein. Unlike a neighborhwd clementary, the adminisUativc costs for thc ovcrsi6ht unJ manngcmcnt uf these pmgrams would still bc; necessary evea if ihcsc programs wcrespread out in facilities where space is available. AddiUonally, two of'these facilities - f3nncroft and IIryxnt xnj physically too smal) to meet our capital program necd to pravide a`whecl school' tu tcmpururily hause an elementary while it is being modernixod. As the property that these twu facilitics arc located on is also too smnll and crartipecl to allow for the additian of relocutrible clxssroom units, tltey cannot be utilizEd xs a 'whec:l sehool.' Also, the Uisvict hns investc:d capital dallars in these fneilities to enable them ta pr.rform thcir uniquc roles and functions. Page 9 _ 1 i I -This filter muioves the fallowing facilitie$ Irom considemtio~n: I Bancruf cautruclrci in 1954. numerotes minur upgraJes ovPr tinre Bryranl vriginul conclructiar rn 1960, nrajor upgrade in 2001 I ibhy oiiginal construction in 19218, najvr renrai-nlrrnr uttcl udcfilir.»r in 194' ►:le%,en I I) facilities remain under considerution. Filter Five This filter is bascd upon the Uistrict's Tlementar}• t;ducational Speci(iuitions, which N-ere establishecl shortly nRrr the p3ssage of the 2003 F3ond Issuc. The F.ducation$15pxcificaliuns Stipulate a targct sizc forthe most efficient and cffertive operation of an elementary school. Snutller schnols ean be desirable frbm lhe standpoint of student-stuff interoction, Uut are typicnlly raiore castly to operatr. I.urgGr schools are desirub{e from the standpoint of efficie:ncy of opcration. F.stahlishing a balanc.c point briween these hwo opposing nceds is critiutl in ~ dctcrmining the desired sizc of elemcntFUy i'acilities far cacti school district. Spokane Public Schools hEts established a range of 400 to 550 as the desimble elementctry school sizc. Cliis r,3ngc halances providing n qualit}• educalion with an ctTicicnt cost of operation. 7ijhle S C'rirrenl F'nrollirrenr vs. 7'urge! F.nrullntent Location Enrollment (FTE) Within Desirod Range , Acfams 333 ~ NO t3alboa 366 ~ NO i Finch 543 YES F~ankhn 312 NO ~ ' Hutton 461 YES ~ I~ Indian Trail ~ 350 NO Jefferson j 512 YES Linwood ~ 390 NO Madison 295 ~ NO F'ratt 231 NO Westview ~ 357 NO V ScUc..r 14u4cntScni:cc-II;'ti} ii.i-nrrllmcnt:0i~7(l:%'ct,wt=.) fhe median cnrallment of ull elernentary schools fur thc _2006-07 school year is 426 1-L'' (basck1 upon October 2006 -Iuclent enrullment cuunLs). ~ This filter renio% cs ttie tollowing schools fmtn consideraticin: Firrrll Jurruurv 2007 ertrullnlenl af 543 f'7`l tlurlr,n .tunuury 2007 enra/lnre.rrt (~j4b1 I I7: I~ Jefferson ✓wruu ,N 2007 enro/l,rrcrrl j SI? I-71 - - - IF Fi tcr 5ix Fitter six reviews the cost oi'praviding services to children at the remnining Icxatians bc:ing considered for closure, and campares these costs on an Rnnual FiT basis. Costs w-ere totaled for the salaries and beneGts packages of the staff members assigned to a pnrticular locaiion for the cument ycar. Non-i:mplaycr Related Costs (►vrERCs), suGh as supplics, materinls, utilities, and maintenance costs, were tvWled fnr the last three years, and an annual averagc cost established. Thc Taskforcc rcviewed four diffetznt mcthods of analyzing this data: l) l'otal cost of sularies and benefits of the ac;tual sta['f working at each locafion (sec Tt+btc No. 6 below); 2) Total of the average salruy and benefits package for ench classification uf staff type - this method eliminates the poteatial disadvantage of having a morc seniar staff at n ptuiicular location; 3) Tutal rost uf the nctual salaries, benefrts, and NEItCs for each facility (see Tablc No. 7 beluw); and 4) ToUaI cost of the average salary and benefits for staft; added tn thc actusl N(:RCs far each facility. The inclusion of faur diffcrent methuds uf analysis was undertaken to avoid utili•r.inA a singlc mcthod that cauld potentially he biayod against a particular site. In all cases the highest cost per FI'G was repnrted at the samc faur schools. ln all cases the single highest cost per I•TF, was indicated for Pratt Elementsry School; and this by a signif icant margin. Table 6-- Cvst per Shedent 5en'CII.' AGlltAl Sularies & Benefrts Locatlon Grand Tota! Per FTE Ranking Adams $1.659,688 S4,896 ~ 4 Balboa $1,739,995 $4,786 5 II Franklln ~ $1,581.028 S4,964 3 Indian Trail ~ $1,561,332 54.532 I 8 Linwaod { $1,763,513 $4,539 I 7 Madison ~ $1,429,087 $4,979 ~ z Pratt I $1.303.495 I $5,655 j 1 ~ Westview 1 $1638,USq ~ $4,614 I 6 ~ (5ourx: BoJget d~ Accourrting- Elem ecrst per student 02•2047.xte► Table 7- Cust per 5tudent Served.S'alories, Benefils cYc NFRc '.r Locatlon qrand Total Per FTE Rsnklna , ~ Adams I 51,770.792 I $5,224 I 4 ~ Batboa ~ S1,840,559 ~ 55,063 5 ~ Franklin ~ S 1.G78,118 ~ $5,269 3 Indian Trail ~ S!,669,1 fi5 I S4.845 7 Linwood ~ S 1.867,479 ~ V,807 8 ~ Madfson $1,550.100 $5,401 2 ~ Prati $1.386,534 $6,015 1 ~ Westvfew ~ $1763,818 $4.969 ~ 6 ~ tsCArar: »oJpt sc 11~.-wuating - Etem Cast pcr snulent.u2-2o-07.n1b) At this point the Taskforce could easily have supported the Superinteadcnt's rcY:ornmendxtion to clusc: Pratt. T[owever, based upon our dcsirc to npply filtcrs to revicw a couple of addirionaJ purametss outlinod in the Study Criteria, we therefore passed all four uf the highest cose l3cr student facilities (Adams, Frunl►lin, tiTadison, and Pratt) on for further considcration. F':~r I I _ ; Eilter Six removes the foUowing schcxols fmm consideration: Balbva hrdian I rail Litrwoa! Wesrview Four (4) facilities nmain under consideration_ Filier 5cven 1he final filter 3pplied was undenaken to review the n:maining four schools for capacity and I impact. Would thcrc: bc sufficient rapacity in surrounding schools to absorb the numbrr oi' students in the facility being considrred for closun:? Nuw many adjacrnt schools would tx. required to abwrb the students fram the facility being closed? Wauld wC have to go failher than just diosc schools immeciistely surr4unding the school undcr cansideratiQn for closure`l As one of tlie study criteria esttsblishai is lo minimize the impact to surrounding schools, we wcn: also nssc:ssing how many sehool attendancc ur~s would bavc to be changed, and whcthe~r thcro would be any feedCr school re[aNonships disnupted, in order to find sufficicnt capacity to close n pariiculxr school. tn cach instnnce we took a]ook at the number uf clussrooms that would be required to absarb the I titudents Gnm the school being cluscd. This number is out mcessnrily the totul number af classrcooms currently in use at a pnriicular location. One ceason thal this number may be different i; thnt if there is sufficient space in the Resoun:e program at the receiving schc>ol, then the llisirict wuuld not need to relocate the Resource progrum from the school being closed. In addition, cach school has a number of students who live out5ide the regulnr attcneiance area bcwndarics thai 'Choice' into that partiCUlar schuol. These studcnts wauld be rcturncd to their `home' schoul if uny school is clvsed, so we du nut nerd to include them in our calcult+tions uf huw mauy clsssroom spaces are required in the immediute vicinity uf a clused school. Thew. students would ~ cither remain at their home nciblibochaod schaol, or would choice into gnather fncility of'their chausing. ~ h inaUy, thrre are wme sJxcial cducution progrnms that :u-r; morc e:asily relocated (such as a BI ~ nirnn, DI room, or Pn:-schaol) whilc utltcrs arc more diPlicult to relocatc: (such as Auti;m or MH011 clas,crooms). Tliese issues were also txken int(i consiclcration as we reviewed the impact of'closing a particular facility on surrounding schools. '1'a assist the Taskforce in assessing ctassraom utilir:.tlion wc utilizcd currcnt student and classroom dat» for Adsuns, Franklin, tiSadison, and Prait, as wcll as for surrounding `receivcr' sites. 'llus data included the total number of studecits registetccl at a given site, the totnl numbc:r uf classcs, the number nf students for each grade, the number af students in each ctass, the type of class (Regular F~i or Spccisl Ld program), and othcr pcrtinent infarmation. ln additioo, Adams. Franklin, h9aciisuti, and Pratt, as wcll as all `n:ceiving' sites under consideratian, were visittd by staff'and physicnlly surveyed to doublc-chcck the datn available. l7iis inforrnation was then utilited to determine which genernl education classmams were available for mcoming studen!". and wluit spe:cial programs were present thet we would need to accammodaie in oar planniny ~ 'fhis prescntcd the task forcc with an accutatc picture of how many class'ruoms cach facility 1. : in total, how many wcrc bcing fully utilizeci, how many werc undcr-utilizcd und cauld be ma'. uvailable, und how many could potentially be rclocated ro ather facilities in nrder to pmvide ~ ~ additional capacity at a particular location. ~ }'a-pc 12 ~ Adams. !7 claesrnoms ne.~eded ro close .aJums Feeder.Schoo! Progresslvn: ('huse 1 Ferri.+ Classrooms available in viernit}r: tlomblen - 2 available L1ncoJn tleightr - 8 m~ailuble Aforon Pruirle - 2 available Franklin - 0 ovuilrlble (tior arijaceirt) Hultun - 3 m-allahle (iiot adjacent) (Sac i L.('.) Mu!lcrn Raad - 2 available (sac / L. C.) "!'oval clccssrvum.r uvailable: 12 available wrth ininimal impacl 17 iJwe cutinl tfwse not immrdiataly adjacc•irt or whose feederprogression is nnr idea! Number ojsrhonls imrcutecl.• 5 Adams Elrmcntary has scvcntaen classroams that would nc.tid to tx: rclucatcd tu surrounding schools in order to clase the facility. Adams foltows a'Chase to Frrris' feeder school ~ progression. 'Chere are twelve classronm spaces available in the immediate vicinity that mainittin the Chase-Ferris feeder school progness+on, and an aciditional tzvn (for a tntal of fourteen) if wc do nut maintain that progression. There are three: clussraoms available beyand the immtdiaie vicinity, but ehese also do not foltow thc Chase-Fcrris fe«fer progression. Thc closuro ofAdams would impaci a minimum af five schools and schoo) attendance areas. It is the Taskforce's belief that Adams daes not fullv mcct thc estahlishe.d criteria for closurc. f= rankl in: 14 clcusrooms trc-eded to rlase.• Franklin Feeder Schoal Progressinn: C. hure / f%crris Classrooms available itr ti-rciiiity: Litlcoln NeiRhls - 8 availahlc Sheridart - 2 mviluble .4dams - 3 available (not (uljrx-enl) Iiamblen - 2 available (not vJjacent) Grant - l available (Sac / 1.. flutlun 3 uvuiluble (Suc / L.C.) 1 ura1 clussruonts uvviluE,le: 10 available with nrinimal impact ?0 ifwe cawrt lhose rtot inrmedialely adjucen[ or whnse feeder nrngressiorr is nol ideal Number ujschuals Impucleci.• 4 E'ranklin Elementary ha.s fourttxn classrooms thst would need to he; relixatrd to surraundirig schools in onicr to closa the facility. Franklin predominantly follows a`Chase to Ferris' f@eder scltool pragression, thaugh there atc a stnttll numhcr of students who end up attending higtl school at l.ewis 8c Clark. Thecc are ten classroom spaces available in thc immediAte vicinity tliat mainwin the Chusc-Frrris fecdcr school progression, and an additiunal ten (for a total uf hwenty) if we move h'arther out into schooly that arc not immediaiely adjacent to FrSnklin, or irwc do n(it maintain thc pceclominant fevdcr schaol progression. "l"ho closure of Franklin would impact a minimum uf four schoois and schcx►1 uttendancc arcas. Pnge 13 7aiddifional considrrntian is that tiie l~istrica's Applc progttun is currently lacated at Ernnklin Currently this progrntn utilizes four classrooms, but n tifth ~'lpple class has already ed Cor the coming sc:hcx~l year. 'Iliis wauld reyuin: locating a rninimum of five classroom spuces into the same building, which can only be accomplished at Lincoln HeighLy. ft is the Tatkfarce's belief that Franklin cioes not fully meet the established critrria for closure. i ' Madison: 1-7 classrooms neecled lu cluse 1lWisan Feeder Sc. hoo! FrnRression: Gurry / N. C. C lcxs-.srcwnas available iri vicinity: Lidgem•ood - 3 available (Garry / Xugcrs) l.Fnwvvd - 2 available (.4ulk l e'V C) Ridgeview - 1 cnailnble (Sallc / Shadlr Park) i~illard - 0 rn~ailable (Glover / Shar~~e ' .V. ( ) '1'olul clcusrvoms ctvuiluhle: D avaih7ble with minimal impnc•1 6 cr►nuilcrblr in non-confornrinX feecter vehc,ols Number of srhaol.c impar<ec1. trn.knnwn, hu1 mnre tfrcnr a Madison Elementary has 12 classrooms tlhat «ou(d clerd tu bt; reloc;ntcd to surrounding schPA)is in ardrr tn closo the facility. Madison Fredominuntly Ccilluws a`Gnrry to North Ccntral' feecier school progression; tliough therc are a small number of ,-tudcntti who attcnd Gluvcr and Shacll. Pgrk. Thare are Lero classmam spaces available in the immediate vicinity that maintain the Garry-N.C. fecdcr schoul ptogressiim. Six classrooms can be found in the vicinily if we ignnr: the predominant Fexdcr schoal progression. Additinnal rooms could likely be found if we move Farther out into schools that are not immadiutely adjacent to Madison. Itowever, given tho timited number of rvams availablc in the immediate vicinity, und the ctimplications tliat would arisc with tfie fecder sc:hoal pragressions, we did not continue lcxoking in awider aren. 'Ihe closure of Madison would impact a minimum of four schouls and school attcndance arcas, and most likcly a sip,nificantly higher numbcr. is lhe askforLe's hciief that Madiscm dcx;s nvt Cully mcct thc cst:iblishrd critrria Cur ctosurc, Pralt: 10 i lussrounky neeclerl !oclr, so f'rtit1 I eeikr .tic Itonl Progressron: C'hase ~ f i rri.s Clussruams m•uilable in viciriitv: ,Sluridan - Z available Lirrculn Heigirl.s - 8 available 1 ulul classruuras availahle: /U uruiluhle titi-ilh iniriintul tmpnc•t Number ojschouls rnrpucltd: ? Pratt Elemenusry has ten ela.ssmams that would need to bc; nlucatcd tu surrounding schuols in urdcr to clasn ttte facility. Prait follow•s x'Ctiase to Fcrris' fee:dcr school progcs.sian. There are ten classroom sjwces available in tho immcdinte vicinity that maintnin thc Chasc-['rrris feedcv schoul progression. Tlieretore, Pratt cauld bc closed widi minimal impacl lo surrounding schools, attenctance areas, and feeder school prc►gres.sions. Paue i-t J I ~ Additional Cousidcradoas Uther issues tuken into ransidcn►tion by lI1C CBSkfUT(:C IR COI1SIdl'tIRg Tt1C viability uf closing Pratt Etemcntary were population density and housins cicvetupmcnt within thc attcnci.3ncc arca. "fhcse twn factors provide us some guidance in determining whedier the curmnt enroilment numbers and psiDerns are likely to change drastically in the near futum. Siaff widiin tbe District's Facility Services deparnnent c:antinually monitors Federal. State, County, and City census data. This data is also utili7,cd by aur District's Analytical Services -taft' for enrollment pnojectians. The Facility Services department's ptanning staff also receives a variety of notifications frum the City of Spakane, City of Spukane Vulley, and Spokene County. Ihcse notitications include 'Requcst for Commcnts' and 'Environmental lmpact Statements' that are part uf the approval proccss for nny potcatial develapmrnt. Thesc notificatians are ontcred into a database, plottrd using MapPoint or Gaogle Earth Professional, and are cluscly monitared as they progress through the variaus stages of approval and/or development. Hacility Seivices planning siaff'also routinely speak with real Gctaie agents and devclnpers regerding thcir projects and deve[opments, and perfnrm sile visits to larger, fullv financc~i nnd appravod de;velapments to de[crniinc the patentiul impact un district aiueatiunal sitc>. Another factor that must be takcn intu ar.count when projecting the likely im}sact uf upcnming devclopment on enroltmont is the value of the propertv. Quite simply, the more cxpcasivc the devetopmeni, thc fewer elementar►+ abc studcnts it is likcly to produce. T'his is betieved to be due to the fact that many home buyers looking for high-mid to upper-end propenies are typically older and their children are most often alncady past thc elementary age. Additionally, the buyen in this dcmographic are waitinrt langer to liave childmn, and are having fewer children than has bcen the case in the past. Table 8 - ftousing Slarls & Vacrnuies in Pratt.1 tttnrluliL-e.-treu Site I Variablc I 1 Mile Rndias Pratt Owner Occupied Units I 2,346 Renter dccuPied Units I 783 ~ Vacant Housing Units I 163 Pratt I Units Buflt Before 1939 I 241 ~ Units Built'40 -'49 ~ 280 Units Built'50 -'59 ~ 429 Units Buflt'60 -'69 I 203 Units Buitt `70 - 79 I 774 ~ Units Buiit'80 -'89 I 351 ~ Units 6uitt'90 -'99 ~ 243 (5ourcc: 20xM lt S. tfovsing Ceneus) Utilizing the latest census datn frum the fedcra) governmenl's 2000 Housing Ccnsus, «c notcd thst thc housing starts in a one milc radius around Pratt L'lementary have bu;n sEcadily decliniug since the 1970s. Tllis is indicativa of several distinct possibilities: 1) that the area is huilt-out, and hss reached or is closc: to maching the czpa:ity nllowed by ardinance; 2) that the cost of construclion due to die topography or nvuilability of scrvices is higher than othcr nmas in the viciniiy; or 3) thnt dcrnand for additionnl housing in thnt pnrticufnr arra iti low. PA&c 1 ~ 1'able 9- Nausing Densily (,umpuri,s•un I ~ Sitc I 1 Mile I ~ Adams ~ 6,259 f-ranklin 5,832 Madison 7,563 ~ Pratt I 2,529 _ kwra: 2000 U, 5. Hcxusing Crnsun ) Wa alsu nutc tltat the housing dcnsity in a one mile radius amund Pratt way ;ignificantly lower thnn the housing deosity sccn in a similar area around Adams, Franklin, and Madison. What this ~ tells us is that tlie area around Pratt Elementary is thinly papulnteJ in tenns c>f housinL. According to the dstn contained in Tahle 9, it is only forty-diree perLent as populeted ds the area around the next Fiigher region (surroundinb Franklin F.lementary). 7'his would sec:m to indicate thut tttcre tnay be cupacity for growth in the srca if terrain and setvices Ate available, or any issues with the topography and availAbility of services can bc uvercome_ liowever, it wculd afuo seem to indicatc that significant graw2h could ox:cur in the current Pratt attendance arca without prmiding significant additional cnrollmeiit tTOm that area, in that othcr tacilities within the 5chool clistrict are surrounded .tiith homes at u much greater density. 1 he impact ta the school district &om any huusing development is verv sluw in coming due to the typically tong timc intrrvals rcquired For the various npprovals, sc:curing of financing, acquisitIL )n ~ or cxtrnsion ofservices and infmstructurr, ccinstructien of the individual housing units, sale of the hames, and a variety of otber faciars. Therefore, wc typically assess only developmenLes that :ire fully finane,cd, have received all pcrtinent approvals, and are actually undec construction. :iny uther project camot bc ace;utatcly modeled given tttc unpredicuability ofdie process and II timelinrs. (t is nc►t uncammon tor s project tu take scccn tu ten years, and evcn lonLcr, iiI ~ni initiul concept to culmination. Finally, a rcview of the Gity of Spokane Valley's most rcccnt I.and [1se Plan canfirms that t!ic arca in the current Pratt attendrincc zone wtiere housing expansion is most likely is designated a-5 an Urban Gruw•th rlrea. llawever, ncilher their 2006 Arterial I'lan, nnr their 6-yc:ar Scwer Plan, 51ows any cxpansion of services into this arca. ft is therefore very likcly thcst any additions in this I area !11d :i, -t I-•,. ;:i,lC 1~+ 111161 '-.117C IIIiIC 0 Sci' '0 CUnl'l111111t1 Of tlte ciglri schual facilities considcreci in Filtcr Si.r-, Pratt Gementury is the most cxpensive tu opecate in tertns af cost per stUdent served. Each student educated at Pratt Elemeotnry cutrentiy rosts appmximateiy S500 mare esch year ihan Ht the next mASt costly site cansidered. c)f'Uie four school fncilitii:s considered in Filter Seven, the clusun; uf Pmtt C:lementary would irnpact thc }ewLst nurnlxr ofstudznis, dic 1'ewest schuol attendance area5, and wuuld maintain the current f'ccdcr scliocil 13rogressions for those student5. Tfic additiun.sl ceittsiticrutions ot'the current housing availAbility and ~xatential future housing gruwth sht3w that there is nQt curnently a need tn kec:p Pratt Elementnry upc.n at this tinie. ° Therefore, it is the T:i.kfnme's conrlu~irnn that 1'ratt Elementmy is the most feasible elementary schuol li+r clusurc. I'agc 16 ~ - - - Part II - Impact of Pratt Closure Atteadgnce Area viodifications To a.ssist the Teskfarce in assessing student transportation issues and attendance area modifications we importecl all currcnt studcnt datn for ['ratt, as well as for surround'mg'roceiving' schools {Shcridan and Lincoln Ileights), into a`warking' dalabuse_ Thc data imported included the student's address, grnde levrl, and whcther the student was earolicd in s Rcgutar Ed or Speciml Ed program. Thc address clatn %aw then ecported into a scparAtc fiic to extract the number of sludcnts pcr residence, and thai informntion was thett plotted utilizing a mapping program (MapPoint and Guoglc Eurth Arofessionnl). I 7-he team also imix-wrted the district's elc:mentnry sucndanee areas and uver-laid that witlt din individual address data, whicti resulted in u scrics of'maps dcpicting the locatiun uf the residences af each sc:hool's currendy enmlled students. 'Ihis presctitcd the Taskfarce with a dvnnmic visual reprrsentation of where a given school's current students reside, and allowcd us to compare scenarios with diffcrtnt attendance arca demtu'catiuo lines and calculaie the numher of students who would be impacted by praposcd acw attendancc area boundarics. Graphic '.4 Current Prott ElNmenlury Attendunce Arnu - - « ~ ~ M ~ y' y~ ~ ~ BROAOIIfAY a a SQpitBflg ~ ! r y • ` N ~ -~LI.,y,~j; t!',~ , ~ CA& 2IJY= tC p , ' . _ FabrS N~'(7-!JiF; ry~•i; 2 ?'L i.~ r.8f11h ~ va.: c ~ }tr '3+ i ~ V L' ¢ n , s ~ a - ~ SFRArUE : AY 7 1 , ~ 'q T 3 ti "'._•m g{~y . -AL-AC :~i~ c8t 7.y ~v •~A `~t3:F+.:~.~?-~_ v c < ~ 3 °t. - - > ~ ~ •'i ;n Z ¢ 1tt - r ' ~ ~ !5n~ •~~,-~'.~LL UI Pt y r •1 • ~ it`.A W fr~ ..Y' ' _ i.. . . r~ JCr yyr`. • Sq ~ 's ~ - ! ! ~lt hEIGNTa W r n ~ ~ F ~ r ~ ~ ~_i~ -1 ~{w 4 MI a ~ ~t µ ~ • u ~ r~ r ~ i i Av _t.-. ;~c - - - . „M - J~rm E Oqr t'~f N~ol~ldrd a .r- r1 ,r ~ J?! aV F'agr 17 Grapirrc 'B ' - Pratt Studerrt Xesulence Map (tiviJe) ' ~~f , £~i,~ , •r~~ i~~ ~ ~ - ~-~•`c:-~I"y 17 f 2el . w t 1 77 ~ ~ . ,-er :G1:~ .~ri!i p ~i.l;-..: -:c.sn• ~ t f4y~ ~~Jit1 iY ,t ~--~•~I 3 '•~~'7j Y_~ r~ Y{}=~-- -1- 'i_~'' I;Y-M-^~ -~cVi--~rs,+:~ :W't!"i vi •rrl'~~..c~! ~1 - ~~-1 l:'..t'~~!- .a._~:~^r' - - t~y`r -1,- - - ..i.~,. ...r. , i,.. :a~i,.,:1t.-,•' . _ ,,.:,i'__ r -L_ This graphic dcpicts thc luuitiuns uf Uic residcnccs of currcnt Pralt studeats. The light blue area .jusi to the right of centei, and just south of 1-90, is the Pratt attendancc area. As cIIn bc scen ti, • this view thcre are a numbcr of Pratt students who live far outside the Pratt attendance area, a: Nvho 'choice' into I'rntt. 'Me number in each red circle is the number of'students residing at th.. specific addrr::s. Graphicl- Prau Sluclent Re.siclencc :4fup (narruxJ e r.ry a,. A ~ ..._E . au.Y«a, R.. R ItNq AR ~W"OrA Ay4 Aw - .L'_ _ W . . _ - . - - . V . . ~ S°"pu 7w E unewAw n 0 . PKte..1RAn f ?M Aw t )71M lzpq `AO $ r-' _a a d•°.o+. o09~4oo od e'r.u~ ~ ~ A.. 4 ~0 o `c t~OAOO¢q. E otn A.. - p ."fl 4 - v A.' 4 :4 ' oa o- 0 0 oa v~ cw e ern ~ g E~O QQ -ao- _ D 0 e ua rW ps e'eacAq& _ s3k f~w - E tSaJac ~}O+ ~CQ % k+L _ 4 q t~~ s., 4 O ~ ta ~~O ~ 80 o ~000Q'' : s~rM1 .a. g ~ ~ liefr Am t Cmqsu E ~1 n ' y f ^i ?t~t ':S", • ~l~ = , iq . . . 1 . . . . - . . ' ' ' . , _ " _ ~ - • 1:. • - n 7~...'7' r:.'" T. ~..~rn~Yw~• I: i' " _ This graphic also indicAtes the current residences of Pratt students, but is moce tightly focuced on the boundaries of the Pratt attendance area- ('nuc I x After revicwing a varicty of possible altendance area changes, and cansidering the numbcr uf students that each potenual ehange would send to the two 'receiving' schools, the T;-iskfarcc settled on the follawing recommendation: • For the areu north uJBlh Ave., from Carnwhun Rd. evsl 1n 77iierman St., mid then maving up !0 4111 A►ae. ural conti»uing wiih the rrreo nortlt oj4th Ave., sluden[s wvulrl ga to Slreridcm. 77tis wotrld currently affec! 56 students. • For the areu sauih oJ8th Ave., jran Carnahrni Rd. east ta '1'hiernran St., ttnd llwti ntoti•ing up to 4tltA ve. m1d continuing with lite vrea south cJ41h Ave., students wnuld Xo lo l.incvln I/ergh1s. This woulJcurrprtllyaffrc•t lf,,l.titudenus. • From Broad►wy Ave. narth lo Trenl ,dve., Jrvm Nutian<< Sl. tn rlie clistrrcl hnrtler it'itlr I Nesl Valley, strulent.s wovtcl ga to Steverrs. 7'his would currc n11y uffect 2 studerrt,c • From Bracldway Ati+e. soutlr ta Sprugue Ave., Jrom Ha►wna St. tn the disrrict burder i+-ith f4'est vaJley, student.c would Ro to Slreridun. Tlti.s would currently affect 0 studenls. • The,fcmrilles that chaice in rn f'rtut wauhd reti•rrt Iu therr honre sc:fronl.s. 7hi.c icnrrld currentJv uffecr 29 strulcnls. (:ruphie 'I_)' - Prnpused Attendanci' :Iterr Motlffrcutrun.c t..~OM~ hr! k .~iirt6 IwN I fi r. Brr+i Jw~ ~ ~ E Shwp ~ - E Scdn~ +►w ° - EGNdW Ift Cn a ~ ~ r ¢ ~ 7 eq. ~ rn ~ ~ ~ ~ a. E AJsi M ,v . : • C vakra.r M Z =r kaln r.. Sheridan ~ F,urT ,n„r _ _ ~ ~s}3u'r .Li C,..~ E Sra~i"~i~'x` - - ~ ;~x • - - 3'ui I spellsne Val Y ~ '6'sTrArrr s ~ E gth M bt~ :..oi .~;~r ~fw- E i? i, 'iw F- M" E 9rA AI, E Prnt A'q ~ - ~ L y:,~,t.u~~+ '~-~R~~ t~ t2Sr An - :f~ltAa , . - {r AI;L'' L ~CA+6fFi~a~1`W=, . - ~ ~ ' . ~t~S Ys171fi = 4~ tt-Jss - _ r. tt E Wth 11w i fid E gnct+m0 g~r4 s ~ - - • - 3. G~ • ~-!T ~i r~ 111t } E N~ r E 32nd M Z. . , y11F1~y~ M . , y ,°j% ~'i }U-y' -..'~1:~ . . ~ ~ . ~ r !~.a-i. i 1 tt v~.~-~..: i : ' ♦ . . r. .i i t 's~ i 1'Nt 1 - rTT~.,'f' . _ _ . . .,7i 1/ t~ . . . ..l~''~i+~1 [L_:~.~._'_ _ r. _ _ _.Iarr[is1~t?.~' _ •T . ' jQ-_ _ 'I'he propnseJ chxnges in the altendance airas for Lincaln HeibhLs and Sheridan elementriry schnols bulajice llic number of current Pratt studcnts that would be rebcated to each of these: faciiiltes with the number of nveilablc rcwms and the desired enrollment and mitximum ca}ssu;iry at eac:h location. f`~ue 1') 7Therecommended changes in attcndancc areas would result in a prLijected 2007-08 enrvliment ~ for Shcricictn of 478 (October 2006 enrullmcnt plus current Pratt students bc;ing miocated ta Sheridan aitendance area). However, given the changes that take placc from year ta year, and also ~ within sny given schail year, die projected enroilmcnt should be within ttie range ot4 80 and 510 at SheridAn 1-1-1ementary. The maximum desimd capacity of Sherician Elementary is 547. The recommendcd changes in attendance arew would resuit in a projected 2007-08 enrollment for [.incoln !-(cights of 512 ((ktober 2006 enroliment plus current I'ratt students being relacaiod to Lincoln Heights Attendanr,c area). Hnwever, given the changes that take plac.c trom year to year, nnd alsa within uny given schcwl y-ear, the pmjected cnrollment should he within the tunge af between SUO and 530 at Lincoln Fieights Elcmentarv. I-he miLximum d"ire(i capacity of I.incaln Hciglits is 577. 'Chere is, thrrCforc, sufficicnt cupacity at both facilitirs for additiunal ciirollment growth. !t should be nated, however, that if full-day kindergnrtrn is implementeci at either of these locatians within the ncxt Cew years there may be some adjustment of attcndunce nrea boundaries required if that is coupled wich significant additianal c•nrullment growth. There ara a number of possibilities for rninor adjustments to the attendanr.e areas for both these schoals that wuuld rreate the nccessaly capacity for a11-day kindergarien al thrse facilitie5. Equitable Educutianal Progrsims The et3ect that ttie proposed closurc of Pratt Elementary witl have on the ciis[rict's c:duratianal prugram offerings is ncgligible. "The required educational programs and offerings available to current studenis at k'ratt are available al other clc:mentxry schcx)l,,_ inc(uding the proposed `mceiving' schcwls: Lincoln Heights and Sheridan. Therefore, there would be no negativc impact on currenl Pratt students in termy of educational program offerings. [n addition, there would be no impact an class sir.es at Sherid:~n or Lincoln [ iciehts due io the relocation of students from the Pratt attendance area. titpff Redictrihution rne nisc,-ict will foUow the collectivc; bargaining a~,tre:ements hc.twccn the 1)istrict tutd Spokane Educbtiun Association (SEA) as they rclate to the transfer of stxff from Pr:►tt to othcr sites if the schaol wcre eo close. SEA is the legnl rcprescntutive of the majarity uf staff members in the schnol district, including most employees currently atisigned to Pmtt Elementary. Typically, whea staffmembers current positions are no Innger available at a scttool, the impscied cmployces are considered to be in 'involuntary trnnsfer' stcitus. In such cases, staff members are allowed to select another positian in the district for whic_h Qiey atc qualifted prior to the job being ~ madc avai Iable to ather emplnyces in the district or postrd for ncw candidatcs to apply far jobs. The District'; I-lumun Resources staff has engnged in convcrsations with tha Spokane Education -Association (SEA), with the outcomc bcing a Mcmorandum oftlndcrstanding (M()l]) concernin_~ this particular situatian. fn summary, the Disirict and Associatiun have agreed that the ~ invaluntary trsinsfers and/ar reassignments of displaced stafi' fram Pratt may cx;cur prior to the rcgular involuntary trnnsfer or reassignmcnt pmcess. (n additinn, the District and Association liave further ngrc:cd to alluw vnc-year tcmporary positions to bc posted for the remainder of the 2006-07 schoul yc:az, or, to sub out selected positioris in urder to have pusitioivy uvailable fc,r displaccd staff tn transfer tn from Pratt. I'ngc '4i I 'I'cchnology Redistribution it is rec:ammended lhat the redistribution of technolog}, equipment (E'Cs, priniers, document cameras, digital vidco projcetors, scanncrs, COWs nnd other relatcd cyuipment) currently in pli3cc al Prntt, would be handled as fallows: I) Equipment purchased a.s part ofthe tracher tec;hnology profcssional (levelnpmcnt pmgrun would foUow the participating Pratt teachen to their new location. 2) "lhc two Computcrs on Wheels (rart plus I S laptop camputcs and wireless access point) would bc distrihuted intect to l.incaln Hcights undcr thc praposcd sccaario, as that is whcrc thr majority of 1'ratt students will end up. A Inrger percentage of deskt(ip ceirnputers will tx: depioyed to Sheridan ta compensate diem as well. 3) All other technology cquipment including officc, support, principal, teacher end student machines would be neciistributccf w the schonls receiving the Prntt studcnt$ bascd on tt►c pcrcentagc af Pratt studcnts that cach school roccivcs. 4) Any msidual tectuiology bond dollars NN-uuld be reallocated to the receiving schools based on the pereentage of Prfttt studznts thsi each school receivcs. 5) 7'he ccntral copier nnd fax mechine would be redistributeci based un overal I nc.eds af the ' di5trict nt the timc cif closum. Tranaportadan CostR Transpartatian cosis fur rcloc:iting currcnt Prsstt Elcmcntnry s-tudcnts wcrc calculatcd ss fallaws: die total number of students whU would be tian"rted once the school was closed, mvius the numhrr af students thnt are currr-ntly heing tranMwted, pmvidrs the xdditional funding thst wil I be roceived this coming year if the recommendatian is implcmented. This number is then subtractcd from the total cost of busing the entin cunent student enrullment of Pratt to Sheridan and I_incoln Iicighv. Thc cemainder is the total sdditiunal cost or savinvs. 7'tt1r1e JU - Trwt.,pn.rlaflun ('osts DesctiPtion ~ Savln a~ Neded 2007-D8 Trartsportation Ccsls 123,166 Current Pratt Transporta5on Casts - 30,458 Addiur,na! ;t2!e Fund,nq - 7,07•1 Tr;nsportaUon Costs • 88.~634 ;Slr~uicr ~i hi- f SPE•.pvrt Se:cieCS-PRtt(.1DSaR 5ri~ Jc 12 .1;-+17 ~,•,i - iri tlhe interest uti utiliung round figures, nnd ta nllow t'or a margui of error, the Task.fiirr,c uscd a tibure of $70,000 in incrsawd trimspartatiun cost for ralculnting the uvcrnll impact to thc budget. f'we 21 ~ ~ ~ Options for Reuse of Pratt Facitity Thcre arc a number of options far reusc uf the Pratt facility, including, but not limited to: 1) Reiucate the Special Education Assessment Center staff an(i prugrams ta Yratt. 2) Rclucatt othcr programs current(y utiliting leased spuce, such as the Elementary Science Kit Crnter (on Cincinnati) to the Pratt facility. 3) Rela;ate some special and/ar support programs that ere not cumently in lensed space, but um cramped for space or m-e prevcnting other adjacent progreuns from cxpanding tu mect current nccds (such as the Auditory Prugram currcntly locaied at I-lavermale, or the Vision Prograrn currently lucated at Libby Cente;r, or rentralizc; the storagc uf physical thecapy I equipment stored in a variety of locatinns throughout the District). I 2) ti'Iathball the fncility until such timc as it is re~quired for use as n"whccl scliool" for the Capital ProgFUn ur such time :ts it is again nee;dcd as a neighbt,nctxid school. 3) :111ow some pnrtions ofthc facility tn be utilized by neighborhood prugnms such as the "Weed and Seed" program cum;ntty fundod thmugh a Federal grant. TUc bcst localion for small prugrams of this nature wauld bc in the modulnr classcnom units, which are not hcatc,i by the main building's ccntral bailer system and are tlicrcforc much rnure cost rffective tu ope-ratc anJ maintain. 4) Ailow nnc or more modular classrooms to bc utilizccf as a ncighborhood cammunity center, if such A center bccumes charicr«f and they have a Uudget tu ccivcr 6asic utitities and upkeep. Any of these option9, and conceivable m»ny ather.s us wcll, would be a cust effective use of the facility, IInd would reciuce the District's overall General Fund opetating expenscs. Projerted Savings from Pratt Clasure As seen Crom 7'able I I(txlow), there is a projected savings of S470,000 per yc:nr in ruluced }xrsonnel costs. Calculntions fur personnel cost n.~ductions includc the followuig assumptions: rlimination afthe 1.0 F'TL" principal's positiun; cluninatic,n of thc 1.979 Ff[: office stnff-, rliminaiion of tbe 0.50 FI'E Librarian and the 0.170 lihrary assistant; transfer af the 0.50 counselar's pusition to teceiving school(s); transfer of dte 0,091 PTE nutse's position to rectiving school(s); a reduetion of 1.0 F i-E Basic E:ducation teaching positions; transfer uf the ExVa- Cumculnr funds tu re:eiving sncool(s); eliminatian of a poriion of the 1.0 FIT Classified and 4.826 Ce:rtifir.nted Special Education twching stafF; transfcr ofthc 1.0 i= TF's f AP teaching positiun to receiving school(s); transfer of the LAI' tunds to receiving school(s); tmnsfcr of the 1.0 FiT Student Achievement Fund teaching position to mcciving school(s); elimination of thc I~ 2.0 PTL: custodial positiuns; ~inJ climination of thc 0.605 FlT nutritiun scrvicc.s positious. i'arc 22 Tahle 11 - Frujec-tecl.StIYl11g5 fTOm Personule! ~ Descrlptbn ~_Cert. FTE Class. FfE Mnual Total ~ Ssvinqs ~ Commsnft i libray ~ 0_500 ~ 0.170 ~ 40,528 40,040 ~ ReducBon ~ Princi0ei O~ice ~ 1.000 1.979 ~ 213.401 215,000 ~ Raduction Couasebr 0.500 34.878 Ta Receivinq Schools Crossing Guacd • ~ - • ~ • _ None_ ~ ~ 1 - ~ 0.091 2.826 - To Rgceivir~g Schools ~ BJENurse Teach ing ~ 11.000 ~ • 885.899 70,000 Reduc6on at 10 FTE Extra-Curri,vfar~_L_ _ F_. 2,2(f9 ~ To Receiving Sr.hools _ ~ S1E Teacfiing i.ODD ~ 0_826 126,711 I 40.000 Redudion LAP Teadhg 1.000 ~ • 76,831 ~ - To Receeving Schoals - LAP 81d4_(_` - 2.948 ~ • ~ To Receiving Schods ~ SAF Teaching 1.000 ~ • ~ 63,621 Ta Recefvmq Schoals Custodlai - ~ 2.000 ~ 106,641 . 105,000 ~ 1.5 FTE ReducNon Nufition Srvc ~ - ~ 0.605 ~ 30,809 1 • I No Savings ( I1e.aoo 1 5.e71 f S 11,W.3011 I 8470000 I I (~A)utu: Schad 5upc±mt Smiccs f'tatt Cluourc Sav inu Cxic CQ.15--07.xls} As shown in Tnblc 12 (bclaw), the tulal suvings fmm Non-Emplu}•ct Relaied Costs (NERCs) is a negativc number $20.000). The savings f'mm utilitics and maintcnance arc more than offxt by the ndditionsl costs incurnrl in transporiing cument Pratt sludents to their'receiving' schools. Tcrble 12 - Projectetl Scwings from N1:RC's Description ~ Savtnps Ub4tie$ (indudes Communication9) 30.000 Mafntenance 20,000 1'ransportation - 70,QQ0 ~ • 20.000 I lS.nucc SctKxiISuppixtSuviaa-RntiCtusuieSiivingxCalcp2-I;_ti'; t]si 'ilic projcti:tcel recurring savings from clusure qfihc Pratt facility is therefbm calculated to tv • 5450,000 (S470,0)0 savings in personne) casts, less the $?O,UOfI additional ,vERC cost). Thiq suvings will nccruc to the District cach and cvery ycar that the facility retnains cfoscd. nbviou5ly. any use af the Facility wiU somewhai reducc the total savings, UIIICSC SUCh USC It1ClTIpUTHII'5 relocation of one or mon; of tlic Disirict's currenily leaxd facilities, which mny then offset the opctafing custs of such progrums, or possibly even add to the nverull savingg total. 1 able 13 - 7'otvl Projected Savirig.c Description ~ Savings ~ 5avings - Persannel Casts 470,000 Transporhation - 20,600 I - 45o,ooo I ti,iurc tiLt10u01 tiupp.)rt Scrvicrs - f'rntt Clusurc Sav m>_s l'.il.: 14 (i7 x1;1 i'nEc ? 3 ~i~- Part 111 - Assessmcnt Center Retucatiun General Infarmation 'rhe Studenl SuPjx)rt Seniccs Center (Astiessment Center) tivas established to pravide appropriate office space, clerical support, maintenance of special educatian records, and monitoring ofcampliance standards. The Center is localeti at 3102 E. Trent Ave. through a leasc arrangement. The rlssessmc,'nt Ccnter houses betwven 90-100 staf'F. Reyuests to move additional statTout of schuols and iutu the Center have not been possible due to space limitations and additiuna) cost for leased spac;r. l. Ilhe Center is the hub for the refcnal and asscssment of stude:nts to dete:rmine special education eligibility. Approximately 3,000 evaluations and re-evaluaiians are conducted annunlly. The Center images and maintains rrcordy for each special educatiun sludent. ReCorcis are maintained on 12,589 students, and currently entail 8$,945 ScParate documents, and 1,334.175 pagcs of documentation. 3. 'l'he Center provides clerical suppart for assessment and record keeping activities and generution of dra}t Inciividunl Education Programs (II:Ps) bascd on input and dircction ofccrtificated statTand administration. 4. The Center hausi:s a.:9sistive technology dcvelopmcot, repair, and support to studcnts and staff in the field. 5. The Center receives and disscminates curriculum materials ta s-pecial eductttion teachecs. Cost of Relocgtion Itclocation of Ass~essmcttt Ccntcr stafTtu the ['ratt lucilitv wuuld entail at Icasl somc minimal tenartt improvements tn bc ablc tu utilize an elementary cducaiional facility far an oflice environtvcnt. Such improvcments would be detsigncd nat to advcrsely impact thc District's ahi li 1. to return tbe Pmtt facitity to usn as a ncighborfiood school. Typical tenant improvements wuuld likely bc lighting modifications, additional data uipacity, installation of additioaat telephane lines, storage mudificalions, nnd the installatian of carpet in II any current classroam spaces thut would be converted for use by assessment staff, and thc instsillation of workspace partitions. 'iliere mgy also bc soma code myuired improvements neccssary once the City of Spokflne's building department reviews thc Uistrict's plans. Minimum tenant improvcments src calculatcd at S20 per syuare fout, and cnvisianed only for the 12,000 sq. ft. that is likely to be required For the :issessment siaff. This sum will allow t'or critical I' imprpvemenLs and mQdific;ations only, but wil) provide a fimctional space for the Assessment Center staff. incrtased off-strcet parking is 81so liRcly to be required.'1'wcnty dollars per square Cuut iti a vcry minimal amauni for typicul tcnant improvemenls. Ncw cunstruction is running in thc ncighbortuxod of $200 pcr squnre fout, and remuJcl pricing is coming in ix:twcen $140 and $ I bti per squan toat. 1'en7nt imprnvcmcnt.s an; typicnlly running botwcen $50 per squnrc foot Pagc 2•t ~ F~ - anJ $95 lxr square foot to maiify existing spaces for the specific needs and to the Ievel of finish cieemed appropriate by the entity utilizing the space. Thercfore, therc will not be sutTicient funds available to make substentive modifications to the spaces, nor to 'beautify' the interiur spacrs. The funds avsilnblc nre sofely for the infi-asiructure rcquircd to be able to opernte the program, and for basic necessities such ns pnrtitions and task apprapriatc lighting. Table 14 - Cvst oJ Terrunt Inrprovrmenl.s Arss Sixe New Remod Remod Ti TI Tt 0"1 (ikpt) (heavY) (kpt) (bere min) $200 $165 $110 S90 S50 S2D Maln 8uileing 21.424 S4,284,800 $3.53+1,860 $2,889.360 51,928,160 $1,071,200 5128,487 ~ R,elocalables 9,840 $1r968M 51,513.G00 ~t,377.600 885600 p 000 $t98.W Tdal 31.264 $6,252,80Q $5,158,560 $4,376,960 S2,813,780 51,563.200 5625.2BO Assessrrwt 1ZQ00 S'l.+IOO.OQO :1.660.= 51,680.000 $1.090,000 i800.000 S240,CA0 PW" tmm s261,365 - Mova Coals 516,500 f:fiT,Q6J ~ScHirx FaciliryServi~es-C~tafll'sf~wA~sessmcnttit~) 'rhe costs for additional parking are basod upun the District's most rocent pxrking projecLti at F3ancrott and Longfellow. Any ability to park diagonaliy a1ang any of the surruunding streets will potvntially rr.rlur,c the ovrrall expc;nditurc for pttrking irnprovements. This will, however, bc dependent on the City of Spokane Valley and their mquirements. Move costs werc rxlculated b3sed upon ra:ent contr-dets for the reloi:mtion of statTand prugrams fix the Ilost School progrxm. I Fhe total outlay for the rela,ation of the A.ssessment Center to the Pr-au tacility is expoctecl to be approximately 5517, 865. This expenditure will be out of the Capitnl Fund, and will nat have a Genaml 1=und impact. 'ihesc c:apitnl funds arc from the 2003 Bond issuc, and are pnrt of the Annual Capital Progrnm allor.eUion thxt is elcsibmcd to nllow tlic Districl to rcact tu changing nreds and rrquirecnents in our facilities and infrastructure. As Capital 1=und dollnrs cumat he ~ utiluxd for basic or special c.ducaticm purposcQ, thcy cxnnot bc uscd for saJarics, bencfits, supplies, materials, or sen•ices thnt directly svpport the educaiional process. Capital Nunds must, by la%v, hc utilized for iavestments in our fecilities. Tuble.• 15 - Suvings due to Relucutlvn ojAasessmrnt Crirrer to 1'rut! Eliminadon of Aasessment Ctr Lease 145.000 Elimination of Fibertfnk Leaso 12,000 Custodial Staff (0.5 FTE) (27.000) Maintenanoo of Facllity (10.000) Cost o1 Utdiiics (1 rl,QQg 105,000 _ »ouccr: Schanl Suppart Servioei (Ratt Clooure 5nvinLs Cii[c !j=• Ii-07 ,l_) Ilie mcurring s:iviiigs Crom relocating the Spccicil Education Assessment Center tu the Pratt facility is priijrctrd to tx; approximaiely S I U-5,000 annucslly. Pagc ?5 ~ Part 1V - Summary Fiscxl (nlp:+t t l'he recurring ssvuigs fruni twth clUSing I'ratt L-Icmcawn uiid refu,~atuig i1ic ti}xcial t=duL..~ Assessmcnt Ccnter to the Pratt Cacilitv is pmjected to tot$l appmximatety S550,055 annuiii 1 "I'a61p 16 - Eslimuled Grund Total af Suvings I Personnel 470,000 Utilities (includes communicatians) 30,000 Maintenance 20.000 Tr3nsportation (70,000) Net Savings from CFosing Pratt $450,000 Assessment Lease 145,000 Fibef Lease 12,05:~ Custodfel (0.5 FTE) (27,000 ~ Maintenance (10,000; Utilities (15,000, Net Savfnga from Relocating Assssament ~ y105,055 Eatlmated Grand Total from Doing Both ~ $550,055 ~ fSuurcc ScNxd tir,pixin titrvicca - Pr:ui Clusu:r 5nvuns-v ('alc 112 -154i7 tl+) USing the ty,ical business madel unalysis ol'tlie Retum an Invcslmrni (ROI) to assess the fiscaI viabilitr+ of the closurc of Prutt and the relocatiun c►f the Asscssment Center to the Pratt facilit~ ~ shows thnt the simple payback periad an t}ie initinl capital invcstmrnt is 1 1_2 ntonths. Anything undcr a 7 year ROI is considcrod tn bo worthwhile investment, and oftc:n n RC)1 of even 11 year~ <ir more is undensiken ifthe long-range use ofthe facility is be{ieved tt> hw.- wnrranted. ,1iz}ihini~ under n 3 ycur periud is cunsidered to be an cxtremcly KcxA investment. It should again hc nat«l that the initial invcstment in relocating t!w :1~~c~~;<<.:nt t'cntc,, an jilie tenant impmvements roquirr.d to make tlhe relocation to Pratt viablc, HouW cume uut ol' Carital Fund dollats, and not impact the Gencral Fund. ~j T~rble 17- Reltinr orr hweslntenl $517,865 Totel Cost of T"enant Improvements $555,055 Rewmng Annual Sa, - , < - 0.933 Simpio Paybar,k Fot ' 11.196 Simple Faybacic Peri r- j',' iSuui.e: Fscd~tv tirn icc- tr.t .,I I l 5.. , 1'are Zh ~r.z A simple saving.s calculation (which does not includc an), inflationar}• adjustnient Factur) shuws the total accrued saviogs - if the Pratt facility remains closeci and the Assessmcnt Ccntcr is aperated ai that location - wil) catal over $1.6 millian in thme year,, over $2.7 million in 5 years, nearl}• $3.9 million in 7 years, and $5_5 mitlion in 10 yeurs_ Tuble !R ?llultiple Year .9ccrued Scrvings I I Savinga Period Total3avings 3-Year Simple Savings Total $1,665,165 5-Year Simple Savings Totat $2,776,275 7-Ysar Simp{e Savings Total $3,885,385 10-Year Simple Savings Total $5,550,550 (Scarra: 5chaA SuMxt Services - F'tari 0.35urc 5xvmg+ t alr 02- I S-(17.i1v) Impact on Studeat Capacity Anothrr considcratiQn is whethtr the closurc nf Prett ElementFw will negate the District's ability , to implemrnt fult-dxy kinde;rgarten. AS ShDR'it by the CI1AR f1CIQW, dle maximum capacity at the elementary level curreatly is 17,400 studrnis (gtades K thruugh 6). 'llhe (ktober 2006 enroltment count shaws e cument student enrollmcnt at the elementary level of 14,756. Tliis Ic.wes an sdditional capacity of 2.64-1 studcnts syslcm widc. ('hart 11-.4vuiluble (_'apwilv at the Elcmentary 1.e1•el ; r~a d L. Lo ~;,D~ 1!f QI) ~ - - - ' -1 - - - , . - I - - i~ 13.~ : - - - - - 17,WU - - - - - - - 11,5CA - - - - - - ! 11,~~ - - ! !QmU ~ - - - - 74om - ~ - - - - 9,tlm - - - - - - L.GM - - - RSCD - - - - - - - dnoo fl - - - t - - - 1 r.soo - - - - - - - - am S.5C] - - - - - - - ( I 1 :tOC1) - - - - - - ~_i ♦500 - ~ - - - - - - ~ 3,~XD - ~ - - - - ~ zsao I - - - - - - - f n i~n eem o~f, r -j t'UUD I- - - •N1pkK ~_p~Wqt'sdff~rn/"TEus+r at! mmza aw- aI- ~m- rn- T~ rr •Yri+ ~~wr~ wV~/ ~lr I'~~ oav ...a.i' I:Stwrec Hudget e4 Accuunting - Afl-dny Ktnd Capsciry LM Pagn 27 . ~ Thc clusurc of Pratt Elementary will recluce thc Disvict's totni elementury capacity by 350. Therefore, using our pmjected Ociuber 2007 enrollment of 14,776, our eIementary capecity for gowth will be 2,274 studrnts. A quick calculatiun of the number of kinsiergarten c[assrooms that would be rcquired if all schools implemented a full-dny kindergatten prograin indicates that we woutd ttr.cd an additional 50 kindergnrtcn classrooms. Fifty kindergarten classrooms would equatc tu u studcnt capacity of 1,250_ This would leave an additiunal capacity of 1,024 students system wide, which should providc sufficient capacity for growth at the etementary level until wc: are able to modemite additional clcmcntary schocil sites as part ofthe 2009 Band Issue. (t should bc noted, howcver, that this is a system-wide look at availublc capacity, and diere may well he individuat schools tfiat will not easily bc ab(c to implemeni full-day kindcrgarten, or nu:cpt additianal growth widtin their cwrent altendance areas. T'tus may nquire additional modifications tu eleinentary sr.hool atiendance areas at samc futurc: datc. Fcstsibility C'losure of 1'ratt Elementarv In the opiniun of thu Taskforee it is icidecd fc,asible tu close Pratt Elemcntciry snd madify the attendance area baundaries of Sheridan und Lincoln Hcights elementary schools to uccammodate the Pratt students. llie rccommendation to close Prari L-:lementnry is prujc,*cted to save S460,000 per yeur, and this sAVings will bc rerurring, and thus uccumulato uver timr. hCIT(:: ('lusun of Pratt will not precludc :ill-duy Kindergarten. Kelucntion of Assessmcnt Centcr [n the opinion of the Taskforce it is indeed f'easible to retur.atc ihr Asscssment Center to tlle Pratt facility, and to bnse operaLions of thnt unit at the Pratt locatian. Thc ra:ammendation to nela;ate the Special Education Assessment Center is projected to save $105.000 per yeur, und this srivings wil) bc n;curring so long as the Assessment Ccntcr is 1ocxlyd in Distriet-otvned facilitit-s and there is no lease fcr. n, Inn4 ns this is the ca-se tlic savings will acctrmulate over time. N01-E: Additiana) supFsort scrviccs oc prograrns sucii as M.ar or che scienGe hit ('enter - Could also be located at Pratt, savins; the District additional doUurs. I " . CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY ' ' . Request for Council Action Meeting Date: April 3, 2007 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent ❑ old business ❑ new business ❑ public hearing ❑ information (2) admin, report ❑ pending legislation AGENDA ITEM TITLE: International Trade Alliance Presentation GOVERNING LEGISLATION: PREVIOUS COUNCIL ACTION TAKEN: BACKGROUND: New ITA Executive Director Roger Johnson will introduce himself, and give a brief update on the International Trade Alliance. . OPTIONS: RECOMMENDED ACTION OR MOTION: BUDGETIFINANCIAL IMPACTS: . STAFF CONTACT: ATTACHMENTS: . . , Intcrnational Trade Alliance Page 1 aF2 r I'~,t e it . .l~.~llC~' sPo~:t Ni6ar x,ataur. Nkar pirEovt. ome ~ About ITA I Board of Directors I Events I Members I Join ITA I Contact Us I Exporting 101 1 Resources AbOUtI'I'A Mission Statement The lnfematrona! Trade Alrrancs providss leadersHi,a in connecting !nland Northwesf busincssos ►vifh gtobaf markets +vnife provrdrng; resources to Qnharrce awaranoss and compGPrtivaness. Everywhere rre tum, we see the effects of a worid made much smaller through advanced teclmology, increased cultural evrareness and expanded disbursement of knovrledge. Our abflity to function, both socialty and professionally, is dependent upon our real'2atian that we live in a global soaety that is rnuch larger than the Inland Northwest and even the United 5tatas. It has become vitaliy important for companies to explore the »ossibility of iniemational trade. Trade is no longer just for largor companies. It is for virtually any company, regardless of size, that has a product or service to market end s desire to expand. How can the International Trade Alliance help you? As the region's only non-profit organization exclusively facussd on intemational businoss, the Intemational Trade Alliance (ITA) connects regfonal oompanies with marisets worldwide. It partners with business, govemment and ather organizations to increase interrtational trade in this region. The ITA opEns doors to internatconal business opportunities through sn extensive, esEablished network of domestic and foreign relationshfps with blic and private organ'rzateons. It conducts trade missions and hosts foreign visitors interested in establishing stronger tios tivith Intand .rorthwest firms. "Inland Northwost companies serious about grotivth know that signific9nt new opporiunities exist in the global maifcetptace," says Roberta grooke, I7A Executive Direcfor. "We have established relaUonshfps that allow us to oonnecR businesses at home with decasion-makers worbdwide." The Inland Northw2st 2verages more than $447 million in non-agricuitural, non-senriCe exports each year. (Source: U.S. Dopt. of Commerce) Spokane-area companies also rely on the ITA as the region's go-to resource for the information necossary to doing business fn the global . marlcetplace, accessing knovrledge and oxportiso that saves companies time and expense. 7he I7A's proficiencies span the fufl range of internsGonal business topics, providing acoess to extensnre services and assistance programs. A large portion of the ITE1 mission is to assist businesses vrith developing a marketing plan. The planning procoss indudes conduGfing market research to match markets with the company's product or service. • As an informaEion clearinghouse, the ITA helRs oompanies solve problems, overcome barriers and identify opportunities. These benefits are especialty important to the smaq- and mid-sized companies that dominate the Inland Northvrest economy. "In foreign marfcets, Vade organizations like the I7A and govemment conduits have high recognifion and value," says eill Hogoboom of Jones Double Reed, which tapped the ITA's expertise to expand its reed manufacturing business into Europe. "Their credibility and established nehvorks opened doors that would have taken me months to find independently.' . Formed in 1996 as a public-private partnership, the ITA is an economic development tool that helps Inland Northvrest firms capture aompetiiive advantages in the global marftettplace. It plays a leading role in promoSng regional infrastruclure improvements thai encourage broader intemational trado, and is dedicated to helping Inland Nor4hvresi residents unders4and the significant econamic benefits of increasing intemational Uade and globalizalion. • e goal of the 11'A is to establish foreign relationships, nehvork with domestic and foreign trade associates, and create Ues to govemmant. Justry, and cultural organizations. The ITA has built a strong foundetion of financial support from both the public and private sQCtors, and provictes seivioas to members in 12 counties that reach awide range of business sectors. hAembers indude such companies as Avista, Itronix, Bank of America, Itron, WagstaH, http://ww~v.intracie.org/intrade/sub.aspr?id=1835 3/29/2007 [nternationall`rade Alliance Page 2 eF2 Jones IaoublQ Reed, Lee & Hayes PI.LC, UnitEd Coatings, Kim Hotstart, Spokane International AirpoR, and Whitvrorth College. Inland Morthtivest ITA partners include the Ciry of Spokane, Washington State GTED, Ciry of Spokane Vel3ey, Spokane County and the City of Liberty Lake. ~ \1 The ITA measures its impact through thc sucoess of msmber firms campeting in intemational markets. Kim Hotsfart, which manufactures pre- heaters that keep diesel-powered engines v:arm and ready to slart, is one exampte. Locomot+ves, emergency generators and other large pieoes of equipmenE save fuel expenses and reduoe pollution with such devices. Kim Hotstart executives tumed to tho ITA for assistance to expand lhe firm's internaiional presence. `MeeGng with other Spokane-based businesses doing intemational trade through lhe ITA is particularly helpful as wall, because it creates a strong nehvork and professional association of peoplE who are in our business, alihough noi necessarily our industry," says Trond Liaboe, Intemational hlarket h4anager for Kim Hotstart. "IYs import2nt that the ITA is pufting international business on the table because iYs one of the keys to helping this region prosper economicalty.' Read about Spokane companies who have succeeded internationally with the help of the ITA: E.C. Ryan Esterline Advanced Input Systems Itronix Jones Double Reed Kim Hotstart I'Aanufacturing Stcelhead Specialty Minerals United Coatings Wagstgff Home I Contact Us I About Us I Site Disclaimer m Copyright 2002, Intemational Trade AOiance ftvvo,ov Ov (509) 459-4123 801 West Riverside, Suite 220, Spokane. Washington 99201 Suite ROCKEY HI LI ' `11ULTON _ .~http://~~~N,NA,.intrade.org/intrade/sub.aspx?id=l 835 3/29/2007 International Tradc f111iance Page 1 of 2 `E KAN Iltet'natloIla. ~at E i, tance sP,a .N ct. 4ome I About ITA I Board of Directors I Events I Members I Join ITA ~ Contact Us ~ Exporting 101 ( Resourccs 2006 InYernatinnal Tw•ade Alliauce Board of llirectors Euecutive Committee President Terry Judge Krm Hotstart PAanufacturing Past President Steve Helmbrecht Itron Vice President Tom Reese Black Rock f?2velopment . • Secretary Michael Senske Pearson PaGkaging Systems Treasurer Ken Parkes Wagstaff @oarc~M~¢Ll~ Joe Ball 'Iron atL Ewers mland Empire Distribu6ion Systems , Matt Gerber . Itrona Warren Gross ' Export Finance As.sistanoe Center of Vlashing#on Paul Hamacher Zak Designs Bill Hogeboom Jones Double Reed Wally McGregor Steelhead Specialty Minerals _ Brian Pangrle Lee 8 Hayes PLLC MaryLou Thomas Triumph Composito Systems . Keith Trefry Paine, Hamblen, Cofiin, Brooke & Milier LLP Ex Off-icio Ben Cabildo AHANA Janet Daubel US Export Assistance Cent2r Jon Eliassen Spokane Area Economic Develapment Council Cody George City of Spakane Eldonna Gossett Greater Spokane Valley Chamb2r of Commerco _ Rich Hadley • iokane Regional Chamber of Commerce :rry Lawhead Washingtor► Stafo CTED County Commissioner Todd Mielke Spokane Couniy Jason Munn httn:/Av,,v,,v.iiitrade.orgJintradelsub.aspY?id=2222 3i29l2007 International Trade Alliance Page 2 of 2 PAoss Adams LLP Councitman Rich Munson Ciry of Spokane Valley Lewis Rumplor Institute for Systems Madiane ~ Bill Staffiord 7rade Developmont Allianae of Greater Seatlle Ed Tsutakawa hAukogawa Fort Wrighsi Institute Kyle Usrcy WhiN+north College Hqme I Contact Us I About Us ~ Site Disclalmer 9) Copyright 2002, Intemational jrade Alliance (549) 459-4123 801 West Riverside, Suite 220, Spokane. Wast~ington 99201 ~O'"~r~`~~ . ~ InSuite bank. ~ Ypur~rrcei~'s::O.nir.tt3Ql~ ° - http://4«vw.intradc.org/intradc/sub.aspx?id=2222 3/2912007 CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY _ Request for Council Action Meeting Date: April 3, 2007 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent ❑ old business ❑ new business ❑ public hearing ❑ information 9 admin. report ❑ pending legislation AGENDA ITEM TITLE: Update on Spokane County Jail GOVERNING LEGISLATION: PREVIOUS COUNCIL ACTION TAKEN: BACKGROUND: Jail Commander Jerry Brady will give a brief report on the current conditions of the Spokane County Jail; and answer questions Council may have concerning the jail. . / OPTIONS: RECOMMENDED ACTION OR MOTION: BUDGET/FINANCIAL IMPACTS: STAFF CONTACT: ATTACHMENTS: ~ ~ CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY Request for Council Action Meeting Date: April 3, 2007 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent ❑ old business ❑ new business ❑ public hearing ❑ information 0 admin. report ❑ pending legislation AGENDA ITEM TITLE: Proposed Amendments to the 2007 Budget. GOVERNING LEGISLATION: State law requires a public hearing and an amendment to our budget when the City expects to exceed appropriations. The public hearing is scheduled for April 10, 2007. PREVIOUS COUNCIL ACTION: The City budget for 2007 was adopted in November of 2006. BACKGROUND: - , Budget adjustments are needed to: 1) transfer $1,746,000 to the Civic Facilities Reserve Fund; 2) transfer $161,000 to the Service Level Stabilization Fund to•maintain operating service levels during reduced economic activity; 3) adjust revenue sources to anticipated levels; 4) update the budget for programs- and projects carried over from prior years; 5) pay increased council ' salary/benefit costs; 6) pay copy/printing costs in excess of staff's prior estimates; 7) budget for town center real estate consultants; 8) budget for Beverly Hills storm water project; 9) budget for development engineering & surveying review; and recognize the General Fund 15% reserve. A more detailed listing of the proposed budget amendments is attached as Exhibit A. OPTIONS: Op4ions include amending the budget, amending the budget for some of the changes or making no amendments. The budget should be amended to comply with Washington State law. RECOMMENDED ACTION OR MOTION: Continue with budget progression, including holding public hearing April 10, 2007. BUDGET/FINANCIAL IMPACTS: Passage of an amended budget ordinance at a later council meeting will provide the authorization to move ahead with these programs. STAFF CONTACT: Ken Thompson, Finance Director Jason Faulkner, Accountant/Budget Analyst ._.,1 ~ ..,,A • , AMENDMENTS TO 2007 BUDGET - "i•',~'~. ...t ~ 1.., APRIL 3, 2007 r'" KEN THOMPSON k''•y',-~` JASON FAULKNER ~ ~ AMENDMENTS TO 2007 BUDGET, Continued . Programs/projects carried over from 2006 • Transfer to Civic Facilities • Transfer to Service Level Stabilization ' ~~'.r;. • Copy/printing costs Council updated salaries/benefits ~ ~ • Town center consultant . - ft~S'~ • Beverly Hills storm water project • Recognize General Fund operating reserve • Increase development review-eng., survey 1 ~ City of Spokane Valley Exhibit A Amendments to 2007 Budget Aprll 2007 REVENUE EXPENDITURE Fund . INCREASE INCREASE Exp±anafion 001 Unrestricled fund balance $ 7,068,000 Increase beginning fund balance 001.032.000.532.20,41.05 $ 77,000 Public Vk'ks road star~cfards: JUB 001.059.000.322.10.91 139,000 Irvcrease developmern tee esti+rwts 001.032.000.532.20.41.02 74,000 PYJ devalopment review assistance 001 A58.000.558.60.41.05 65,000 Dovclopment scrvoccs assWarrco :or C.D. 001.090.OdD.397.43_00 • 35,000 7ranster from Street Fund . SRTC . 001.058.000.558.60_41A5 50,000 Real Estate ConsRtltanis - tovm center . ~ur~,r tmnsicr~; 001.090.006.597.19.00.01 1,746,000 Meet goal f-~r Civic Pacilities 001.090.000.597.19.00.02 161,000 Meat goal for service level stabilizetian Other. 001.011.000.511.60.10.00 31,000 Council salaries 001.011.000.511.60.20.00 3,000 Council bcneets Various gen fund copy/printing costs 35,000 Copy 6 prtnttng cast adJusimern Cash 8aw reserve 5,000,000 To moet 1596 resenre goal Total General Fund $ 7,242,000 $ 7,242,0,00 101 Street Fund Unrestricted fund balance $ 238,000 101A42.004.542.10.411.02 S 44,000 Transportatiooping. Cen?ury lh'est 1011.042000.542.10.4i_05 197,000 SUeetmastcrpaan JUB 101.042.004.542.10.41.05 38,000 road stenderds JUa 101.042.000.542.10.41.05 9,000 lOSanalysis DEA Total Street Fund $ 238,000 $ 236,000 303 Street Capital Projects sRTc $ 277,000 , TIi3 & Develope,s 343,000 Pine.sJmansfield $ 620,D00 carry over 2006 pro)ecc RE ET2 243,000 Vera Terrace (Step) 133,000 Carry over 20D8 piaject Verad81e Heights (Sfep) 110,000 carry ovor 200s pcoject Total Street Gapital g 863,000 S 863,000 307 Capital Grant Projects Arterial St. $ 270,000 S RTC 1, 730,000 Aoplevray - Tschirley to Hodges $ 2,000,000 2007 phaso II projeci 7ofal Capital Grant Fund $ 2,000,000 2,000,000 Severai other 2006 prcjects cartied over but no adustment needed tn 2007 hudget 402 Storm Water Fund Unrestricted fund bal, $ 340,0-00 402.402.000.597.00.55.03 S 340,000 Beverty hills projcu Total Storrn Water Fund S 340,000 S 340,000 GRAND TOTALS---> 5 10,683,000 $ 10,683,000 ~ CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY Request for Council Action ~ . Meeting Date: April 3, 2007 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent old business new business ❑ public hearing information X admin. report ❑ pending legislation . AGENDA ITEM TITLE: Amendment to animal control regulations GOVERNING LEGISLATION: SVMC 7.30 and SVMC 7.35 PREVIOUS COUNCIL ACTION TAKEN: The Council amended the City's dangerous dog regulations in advance of these changes earlier this year. At that time, staff advised the Council that #hese additional changes would be made. BACKGROUND: The attachments to this RCA represent a renumbering of two chapters from . Spokane County Code to the numbering protocol utilized by the City. At the City's date of incorporation, the City adopted County Code sections 5.04 regulating dogs and cats, and 5.12 regulating inherently dangerous mammals and reptiles. As you know, the City has a contract with SCRAPS to provide animal control. A requirement of the contract is that the City adopt County code provisions for animal control. As the Council may recall, a change in state law around the time we incorporated required the ~i City to adopt its own appeal provisions for dangerous dog cases. As a result of that, it made little sense to have a portion of the City's animal regulations in County Code, and part in City Code. City staff has been working on this conversion. Additionally, City staff has been working with County staff to work on a general clean up and update of the code provisions for the benefit of both entities. We are attempting to keep our Code provisions as close to the County's as we can for ease of use by the SCRAPS staff under the contract. My intent on the redline versions as they move forward is to show you in this first touch all of the changes from what the County has notiv. On the second touch, it would show any revisions the Council has, in addition to the changes noted in the first touch. For the second reading, everything proposed to be the new regulations will be in redline, since it will all be new in the re- numbered system and as our Code. Please note that these drafts also have highlighting on text that pertains to fees of any kind. All referencss to fees will be removed and placed in the Master Fee Schedule concurrent with the final adoption of the amendments identified herein. OPTIONS: Approve as drafted, or instruct staff to make additional changes. RECOMMENDED ACTION OR MOTION: Council consensus to place an ordinance on an upcoming Council agenda for a first reading BUDGET/FINANCIAL IMPACTS: Anticipated to be revenue neutral. ' STAFF CONTACT: Cary P. Driskell, Deputy City Attorney ~ ATTACHMENTS: Proposed changes to animal control regulations. i<< is the publ;c policy of,:% ptkttpetit% tu sccurc and maintain such Ievcls ut control over inherently dangerous mammals and inherenily dangerous reptiles hsrtwred :ind/ur uwned within the f;►tn~.i--~-t=~=.~Wj~r-i-,;.~•, as will protect the benernl humnn hcaltli, safety and welfare as well as provide for the humane housing, carr and treutment of such animals. To this end, it is the purpose of this chnpter to provide a means of licensing, housing and caring of inhcrcntly dangerous mammals _3nt1 irihtrcii Il~ d111~Cfilll-~ fc(?l1IeS S(1 (}lai !~tfl'}t :1'11i11nk ijo Iliit 1-,C'oi71i• rf1111C 'llil'=:1'1CC~. it Ul'Gp1liUI1S. Ihe following words, terms and phrasts, %v hen uscd in d) is chrsp trr, shal! ha<< thc meaninss ascrihed tn them in this section, exccpt where the context clrarl~ i~ii~~,~trsa . ~i11~T11i1 ~~`I;iit~) cj.'~~;iftliltTll , !11C.l1'1~ 1~l.ll ~jC(~.ilUll~-111 C4l'.!l?11511Ed by tht' ~ Ii~F~c.t:.r•i ct?-t~=~-:if=:t it~iF?ui~'~_''i~-~li• Tric;i}t2tt+i3 t'r Cllili~ '~>>-the c'ity to administcr and ent'orce the provisions of this chaptcr. lt. -_kfe*4ofdeparnnent ead shall bo refernsd to hereinaRer as the "animal control directur" anSnjil nrutection ciircrtur'or "I?irrrtur." :'1n ".qIijr31 control oifice," or "anin:_ ;)roteetian officrr" is anti ancrson desiaiatcd hN thr am~ftal eefi! JDirritur witli _imiini law egt'orLCment commission for t e u se of administerine or aidiU in . ~cilorrcment~f this charstrr at- " ' ~ Aft . Ti_'- tlt~fliS~Cri?~i -i-f-tiidifii . - . . . , ' ' --l -:xhibit" means to show or display either puH irl.. ~,r l~riti ar~i~ . "Ilousehold member" mcunsa person related by blood, marria.ge, ac1oE~i:(W. ::j .:71: oihcr pzrsnn residing on the premises with a person harboriniT ancf`nr tn >>Sliemntly dangemus mammal ancllor inlicrcntly dangeruus rcptile. "lnhercntly dnngerous matnmal" means any live member ~11 lI}t' ar i.:L: families, including hyhrids thereof, which. Jut• ?o ihcll ~il~?CI'iI'I 1?:~~~;n_•. rr,:~~ fn,.id,:r,:d dangerous to humans, and which includcs- l. C'anidae means and inc:ludes any memher oi llie dug (canid) iani i!~. custoniarily domesticAted by man, or any hybricis thereot; but not incluJil dDII1eStIC d0$5 (C3I11S IU(tii; 1% it Wolf and a damcstic do: 2. Pelid.ae means und il~~ domestic::strd by m;in. c>i• :uiy llybrici, tltereot, bilt not I11CIltdllli; ~:Il(]1L'lTil' l'i3IS Dratl C'odr Ch;in,r•, f':st~L IiNf iK I I. l;rsidze mc;ins and includes any member uf ille hc:ar tauuly, or any hybrids thereof. "Inherently dangerous reptitc" means any live member ofthe class reptilia which: L Is venomous, incluciing, but not necessarily limited to, all members of the lolluwina famiiies: I3elodermidne; Vip::ticl:ic; (_'rotalidac; :11tr;tctatiPidcte; {{ydrorliifiii;ic: a!id l-l<ipidrir: or !s a"rc.tr fano:cd- -~uakr ()C tl;C I1imi!} ( 0111hridtliat arc he dangerous to humans, including, hut nut nec:essarily limitc;J to, all R3embi:rx of tlie fullowin.p I_1iililieS: f)k'plioli:lii,; typus: Thehtc,mi: kirtlandii: atid RhahdoPhi:. ,Pp_; ,;i 3. fs a n3eiiiber ut' tlic urdcr ('<owdilia (crowdilcs, all%ators anci ca►inLUi►. "Hurboring of an inherently dangerous mammal and/or inhrrently dangerous reptile" means to tillow an inhercnlly dangerous mammal or inherentEy dangerous reptile ta rc:mtiin, lodge, be Ced, or to be given sheltcr or reCuge within the En:rson's home, sture, yurd, cuclosure, outbuilding, absndoned vchicle or buildiniz, plaec; of business, or any' oihcr prrmisc s in %tiltich the prnou resides or over «hic:h thc rersoil has cuntrtil. ",25.03p;-.12 .+1:) Ruoningat largc -+1u►% tti itr-i iti\ :inirual cot;tr•+~I tic.p:irtrnt. flt - ~ io ation. ~ l. No persan uw1ning or harbori►», huvi»g custody, c;rmtrol, or posscssion of an inhcrently dangerous mnmmal anci/or 3ny ulherently dangerous tcptile shall pcrnut or ullow tlic swnc to tun ut lnrge upon any highway, strcet, tnne, nlley, coure, Qr uny other place, public ar private, or witlun the premises af such pcrson, lil such t11a11111'1' :1s to cndanger nny person Invvf'ully cntering such premises. E{ A.il\ DtCS0E1 0\1111112 UI' lidfL)oIIfiL. IldtlllLY L115I~~t1~. 4~o+ilft-`I. k:ff UU••CS~i~•il 01 ~-jierentlv dnncerou.ti mammal and or anv in};rrZntI', danecrous rentile 5hall have !I•r d•.~~ . •~'1ol11V ti1C.31ijni,0 ~•~iii};o~ ,(_•^.iI1(~i~~~i ~~f'C'1 !f'~~ :~i~['~\l' fi( jf'i(~l.°~ij rr~;r.~:~hl~• l-" i i ~ ~-,-ntlv dan: • ' _ ; ; :3 ~t~i•,,l~tl'':iti~r. liarburingj,,%vniut; inhcrcnll\ d:ingcruu, rnamiti:31s andllir inhcri•ntly dan^ernus rclifil«. I)ratZ Cc,Jc (,hangcs {'<ige 2 ~~t* 18 hall be a violatinn of this chnpter for any pcrson to harbor andlor awn an inherenily llgcraus marnmal andlor any inherently dangerous reptilc unless such pxrson has iiieved the uge af eighteen yetirs and obtaincd and maintnined an annu:il liccnsc .~:i,~wing that perscm to harbor and own sueh inherently dangerous mammal anci/ur ii;lierently dangerous replile as provided fur in this chapter. Provided, however, anv P_rson who has achieved tbe age of cighteen years of age or over, and who is hxrbarin-1 and/or owning an inherently dangerous itianunal andlor an inhercnUy dnngemus reptile un the effective ciate of the otdinanre cudified in this chapter shall have a sixty-d;3N, time ~ 1imme in which to obtain a licensc from :r:,-nal I a arboring xnci/ar owning an inhereatly dangerous mammal and'or an uilierent 1y rcptilc by a pcrson under thc age of ei:rlltccn ycars of 3!.*e tir «itliouI in ar}1?!i;;1 I _ ,+i . •i F'xcmPtions. l'he following are exempt tCU[Il all 1111-~ ~~L!j~!tC t•ti:Cc;(1: 1~~I1t~i1'i I f 1_ 3_ Any fucility accreditcd by the Assaciaiion of Zoos and Aquarnm> > (.V,1 i; ~ E2,f _Any liccnsed or accreditecl research or meilical insritutinns: I'.lclre<<1t'f,d l'_i!1c :filol:,fI lli'rlllllilI )ti>: -9 VctetitI ary clinics iu pl)sSC:-,s;t~l: kii, inl;rrrntlti L1a1:;•trOUs IfIaI :Mi.:1; r•;inherently ciangerous reptiles for ete:il11'.L'lll O1- _'I'raveling circuses or camivnls: 6 1- Persnns trmporarily tmnsportinb inherently dangci-ous mitmrnals or ir.herently dangerous reptiles thr„ugh thc M.providcd tht31 the transit tirnk: :~k::il: nnt hC m,,;c th:it~ tl~r~~~ ~f.►',~: u __s 49 A. + . ._~~€t-s-~~►~►{~3~81ris4E3f}':-i!~-~. - - , . - -4?444-kt'3 4h-i appk ;Y' ~;ifeh ~i't'l'it.5~if}~ Ei.4iYtl}-. Although the above are exempt from the provisions af this chapter, tbey mnst comp; . vvith all other appiicable federal, siate and loc;al regulations, includiUg but not neces':- „ ~ l!Rll!t_ii in • f'tt''-'? 1( S~ r'f~?- . CnP('r>TTllrw f~i` l)f'.itt CoSC ch:l!lg1'S p 3' t ; o t ~ .14 ~ ~►ri ~r~~ U~~r u~ti~i a~i iiihe~ntiy License Applicatic~n l~cirm. T~~ c~btaici a licrnsi: w liarlior -inL dcuigerous mammal andlur an inlierently dangcruus reptilz within the ~~k-di t~~ ~-~~~~-~=_=~~=t•, a pcrson shalt afuivally make a written and campleted application which shall include the following: 1;- All intormation requested an thc application form rcquired by the ~,,;t-!'.S -animal control ziI}irector as decmed necessary thcreby to assist w determining whether the liceiise should be issued, including but not necessarily liinited to, front and profile photagraphs as well a.s any existing identificaiion, such as tnttooing and micro-c4upping of the inherently dangemus mammal and/or inherenUy dangerous reptile; ~ Altach to tlzc completed application 1'orm proof of liability insurance in the :uuount of tifty thousand dallan per inUerently dangerous manunul and/nr iincercnily dangerous reptile up to a marimuin of three huncired thousand dollars, which shall bc; written to eover aiyy acts of tlu; inherently dangerous uismmal andlor inherently dangecous reptitc, ccrtiFcate of insur-ance sh,all be immediately submitted to the ~K•~~~-~--t-~J~r animal control A>irectar for approval or disapprovat, and which rrcwf of liability insurunce shall pruvide thut the (=~~L=~:4-animal control 3(?irec:tor as the persan ta be notified ten days in advance o!'the rancellc3lion of the liability insurtuice for any reason; ,3-_Atlach and/ur enclose a non-rel'unciablc license application fec L, esiablished parsil resolution_ +_~i t!tr_ LOlir"11_ .•~-~•:~-sttft}t~--dc1ilftf.a--~~-stlhefeptl --ddjfe-~-~~~#---.:--t~i~~ft+~tt~~ . --Pef r-er .-~IJrr-_ +:~d_%Hffii►-.4,+tte--hundfec#-fi##,,-~~I&-, pefLad~#rv,,; an(i ~ 4_, _Submit to an initial inspection of the pre►jiisc; \%hcre the inhercntly dungerous mammal and/or inhen:ntly c.(:it%crous rcptilc proposed to hc harborecl. Eirior to the license being issucei, and to additional inspections, announced ur unannounced at the d1?irrctor's discretion, at any other time decmed necessary b~ the dUirectur bctwcen the hours of scvcn a.m. and nine p.m. daily during the litc tif the macnmel atidlor rcpti(e; said iiLSpcction to bc: pcrformcd by the d1)irector. any animal eontrot 4ifec4,.-r,,t:ior any person desigmated by tbe d1?irector tc) assist in the pcrformance of the inspectiou which is perfornicd in accordance with ~ of this chapter. ~ 1v'v license shall be issued by the d!)irector unless and until the applicant is in COI11p113I1CC with all of the provisions af iliis chapter, including, but aot neces.Sarily limited to tbe standarcls for hou4ing and care es set forth in Section -~.QRO of this chapter and the premises andlor property upon which the application for a licensc to harbor and/or own an inhcrcntty dangerous mrimmal ancUor inhcrcntly dangerous reptile is properly zA)ned for such uselxctivity. The licen5ee shall submit a writlen st3teuient from the Spukane ~i- ~=iz;~-'-,' llla9t dYC Dratl C'ocle ('hannes Pa`te 1 cit~ 19 . usela+etivity complics «•ith applicablc rc~ning 1av-N. All licenses shall 4x eftcctivr a one-ycar time fmme from the date of issunnce. 13`I.icense Ivot Tcansferable. Any licensc; to harhor andlovm any inhc:mnily dangemu5 niammal and/or inhcrcntly dangerous rcptile is nvt transfernble ta any othcr subsequent uwner/harborer ar to any othcr lucation withi.n the_Ci,.~ufaneafated--afe-a License Not to be issued. The Spekme--a +--animal cantrol dl)irector shnll not process or issue any liccnse to: +l.}-_any person charged or found guilty of Section ,-;4-2.430 either before or nRcr the adtiption of this subsection; ,2+ any person who is s housc:hold member of a person churged or Found guilty of violating Scxtion 7a.?~422.Q30 either bcfore or eRer the aciuptioa of 14e ift-this subsection; or t 3. __.any person For thc harboring and/or o%%ming an inhzrcnlly dangemus mammal and/or inherently dangerous rcptile which mammal or reptile has been the subject of a chargc ur violatinn under Section 5P_.030 either before or after the adopeian of thi,, 4:3tit+n. [n the event that a licen.se is being processed or has been issued prior ta the effectir•c date of tbe adoption ot' this iunendment, such processing shall be terminaled and/or license issued shall automatically be tt;voked by the ?~~•n~~=~u}-animal convol ;Uirector and the appeal rights of the licensee set forth in Scction 'a.,;-Q, lOUt~-;:1 shsll aot be applicable to such tcrmination and/or revor,aiion. ~ 7 zS.070-94?-,0,0 RcACwal of licenses. ~1,4:aA_-The license to keep an inherendy dttngernus mammal and/or inherently ciangcrous nplile shall bc renewed tuinually, un or befor tIit; date of issuaucc, upon the submissiun of'tin annual reaewal fee : s IW_IS2P:lF'diC CC~VlULiV(1 t'I (Ill: Cll%iiam ~T-f1CF , . _ , t14liflt---~~lft~t! addfe%; - lhi!`:rpef-tf4ht'f , dengeraus zz>~.zt- a'dfes* htindft4j fl-ti-jt'l All renewals shall requirc a curnent im-pectioa and submission af current information as ~provided for in 5cction 573~';4-2.060f-a-4a0 i and t21. ~.Y--B_'fhe animal coutrol departmcni shall notify the licensee by mAil nat less thnn oac munth beforc lhe expimtion of thc liccnsc of its renewnl fee and annual inspection are ~ due. ~1:1 C Atiy rondition imposcd on the anprnvul ur renctval of the lirensc shalt bc strictly Ura11 Cude Change: {'age i of 18 ~ Cl f: \ f E adherzd tu by the appIicant`licensee wid 1'aiture to do so c:onstitutes c;ausc for non- ~ issuance, non-renewal, ur immcdiate cevocation uf the license. ~t-~t U. T-he animal control depurtment shall mai.ntain a rccord of ehe date of issuance of, the condi4ons imposed on, and the name and address of the person to wham a licensc has ~ 6een issuecl pursuant to this sectiutL ~+z+-f . . It shall be u violation of this chapter for any persart to fail to renew an annual license for an inherently dangerous mammal and/or inhereutly dangerous rcptile. Failurc to renew an annual license for an inlierently danberous marncnal nncVor an inherently ~ dangerous reptile is a misdemcanor. ~i=~! I Liceasc Not to Be Renewed. 'Ihe ;pAinfie k:'•-tt-4~_~~nt F-E4 1-dDirector may. at lus/her sale disrretiun, not proc:ess ur issue the rcncwml of any liccnse under this section to any licensee failing to camply with any (iccnse conditiotis or any other prcivisiuns of this chaptcr. ~,.?~.!►~i~~.-1 Standards for huusing and carc. , Huusing and Care u!' Canidae and I lybrids -I hcreot'. A harborcr andlnr wwmcr of any inherently ciangerous caniciae and hybrids thereaf shall comply with the foIlowing standards for their housing and care es a condirian preccdent to obtrlining or maintaining ~ the ctquircd license pursuant to lhis section. ~ _Enclosun. Uimensions_ A single small canid, or hybrid tlien;of, weighing less dian tilirty-tivc pounds shall have an enrlusure mcasuring at least eight feet by twelve feet or ninety-six square feet. For each additional small canid (or hybrid thereot), the enclosure shall Ue increased by fifty percenl. A sing.le large caiud, or hybrid thcrcof, weighing thirty-live potmds or more sliall have an enclosure mc:asuring at leasl ten fect by Ffteen fcet or onc hundred tifty squnre fcet. Tor csch additional large canid, or hybrid thereof, the enclosure shull be incrcased by tifty percc:nt. Enelosures shall havc a secondary barrier af at (east eight feet in height to prevent ac:ces5 to the area hy the beneral public. The secondnry bamer ~ shall tx: a niinimum oi' five tcet from the priniary enclosun. ~ t-2_+-_L'nclosure Materiuls. L•ncEosures far canids cund hybrids thereof shall be constructed of not less than 1 I-gauge chain link or its equivalent fur mammals of an adult wcig,ht Iess tlimi thirty-fivc pounds and 9-gauge chain link or its equivalent fur animals of an adull wcight of tllirty-five pounds or morc. Perimeter burriers shall be at least cight feet high and include an inward-facing overhand of no less than eibhteen inches at aii angle of f'oKy-five degrccs. In addition to vertical harriers, all perimeters shall alsci havic either a concrete footing or liorir.ontal protec;tive cnatling arewid the entire enelosure to prcvent escape Ihniugh digging. All tnclosures shall have doub(e doc,rs hetwren the animal aiid Drart Code h;uig.cs Paite (i1' 18 pussible esCape, une being a prirnary acress duur and the sccond beinb a safety ~ door. All enclosure doors slwll be secure(y lackeel and include safcty chains. ~ - 3i_-Indaor Housing. Whcnever any canidae or i3ybrid thereof is not within an enclosw^e as described herein, but is w•ithin the residencc of a person having a license as provided far in ~.--:::•~~1~~, ^,!c: i,. ;'4 =_070, the residcnce shall comply Ntiith the fallowing criteria: ~ (Aa) All windows, excrpi thosc leadinK tu an uutside cage, shall he screened in material suitable for tlie canidne or hybrid thert-of to contain ~ tlic aiiimal(s) from potcntial cscapc; ~ (i0) YNll doors entering the room will be ot construction, suitable for the canidae or hybrid thereof and be sccurely lockeci. If the doar is solid in cc?nswction, a device shall be installcd to visuully locate the ranicinc or ~ lrybrid thereof before entering ihe roam; and ~ (Cc) All constructivn must be of propcr strength matcrials for the weight of tlte canidae Qc hybrid thereuf they arc ti) contain. WaIIs must be ~ appropriately reinforced vvhere necessary. ~ 4 ~_'I'emperatures and SheIter. All canidae and hybrids thereuf shall have access at all times to shclter from adversc climate conditions and thosc animals kept ~ outside shall have ac;cess to shade. ~ +5_1-_ Watcr. Fresh clean water for drink.i.ng sEuill be availablc at all timcs. Watering shall consist oF either huilt-in deviccs or sturdy portable contniners; such devices or cuntaincrs shall be e4e:ff-e4-Lr-+i 4i~+~#eet~?~•rn.~~~i.~~:~ =L' :1 ,anitarv car..! ~ 6 i_Food. All csnids und hybric.ts lhcreuf shall havc acccss to foud wlvch shall maintLiin the animal's proper weight, nutrition, and health. ~ i7, }-_Sanitation. All enclosums shall be cleaned daily and kept tn.~: of debris and tecsil material. Drainage sha11 lx established to pravide dry huusing conditiuns. nctergents and disinfectants shall be used on hard surfaces, pallets, and food and waler e:antainc:cs. Drainage and mwns of disposing af debris and fcrAl materiai shall be in complinnce with al) applicablc state, rand lucal 1aws and rcgulaUon. : 8: i _Medical Attentinn. Proper medical attentian must be grovided Nvhen and iLs necessary to maintnin thc canid(s) or hybrid(s) in a healthy condition. ~ ; 9j-_Transportation. At nu tinie shall a canid or hybrid thercof be transported away frum the owner's premises hy use oaly of a leietih. Such animals must be traiisportecf in a manner that woutd not cc,nstitute a public threat (iT 11UI531tCC. f)ratl l'ode Changeti I'a,c 7 ul 19 ~ i►►i \ . When in ur on avehicle, said canid or hybrid tliereo2 shall be approprialely acid eflectively contained in a secure, locke4i porteble enclosurc. Whem moving a canid ar hybrid thereof a«-av fn,m the o%rncr'ti prcmiti" ic► :1 vcllicle. a cahle ~ system shall be employ<<]. ~ (10 l Animal RcstricteJ !U l.1\1"I1Cf 5 l'roperty. At 110 timc: shall a LdnR1 or hybrid thereof be lacated uthcr than on tlie liccnsed awner's premises in an approved enclosure or indoor housing as pmvidecl t-0r aho\ e, excrpt (ltirini, tran~portation as ~ described in subsection (9) above. ~ , 11 - Signagc. A sign or signs, includinb a symbol recopizzblc to c:hildren, sh:ill be permanently affixed to the sccondary barrier indicating tliat there is an ( inhcrently dangerous canid or hybrid thereof within such encicisure. - 12_<-_Lx-hibiting. No inherc:ntly cianKercius eanidae c►r hyhrid thereof shall 1x- cxhibited off the licensed owner's premi,;cs. o Housing and Carc of Fclidae nnd Hybric3s Ihrreot'. A ilarl,urcr aiitl:'or ,:mncr oC any inhetently dangerous felidac aiul hybrids thereof shall cumply with the followinL= standnrds for their housing and catc as a contlft1ti12 (1Cl'Cccie;it tu ohtaiiliiig or mailltt►iilin., ~ the reyuirtd license pursuant lo this cliapter. ~ c 1,+_F.neiasure llimensions and Matcrials for Very Larbe t'anthericis. Very large panthericis, includinb lions (P_ leo), tigcrs (P. tigr'ss), and any hyhrid.s thercof shall be maintained in barred or heavily wired cages. A cage for a single animal shall measure at Ieast trventy-four fect wide by twenty feet deep or f'our hundred eighty ;quare feet. It should Eie either a minunum of eight feet high with d secure coverecf top or a minimum of twelve feet high with an inward-facing overhang of no lcss tlian cightecn inches and at an angle of forty-five degrees to prcvent the animals from escaping. Cagcs shail be Gtly pc,-rccnt larger Cor c.Y.ich additional animal. rnclosures shall have a secondary harrier of ai least cight feet in height to pr+evcnt acecss tu the acea by the beneral public. Thc secondary harricr shatl be :i ~ nunimum of five feet from the prirnary enclusurc. ~ i 2. ► Lnclosurz Dimcnsions for Other Large I'l'I1d5. OLIIc:C IaTge tclids, inc(uding jaguars (P. (?nca), leop:irds or panthers (P. pardus), pumas, cougars or mountaill lions (P. ennc:olor), snuw leopards (P. uniea), c(ouded leapards (Neofeliti nuehulosa), and any stihspecies or hybrids thereuf shaIl tx; maintained in a cavc \ti,ith uinimum cage dimeiisions for a singlc large felid equal to at least twenty f'eet wide by twelve feet deer or two liundred and forty snuare feet by eight fcct liigh and have secure covered tops. Cages shalt 6e fifty perc;ent larger for each additional animal. Enclosures shall have a secondary barrier of at Icast cight fcet in height ta prevent access to the Lirca by the general Puhlie. 'l'hc seconcilirv barricr shall he a miniiiitlin ut'ii\c t'Cct . ~ Irom the pritn.:r,• ~-rc14„urc ! l~_r~r i~i~• ~[i i~,~,~. ~',i!~_ ti; ~I y ~ I►ft a f~ I ~ • 3~ Lnclosure L7imeiisions tor tinialler Felic3s. Small telicLS, tlie~se l~a%iit~: :ifl i(IUII body wcight of less than forty-fuur pounds, including any hybrids but excluding the damestic cat (fclis catu.g) shall be maintained in a cage with minimum cage dimensions for a single small fe[id equal to twelve fret wide by ten feet deep or One hundred and twenty square feet by eight feet high and have secure covcreri tops. Ftoor space shall be increaseti by Fifly percent for each additional animal. Enclosures shall have a sccondary bamer of at teast cight feet in height to prevcnt access ta thc area by the genera) public. The secondary barricr shall be u ~ minimum of five feet from thc primury enclosvre. ~ :4 l3arrier and Enclvsure Materials--General. Enclosures for very large and large felids shall be constructed of hars ur not less tlzan 9-gauge chuin link fencing or its eyuivalent. F.nclosunes for smalier felids shall be canstructed of bars of not less tbnn 11 -gauge chnin link fencing or its equivulent. In addition, all peruncters must hnve soil piping or other fencing material or tension wires along the ground, except those for digging felids wtuch yhaIl be eitlicr a concretc footing or horizantal protectivc nintting around the cntirc encloseue. All enclosures shall have duubte doors behvicen the animnls and possible escapc, onc being the primary access door and the second being a srifety daor. AI1 enclasures shall c«ntain at lcast oac abavc-ground plntform largc enough to allow thc felid cucnfort and be locatod at Icast thirty inches abovc gmund. :111 rnclo,urr duurs ~ shall bc securcly lockcd and include safeEy chains. ( +5+_Indnor Housing. Whenevcr any f'elidue or hybrid thereof is not within an znclosure as described herein, but is within the residence of a pecson having a licease as provided for in ~:_.!••_='~VM(' '-i. ~~L).070, the residence shnll comply with thc following criteria: ~ (A.i) All winciows, rxcept thost Ituding tu aii crut5idc: cage. 5hall hc; screened in matcrinl suitablc far the felidac or hybrid thcn:of to contain the ~ animal(s) from potcntial cscapc: ~ (uh) All doors entering the room will be of constructiori, suitaUle for the telidac or hybrid thereof and be securely locked. If the door is solid in constructian, a dcvice shall be instnlled tu visually locate tlle felidac or ~ hybrid thereof 6efurc cntcring the room; aiid All canstxuction must bc uf prupz:r Strength matcrials t~ir tfie wGight ot' the feliciae or hybrid thc:reuf they are tu comtain. Walls iii►L~t be ~ appropriutely reinforced where necessary. ~ 46.+_Temperatures and Siielter. All feliciae; and hybrids therevf shall tiavc acccss at all limes to shelter froni edverse climate canditions and those animals kept ( outsicle shall have accNSS to shade. I)rAl C'ok1c Chafigz; 1'ace 9 oC 18 ~ .7 t _Vtiiater. Frrsh clean w-ater for drinking shall Ue availablc: at all Watering shall consist of either built-in devices or sturdy purtable contuux;r,), ,uch dcvices or conlainers shall be mairL:ir:r.f ri± a~~t~it.~~ ~l+n1~111~~11ti'icEtF??c;-t3t?-3 • 8. i. Food. A11 felids and hybrids thereof shall tuivc access to fac)d which shnll I maintain the animal's propcr wcight, nutrition, and health. Sunitation. f'111 cnctosures shfill be cleaned daily and kept tTee of debris and fccal rnaterial. Dminage shall bc established tu provide dry housing conditions. I)etergents and disinfectanLs shall be used on hard surfaces, pallets, and food and water containers._ Drainage and means of disposing of debris and fecal material shall be in ciimpliance with all apPlicable state:~-~~+~==t. and local laws and regulations. 10 = Mediral Attention. ProE,er riirdical attention must bc providca when and as neeessmy tu rr.siiitaiil tlic telidl s) (ir hyhrid(s) in a healthy conciitiun. T1 l- ran,~uriatiAt nc, tiitie shall ;i tclid or hyhr;d thcrcot hc transPurtcd I away from the owner's pI'eIIll5C5 by use unly of a leash. Sueh animsls must be transported in a ntanner that would not wnstitute a public threat or nuisance. Wlicn in or on a vehicle, said fclid or hybrid thereaf shali be appropriatcly and elTectively cuntuined in n sccure:, locked portable enclosure. When moving a felid or hyhrid thcreof away from the owncr's premises to a vehicle, a cahle system ~ Shall be employed. ~ I 4 12_~-Animal Restricted to (lwner's 1'roperty. At no time sltall a telid or hyhriJ thereof be lor.ated ather than on thc licensed ovmer's prcmises in an approvcd enclosure or induc►r fiousing as provided for above, exccpt during transportation as ~ dcscribczd in subsection ( 11) ubovc. I A 3, f-_Signugc. A sign or signs, including a symhol recobnizablc: to cltildren, shall be pcrmuszently aCFixed to the secondary barrier indicating thnt there is an ~ itUierently ciangeraus fclid or hybrid tliercof within such enclusure. : 14 Exhihiting. No inhcrently dajigcrciu_: f'elid or hyhrid thct-cof shall be eYhibited nff the licensed o«ncr's prcmises. I iuu.sing and Care ut' t Trsiciaz anJ f Iybrids 1ltertut: A liurborer and/or uwnrr of any inherently dangcrous ursidae and hybrieis tlicreof shall comply with the following stanciards for their housing and care as a conciition pncedent to obtaining ~~r cnaintaining ~ thc required liceuse pursuant to this chnpter. ~ (l) Cnclosure Iaimensions. All enclosures tur a sulitary udult brar or hybrid tlicn:of shall measure at Icast twcnty-four feet hy twenty feet or four hundred and [)ratt Ccxlc: ('hnnges l'ctge 10 of 1.4 ~ U1:1t~ 1 eighty square fc;et -,vith a te.n fuot Itigh se:cure co%er«i tup. Lages sliall bc increased fiRy percent per each additioncil bear. Enelusures shall have a secanciary barricr of at least eight fect hi height to prevent access to the area by thc general public. The secondary harrier shnll be a minimum of five fcet from the primary ~ enclosure. (2) Enclosure Materials. Enclosure material shall ik; cunstructcd nf welded bars or not lcss thnn 6-gauge chain link appropriatcly secureci, or its equivalcnt In aciditian, all perimeters shall have either concrete fouting ar horizontal prntective matting around the entire perimeter to prevcnt escape by digging. AU enclostues shall have twn doars 6etween the animal and possible escape, one being the primary access door and the second being safety door. All enclusure daurs shall ~ bc securety tocked and include sttfety chains. (3) Water. Fresh clean water far drinking shall bc available at all time.5. Built-in Nvatcring devices may bc used for larger bcars or hybrids thereof; sturdy containers mav bc suitable far smaller animals. All watering devices and ~ containers shall be cleaned and disinfected daily. (4) Tempeiature.5 and Shelter. All bear or hybrids thereof shall have access ai all times to shcltcr from adverse climate conditions and those animals kept autside ~ shall have access to shade. (5) Foud. I3cars and hybrids thercof shall have access ta faad which shall ( cn:iintain the animal's proper weight, nutrition, and health. (6) Sanitniion. All cnclosures shall bc clefuied daily and kept &ec of debris and tecul materitil. Urainage shull be established tu providc dry housing conditians. T)ctergents and disinfectants shall bc used on hard surfaces, pallcts, and food and wwer containen. Drainage and means of disposing of debris and fecAl material shall be in comPlianu: with all applicuhle state, county, and local laws and ~ reEulutions. (7) vtedical Attention. Yropcr medica) atteiition must be providea «0en anc! .:s ~ iiccessLuy w maintain the bear(s) or hyhrid(s) in healthy condilion. (8) Transportation. At no time shnll a bear or hybrid thereaf be trwisportcd awny from the owner's premiseS by use only of u lea5h. Such aninuils must be tmnsported in a mgnner that would nat constitute a public threat or nuisance. Whcn in or oa a veluclc for said pwpose said bcar ar hybrid thereof shall bc appmpriately and effectively contained in a secure, locked portable enclosure. When moving a bear or bybrid thcrcof away from the owner's premiscs to a ~ vehicle, a cable systcro shall bc employeci. (9) Animril Restricted to Owiur's Property. At no time shall a bc,ar or hybrid thcmuf hc located other than on llte licenseci owner's Premiszti in an appmvccl Dfi1l1 CIIIjL' Cll:?I1LLi Pili?L I i vi 18 enclosure ur indoor huusing as pr- ~ aescribe:d in subsection (8), atxn (10) SlgIliigC. A sign or signs, llll'lUl:lilj~ 11i111~ij j';.,A j Li:li..tl~~C iu ~l11~11L'll, oI;ult be germanently affixed to the secondary barrier indicating th;,t thc•re iq nn ~ inherent[y dangerous ursidae or hybrid thereof within such enclo~ i ( t 1) Exhibiting. No inherrntly dangerou. ~ exhibitc-d off the licensed owmer's premise:; ~ tLi+ 1). Housing aud Gare of Inhercntly Uangerous Keptilrs. A harburc:r wuL'or uNvncr t.: any inherently dangerous reptile shall comply writh the following standards for thc:i housing and carC as a condition preccdent to obtaining or maintaining the required licrns, ! pursuant to this section. (1) Lnclosure Dimcnsions and Uther Reyuircments for Venomuus Snakes. For up tu twa specimens, u cage having a perimctc.r one and one-half times thc length of the longest confined snake. 1=or each additional siiakc over two, the cage Floor ~ .ire-a shall be iiicrcased hv tucnt`-iive percent. (2) Fnclotiurc :0aterials ti)r Vrncimous tiiutkrs, l'a,!c:; 5hall be franlcd witli sixteenths incti thick I'lexi6las or tempered glass. Ventilation openings sliall t covereci wich one-cighth inch mesh. For venomous snakes, duuble walls of ine>~ Sufficient tu prevent penetration of f'angs to outside of enclnsure stiall he installet! Cages must be struciurally sound and may be constructed of waierproofc,! plywood at least one-qusrter inch thick, concrete plastered over wire, sheet metili Gberplati4, nr a minimum of cme-q«artcr mch thick motdcd plastic. C'anstructio! sha! 1 1;) EnclosutZ: l) imeasiuus aiici Uthcr Keauiremccils tur Uila MuluWrN LuJ li<<id,_. Lizards. ror each lirarcl, miniinum cagc; length shal) be one and nne-ha.if times tl~. length of the longcst coniined lizurd and minimum cage width sball be four timk- tiie width of thc largest contined lizard. Gagcs must havc adequate ventilatio!, fresh water, and acccss to sunligllt or full spe.•ctrum fluorescent lighting witil appropriate shaJe also available. Fur eacli additionnl lizard, the cage floor arc:a shall be increased atie hundred percent. Doors are to Close securely and be kGy- f lc,cked. (4) F..nclosure Dimcnsiuns aiid Oilier Reyuiremeuts for Crocodilians. For one crocodilian, minimum cage size must permit moving and turning buth on land and in a pool. Por ndditional crocodilians, the combined area covered by their bodies shall not exeeed fifty percent uf cage areu. Poo) must be of suiTicient deplh ro permit entire body submersion and must be readily acc:essible to caretakers eitlier 1,y sccuring ramps into aud out of the watcr ur by building a snnken pool with a sloped interior. Enclc►sures for crocodilians greater than five fc.=et in lcngth must 17rat1 l'oe1e l,h,►ny,es I'agc 12 nl' 18 ~ Im \i i h:i,,c sliift t'acilities to perniii safe cleaning, cage repair, or otlirr separations. Shifl I cages shall mexSUn at least eight feet hy fivL feet. I (.'•.:1 ln addition, induur facilitics shall br eyuippc;d ~tiith t'ull spectrum fluoresccnt lighting and heat lamps !'or basking. Cages must he sccure and ~ escape; proof. Dnors to cages must be key-locked. ~ (l~~)) In addirioa, thc Ilaors of outdoor cages shall bc of concretc or mas4nry canstruction. Walls shall bc a minimtun height of four fcet and constructed of win- mesh no smaller than 11.5-gauge. 'lThe cage is to be complctely roofcd by mesh wirc. Crocodilians shall havc acccss to shndc and heated indoor f'acilities during cold weather. Fntrance doors acrmible ~ to the public shall bc kept key-locked. (5) Temperatures and Shelter. Species appmpriate lemPemture, lighting, and ~ shelter shall be provided at all times. (b) Faod and Water. Reptites are to bc fed and watcred at a rete at which proper I weight, nutrition, and hettlth are muintained. (7) Snnitation. All cages nnd enclosures are to be kepl sanitary and in good repair. Feces and uneatea food shall be removcd daily. Crocadiiian paols are to be fuli at ~ all times and thc w-ater replaced weekly or continuously filtered. (8) Medical Attention. Proper medical xttention must be provided when and as ~ necessary to maintain the rcptilc(s) in a healthy condition. ~ (9) Transporiaiion. I (Aa) Venomous RePtiles. At no time shall a venomous reptile be lransported away from tiie owner's premises, except for tr.unsportation to and from said veterinarian's offsce or foc lransfer of ownenhip of said animal. Reptile shall be appmpriately and cffectively contained in a secure, lockcd, portable container. 'I'hc contaiaer s6all be appropriately ~ marked to advise of its contcnts. ~ (13t1) Reptiles Other than Venomaus Reptiles. At no time shall an inhcrently dungcrous reptile be transported away fram the owner's prcmise9, cxcept for transportation to and fram said veterinarian's off'ice, approved educ:ational progrFUn or exhibit, oc for transfer of ownership of said animal. Whea in or on the owner's vehiclc, said reptile shall bc appropriatcly and cffectively cvntained in a secure, locked portable I cantainer. 0 0) Animal Etcstricted to Ou-ncr's f'ropcrty. At no timc shall a rertile hc.~ locatcd Urall f`udc c-han};rti 1'iige I;of 18 i :i'J.i'., .1 '1 1, i1.J._ . 111 .lli .I~1• !il'_.i i~.L.~i. _'.1'`J''; ~ duruig transpurtation as descrilxd hccc:inabu4z. (11) Signage. A sign or signs, including a symbol CL(:11gIllZ£ible to chi(dren, ;hall k- pcrmanently affixed to ltte secondary barrirr inJicating Ihat tlicre is an ~ inherenily dangerous reptile within such cnclosurc. n1C 3I11II1F1l control directar LIl conjunction with tilc t~~!1.1I1~:' Of :i:l} ~;C'.'!1~~ fequired under Section ---~=-2.060 of this chapter, may grunt n variance from the enclosure dimensions, ancL/or enclosure materials provisions vvithin this section for anN cnclosures used to housc inhcrently dangerous mammals and/Qr inherently dangerouti reptiles whicb werz in existence on the effectivc ciate uf thc ordinance codified in ttii,, chapter, so long as sueh vuriance does not, in t}it solc ciiscretiom of the clirector. ~ jeopardi7e lhe aumal's welCare or public suf'ety I;-~, 4 Harbocing endlor owning an inhcrentl} Jangcruus mamnial ail:Lor rcl,tilc in tiiolativii of the provisions of this section is A misdemcanor. Impuunding/huusing fecy, violatiuns, penalticti. Impound fc,'s f~r servic:es providcxi by the animal cc~ntrol department shall incfudc all custs actually incurred in conjunction with an unpound c>>:'!!i-hC.i h% t 1tc , : c%. u usir i 1: tw+6c~-t#aP~.*fit--hir~#-~=r~-~}~~~ ~i~--pe 14,-eitrli tflh2ic'mly-Jail:►Cf.:~kti-fttztmfitis!-f+f-it~~'it'rcr-}t~i- to bc paid by the un.imal's owner to the animal control department. Thc animal control department shall maintain u detailed accaunt of all expenses incurred in canjunction with impounding ttny xnimal. This fee shall be paid regardless of whether the animal is returned to the uwner and shall be paid prior to the animui's rele;~se to the uwner subjcct tu thr - ~ - - :ininn:►I contnd dcpsrtmcnt cjirectc7r's dcrision to releaw lhc animal. fhe d'ucctor shall tiavc clie aut-hurity tu dzterminc: ilic sizc of :inimuls whicli -.,:i : -ntr«laIis will impc»cncl hast.d uPo~n thc curahilities, eyuirnictit ,ind f~tcilitic, availablc for u,-,_- I =[3 ) IIDU$1I7g i:li ~Ul Si;[ '.l~11`. ! l0l:1]Llj I;'lll~' l:l.:) .l'C:iii;! J '.7, .,.IC131:~i.. i'- cstablished by the animal cantrol director f()r eath inherently dangerous mammal aiuir'c,i inherc.ntly dangerous reptile. Such fces shAll include a11 casts of housing such animal, regardless of whether such custs arc incuned at a owned or uperated facility ur a contract facility. s-ftAffZ 'n-~~---iflipHttad-1;e~-OfT~- xe;r5--r; r: qetifeJ--i-i--i#-r: Ura►t (_'(Oc l'hange.i i';lgr I•1 of 18 I ~ [)k_~f= I. i oi►5. 1 1 tu+ Eaforcement provisions. r". v Revocation of License. A license issued pursuant to this chapter may bc revokcd by the director for failurc of the licenscc tu comply with any license conditions or any other provis'tons of this chapter. The director shall_ an sdfiiinistraw-c det_°rnt~nation in %vriting, >s!~ci:Olie--IiEen-ee-4 the speciGc lic;cnse cundition(s) ancUor provisions of the chapter violated, the date that his/her license is to be revoked, and his/her right to appeal the license revocation._- .fi . ..-4he diFeeier.-lbe hQldcr of a license subLtz~Lt '>UCh re%cx:qic+n rna% a •-J in %%ritine ti;c tinal «TiL2en detc-rniinavun to the 14earing r ,amsner m6illin 1-itii'21l d3%5_3}tCf tcS.::fii':: ot Sflt uCitSlo(1 1". :S 110[ICC c:l "Sith thc .:nimal CO~iirill The w7-itten eppeal shnll specify the reason(s) why hislher license should nut be revoled. In the event futy person appeals hisTher license revacatian, all inhereatly dangerous mammal(s) and/or inhemntly dangcrous reptile(s) sl~all be impaunded under subsection ;~?13 hercinafter until the appeal is cancluded with tinality. Ehehr4iring yhall k±t hc11.1:i,,~ ::tter ;«<ipt of thr n.10rt: of .:^neal, un1r>} it is centinued for gcx)d causc .tihaChe animal contsul dirrctor or j~;iLnee shall nvtilv the license hulopr In writing of the date. tiine and location of the .:~,Lv_al hcaring befi,re the Hearing Examiner. and stid noti4e yhall t►e recciti•rd at IeaSt ii~ c davs bcfi rc ilie hearing. The aMwal hearing sha11 he mc4rded. and the liearin E:.:imincr mav allow te5tir~nn,v and dtx:umrnts that arc rcIcyant to thC adrninistrative .:~tcrminxien that revocation of the licensc is \►aRanted• , NN:Htt : . _ • -e-#~i - Countv --~anz ~ • _ t, t t bs g;. least t ~ Ae.L.. Th, .t,.. v ndar . . . . . _ • ~ . . !t$ff + . _ -iiic .i•`c'fi'iftl0-Hf , • e ' I . , the 1,;• ! ha,.,ll issue a%%'ritten d"ision, snd mail 3 coqy o1'Lhe dccision.LQ -!~e lic~~z:c hutdcc and tu tbg animal contn,l dimctor or dcsicuiee. «ithin fiftcen davs af ~ iic aprral iiearing. Thr Hearinp 1=xaniiner s dreisinn sha11 ac4:ept. re; ect o aldiA, the .lLirninistrative dctermin.~tion that that a limse shoulci x renc~ked. and shall includc ~-ndines of iitt and cqnrlusions of la" th3t sup~22ri the dccisiun. The dccisiUn shall Lk ,i%zn the effect of a tinal dL,cisien b_the Citv Cc~unril. and shall state ihat the drrisirr~ >>s~• t~e ap~~aled ro ~ . . ° : .i•i-~~r , _ •R1-t:.'. If a liccnsc is rcvoked, the uwner of the aninial(s) which is/arc tlie subject of the license shall trc;nsfer awncrship of the animal(s) by salc or gift to anothcr person who alrcady is in compliance wilh this cliapter, with the written approvc►I of ttie director, and prcrvide.el l?ratt Codc CIiani?es Pxl:c I 5 uf 18 I Ok~ ~ the othcr per5on iil:s ur can ohtain tlic licensc reyuired hy this etiaptec. [n thc: altemati% C and with the «Titten approval of thc d'uector, the Fuunial(s) can bc permanently removeci f'rom the unincorpora(ed arca of S}xokane County_: in cilc ek k:rt nt,nc of ;fze v;i'%Idc:d !ll ltlls SUb>CCilolt 3f~: u11ll1_.cj Ic~lu\11!li or upon approval of the owner-ani the animal wiU bc evthanized. ?~,(k ,:__th.tn!zinu aw. aiiimal undrr this stibsection tihall hc Paid bvitte licenscho: ~"~'B. lmpoundmcnt--Dispusition of Irnpounded Animals. Any inhcrently .i'ui-mous mEUnmal andlar inherently dangerous reptilc which is kept hy any person in violation of this chapter may bc: tal:en up and impoundeci by ,~~~~r~~ tNY2Y-C~-41fliulalal contral directar. ,In .i,:_11.~1 cur;tnd otli~:cr, or a!aw enforcement officer for the protectian and health of the• animal andlor for the protection of ihc health, safcty and wclfane of the public. Cost oftalce-up, impoundment, care and boarciing of the animal will bc charged lo~ its ow-ner or hanN)rer rcLardlrss of whethcr the anirTial is claimcd hv or rcturned ta said ~ o%vner or harborcr. ilie owner or harbunc o1 thc :viiiiial caii ct:ci:sinn tlte :it►iinal oii{v ii' llic F)~:isun iti in compliancc Nvith this chzpter and orily after aII hncti and costs hAVe heen paid by tht 1Iwl7er OC h.!I!"'..'1 Vi J thc direrto r lf no ownu ur tathorcr caii bc; luc;atecl ur WiU Llaim the anitiual ~%ithiu live catendal• dLt., af'ter impounciment, the director may cause tlic sale, adoptinn, dunation, ar euthanir.atiun ut' the animal. Prior to any salc, adoption, donation or euthanasia of any animal, thc director shul) mail written notice to thc: last knawn addre:ss, if any, of the uwner or tierborer. If the disector is unawmre of any last kno,~%rr► oNvner or tzarborer, the direc:tor ~ shall cause to bc published oncc in the e~ota:stCit% legal niwspapcr his/tter intention to causc thc sa(e, adoption, danatiQn, or euthanssia of s+,, h ~ reclaimcki 1vithin ii~,c duys of lhe tirst day ofpuhlieation. iii .ictditian tu any oihrr jirovi5ions (if this chnpter regulaii.ng tlie eutiiana.sia o1'inher,2ii'k ti:ulgeruus tuatnm:ils :uici/ur inherenlly Jangcrous reptilcs, inliemntly dangerous mammals iind/or inherently d.nngcrous reptiles harbored or ouned in violation of this ctcapter ma,~ lx; subjeet to eulhanasia if any onc of ttte fnllrnving cxigent circiimstances is &ettteij to exist hy chc dirertor- (1) lhZ 3171i;1:11 ail lllll?illlCilf llk-clihuwd oI Pii_rslk:.il i~!te I piihlic aiId ehere is no otlier re.a.tionahly ,►vailable means oCabatc cueiit; or (2) l herc; is nu rca-suliable i-iusis tu hclirve that a viulatiou can be or in guuLl ::u?L «•ill be corrected and alter reasonable scarch ar inquiry by the dircctor nu lac;ilit% I as authorizecl by local, state or fcderal laNw is availablc to house the animal; ar (3) 'rlie animal suL'fers from a cummunicable disease injurious to other aniinals or ~ liuman teings, as detentiincd by ihe hcaIlli olliccr, providcd, that this section shall not app(y i1' the animal is under treatment hy a Uraft ('c,dr l'iianges ['ace 16 o1 18 i ►~Ez~E~ liccnsed veterinarian and may reasonably be exPe:ctcd to recovrr without iiilecting otticr anuiials or human beings. 12: }-}07.3;.110 Sale aad transfer of inherendy dangerous mammals and/or inherendy dangerous reptiles i'\ny pcrson who sells, givcs, or in any way transfen possessioa or owncrship of an inherently dangemus mcummal and/or inherently dangemus reptile to sinother persan %vithin thc ►.~~~~rnc~j~=.r:~ ar-ef~r --~-:=~-t=<-tir:Ait% shall maintain records reflecting - the name, adciness, and telephone number of thc recciver nf the animal. an a complrtc and accurate description of the animal transferred. 'I'his informstion shall be ~ cummunicated to ilie --1.inimal Gcontrol I3rtNa:~-~:-nu Iater th;ui r~c-f -~the tidn:e time as the transfer orcun. ~Z.UA-?13 lttsntting ~rt ~~wz--tltt~r-t4 eotifr eflic~s~cantre~~~hi3arttt~rt:f. f , ` . ar- , . ?~tCfrtsi-~i- , ~ ._fjsrit~£ . _ "hftll . _ i - • - _ . ~ . . - - - ~ . - i . . ; 1:...-. . Q . . ~~if-t~3cs2iiti'~--c~iii~Cliit3`rfCf~flC~`rfvS~Sz3f:~ _ - .r•• iirvecQni , _ f?z.•n"N jti :S s??ht~C I~..;;, Rahies virus testinfi- duty to reimbursc Cor eosts. It shall bc thc respnnsihilily of any pcrson owning or iiarhoring, ltaving custouly, contrul, or possession of wi inJicrcndy dangeraus muinmal tu reiniburse the ~!_;tiill U15I~ll:l?1~t~rc'.f~c'`~-t=t~~~!ie;dth-di-,=6t', OC 1tS 5t1GCt'.SSOf, for all costs, including but not limited ta, the capture, holding, testing, transporting, reporling, and notification connected with the destruction ot an inhercntty dc;ngerous mammal far su6missian to the ~ tipokane RCLSonill Ht'.3lI!1 ~jt~:ivi d+si:+~_, or its succcssor, for muting to the Washington State Depnrtment of f Iealth for rabies virus testing, which testing is a tiirut resull of ttn ordrr issucd by the healLft offliccr. Sucli costs shall hc raicl «itliui ttiirty days uf date aFinailing. ~_,-.~~.z~ - _ : • • - - . _i I ct.• F {--:.r.' t;=~ii j• .:{=ti r.---. .-<-f-„ ~t!t.:c- " ' . . •I-.. - ' 4 ' . • • . _.-:~cr..-'__' Afirrcmcnts. L)raft [_'oclr ('hance., P~;.c 17 ~,I 18 ~ I►IL ~F~ I may cnter into agreements with any veterinnrittn, governmcutal^agcncy, city, corporation or individual it dccros necessary to carry out the provisic►ns of this chaptcr. Drnt1 Cude Chaiwcti {':iSX 18 of 18 A -%4 1_1144it.A►E C_8WkT_Y' ,+1_**I7►lA~.-C~(~►~~tAE ~ ~ TLE3 ":4m Bets-~ed-El~S f~hcrrrtl%, 0aet!cmrs ~ie+t►T:!~,end Re;>tilr_ c ftr prti. :.:+a {u.O . ♦ k ti t_ { , ~ ~{-4#~9-P~•~,+l; ~l'Ct1UD8 4.$440' z» Q.1 O~ PU rpOSl. 4.84.0207.3q,10~ Definitioas. 4:44CH367.30.I I'i Dog n Ca licensc-Rcqofrcd. =,9i~A3-0 4~si +tcce~e-~te:{K+ree#. !;.04:83017.30, 11 S Dog/Cat Rabies Vgccinadoa ftequiml. ~.8+832'30.120 Daagerons [kog-Heariag and Appeal. !!:04~337,M,12S Poteatially Uangrmus Dng-Hcaring and Appcal. ,;:04:035730.130 Rcglstrotloas of diingcrous dogs-Raquiremeats and annual fcc. 5,849Aa67-W.135 Daogeroas Uogs--Identitlcation. ~;.94.9497.30.1 4 0 Unlawful nse of tags. S.0I,94~7;l).{4~ Comnisrclalkcnneb. ,r-,$4.043730.150 Prfvete kenne!!►. ~_iN:94!S7 ~q,l Si Desigwtod off-leash irea(e) -Rules aad regulttioas. ,z:"8507_30,16 0 Enforccment powcr. ~:(1+.0607?p.]6 ~ lmpaunding of dogs aod csb. S AH&W3t1,_l 70 Rdease for adoPHoo. 5:g4;gb47'S Aaima) .Adoption-Agreement to sptylacatcr. 4$4$66 ~en~Jrn~tf~att. 5.04:8677.30.18U Controlofc2t9. r-;",8707 1U, 19 ; Cantrol of doge. ..":A~$~}7~.190 Violntions ss infructionc-E:ceptionc. ; iµ:H=a ? -0.195 tiotlce o[ infrnrtlon--issuNnce. = 44:49;37_y..1 tiotics af in[rnrdons-Ihterminstiva fioal anless contcstrd-Form. ~ ::.y.31i Response to aotlce Uf iafraclion--CoatexI i n g ~ Jtlcrmiaation--1(earing--feilure to respond or appcar. I Heariag.s-Rules o[ procLKfure--Cbunxcl. ►:0i:A:f7,az0.2ji Hcaciags--Cuatating determinatioa t6et in- frsctloa commfttcd-Appeal. ;.04.Q!P'.30.220 Heariags-Eiplanation uf mitigating circumstances. 73012: Ordcr of court-Civil naturc-Waivcr, reducNoa, suspcnsiao of peoalt7--L'omntunitr sorvicc in lieu of penalty. -14:9=9".M_230 Notice uf iofraction-Per"w!-r-fefl*tr-fetmpeed-a4isdenreanee= Failnrc to Sipn - FAiiure to I'av 5.64:$=417,30,23: Person rccciving naticc-IdcntificrNoa and dctentiua. S,44.8=937XO.240 Feilnrc to Obey lnstructlone of an Utficcr 54438Q97.30.245 AnimAl Control Director or 6islher designcc--lssuanre of crimiaAl citstion. :.04407•-;0.25U Redemptfoa prncedures. 4.9+.i 29".30.25 5 Removal Destrnction of Daaperous aad tViciiius dogs. ::0+A3A7.30460 1'eoalties. 4:84-431 Ir r+#cm-mn :tie0ftclrtIrftn-_*"Ntr mrs.ar.cc ~44N67.30.:6~ Fee Setting Authority !~:~~•p?.3Q.2?(1 Duty When Strikjng pamestic Animal With Motor Vehidc 444-468730.2'{ paimnl l3itcs 'fo f3e Rcported ~:84.1-78730.2 0 Spaying And Nentering Scrvices ~~966- Stti-e~~i1♦ ' 311. ilt~_Purpoae. ; is the puhlic policy ol't it,. ;,i S-mtaDc % a_•!c-, co secure and maintnin cis of animal canual wic6in the 0;~ uni~•~~~esr,! ur•rAS-14- s;~,~~,~ •~-,~„u} as will ptotect humen hr,aIth .111,.f :►fcty, and to thc geelest Jegrcc pra~.-tieable to pncvtnt 'tnjuay dama~e to propcety. To this end, ii Jic purpose of this chnptrr to provide a mcans of lieensing dogSJcais and contro lling crrant deg c.:; I ,ehaviar so that it shall not bccomc a pubtic nuisance. It is akcjfurcficr the policy of lic irN to prevrnt the inhumane tecatrncrt mimals. 7lureforc, it is also the purpose of [his chapttr tn pmvide for thr humsnc use, care, ar: ! f11:' :.-I)d ~,I: , ' ' ' - . ~)lfII11U(i(l~. !n con.stiuing provisiaru vt' this rhapter, excc-pt wfiem othrrw•ix pltinly drclurd , ,r ,_lc_iJ; , npparcm fmm the context, wards used in this chapter shall be given their common and urdir„a-•, mcaning ar►d in addition, the following definltions s6aU s►pply: ~ - • "Abatemerit" marn9 the ierminntion of any vinlation by reasanable nnd lawful mc;v,, d:•ierminaf by the animn) cocstr,nl officer in arikr thst a per9an or persons prr~umed t,, hc naQr kocpcr shail corttply with this chapter. •,Animnl" mrnns eny nunhuman mammal, bird, rcptile, or amphihi,:: r. °t4i11[lllll CQt1tiUl" r ~t!!lE~r-r~f193~-EHttffE~}-~M , . - - Anffii,t3 «e--a=,j41tc4ct4►rn k~ees=*- -k~ a4~~{i:• W_-~n:~ mcnn . ilLat departmrnt cstablishai by thc t~~#-~,+-~~sv~►t~ui.xK" Or cr, ~~tracccJ_.. i4~~ Lv-% tfic t ii~, to adminiztrr and rnfarcG the pruvisions of this chapter, c-#avief -:.~-~~~trr<:utd RCW 1 Ag 16_52. and 16.54 RC--w. its dkakx dgpgrtmrnt head shaii bc rcfcrroi to bercinnRer as thc "animel control diroctor", "anima! prutoctinn dir qf or "dDimtor." .•1~~ ",uiimal contro) officcr" or "anima) nrouxtian officcr" is any person designatcd by the ~is►~~! dDircrtar with a limitrd law enfocacment commissia~ a~•,; .~-,r~-.:.~..~.;fi-~:~•.4~F}w"~-~.i : ._.e?-Y--++4v t=4-~5=~+~-;'-~,;,a►~-,-ur.;. fnr thc purpose of administuing or aidinf; ;~hr enfan:emrnt ofthis chaptcr, ei►aatef-~-~-' arad =,-~u~r*.Rt'~t 16•08. i6.SZ_ a~d_J6S4f~-14. ~_1-: "Mirrul Shrltee' means u furility which is used ta house or canisin stray. homelc- :ibandanecl or unwitntEd animals, und which is owned, operzttrd or maintaineci by a public body, :n c:.,tablisheci humane socicty. animnl welfam society. sacicty for the prevrntion of crvelry to anim:,1 ; ,Ir other nonpmfit organitatian devoted tn the %vclfarr, prntection, and htimane trcatment , i ~nimnls. fi 1 "At lergc" nieans n dog which is phyiically aff thc prcxriiscs ufthe awner.jh; Rd lc or Icseper of the dog, and which is not sectued by a Icash which is unsier the conirol of 1he owrn II i:undlu, or the keepcr not exceuling eight fixt in Icngth: providcd. ,•at large" doa not include dc exhibticd in dog stnws, ficld trials, ubcdicnca trnining or trinls, or tfic training of dogs therzfi,:,-: ,-.r the uso of n dog undcr tha supcrvision of n pcrson to hunt, to chase or trrc pnxintnry animals ~ i _,,arnc birds; or thc uso of tt dog to rantro) or prottct livestnck or pr+apcrty air in othcr agriculni. .+cdvitics; or s dog or-eat whcn othdwise safely and sccurely oonfined or rnmplctdy ronm>I!: ! .,ithin or upon any i:-Ic: r ur,acr : i-rr••1 ,ic-;~n,<t d ,tr_I,•0 . , r-'•n,r t='~1 h•; ' nforcement a¢cnc~;~ "l'at" IT7C.lI13 8 dulTlr"sUqIIYI FCIiS catus. "Cammarial kcnnel" means a plaao wherc fivt •-i+or more dags t~or fLv_e±~tof more cats,.irrgpectivc of duratiorL,arc boardcd, bred, houLrht, sold, exhibited or daincd for wmExc►sstion, but nut (nduding a ptt shop, animnl shelter or vetctinary clinicJhospital whcc+e ~ baurding is incidental to trcatmrnt. lf more thnn eigic tS4_dogLpd+'or tcn ~4141 cats (over ( manths Uf~a 1 erc kgpt then such estahlishmrnt shg_bo deen►, dg~ "camr el kcn4tl mv-*rdless whcibcr the nwnet or ker rtceives coMpensatiqj], ~ !9i-"1)angcrous dag" menns any dog thai (a) inflicts sevam injury on n liumnn bein4 withuut provocaiion on public or private prvFxhty, (b) intlicts xvere injury oa or ki11s an anintal withnut provocation while the dag is off the owrnrs or kcepCr's prapcrty, or (c) hns prcvivusly bccn found to be pottratially dnngemus, the ownrr or kccper having roccived aatice of sudt and Lhc do.•, a,ain aggressivcly bites, sttar.ks, Qr endangen ths snfety of humans or nnimals. If lNvu ur mon iiogg joinUy engage in uny cunduct dcscribed in this subsectian, thrrcby rcndcring proof of tt±c individuel dog that inflicted any particular injury difiicult to asccrtain, thcn rcgardless of thC degrec of participation by the individual dRg(s), all such dogs sha11 be dccmad dnngerous dugs. A dog shall not be daclareci dangcrous iCthe threat, injury, or darnage was suscnined by v persan whn, at thc time, wss committing n willful tn5pass ar other tort upom the premiscs occupied by the owner or kerpcr of the dag, or was tcnmcnting. abusing ur assaulting the dog, ar hus, in the past, been ohservcd or reparted to have tormcntcd, abuscd or assaulted the dog, or was committing or attcmpting tn cnmmit a aimc. ~ t4 r "Uog" means n domesticntcd Canis familinris, hred in a great many varieties. including «•ulf hybrids. ~ t-k+,+ -"6uthenasia" mcans tlu humanc dcxtruction of un animal acr,omplished by a mcthcxd that invo[vcs inswntaneous unronsciousness nnd immediate death, or by a method ttwt cuuses painlcss loss of con.seiousncss, and death during such loss of consciflusnGSS. ~ •Gchibiu vicious propcnsides" mcans: The infliction of a bite- or bitcs, on a human being ar animal, either on public or privatc property; or f_61 killing or srvrrclv,n'urin an anirnal wh(!r t►#;' thc dag is o thr owncr's ur kecpcr's property; Pruvided, the abovc definivon uf viciaus prapsnsities shall not include those situaiions descnbed in ftCW 16.08.100 (2) and (3). j "l.icense yrsr"means ticensc rxpim twelvc t+-=tmonths fram munth uf purchnsc. "Micrnchip imptsnt" means a possive electmnic trnnspunder that is iajocted into an animal. sutxvtaneously, by mrsns of a hypodermic-rypc sy-riifgc device. Gach microchip shall contain n unique and original numher thst is rcad by an clectronic scanning devica for purposes af animal idrntificatinn and rccovcry by thc animal's owncrs. Thn microchip implant sha11 bc suppliai wich an extcriar collar•type tag for purnoses of an extemnl mcnli.s of notifying others that the animal h: brzn implantstii with a microchip. il4r "Off=i,eash Aren" mcans ati arrA specificnlty detignated in ~•.._s~-rt- . 5.04.045(!) in wtuch mt owncr. hendler, or kerper mny allow or permit their dag to tun at lar:_ Subject to thc tvlcs and rrgulatiuns in >'~"\t('~~•_~ 5.04,045(2). ++-~"Owner, handia or keeper' means any person, tirm, cutporatian, organi7Ation ~.r department possessins, hnrboring, kecping, hnving an inierest in or having control or custody af a! ! nnimul. reganllcss of whalhcr tha animal is licenstd pursuxnt to the ordinanre codified in thi, chepter. ~ 4 i+++-••Pct shop•• mesns an establtslnncnt w}wm animaJs brod ofi' fhe pmnises erc ofl'emd r sele to [he pub1iC. 4;+ "Patentially dangerous doC means my dug that whtn unprovokod: (s) inflicts bitcs i A hvmsa ar anfmal cither an public or privacc propcrty, or (b) cheses or approachcs a person ui-k+i c strrtts, sidctivalks or any pubtic gmunds in s mcnacing fnshian vr apparrnt attihidc oEattar.k ~_•,r ) any dog with a knnwn prvpensity. tuldrncy. ar di.spusitian to attack unprovoked, to cactsc injury. ; othcnvisc to tiutatrn thc safety uf humans or animals. 0-8+"Prcmises" ttieens tho Yrw of lund siumunding a house, ot dwelling unit or units, nll :i .!--iually ar by legal constnjc;tion forming an enclosure witfi it and to whiCh thc owner or keeper of a 1'1+g has tegai aad equitable rigfit thrnein. "Premises" docg not extend iMn arras of commr•n ~~%,ntrship ar use in tbe case of eascmenis, trailas parics, spartrnrnt camplexes, priv:,tr -rnmunitics, ctc. WW'Private kenncl" mcans n ptace, otha than an animaf shetter, where fivc to eight "Ous md/or 10 ".Eu-rats (ovcr six munths old) anc kcpt far perscmal ar nanrommcrcial purposcs I! ;11t,ra than cight dugs endlof te~_gt+► cats (oycr six motrths ald) ert kcpt at n privacc krnntl, tlwn ~:j.:h cstablishment strali be decmed a"commcrcsal kennel." ncgardteu of whcther titie owncr ~,i t.::epet receives compensation. •'Proaf of vaccinatian" means a health or rabies ccKificata issued by a liccnsr:l v eterinarian. ~ f?1,+ "Praper enclosure af a dnngcruus dog" mcans, whila on thc owncr's or kccper':; f,ntiperty. a dangecaus dog shell be securefy cunfinod indasrs oc in n securely enclosed and lockoi r,~,n qr structLM witable to pn.wcnt thr cntry uFyaung childccn and dcsigned !o prevent the saimiil i -r, im cscaping. Such prn ar structure shnll havn sccum sidcs aod a secvrc top and botiorn cnclosur,:. .mJ shall elso ptvvidc protoction frum the clcmcnts for e dog. ~ ~"Scnior Rate" me~si the saccial discouqtRd ratc anv dmt_ac -«nrr n; -.;'A; ;:,t tcc ,r oJder mav rogNesi for the licen5e of anc segyeci/nculcoccf snimul, ~ t4a44--"Sevcrc injury" means an}• PhYsical irtjury thet wh::;lr rc~,ulr~ -~n ;figg,ramm!_ or Inccrations rcquiring multiplc suducs or surgcry. 'iie cl:ri-=kt~-i=i~7~c~r~-.r~zi~~~eFa.}~~F-L~w.j~viN`:~•~•i~}st--ut?=.~1~Ilczi~•.. ~_4~►"Triu Fee", meqgilbe resoonse fet an r-i i,; f'y ~ , ! ~shcn :fn ;niinil • - l)n;~ .~ni1 t qt ( iccnsc {tri1 uire, l. •w?t~,- r111 dng-s Six months of:igc „r -,1;-1I hc licensed. Tho anni:,sl fcc fur r;ich ,Si~~s~ •,ha:l bc '<< - J ~ -f iirC -i;~ ir~,. ~.lCPtISC Ti^~_ - bc pnid either to ":.•u . ~,;r,.j" or "privaie" licznsin nutlet5 , .~,7, •.~•,_ij h'; lflr` C~i(i~:in•• ! . ~:il~i -~i:d:.~..1 . , ~l~f`-,7f d ~-in addition to the regularty sct fecs may bc collectcd and retainul by all ;)rivate" licensing uutlzts appointed by thc9~c'--e-Eeunt~-~+mal-EenEm} Dirccwr for .~r.h dag liccnse issuod. Upan payrnrnt ot the licensc fee provided abave, the ticenaing u','ct she11 delivcr lo ihc aw-net tir krcpcr of cuch dc- , a liccrtsc and mct:;llic t.zg for c:sch licenscd All c-3Ci S1X lT1C~litf)S U( ;IP.I' ~~r MdCf h:ifbiliCd, 1,:u1il oC Itlal[7131SYCd IEI . ~_.•r_~ _ ,,I~,1I1 f~e liccir>c~i Rc ::r17;:1al N~.:•,~~,~ t-L-: f:: r i•a..h ~at >(tiail F,c -e----~--,~-= _ Liccnse fccs mav 1~c P;ii,1 1,, ~~r'.-• ' . lD:cn.,in_ i,utlrts a; &-ip-nated Ly rcL Mointed hr tht Uire-itor ibr L,~ li li lILtncC CCL' ❑fUNlif.Cl abUVC. (f1C IICt.IlS10L UUIICt Sllilll liC.16.Cr ,L ~ .:.~-i ~~~~~alli~ laa fbrcech cac IiccnSCJ. ef-lcew 1 I I' i,_cascs issued pursunnt to this scctiun 'I, :il ht: ~hrv 1.lnd numiY-re:l, _n:! ,hall bc-ir thc nsrnc of ~[,F.ai", .!!L,, the namc .:nd address ut t Eic owner und kccper of the Jrg or cat licensc, und A desr.riptian of the dog g ca i►x:ludin2 :es colur anJ sa+c. The mdaltie tsg sfiall t+ear n seriul number corresponding with the tti:mber of the Iicensc. 8nd .41flz -tiFokRI}t f%t~'-•a~.~.{ti .u-fb~lf> --~.red It shall be the duty of cvery awncr or keeper ot' n dog csr cat to krep n substantial ,«Ilar on the *~g animal and to kce tirmlv suached thereto the metallic tes for the currerit cnsin 6Ear t; 1l1} i cr\...n rcprrscnt Khcthcr ttic ~1 r..~t i-, . - ci, .i!~rr.! i: c_I r._at-,,. i.'~.:.,', ..!i, !1 f~•_ I viiiIty af a misdenteam r I ;i101*,111, k_it iiir .fa;..: tii~ prcvious licetue was issurd. A ncw licensr niust bc purchnsed within thirty t=+.~, days after .i dog nr cat wa5 fit5l ac~guired. hotborcci- kcnl. mnintnincd. ar„~rouszht intn ihr , residing}n;hri'i:.ietfri#H.we+►nty. r,►-F_: All fees and 6nes collcctcd uncfer the rruvisions of lhiN ,:runinal fincs shell be doposited in tlte cnur.ty ceinent cxPcnnSZ lim:f crlo%~al \Lren7l011 hcl%%c-;t~ , I T-+_ llu shall hunar dic reyuc3t by u blind periom an ccaring impaircd parson noi to bc chargod a fcc to licensc his or het tMingguide dog g,ulde or a request by a phygicslly disablcd persoa not w bc chargeii a fea to ticcnsc his nr her Lrointd service deg nnimal. ,~FS► H Thc ownct or keeper of such dog or est stuall providc F>pa~cn-- C-atffity Ani,fvA-C-enlrei SC-R=-NP5unimaI ztmqLlLupon requtst witb proof that thc dog or Ca4 is currcntly liccnscd es providod by this choptet. 4u+-I. Any incrcase in currcnt dog Ard-M licrosing fces ur penalties in this shall become effectiti~a cwSepisrribm 22, 9(l3 -,~-ai 12.01 a.m., ~.n che ilnte idefl, I ;irc_Fn. jhr rc- aiuti<<ri a; hcirc ttte rffeir.~ ' detc.. I4 {4:H34 4 tp.115 Dog/Gt tn have curreat varclnation sga[nst rabies. All dtigs and cats six *4-+ moRths of agc ar older shaU bc 4mcdnacaf a.gainst rabies. 'Iho ut+•nrr or ketper of such dogJcat shal) provide Speksne1-~ty--A~~! Sk-R-~-I;Orrta] .k'nirI'lwith proaf that such dugJcat t+etft~i;, Lurresislti vaccinated agttinst rabies ns Ne11 as thc expinuiun date oF such vsrcinntion. An awner or keeper who rtCuses to provido proof uf such vnccinadon upon roqurst by the Animal-FeelrW Diroctot ar his(htr designae shall be dcemcd to havc failcd to providc such proof. 5ti04:833 lUa! L-iccesc-ltrriuircd: t,a) -~}1-csatti-six-nc~itt~s~lder-1~~-~ca~-er-ffaseteir►ec~+n-SP'e~e-~-c~wy` s#e" . . spay-e"eateFed-eas-an+#-fiRaew&liats . ' t5:---A-fte-af-dxree &A%M4$a4*}qha}}be _ j• , ion S;$¢, Ian{ . -4h tirnely-obtain ~ ta-saot' 3-Z+a Centml-Ae lwrp{$Z~}~n-ndeiitie~{oth~ fegd"arly seEfezsf+►nY he-ve44eetec#-an#-trEStned-by-all-!pF+ -ountyAnirn°} . ' •pepmeesi-af4he-lNoeese-€ea-pmv+ded ebe++e;ho {iocnsingewl aeeepw ef 5ue-e~:•n #ic+ea~se-~d-~e~el~io-teg~e~-eaet~ aisi-{teensed-or-ict" ~l-beer (~--#i-!' a ~s y'" end keqw-eN~eat-E+aensei-W u•desetiptiee-ef-the-esi-itx~uding-(ts• . TlwotoWlie ' +wgnba oerrespmu#ng-with-than ad-thevoant"r pan-Ehereef far-whiol~ii-+s-ts.ase~ It-Aialt be ihe duty -of'-eve3►owntr-er-k~4epef-a€4-csi-ie-keep k'dep-~nIyWhed-tHtPeEe-thamet~ii~tns~~#e-ea~+t-~. . twa-~MwiS?:~3}~it~-~►1a+.~efttesi~e€-any 1~►si•~c~r+~ 1 t 1 l .i.._~i- ~i . n-~ic•i.irr ...i Al- ~'i^i`._i! .41-• r-Ht!. - • - .-H , . r - . _ 'i r •_~t-i~-spe~~utcre~~tr-ti~-s~~~r~c~tt-~auter~#~4~-t~ gur~ty-e~,r~~ti~kcr~+~: t~}--~_-ie~-be-rrnewe~-wit~-t~e1~(~ ~}-~e+~~l3s-e#'-~ix-~tr-tbo-pre~+a~s-4+err+-~~ waf,+ssna~--ArF+aw~N+awde4ffust-bapumhoSed-++4 int#t'tfFy' {-30} I"uirr' ~ eounly. f^1 A-anei- 't+e1•fin:-~ ;nQ14 -Lc-4 'ctxrtRt-cxpwwwfiff1& •fnal Genu-91 _up,-.,. requem %ith pfflef r,.:stia--i~a-.=:IPi:~i{--a4r-iiit-il•if!ls-~e.'t`~-~i- {~cflik~=iN-.-:f1-.f~!S !:L"t~M???-LFiR~~ ~Et+"~t'..• Q~1VO'6fl-t4c4gu'.i1- ~Mt,n tfit tutimal W~ttrul dircttpr or dcsiencc IiM,,.sut'ficicnt Inf4t7iia tion to i ¢cmus as dCfnrd bv S~+o~:ant ~aunt~ C~x~c 5h~i~~n S.OS.O:Q~,thc_. :~~~~tor or dcsienee sha11 mnkc upreliminaO dci~jAration thui the deQ is dnne- i il,e cvcni r prttiminar% dciermiruation is rruade that the Joe iLJ+vi •er us._ t-fll natif'N thc dega«nt[ tir kccRer ; int ~ .I._II nnd c-cnifial mnii. return rece '~_~L. ng,tix or dctcrn►iT►,a_tion mailcd ~ :nr in uhich it ~s add~- - ' ~ :laraticx~ of,~scndil~c n~iee mus~ st:,•. the swt.. . .~lt ai ihc jvg the _ n dtsc i 21 titcnx number. i an%l. . rcdsur~s lhc enimnl qontrel dircx-tar ar dcsianre et sid M the uni- - ~ ic c}oiL 11A5 ~+ecri dclufTltl to be dAtl ous~ . ihcn the cc~r►m~ls st.~tc~ y• muid 1i10.045 shall ivL acrl nLhts ntld chc prIMerL, .;I :Xplnnntiun ofthc o+yncrs nr kge _ prvlin¢ o dcclara?iqn a dot~,~Y i~w,yinc(udin&u_, . L:!,. ~ [raijl.cirGvieK• 1ftG1 DTc1linill8tti' 0dIillI1qsgdtivt drtef7T11np1 , !iminan~ U,£t crminatit►n of 1]angrr~u5 lk!R, - f'riu, I r.,:tar c.~t dcs68neg.issuine n firial dctcrminntic-n thgJ ,rFtia! conim) d1rty4trr_Sjr dr.,-hee shWl tlotifi, llu Vuner or kvr „:;nu that hr or_.he_i, aititlcd to nn o+xortunirv to mcet Niith the ani:, as in rrsitin~ .l....~`_ • C,C k , o!~~~i• im ,stc nn~ h~ nsccl ° e - k4 or~, ec- ~ c 1 ton el di -toc or ~ cc,nu°l au v ~ ~ ynim ~ v►t 'trica ~b_~CtO % cct~n iurm ot Iri chz ~ in tbc ~tin ' ► ~tccmine 11,.'c te`'sew m ~ n final g~~nistta to ,t{C-cmc-l ' sh » ' Sn"5 a ,t t - i p~Stndu for fAft`~' ntrol d'•r~ ~ autt~~ri e d ir c~sri~ the im !_t ~ su I `x f { ~1°~ ►n i° . ig.~}~-~µ f ~ a n~inr n ° p ~o~~ i,, ~~p dc►i~d'' 'i. ~4 OSCSC~ N y wt_ll fi~, ecaus ~ t ~cd un ~ n °,n . c ~atclv the fa► N, Q ~s ta tl.t th~cl CkW~~ dtrrcu°3o d~i_~s a~ davs f ~t o lstt c irt~ ~ P5~ c p mu _ ' t~ar 3 ~~bli4hcd b~ ~hz coau~o ~►cit d ~ da`s 5hc1ia s►~a '`an ~imat c ~ t ~ to t C ty Ca1~wich Ie - ` ~.ri5 ' b tctm T ~ ~ -s s~f►~ ~ , ~ ~ h n»-~ hes~ tlc N tv . thc t i uanr.c a11 c ~„m, locai`an t f`,e 59~, h5 ta 3t n-~`"`-.ma~ aU n~ •n w t~ ~ t. e s~t tt~aicS'c do ~ ► , ~T k um~ '~t ~ },c cccac tl~t ~ clc~ ~ ~ c- tbe. ArC c~' t to ~he -~ja ~ ~,•i~'h►n ~~1.~- 4*j;;'s, n "c tc 41rt+ sn~~, to tih~: ammai ccm~ 1~iR 2) t u} 1uet 4'indln~zs ~,~ifv •'~%'~h~car,~4zv~~ ihon ~~.;seo+~• T1" ~ tR~1V ~ DL 5u}'~~'- ytt11 ~~,nclusic~n4 9 :,mizCr.7ui. !1 ttic Cu15 watr.nL'and jI112+j.c aji% c.I IhC fiNIlLgY:ilt`I[s iC( Ivrtt1 ip_}\ 1S!_ '?Qq40(a) Tl~c dtcisian shall k.+t ~itirn the efi'zc[ of a finul de~;i~iqn bv tht Citv Cc~un~~~ .ind sh.1ll scate ctsaf chc dacisivm mat, tK a -al.pi_to 5unerior Coun pursgant cn Rt W 7, ! ~ ,.ithia tNtntv ds.s frtxn tbc dute the dc~4~ion weS re~iticd. lf thlicxi unht+jd_stb: ptQrr fails 1. ►dministratit, c deiatninatic►n that a ►ioa is ctuiarrc-u,i and the dag ownet or ki -imck rc►j<tr the dvs cvr dvDea1 thc &!~~tfl Suprrior ('~,~rt, lhc dc, ++~ll be eutlianir_.1 na oi kccc+er tiRfc st the dirok;:iQn of the animal rpntn,l direci(iT ar dcsismcr ffthc dc+geu, sooeals the danaemus dN. dcclarati~►D,jt; doa wiil hr ttc d ,c ing the outwrtre fj thc a[ 'c~~~; .t! '1! '.t~{•_ . _ -~.'.f!- _ , 1 f:1. ,_:f~l,~,l. I'1~ !lf".I~ _ I~:f ) ,'i!IlC' L I44.02 VR"!:1. ~ 11~ Slf' ~ E.}t µ~itp. • : _ . . . _ - . _ ~•c'~!?i~l~~iftf3E!!4E-~f~{•Aiir~it^tri-r-~^:'liffiiit ii3ai-~ ~-.-t ' ~ ~ v.u~r: ..r~<i~; :z-~ vYi"tC•:-"• '•t-~:}.. - i~4t--r1f1tm@~-~~Mfi►~ [~ifitiic7F:-8F-hl►e►-sdeStb!F►M~ 40*16fC-4hl-~E►l,`f'~t2~+lff-:- .4-$fld4M4 _ . . fn--pl'f~t`~41►f-~►W` .:•~:~iFNF~i1~i{~iFije'!lf~ft4f1~lh~~tst!!N _rpaqtj.-O " hi4fJdY fl►4sf14-!h!-PileM-!MlFi1►1PHi1l1}ii?tt f e+-ilmA-d+e feetiais th&_ --.}-+-~~.ectfert-f►:(1~:A_~84$~ kr Ae-bretvl;vc+icx: 'sex;-adtd aieemx+~tt~~-t~-~+nctwr►1r+#'t#+e-Sa+~l-ik~--. I -A-e~. .s._.., "•#"--(erfft4t+c-bacis jeel&ifvg -tia") hr-a~inf+gffeui, dot t#ffwo~ - . if-ko- - R me+-s~a~lab{e: {44 Thfi;--tat~n~t-t!~ tik- _--;~es~-as-~#nti*istt+a~ta-r~t+ear+n}~i~-+~--~► ~ ft~+nproN;dod-~1► , _•~~~_(~~-«3~►,r+-c~€~l+a-Feeeip! of4hr~~t' . --1 : - . !he +iwr --.,.,~~,..~,:~-;~~,~.i~-i►e ' ' _ ;r~er~~heneiier--~►-Fe{uest-6 p'aetd-+n-+Ire-snaii: _pH . h~-w1 hr~+ "4 _ y ,~~tKOT1Tf~'~1c' -dl3lpCt. -411d--~1lA~--wppll~RTlR4@!}` tfMter-iw shfill-}- }t~pfll%.t. - - df'. y.rvqk3{fv{i,.. _ a}^~d-~i'2~@E-~.~~C UL~fi4i _ _ ~-~F{'$fi~'~1W~kY ..r ~ 19M-~teiCli}-t4il~!'!1t"@$fl~{t3ifftf#tiV+1M:+5!'S-~{'@i-Cf#~: stj'.: t3:_ •E•, -.:c_?_ , - - _ ~ 1~Bl4~t"~tt5r+~l~`• [Tr-A*} _ lS-oflJe-44k-~iftQii~-'f~fi~`iiS+.f. •~l~1t?FF2l'c~'~s~t'm#1!'l44fl4 - k.-li►ii'ARt.`fi:r3L-, . , t•i!t~ _:ir~~_ •--,-=ree~i-r-~e;r. ±~~~#-~t4i1 r.~+n+r€-~t~ec-the it►- 5:1ett;.- - ' - - ,---i ~ - - - .i.- - - I +1 -~:t-tv~`:`c:lait~:"'_-.-•~<'-i;'y-r~?~ - . ~~_~I {..+rr cr-Y-~i•tiiir_i-i-t-c^ iir.-1-. ^~il~i{...~j i~.~ _r jm it11" ~~;a!S-fM~-N -is ~.~yp~m - - . Ac- festikSHf thC-Appeal- 1 y_Q L_ i1C„ '~'iII ~l~ : . _ I . . . i i-KfTC~ l'~'T~G'~'IVti { 2 Apimal GO- . • • wnae er Leep.a ef the dalr, ' , -ef'2i 6ewiir+~t~ 4wi b :_{vyml WWI-eL+m - '%Nm +ae!-' _4 . 1t bt -reeaF4fA Famw&sds Dullds inA Nwbeing , Mto#-~ ertirF7ra~-~it~+t5'e* _ - - - ftA!g}e"Alt • c " im of~t-4e+uttg '~e-~ddi4 t3re f_s~mqoest~o~t#~e homiag • 'e`i _ • -and - •t~l~b C-ammissieners (-S-k~r►~Cc4msr{er .L ~ ~ , ~ u ;i_ _ - ~ „~f! 7 . . 3f fhe %rim" mr tho he-orifig on;_~, ' ~~~..S. ~ scf.rs.~u_~ mver~'- cTC~ ?}iil3lF'61► iho-t 10" ; i- hmfin+t-t.~ffieer-a"ire fi~ , -Rowd - ( . . ~-A#se , . il4..- , - {ef@m L!!`~~IlRl4Ma, Offil . k1 *ca6i}g ff-Fd~~tlCS&d-~-~iN41~#Rg +.•~.lE-tr111fl~ , - ff14~1l1l~iF -~~t+n an-~1~4tfi@44t@!~!O am-H 1• •J i k.cer. The 4fs }-~MeTfN~-f~~FfWfi-led-~Wbweefioa'1 : f )q~d, . . , e-t1C-ss3t4!YliY'tU fl1 ' i"W1-1d _F4w4"kfw ' -yR1S-) .-the • _ _ hemitig . ~►inqfi1eRb'*ff v-d . _ . ~~!`f = ~tM1-3!4~_iiiit~-i~4tkF-F~tl-E~'Q-t~-~►tlRiltE{, :`ll~ll:> :s5~t~_lwats??c-~--. j~..a. •-~i-:~t'f -~~tl:a..~-_'1_i~h• .i-~!1_r.-..~~-4"=_ _-,~,.{~t{..~~ - -t-•._r_~ . _'~"iT~_ " . 1*. . - . . ~ ..y. . . - ' - . :a!--"Vpe; iv ~3 :=~tF4ih~fi'r-tfi4f}Nic~-v~il!F'~lF1~c+! • Ic~ifl~-ti•€ _ suc* fal'~'~~ ~i~'`~!Q-y►11 #htci'.%fWFb lb)~sic+r+ - cce,~tl+t~'g ~°g+~+~t-be the ~ - . ec e*eep; •e4easEadeqtmierc~.~,t ~ . *'+MLW f.-F 60eQv-iFOf'6 -e~.'H+t'r4rAi►~-~i--~c~i-~~-~cur4 =:.s~-~itti!!~flf4`•-i?_ _ i:fwH► teltJ-+nAf--O$t -d~e 4og-f5--eo'tC}~4►R}~i fqlYM3 be-4RQa. F~1!-E1wRrdf-s7f-~ - fAUEtf~liH1l~F5i4iplAf-~ti~!'~3}f}Q-Ff~l~it' - :=iii►t~f {~t'!!S-!~^~R~.-~C-~W 4-fY'0' ~Ft}! ~1i{}l4ts~-4t.'-1 ~1t`~fi}~=T ~ ! r-x . the _ =i'~'=s~~~~ ~~~~54~e~i~~► ~-+*iihtn. rk4-;__, - _ ~I J • -111 po -i!pl o- lim @e1-- 'iff, The I`3t ruR~" the Rotion, ph! li ~pj-cM.-I~ _ f?3-~M i - - - i . . . . . - . . _:_.L__....._,,4..r. ~ ~_..r-.. r_t •i-:ir`fi ' _.t-t{_.... . .1::.......-i~ -1•._• .f ~"y "em"'S °ffieer(*j'f")`. in-Ws-fN.- •ii. Ir• _r,_- ~~~~:.:i_ ~ .-1:=•.1 t},ft`c4i.K4+!-;1T5~~iEFs~l51~8e''l~1t' , . t 4F1dfil.. ~:tFfiihf~►! . E!`i}1L`-$ttF~d'R'SFi~A6 ordinanel`--Af10wTMF ;•:~~-p~en~++~}Iti tl+,c4e-a~td+~4-cl+ell be gdtl4~et =+~s~~v►~r: 01 -P+e--t+%+'ner or 6cepai Ff- -q+ou - Wet:►~ati-,t~-;~--l►r.~±nni~;t~ut~}r" ea!lief wF-rt~►,ia~i.. ess-this-f;mrj-efiod-#iafbccm retended ~-ta~►h4i.ar 4 --'-04--f-cb+ - . , . , ffoaw 41- !he lU4en~rF-:-!„ =-_;~e~_~ea~-E+eat+ng-~la:s t -d aaww i .imger-ebs-d?►t itt&t ' t#&ewo- - _L._ a►7,. f*-!'. ~+.t,~r~ ~~~',:,~i ~--rl~-}--a?_?F+r t•ti.nes -:f-!~r~+sr~k.~; !uti taffrir I? MfiH-, ~Cr'!e.lt .1~.i ,N ii.C .i_.- ~It1:1 tT 2-~'!fi-~.~-`-~ "-~.r-..--~•~:-'u-.. -'.t - . r ! tWAM .-pro+4-ir-A- _ . -~rva+Fi-she-•fieea~+g-~et~ts~i i • ' . -R~ ~demienbes-dog +n _ . _ w4FMi1F-kmfEeen , ' ~ia;rs.~f-~~+a owty ~ A fi"Fig "-a dft _ - i g fv!iui& . Jqe do im i/1 . pwe; 1 , . -the deg isenA+"s ' -it-Statien •n . nc c.~°r' - ~ - - -5 : * F 4w*gereoE,~ i Q'. ~ n _ hecties _ P a J.. L :L.e.ow.; -d: _L~tt l_ 'h. ...P.. A ~+~+E~-L'4iaW?'~-M14 {~Hh~+t!iMlr ff=i!!('u~i~-~i~Cf-~?!^~c'L4i+~fi .~e1S2 ~i.`~~tlt~FS~-~-~i3ifi3tti~.?it`flfu'f-. ' :{i ~?~iil ~1:~1,i-.~_i >n_ 1_ t~ur, ~:I•. i ~.tn~rr,ut. i)r•._ i_le~r.--ri~~_::tinr~ \~,~,._.11~ R''~~ltft¢ V Alun cltie animal conucil direciQr ut QeSiMhas wflicicrrt InfarmxUC+n 14 4gomiac that a dc►¢ is aotrnciAlly daakergus as d_cfmcd bv Spgkane Caunfy C<* section 5.01.0:4, t!►S animal cQnnl dirn.'F_er or desiena sha z.c a.~,rclijninnrv dcrlarrticxt rfig{ ttx dog is ; uuntiallv t3anarn-lus. in [ht e,~~nt a gscliminsstV dttamin~li4±1 ls Ak that thc domt is autet~tiallr .'.an=nus. ~nimgl conurl_}.t~11_natifv tYtt doe ownct or k~r_in %+ritinp_ cithst bv tcrsar4~l_c~tll~, r h• r.•,.ular mail. Or determina ~n glIcd p~!Qunnt this ywtion ~hail be dcecncd received bv thG n.►r\ ;u ~kl:ictt i1 is a0resscYf_en the tlsitd dw, atler it is IQ wed in thr mail. as sct futtiL~Y 4 cclarntian ofthc srncicr. f; TZir mAcc must statr' t the s#atuton. bjtsis frx th£pLaDosed actiotr _~.latr~.J i scueht (b~atd. cetR~.,~ .1 dw~..Pticxi of the dogfot wfiich_tk ,;.d ~iccns^ num!-~cr_~f am1; li 1 • . . _ . . ' i. _ _ _ p~itG1i7D~~\ ~3lll'L;~LLS. - . a s~atcmenc chn~ chr rz '~snnan and a~ncrols ~ frrzh in suhscrzion lxluw_ ma~ ' .in c,.Dlangion ot tht vu•M';_jL'Trr'i ~~rp~jtunit~ ar?d li~tl]t.p,3~uuni 7.10U4(]t : a co par,icitHlte rT1 oLn administntike rc%,irw N ith I1,.: :mimal cnnuvl 4imnqr or d.sipcc tn ptrscnt infonnutctn rn +►~hv tttt ~1~,_ ;houl t he dedared a91giciall. dnngenwia, sretcmrnt. DuguAns tn S\MC -o UsUr? H b1. ~h~t ~ failurc by thc dl "u-~ ~ ~Wp-ff to reauect nnd attrnd nn a+irtjnistruitie rcvicw 'Aib_~! _!,,,r drsiunr. shpi,l rc►nsticute x failw-c tu cYhnust Lnal cmtR,l direqloI - adrr.inistrativc MmC4ies. atfd th4t 5u~~i [Ailure to c,hat~st_all niimin'rstraa • :_cmcd~'t~f.}~all prrclude an• "c.al of i he auiminis;M~i. c drtaMiUatiQn-w .t. l_Ievi_n.~.Lxeminrt c,f tqCpurj,.and ,zn cwlellALi4n 4~1 lhe owixrs of kr'y rtYhiS :if74 t}1C PIum 12tp:.LdtitC lv; ,ippe-jljg a decixration t~ai a dos h piltesatiailr_dbnsxrous, fnci4ding an forZt►. l--',%c rn icw a r rcllm-t~rv n.irninis ti~ ~ dclcsminnticrn: PrelIminan• L7c;rn,~inatim of Potcntiallv [.)augcr.ws Dug - f'~to the control dirrctur cx do-ivttre issuing a finnl dctcmtlnatinn tfial a doQ is .-_ntiallv dangcttwf, lhe ariim„g1 conwi dirwot or &siLuIce shal) noiifv tfie ~!:-r ur kcroer in Nridng ihzn he c,r she mAv rpqupt in µnrin¢ to m~+ "k I' Aj►imul conuol dircanr or desiancc far ~ sdsriinisrrori~e_re~_le+~ mcnr _ ~Hn tiftecn calcndar dn~;s follcnkin}LEygei t nf., he nQtice. at uy- ~lmisitaci%t m'Iew fpertini -,►ir qwntr Pf.~:~e.~Cr ma% ci%e. .tirl1~ c" or infi~rmuUon 2a-io wh,~ che do auld not dMla,: •.•ntjqllv danurnxc~. ~l~_e._an adrninistrati~t ~lr. moetin is ry_e,. ~ntin ~,ig Lxncr nr cvnlm) dimto~_,LK cleaim:. IprL•yide a~-itt na ' Y te thr ow-na ix kmmff, af the Jatc, ttms . e t t;tdministreti% e rr iew meetin~ :~dmini tr~}t~~•~rc~ ica- mcetinus br .,ottductcJtrlrphcmicalh. J~ h% the 4nti cn~ner .,r l~prr i~,~ rruurst anau.~i ott ndmirii~lrative '-w mrrtinQ wi4h tttv animnl c4mlr:rl dlEz-tr c+r dcsi,ma 5ltall canstitvtr '.:Ilure to sX,i,nyt AJ) adniini:trati~maliri. an -h failurc ta cahuu~ ~ ailm►rusttativc rcmafic}aJl pm-Llude an% n a o thc ndminiqrutivc :-rrninntiun to thc Ilririnc E,.nminrt or to Court_ such adminiSVat~~~~.Kicu mrrina, the an~nlp!__cgtitnd dirrctor : ien 11 i sut a final dtttsiinatinn. in thc f.irm kif a-,*,rincn eni .lnistratirc rc ~'hin ffte~n ~dnr da% s ~~f (n I ~1K~► 1hz udnl MCCUnU- f(--~.1 . ,w '.Ctl'1;i'. ?P.I!*l~l~ -~'fl[fY~ ~If:~T•~' :i ~I r ~c ~v ~ ~ ' , -A !.tiiC 3 : . 1 _ f - 1 . . . . . . . . . . ~ ' . , - . : ! ' I . ' ' ' I ' . . . . _ ~s ~ f~,,-L c ~ ~ • ~,n, ~ - ~ to . t ~ r~►tnt tun o{ tht ~ ~~~tts!ti 1~•+~ t~ ininQ in N~~° e'ct'cr hv n ~K cs ~a undd thi5 etsa ~ ~ ' ~ d is a[ imited ` o c~c~ ~ in~ ~ s ~hich ~ , w• ~ ~ d wit3lin oN o f Nltt1 ~t ~ C `T! ~ ft • :tti idrn tc~ o 5.04,03b' whc►~ cin u Xc t o ~ ~ tn }n ~ , NA ~ k ~ t~ ri r t vi ' lc N't~ia ~ ~i . `,c ~ ~ r ~ V. ~di; ~Oh" N in S u • jv a~ro"~r~N' ~ d . tT1 c' sh' d► ,~tis11 d°n cf° ,tCntialh' ;,hall ~,cncc aC a ~tit do ► c n • chi{dre~ Oi sub ~~n K S thc dc~ ~ 'o t0 a 1 wi ~ µ J af a.a -i~i ~i tn V~~,C-.~=~~a ~3.-~ nt v a IDA °m dars a ct issunnc r.~ID=~'t~'4~Stai ~ tcc of ~ N fiRecri ~ hcgln- hcfe ~ . ~ 1rc1d tin twen co ~ w a~c►d 1°cat~ ~ (91 ~imlln`~ and tim~ ~w t ~ ~ 'f s n x rt ~ m~ ~ ~ ~ 4 ~ict~ • . , ~nd the H •p ~ isiun cu V ` as~d mntl e~ .ai in tft e ~ t', `u-s-'_ Cu Ji ~y t, h 11 is • 1 dittCl,, of cQntr Isi 1 ~,nctudC tr ~ carin ta h t's ~ °s' sholl "v d,nti c t ~_~~~t tht . ~e tn`~ t~t da rs chin ~~•cn~ ,i , ,15 7 4j~d'~ ' c ch ~R,~w f rint ~ - uu~o ~4icct ~ u Su rir Couri ca.i a N . " 15 4.;1-i4..i3 i)ttrrmeas!evn vF f'-rtr+rt+e~r--f)en~~r»tr~--k.+c,g-~~>ttrc ~~~fnrstrslwc ~te*+ew ra fieg, mod Appesh >-~--+*r)li++es -~--a-d±--:Ta-ff4eotrull%r-d,asgeFr+,*+dc+g-es defined+ff "~:•~-nottee -:-dt~Ri}I Nimg-tf1~: NR1gHEw F~ ~--E11d' At~sc~r'tatit}~-F~1r-n~d ?t k ' defiped i -t:",8_'1*t4_-'4, ; }~j The . aelef. . 4-4 _ ~-e; ' . 41 Th-I i€4hm- g; - - e1a~-a ;-afik~-Fe,4a+pe#-~« ~+e F-egimefed arrft►r~ irtiSeAen - -•i!1?S; Ft { qii}5i-safii"AMl4+Ef!-!Y~`5{ffET'+~~'TV-~=rnr-fT~t~1t~?ftcY-2Sii --'-1tt11 _ mr1ci-ihili£'lMw-1fl9V - . - ~lsjfK-as+f11Q4 be fmpdriCd f.'f~AkC mN71lY _ - ti. ....t etpff _ ~ -~4"-~-r. cT3 14!!tL'S--7l-'~fl ~M14'- Ntgy Wous _ ~1!`fN4l1@~ Ce~ flti{MriL4 it`iw-ffl!lflftft _ _ '~}~BYS-(►~-F~1N ~-~-iftfif;-4R-v►pTEtiffed-wItt-OI1' }K►tffl-Yr44 katimee" --.-+~E-c•€-ti~e-~~t+iet ~t . ihiS . . i . - _ Fed ;t~~►~~-e Q} - ' j±3 ~~'~`-'~•-i - ~ - ~v+i#► '-z=_`_',~,--_~'--',~.°'-__'-'. _-a_•* - ; -1~iftffe - . 44_ d~entfli~+Me-#emad+g~ -kfyh -le eshyMM °.!1 t - < c~±►n s'~ F_'? 1,►Ac-e1-OM- _ 4fm ~.~_.r,+~t as . ~F-{.~ ~-+#n '•-.~::-n.--w { - - ~,~;ttart~~tsl~-~e-#►ei~~ ~ . -+r fiw-d"tt- The-#ew:-. --=-,--tt~► AiMt-MVrbe-~wt~~n~t~--4:~~~# . . ' .4-1trt_ - ela;i~~-AMW J. . lI 4p" . . , ~►{e.~e tlwdjf",,MjSkFaEi+tre~Jgm~-meetif- ,•trig.-as-w-rl;_.as_!hr. , .wltr--t#te-dog~lk~s~!-t~c•t .::.•:r.~--i . ++.~~~l+~s4k-~+e hc►Id km- ,h_ fria1-C-t-m,,. . de%igme. je-bam nr-a► rt,a,n,n _ - . .t,ev 4~1#~r~l~ilc-Aeliewinn m! ma) 1~.v!-kie~s~~.H►icall~: "►iiiFi-E---L-l+s2OOs--_ be?f~i~te=-i~'v~A4" -iM-fl4erF.t the 3-jog-:tpe't14W4CFC+`:- -t-~!ElMi~M1R6Fia ~ lR~~1~-e~~-i=rs~~Fr~t~ i~1! ~ -~11a6'[(►f . :~fr~~ee _ ~bfl5ic'N41~e-fe~fics?4!Mr.~ti'~1'Hii-~{ ' the -CtC-f a-"Iel4!tl11V 141 ~--~f4tRi3~-C1►RLlt►{. ~f~f-af-~tE~ _ . • -t~11'`t~w~'.-, 16 , •~c+-t?itli', i~"rc i:-LEt~re~r-~?~.itC -~frrr:td• ~-~+fi'r.=---:-~-?ct1-.---.-'-?rtr'fN -t!-.•:•'r•- }Y-~~~~~:zi-::: ' Fs-{ -Mtt~~~_¢~►f f :-c•tf11}IlR~HR: ft- _ _ , . _ , ~ awncr or I:ecper of a dange~u~ d~rtiusi oAtui~a certifrraic at ifsra~ion iar surl~ animal fram u►imal conlrc,► .-ilhip fif3ees, dnm uta cfeLtar3tim Qjdan=ous dogor 'A iihin riftesn daNs af thc~ta ,M1 dcrision if at+cxslC4.fj Rmvitkd in 5N''N1C Sagion 7=4.~No dog shall t±c tstums4 b%.SnoEcune C'oumv animal cvntrt3l tn_an3_Qne nclcx to the issuattce os ~hr crrtifrt ~f rs~strsticm Thc cen,fic~u rc~is~a~~ s.ha1) bc issuec! pnh sf chc oN~na ~ kc-•ca of thc dwe.g.rus dc►e orcmcs sufficicnc PTIZgf nf chs tellowina: IA prrncr cnclosurc to canftnq adangn"us d,o and nvstiiie af thc Qrrmises with a :Icarlv ~isiblc s;¢n that thc.rc is a dan¢,eroucs&u on thc provcnr. in uddition, ihs o.%=, sW conapiwous)v disnlsv a sicn with a wami Q sNmbel thet informs , tilldrrn of tho nrewcc ota danQCrous due: ? qs rctv bond m rtouircd b,, RCw' 16 08 D$0 as adopicd o► amrn5~.gA bvA ;uret% uuurrr aunlifirtl under ~20ter 4878 RC1l' in 11 f~_~crtnble to thr ,~N,kane Crn~rrn• animal canval in thc sum of g Ica~ mo hundrcct fifci_ffiqqWA J:'i1n_rli. ~at~ablc w any dxrwn iniurtd bv thc dang"s daa reQadless o,f whcihcr ;niurv occuts on s+s off thz ownu or kerpex's nretni~s: qL poli,-r af habjlicy_jp&urancc as mq,ir+~d tao RGY►_LI:08UftO as adiLytn1 c~ such as homeo,.vner s ini (M►..~ec~ tn in insurrr gualificd WW RCV1' T-ttle 48 in thc amount of st lrast tMo hur►cirai fft%, tK-tu,s_Qnd dnllus. in~trrina }hc guner nr kVrer for any pcr~,-nal inlurie1 itlflictec! b~ thc dancerp*_~c~g :•:anjlF. ,.f -xheth- tht infun occttr oiff o~.the ownet nr lct;p_er'f_PL4tl!!~: t1i f.x ths dottitcrvus dvc- In n.1clitiun_ thc -4turar_4r kecper of s . c, ~ . . , ~ i fu i e-,1;22kan!: Coumtv animnl canitui a cc►mpletc :apti eC the surrt~~ ~pd or i¢ji~v insurancc nolicv c~j~iW in subsectiun fA)12'I and ~1 3) and shnll allo%% thc Ctuntv t n:a5cmablc timz tc, Mieu ihr bc,nd ar Wicv to '._•t-_nn~rc ti~hc!h:: !h; ii~h~l~n c.~~?n~•e i~ =u?'_'Lirrt. -rr~t rn i::r~in^ ~hc cr~if_:='c 17 , L1 U:i;ecmus dirgs muri be smti-ed-ncu[ere,d Nithin thittv cfavs of reg,isuation. I1Thc_guM ;r kccr)cr of Ihe danecrcvs ,i>e ihdil_pr.~%idcd suffic~en pmc~f of surlt a~m%ingnrutcrinu ~rvm tv t~ ~knnr CountvAnimsi wnlro! In addiiion to_.thc rcvular doa, i 'n fccs st! fnr!► ip ScctiQn 5.04,(1?Q. ihc oarnr t.ca~p- tt of dpgcnuus dira s,tcall Rn,. an annual recigrgii p frc in thc artt~La(onc hundrtd .fallars. I'hc rrgisimior)_►~ill bc valid for twrl~~_ts,~nths. nll"iice dap s4 detine4 in_R('N IS-axia,~ 4 '4 his seqiqp s4! not ap j 1►ccpcTgf adattgctous de tLnlol notih SrkiAanC Count% anlninl .,vf1Uyl_11) . ihe aanrro .+nttn¢ if shC deg is dccrauA or if the_4an.gerous dum is to k►s relmated er if chgm is s n:►ngKin vu•nershin, fnth v, ent of n:hant,e af Owncrship and ut rel4.uion of tl_. t,._gcrvus Yjhe cns'ncr or 6erpu rnut p~vide S~wkant ('aunt% nnimul umvol with :Ii. •+rlete address ond ph "c numbrt of Qte ntu oHnct or keccx~ ~inr to thc chanet lcrshin arxi pr rYlp~cation of die dartgcroos dog. The oN ner or kerver oC thr danpcvu, i un~this subsoc~IcM ~tl~_glsl nocih em u- uent owncs or kce c o's 'i 2nuim as a dat►IeMUs dOg i4,p dortnod dungcrous bv othcr iurisdictiun% in thc stuic i,f 11'as(11n►e_og rvill bt subjft-i !hc snme rv2+)laii.,ns as iCthcv ha%e betr► dacmrd dAr►gaous in S22'snc Counn• Cm __rned dan~aaus bv iurisdicnions otnsidc oPtht sthte of V►"a an !Li11 be tvaluate~ a~4 I: _ iamd dunccrous bv tfie animal sanirnl dirtc,'tur cir h49 or hrr drsignec ar1 An indi,,i~ :i~ w detempirlc ti%hcthcr thcr mcxt ihe [g1ulrcmcnu of Ajuncg ,.us dea, tukina into thc uiteria estnhlished bti Ce+.Yion 5(14.n~niR)_ [)nr~_mertine thc rcauirrments of u :_n,4-raus dag under thiAsi4t: c --ricticns imAiscA 44n~e~ is sc:•? ~ l )3Itl~Crclus clvk -sYqist,~ntian mu~ : ftneA.:i ~ h; t7c~ L~c~ci_ ~l;al l al~ .at.,•% 1•J4_ ~ .ynll 8itl~'. . .i . i . . , , _ . . . , . . • . _ i 1 i r' . tirn ~+'i~ LF-0~-8-~Cf±+l~±s~+•~-siltltiF-e1~4Slfl--t'3z'Yf'~',..._ •i _ . of-tfve-.a".. c-le ?~ti~sk~-~F-;~e~-it~-3+.~(~t~1-~.4L3{~?? 1_:.+--t}~►~_'~ _ _ OR-mNi4'f 4fFtT-5cAft'si: 1 . L. .~.r - ~~:c"_.=f--. •..-:-.s ._._...:i, ....L.....:._ :.:if i t5f=licz a~-=~n-fi`-~.s~~=-ct}i-• ~~-~{'S-i.'~-~= ti-c~-t.""r,."-~t: 1idt7,}.....-r•.^~-t:`~ ~!1-_-i.._..';...~ ~ ~ f t n.W4ion.-44& av►f+er" 1~~sigt-'"3t# . . f ?%Y A mi - - - . . - - ~ _ • - . . . . BR, {S:,' . . -1E! . -bl- - - injuped f ,,..al Ls. - ~ ~an+er~. „ her-~~ ~y►a~~►~~~~} .4. ip-0 lieyo€l+aw!4~ . . , ' i &=?1~ tN_IQ3-i~ - FO ' - A~!'~'r- • u ~ T_d{ . - ,d,r'.i_... .L_ zt_ , -eK-~t - .}{pe4 - - ~f.1~ty62Eiifna%V-E~!@Cf7lMlt& pfiur- . owEific'sk-9f t=~ , l~1t t Mf4y 1444a~Ti ~eeptiL "pnwide itf~~iE'~~l'ft~"~f0f►~~HR'~' -A Animid A r . - od I Mh-11F-3t . F. . _ , 1 mgimral~m fiec i Il`-etl'N?em-J~tMw j1mfidPEii Tl~t5~i8~fitf kl-~-li-►f►lT11i415 ~ ~l~FN'?E~•.. . _ _ -'~-i'!~ _ 1`._, t__...-_ i.1._.1.~ u I <!!i§ J-t~4e~54f~l~-8f +a~ aE1~djHHft4 11f 4hlS 5^@Elf'??-~19MF - - _ ~ _ ~i,~-IeFM4-t5m!'d -~libsafsinll-j!Wl t%t++m fi 41len-{-i ")-s'#eys-€ ' !eny-'---A 1?~ _ -Ic•~?~~1 _er~-~tirs-itrH';e~a-iafl the - ' . _ .~~i•; . . 'i4a 314W -T4-,_•v,-et-•::+.:~,r►<.#'a-~~,~L~?~reci~tt4~t~=~--#--___=;~~~f4,c:c~+~3;n~e{'fict~~ ~f{ i . - ..:i: - ~ _r~ ,~~~us _ ~~e~+c~-~-~Fv~ic#r ?►;~~1;~-~?eir►~~ -~~i~-t==+FILF*_-~~{ {l-1i~--w+~t +QJ ~.unbeat~?- - ,x 6ee~~+t~f--tc~-~i+e ~ dee=~7~+i ~•w:►a~-~.r-~rr~~~t►z _ . .s{-k~( tiM @i~i-~!f'f►i~ _ _ V (~$ft-fft 1-~4~1C. . . ~.tfbjm i~.=-dft-!~f1'1@-fa'~ti3 . . - tn!'f-t-F-L ve'rg'f_ ,i.... y - ~ gi'l~tt1~-~l-t~t'~'-~t~-~~-~-i~►i~~!ft-~-~8~ fl•~t'c+3l'?--4.41 AN-IM&I _ F • ~~K` -5fitWi& -EffltntS i (1-1, 1 11- _ di6- -i'~5!'f.fE-ir:"n'c`~cz" , , . p-1114,Bilih-f ^i.rtfi£l?N!t'4-i4}fPR-I-e4itT~-'11t'R: Ajft±,±~. - lc4j!4v _ - ~ h-. - - . -deemed • •-irf !---~ritmnci-iLxP'FM-fR!!M - - wamigw"to - 1-Q#nf±n t~{ ~ll~Cf~~ltS~3i~ft~f~4tw-wM4SA- , wt4Vt-f12) fne"ths- A"Pt` . The ?V4MQ-{!"~{-she}}-alwi-pq"idt . -C.►Mft4-~~~-FtFtx+f-rf " ' - 7R- iytl tv~ - K1~ly._ - -ac F ~,.avaAA!il4kq-d!!5 Uangcrous dogs-Idcatificntion. 11u owner ar lcecpcr of a dog detamincd to bt dangcrous, pursunnt to S~ 5.04.032 ar \1(_ 5.04.035(6§), sltall have thc dog idcrtitizxl hy a m:cror.hip implnni. l'hc mir,rorhip implant Thall fx iojeclod in nccordancc widi licy cstnblishrd b bpofcene4gous►t% A icc _ . , t.':i2C rCv OI:ESOn OI 1tiC_6 nr kocprr of a dartgtrous dog. I-r.41.0307.3U.14u Unlav►•ful l-sc ut L.mcntic 11.: I, ,:1 It is unlawful for sny o•.; than thc onc for which it was issucd. If tl,L:rc i•. a ::hansc o1 the new owncr must Aprly for and obtain u new license ss requirecf in this chnp, tt: lt is unlawful for nny pcrson to usr thc lit~en.ca tag for an unlawl~~i or ta canccnl thc ownership of thc ani"tal ctn nT "t or rcmovc thr lirrnsc tag pr.,•• :in ihis chapter fri-m any dog (ir cnt, wich che ;ntcnt tu drpri% e tlic c,«ncr t,r kceprr thcreof '~i I A Nvillful viulatiim uf this scctiun is u misclrmexnor. ~5:14,1142' 30.145 Commorcbl Kcoocb i: o - Commcrrial kanncls located in -,1- •k@nt::tiehRi~t~ shall bc liccnsod as roquiral by this saxtion. Commaria) kennel licxnses shall be for a twelve-month 4-'_-1 period end shall bc cenewed on or hefare the expiratian aF the tvrclvc-monih r;_- pcriod. 'The foc~ for a oommereial kcnnel llcxnse s}WI t•e a% 0,tATfi!'hrci b arsasc n:y,Aueion _.t 1t1: att :ourn:il. 9('RAP~=An+mal rontnl shnl) mail a naticc of rutcwnl orlicutse noc las tlian thirty i~+~~dsys prior to the expiration af said liccnsc. Individunl ficenscs arc not reyuirod !oz aay animals Iegnlly mainteinai within a cvmmrr,clal kennel. .i_Applications Car commacial kecmcl licenses shall be mede to Spel:ese C-ounty~n~1£~tE~ ~~4i~~?.ar~imnl :omtml. Each npplicatinn shall be in µTiting, and signed und rtvarn to by the applicant 'Ibc npplicxtiun shaU contain the Colluwing ~ informauon: •n 11 7"he nnme, home address, and tclzphone number of the applicant; A?i=-'Ibe businas name, business addreas, and tclcghanc numbcr of the proposed commcrcial kcnncl. ~ __A dIagram to scale or approxlmately to scale showing the pniperty and structunes for which the license is sought; -a A dio,gTam ofthe kennel fuifity; qlt-; 4. A description af the prcmiscs whem the kennd will be aperated, as wcll as n ckscripticm of the magnitude artef nsture ofthe prcrposcd business; and ~i'j - h,--A written statement from the sp-okenr-kt+ww.-Bw~Tw--~!ki ;'l&VtiPg-4h+i4WiiCi1%~ Comln!:nit~- !~^ticlC~rITlCfii C~C~:~fSTT)cnt thst tb0 contemplated busi*+css complia with applicable zorting laws. I ,1;. $pe►kane-- S' RhPr►-anirnal onuol may fClttse issunnoe ar rcncu•al nf a licensr, or rcvoke or suspend said licrnse, upon finding after such ~ invr.scigatiun on ccaring as it deems nocessery that: 44~- I__ llic ltcense fec has not beai paid; • nt epplication does not satisfy the raquiremrnts of subsection 4_4E3; --3_Upon the inspection by the Aniena1-Gntfe4 Director or hisJher ,lr..igncr, thc business does nat mcet the standards for a commemial krmscl -lct forth in subscctiun iL}! ; -i: Such licenso waq issued illegally, or by mtstelce ar inadvertence, or w,is pcocured by fraud, misr;presentation, fafse nr misleading statements, ewssions nr supprcssian of material facts, or thst sny af the metrrial fucts cuntainrd in tlte applic::ition asr 1alsc; 'I - 1 he ticenscr, nr nny acent ijf !hc (it~cnsee, in c.>nncctit?n wiih the upcraiion of the cvmmercial kenncl, tuis, within a nvo-year period: ~i mit _ ialet~~h+~ I ,A,Wter= }Fi,_-[3ccn found guilty of or cvmmitt~ ~ n violetion of any provisioru ot this c tcr z}+ap4ff -1--~=or ~4•,4}ti _16.08, or-shapter 16.51, or 16.5-1 or +;iiN, -$rtn found guilty of eny other miswnduct, or improper, fraudukm, or %rongful bet►avior rclating to the operation of a comreiercial kcnncf; V10lUICd LUtY Of i}1C SIdIldBfdS ln1posCd 1")t upcfJfiiill M :l t;tltTIiI1CTCIQI ICCMtI I7y subsection (5) of this sectic-n Any scrvnnt, agent employco or rcprLsentncivc ot thc cumtirerci,il kennel Itas txrn guifty of eny act or amissian whilc an tho pcemises of tLc cummurini kenncl, whcre said act constitutcs u criminal violation of this chnpter, j;d4•+a = a_= or 16.08, of-Aatxer 16.52, or 16.54 s~; or has bec~i guitty of any misconduct or improper, fraudulent or wrongful behavior rclaling thr opcratiun uf the wmmercial krnnel if' cho circumsiances surrounding rany of thc foragoing acts ur enussions arz such as tn cstablish tliat sueh uct was knowingly allowed by any perwn sharing in profits of said busincss, or, if a wrporntion, any afficcr or dirrctnr thrnoof, or of any pcrson acting as aproprietor, mennger, or pcxson in ehnrge of such business; or -1•. in nny cvrnt, if twu or morc sut:h arts or umissions hgvc Oxxumecf an dic premiszs within a twaycar periocl. :4- ° Fallurc lo obsave any oC thc standatds set fcirth in subsection ~5•! oi this scLtlon. D. Any applicant who has duly mude npplicntion far a commercisl kennel licrnse under thc provisions of this scctiun and has been denicd sucb Iicense, or any persan holding a licrnse which is revokcd or suspended undcr dte provisions of this sec:lion, may to I}IC Hf1f1;1L Exsntinc~ u'ith3n littLrn .fa~i stt`r 155uaDC~ '~.-minalion bv filinc a noticr ot appcAl with the animl cJR_11, authnrin. ne wntt:•. L.1I sfiull ypstl-_ ttK rtnascmfsl µ-hy his-hsr_Ijccpfr %hc•uld nut be ;n'jlt~tc~ ~34 ~-i1C+ffi~!-t . _ fi!c~R M=lih i}i! 01% C-lTf'ji~ 1~4N--~E~3E~-~~~~i=.riifR4'r~ . -~il~2fiR~--~l`it~F2--~iN-~4'4Fe~•t~- . . • . 4t-Rtat. H.. ' ' , - . n'iledliZnf!, ib<_" ~:--~l--~sS+~HV 9#,K*.\n% drnial, rcvocatian or suspcnsion xhall he ,t:syod until fi:isl rrwlutiun ~tseietr,-peiiiing Pµ-l --it; i P. m o f-At- _ . . _ _ +~+c~.`~=r,r-ne~t+±~er-~-i~r~i sr~viii»-'• 4eF=i•f~~~i~t~ :l .3~Ei=a-'7(.:r:,T_t.;6;,:..::;71»~-_:,-{.t~:.n_ - . . . , _ - _ . t~,c ~~ll t+c hsld w•ithin tµerm d,sys ofter rocciM of :ti_ J :lfif2i> i ,:ontinurcf for g.c cl uuge shown. 1he snimal rnnUVl dircctor or derigyr shall natif%thz ,icrnw hnldcr in writing of the dAsr timt and lMticm of the y2pfsl hearinr k+eferc the I tk4Mnsf.x,miW,arj4 said n,LjjM5hqII ~*e tccri%cci at leau fi%c JaNs hrfcxr the hcar'rn. 7bc anaeAl hearing shall !x ra.ordcd, and tfic tfcaringE,xamincs moti al14%► IcnimQn,* an,! ¢ogumenu dtgt aue rcicvAnt ta the administrativc dctrzmination thas rcvocation of thr ~~~-ma~ denial: - upea►-S+sch-~tg-d+ei-~~}+ . , , sWI- :}--whteh-"1.. idr ~ ~ -~~M ~"~!elllf~ ~!lffFiR~09f~-~~l!!ii#i-~'r41f1lNl~Stif/flMT.j!!!lR11i#~-il~Ia1R4lIlhF~1l8!'1MZ'sbU f 7t _ _ _ -»1 C.E iifd-4-WAAii1[alR: i ne_} iss ,gfaw7iitcn decisinn. and r[~1 a~.~r►._nt ih4 dr~~~~n_~Lu~- licerzs~helder end to the artimrl ccvitr+l director ot desiencc xithin fifteen daNl af th; aw-W hcarine, adminiat~txi~~d,~ie~r~iruui~~n~hat a~ira}se ,sho~tld ~+e dcrticd, re+-ekead es ~uspcr~drei. sno shnll inelude t3ndings vf fau and c«xlusirns of law that suMg!ct the decision. lre dccisio~ 5ha11 lx gi%rn the rffM Qf_a final dec+sinn_hv_ thr Citti_ Criunril anJ_shall_ ctnie_ :hai_tt"_ derisl9'[! !PAy_~c al _cd to Sur: "ihc tullu«'ing oprrstiuu Stxndar,7s shall br i.ih;errrJ in coiuim-lioti wiih :k commctCial kctwcl: •T~"- 1:lll animals must have an adcqunte suprly uf drinking %vatcr, sanitary sleeping qunrceES. adcquntc shckcr, mGdic:nl aitcniian, groomin~ and cxercise areus appropriate ta their size, 6reed charactcristics and climatc; ~ 4}--_-'_AU animuls sha11 bc supplied with sufficicm good nnd whoicsamc faod as oflrn aa the tcoding habits of the respective animal9 roquire, but not less dtinn, in the case af puppies or kittens under four maaths of nge, three timcs every t«•cniy-four haurs; and in the case af adults, ance every• twrnty-Cour hours; ~ ?_-Food "l be stomd in a fashion which pnwcnts coataminaiinn «r infestatian; --?__lhe +-tacilities shall be maintainai and operatnf in a hcalthful, snnit:en m:inncr, frre frum cliseasc, infeitntion aiitl toul I A's1 animxls at7d anin:ul hutldines or rnelo,ures shstll hc mnintaiiied in : clean and sanitnry rnndition. Heusing faciiitics shell he structuraUy wund and sha] I bc maintainai in guod repair, to protect the animals from injwy. to contain tl,c animels, and ta nstrict the mtry of oilicr animals. All recisongble precautians sha! I be taken to protect the public Crom the animnls nnd the animals from the public. ~ - t f; t, Sick animals shnll t►e isolated fram hzalthy ones in quartcr, adequattly vrntilntal to prevent contamination uf healthy animals; d4a-fae4tfy4s-fwt-open fer busines: ~ -•itei x Animals shall bc immuniza! Gom discxsc as is usunl and cuslomnry for the animals' age and species. I , -J.,- U Al) animal rooms, cagcs. shipping containus, and nms shnll bc t1. Sufficient siu to pmvide adeqwue and propcr uccummodations and pratection froin tha wcather fur lhc animnls kcpt thercin. If individunl rvns are utiliud, the surfncc shnll be cPrnent, gTnvcl. or shavings. At n minimum, sufTicient space must h- providcd for rvcry animal in an enclosure to separatcly and tQgether, stend up, lic down, t+nd turn around in a natural pasitian. I ,:l 1!!_All nnimals shnll te mnintained sa as to ccrmply with ~!C~-- • 5.oa.om(7). ~.Nu commercial kennel ticense, or nny rtnewal Wercof, rtiAy be isYUOd unul thc awner or operator lh+xeof allow-s the AnimaWvntrel Dirrcior or hislhcr dtsignce tn inspc,: the pranises uf the license applicant. Such inspections shali be made dwing rcgul,; husiness haurs. The purpase of such inspcrtian shall be to drterrnine if die cnmmerc;J ~ kenncl does or cnn meet the stnndards sct fonh i,i °,!:f~~,erti~~n Tt~c -1+t~ma! l'.;e{:{..; birector, or hislher designre, may inspect thc ~ with the pmvisions af this ardinancr. ~ Any perwn owning or exetcising umtilil u1 d;l LI:L:Cc:115;;.7 v51:lIRGi:411 kL:Ill:il L~ guitty af a misdcmeannr. ~ Privale Kcnacls ~ PrivatC kennck luc;+Ied in ;h;tll hc lict-nsrcl rayuired by this section_ Privatc kCC►nel Eicrnsca shall he for s««I~e manth riod and shall be renewrd on ur beforc che oc iralion of the twclve,~- nzonth criod. ilim S~~1ca►e•Fotmw-:1n+ma1-G8ntrbl ~+-~t-~=~ 1+-:t~~,,: _I .shall mnil n noucc uf n-newal of liarnse not less thgn thirty iiays p6or to thc cxpir;.tian uf t;aid li+;ensr. Indiviclual liccn.rs Irc n„t rrquirc•d for any animiit, Ir:_ally m,iint:+ined •,vitliin a private I _ ;_.Appliraiians for privaic kcnncl licenscs shall bc macic to Spakansfownty Ani,nti!-GeW&e! 5ER-A~nnim~1 ;,-ntrL~t. Each epplication shall be in wTiting, eod signcd nnd swom to by t}tc applicaat. The appl(cation shaJ) contain the foilawing infcxmation: 1_Thc name, hnmc sddress, and tclophone number of the applicarn; _A disgnm to srale ar approximately to scale showing the property ind stnictures far which the license is sought; t~• - 3 A diagram of the krnnel faciliry; A descriptian of the premises wticre the kennc! H-ill bc opcraiod, as well ac a description of the magnitude and nstwe af the ptoposod private ktnnel, including the numbcr nnd breed of dogs or cats ta be hocscd there; I ~et A desaiption of the usrs to which dv propcrties surrounding the propnsed private kemic) arr dcvotaf; +ff n A writtrn statcmem from the spAww (7s+m±-~~+~-3-~*' +3 .-'-Pi&qn+++til i;► (';,mnr-,inot% 1zc~rl:~•-r•-nf It ~e-nt- that the proposai private kennel complies with appliralle usning laws. ~ , - -4_i+pokmne-Qttasty--Af%ii"al-C-a#t+e! *t ~RAPh±Ani A1 cenval may refusc issuancc ur rcncwa1 af a licrnsc, or rrvuke ur suspend said liccnse, upoa finding nfta such ~ im°tstigation on ccaring as it dccros ncccssary that: The licensC fx has not becn paid; 71tie application does not satisfy the requimuents af subsection Such ticensc was issuod illegally, or by mistake or inndvertcnce, nr wa; procured by fraud, misrcprcsentation, false or mislcading stntcments, cvasiocu nr suppnssian of material facis, or that any of the matcrinl tnru contained in the iipplication are false; A, s OpcrntiQn oCthe kennel constitutes a pu6lic nuisancx; c The licensee. or any agrnt of the licensce, in connection with the oPer.ttion of the privato krnnel. has, within a twayesr period: .t- Baen found guilty of ~~mi~ted a viotetion nC any of the provisions of ~~h~rtcr,.,_~,~~rt-~ ±=-or ~=-1►~r~K( W 16.08, o► I b.52, gr 1~~t~;~.i~~«4r•-F :~,.~r+,,:t.-t+; ( sf Ns ebe,4e~' i 6Violated any nf the standards impascd fas operaiion oC pm2to kenncls by subsociinn (4) hereof: or •.~i+~~- =Kept macc than the number of dogs or CaLs allowed by subsxtian il; heroof. i~ '•.i~.^~_rii .iit Nht~ has dul. rtt:►At :tMji0L(tZf0r 3 C!T1%1I[ ICCIIACI IIttT15: iu a di i th15 sectian at►d has bccn deniod suth ligatst oran): ncw~ inga I'tcrnse ih is rr.•oksd or susnend~d un_da che.prv% i+ic,ns of thif uccion, mav anpeA) in wftn; alfTIItlIsir11k-C (l[{tfTtli~~1ll;i,oTl IePt;no~ i°~iA,ng oT sL'SFCrid)Tli' J I1C[!I5t fti the iinring ' . .,i•'-i- ~ , _ . _ ! '~'V:_1n - ' ~ _ : i I . ' I t'_ _ 'J _=.~s.x~ s i uh~ ~u hcr lic€~ shuuid no: ~ deril~i. rc% nl:e~ ~,I sw~ , 'u q sugxnsicm shnll ~a►e.f nntil fnal rewlucjnrof thc aw, i i, hcnrintshall bc held v►ithin t~verm da% s Aftcr rrccipLdthe nuticr ~ !irlLCd (c•f Y(.yd caust S}tC'u~'►1. The animat cont7el (T~Mof Qt Qn1inc- stiaji .~n~e holcier m writi~nr~~.f the date, time and It~~alian of ft hc$ E+etart Uic -'Irina F nminrr, and said noiice shnll bc receivcd ns la~t fi~c davs hefttrc the heaR4$; I~• aaaeal heashall be rexoFdec! and ~ Hcaring~xamincr maI-allow• testiniony erid _imrnu th~t nre releV4W to the d~rt~inisirati% c__drterrriinrstot~ j~at rc.~tip~ uf tht ,:rse IS N;YdlTantutl. Hicsrine Ftiamintr h&ll iss n wr~ctcn dcLisir,Fn, nnd rtiuil a cc?tsv uf tbe dtgision ti.• the nldcr an4 to ihc anirnal cctntrvl dit~'tar vr desistnC;_ %ithin Reen dn%•s uf e ; ~l hea~{Ly: The ilex[i_n~ EutmtR4!'s e3ecisi ~ s1~a11 au:e,p, eic~l ar mo~~'sf~ the i r., ~npsti~c drterminatirn► ihat p litrnsr shvuld be denicd- rei-Ir u,spended. and :i I inclueie f+.t►dirsrs of fa,ct,3nd ccknclufiuns oClaw that the ctcti-isiun. Thc 3~.~c+n ~,!l he gi►•ai the etTco of a fitsal d«isiun b~ :he Citv C'eungil, nnd shal) 's-latc tJwt the ision maN ,V sp+calcv! to Supcrior ('ourtpursuYnt tu CW 7 16 ~+jthln ~►cnt~ da~~ ~~rr i:_ .Je_i~iunti,.nc re.ri%,ed. . f. lhe follnwing operativnal_standards shall bc ubserv«i in conncction with a privatc kccurcl: ~ ~o► I_The nnimals must havt an adcquntc suppty of drinking wntcr, sanitary s[xping quarters, and ndequate shclter, medical attentiongroomin and cxercise are3c appraprinte to their sii.e, hreed chttracteristics and climate; _ All animnls shall lx supptiecl wieh sufficient goad and wholesnrne firod as otZcn us the feeding habiu of the rcspective snimais ttquire, but not Ics, I than. in the case af puppies or kittcns undcr faur months of nge, three temcs ever, tHenty•four ~=s+hauts; and in the cese of aciultc, once evcry tweaty-four r=-i+ linurs. _ -;;_AII enimals and animal huildings or cnclasura shall be mnintainril in a clean and sanitary ecmdition. l-lousiiig facilities shnll be structurally sound and 5hull be maintainal in gcxW rcpair, to prutect the animnls froni injury. to contain the animals, pnd to restrict thc entry of othcr animalY. Al) reasonablc precauiians shall he takrn ta pratr.ci thc public fram the animals nnd thc aniinnts Crom the public; ~icanintxls shall bc isrlntrd frum healthv ones in quwtcrs ad ata y ventilatod cnprevrnt cotwmination u►eafthv animmis; tinimnls shnll be immuniud frrnn diseasc 0 is usual ~an,i tttstomnrv for t_ t enlmals' uge nd s ccics; ~ ;.tG h_All animal raoms, cages, shipping cantainCrs, and run5 shal) bc ! sufiicient size to provide adequate and pmper accommadadnns and protection tiw the wcaiher for the animals kept thrnein. If individual runs are ulilizal. thc surfack: shull he crment, gmvel, or shavings. At a minimum. sutticieni spare must bc provicltci fot every anima) in nn cnclosurti to scparaidy srtd together, stand up, lit- iSo~rn, nnd turn around in a nHlural positiun; and ,ry :,exi-' A11 animals shall bc mnintainrd su as to comply witti • ~ ('Semion 5.04.070(7). f_r; ~ No privatc kctuttl sh411 have mom than cight Nt+dogs Md/at ten .?4i+csss without the cansrnt of Spok+na °r~imnl :~mtn!. af-+--t_,_No private kennci licrnsc, ar any cr»cwal ihcttof may be issued until the owner or aperntor allow-s, the Anims1-C-imtrel DiroctAr, ar hiwher designee, to inspcct thc pramiscs of the Ifornse applirant at a mutunlly convenicnt tirne. 7be purpose of such inspectian shall be tn detennino if the privnte kcancl ducs or can mect the standards set forth in subscction ~ 4C My liccasc or rr.newal tlxreof shall bc cunditioned on the owner/operator ellowing the Artiow1-Cenlrsl Director or histher dcsignoe to inspec.K the premises at any tima to insuro ~ compliance with thc provisians of this ordinancc. ~ F-- F1. Acry pcrson owning or exercising oontml of in unlicxnsecl private kennet is Ruilty of a misdcmeannr. Pr$i natod Ot'i l.eas6 Arw{al - Rnlca and Iteaulations. F.xcept as cxptessly allowed in this siction, ii shall be unlawful for any person to allow ar pcrmit thcir dog la run at large. Dags may bc sllowed W run at largc only in tl+r-fiaHk~wiftdesigrmted ofi-lcash arcast mav be estiblishrd bv resalutlon rf dhe cin, ii._ An arca designaud as ofT Icash area in subsection (-H 1 hcreia, is govemed by the t'ollowing rules end regulstians: !__Any person 6riaging a dog iato thc otT Ieash area rvnaina liahlo Cor dsnage or injury inflidcd by the dog uxd is sabject tn all ipplirable Washington Stnte attd ~,•;~af►c.'t+:joiNt_,v- lawx rcgulating dop. '_Any Dog deemed pocantiaily dangocous or dangtraus by any rccognizal unImul contral amdhority is not a!lawed in sn aff-Ieasb arcY. I My pcrson bringing n dog inW en off-lcash azca must maintnin control of the dog(s) at all times. s No hanclla in allowaf to havc more than thrce E~dogs in un off-leash arca at any ona dma A handler must attaid hisThu dog within an off-lcash erea at aIl times. ~ , Any dog achibiting dsngerous oc aggressivo behaviar. int:luding but not I[mited W hiting ttnd tighting is prohibitecl i'rom an ofr 1cash arcu. ~7 A}femalc dog in hcat is not allo«:rcf in an nff-leash arra. I ' My prrson hringing e dog to an ofl':Icash_arra mu~-t Ics;h the doo NOh;n ic k c,ut5idC tttc ofT-lea0i :i:ca: and. rlu,.t ~:arry a fea-~h for c_3L:h (I-~~ %Oilr insi<lr the ii;t- Icash nre:e Pincli and chu4r ~:UIIdPs (iiC ro; al'w,vcd -.Oc:i ado; i~, ofi;rasii ;n ;fi_ ott•1c:=ili ~ ,-1 i.Mcs must tx: %accinatcd. 10- Any persdn britfging a d~~g in[u un oft=lettsh area mwt clran ttp fer.es :tflcr the dng=deposit feces in the runt:iintn-s at the oSf-Il'.01 tif1C, snrl visibly carry ctluipmcnt far removing fues. I I_ Mychlldrai lcss chen IG rt ;I!•:c ;n thc ,irC:i mu;t by a parent or guardi,in. ! rIo gless contnincr; , r _ilc011.11 ,:II1 .tic,1 in An At Ir..i_.h ,117c.11. li:it1~~~ , tI1d ~•[I:c'Y'.\!;I't!Cli I'CiI'_., :77C (11k'111}~I'C.j ~r-I,.~. df; dfl7 , - .~-<< "0.1;11~ L:nforzrmcrit Pu»cr ta+-r -A 71ie Artirna!-E~ Uircctur Of }1iS IZCf drsignee nre auehorir.aJ ►u takc -such lawful action ss msy bc ruquired w enfarcc thc pro% i5iorts of this chyplrr. _ ,•F~~-=1~ar-r~-,~-..;~ : ..:t and = --i- 16.08, 16.52 and I6.54..~ - •~~:,►++n~tt-!~. H. Thc Artima~-C'-~ot►tro; llirector or hivhrr designee, unless auelwrimd by the owner or pcrson entitled to possession therenf, shall not entcr private dwcllings which are not licensed as either commercial or privau kennels unlcsY g proper waRant has bern issue:l upan showing that the Affirng-C-enta1 Director ar hisfier designee has reasonable cause tu hclicve that therc is a violatiun of this chapter, -v.•IraF+tf 5 12 .-TS;r_ 4•=-~~Tf-,for 1, ',1 16.08, I6.52 or 16.54. 4e..-...~~t•~k-+~-i4-~,1,,,~~,:.,. Thc An+mal-C-e~►tro! 13ireciar or his/hrr designee, whila pursuing any deg observcd by the ut'Ficer to be in viutxtion of this chnptcr. or during tnvestigation for unlfccnscd dugs, may cnlcr upun any public or privato propcrty, txccpt arry privato dwcUings which are not liccnscd as cithcr .;ommsr'c'ta) or priratc kcnncls, for the purpusc nf sbating Ihc Jog violatiun br.int; ~ imestigatal. I I `ti per;on ;hill dcny, prcvcnt, oh•;t:uct or uttcmpt 1o deny. prevcnt or uhstruct T,w Uircaer or hisr~ignee nny-e~,~eF frvrn pursuing any animal otservcd to hc in violation of this chnpter_~•=--•}~L;uCr. 1=t ~~-,•r ~.'~fsr ~ t~iF{y;i- A 3! vi(l .A-L- I6.f18, 15.52 nr I6.54..! u\o pcru,n shall f,l:l ir ^CL~c:f. :~'_'f 3pfi'pif '.4::R1:lt 10 41c'MlA i.'1C Ai..::ic'{ Cantrc4 Dicectnr or hisher designee to enter private property or private dwelling homes to perf'omn any dury imposcd by this chapter_ . or :►~{~:-stikt ti% 16.08, 16.52 or 16.54-.3 ~~~.~dA'.30_ I a5 Impoundiog of dogs aad taJt---`oticc of owaer or kccpcr- Redem ptfaa-F ec. .l, _ N . The haiina[£e+ttrel Diroctar or hisiha dcsigncc may impound any dug(s) and ca s doing any ofthc acts prohibited by ~4-~Kn~wi ir+ Code, or.detrrmincd to bc in dana~ of bcing subja:tod to rrucl trcatmcnt as dcfincd by thi~ chaptcr andlor ~ Kc'Wo}wp_w . 16.52, Rt 14' or whcn the dug or cat is found to be sick, injured or dwd. ~ r-'}--- p 7he Anifnal-G~ Dirtcior ar his/her designcc upon impaunding of a dog or cat shn11 record the breed, color, nnd sex of the dog animnl, and w-hethcr or not the-degjt is wtaring a curtmnt license tag. If currently licensed, the Anifne!£entrml bircetor or higJhu dcsignce shall entcr the name and address of the awner or kecper and the numbcr of the I i cense tag. fflfeeseneMy- ' the iS{~kR~'R51JS45'VOttfled-t • • 1 , r immedimely ' w'the r'~M1!}~--fe@f~~PO~-~3l1~0fiF1`- . lf the dag or cat-+t is nvt reasenebl rcsumcd-t#to-dog to its owner or keepcr. Animat-Gonbet 1hc Uiroctor ot hislher designec shaU notify tho Aeg'9 owncr or kccper -eithcr by -mail or telcphone or personal nutice that the dag or cat has bcen impounded and where it may bc rcdremod. Any currently liccascd dog or cat impounded pursuart to this chapter shnil be held far the awner or keeprr fos ai lmt nae hundred twcaty ++~+►-houls from the time af impourtidmcnL ~nv 6unliccasod dogs-r cat shall be held for the owncr or kcxper at lcast scvcnty-two f-'-=hours frorn the timc of impoundmcnt. :y - Any dog(s) not rcdccmed aEkr the expiration of the holding pcriod as provid«I in sabscction 1=-413 of this sectiom may be adopted out or hwnanc(y euthenizod-er so{ci. Atl seks-e4' dogs ar cats adontcd out shall he puriunnt 5.04.064. te-ralrs an ~ Fxiuniy-An+nW-C-~. ~ - o. An5"-de8-as-rfley-t+a-~eEen►►irted-by-th° . cks+gnea-40,-be suffe►+ 5'-euthaMyRd wit-mt..wai{ing4 . L&L%j~hstanding the pruvision of sub-srction liB uf this se-qion canixminzMdingperiods, the Uirec;tar or his/her designa may.`40h4 cxcrcise Qf thrit discrciion and in ectatdapcc wiJfi txtlicv cstnblishad bv ':''-~-~+~ar.irr..d .,r,rr<<! humanely euthwtize anv ualiansad imcrQUndad dog or cat if thev detumine the animal is zi+I._&rW_ or nngcraus to the sntotv of humans of othcr animals. sufferin¢ from serious inIuMor disea,ce_ ar the desienntod shclter area is at MP-4-1-ity, I ~ .1n}' dugk-,) ~-c cat_impaunded punuant to this scction rtiay bc rrdccrtird upon payment of a11 redemption fors as providcd in section 5.04.110. In uiditiun, any ~ unliccnscd dogs g,Lrat must hc liccnsai at the timc of rcdcmption. Any dog(s) or cat running at largc during rnbies quarantinc xhall bc immedintcty impoundtd by fpeltene-Cednty--Anintsl-~l ~+l R~~anim;►I._.mtt:~l and kcpt at the animnl shcltcr for the remaindcr uf the quarantinc at the ow-ner's ur kerper'S CKpK715N. I:~q++r,4' tU.l'{) Rdease for Aduptlon tr1A Thc Dirt+:tUr inaIn hi5 -.t b:~f_ ,lc ~i~,crc)i_•;~. ...:lin:~ ;I~;.s_.c :~n :m m,:l f- : ndootion undct anv circumstanccs includinu but nat limited t,!: I 'al 1'f'he a(o4oa.,tive adoptivd OWiLCt,~ias a lii~fi~fv--.'t ~~1 tl:i~, chama or hns bcen convieted of an gaimal-related crime: ~ _t-+ 'g_vrosp.,cctivc adovtiYe cLw.Ler has inadeuuute or innygtapriut~ acil't' for cunfinina the animaJ ~d for providinct a~oper caro tn tbe an±[.AL I M4uirod bV (hls ChAI}tgr:4)r~:t! ~thr 'I~ill~ 16. ~ re?, t The cxistcncr u.Cq ucircumstancts whicli, in the oriniort QC I3i-,- Pjrectar. would endanM{ thc wclfare of'thc acrimal gr the hcalth. safetv and wclfarc uf dic_people mid'n in hc ~-~cm+.c ;c ~Lor ~!l1., The animAl is cUssifiad as a dnn emus oQ or opotcntially dange+'dus dug, ~ 1ny_sdoption shall bo Qubiw the Colluwine: i- T1te a tive awnn shall narx in wn,fingtn Cwnish nmper care to the anim:il. in acy,s,rdanoe with this ehanter: eh~ant~ EtrtJ t#~~ p C•..'..-_•- ~l,',, Titlc 16; , Paymcnt of requitei foes undcr_t~ibChuDter: and - All enimsls mu5t he gjAyodlncutcred ge ,foxh in - .'~;i S.(?~3.(~¢5 i ,rn~withstandinn the reaui,gmcnts sri forth in s b.wgiaa5 +-H-\ and this seOn, the Directot' mav relcasc an animnl to an sppro~ed ttscudadnrtinn_.tLcrti` which has a¢reed in writingto abide hv the cow:!r:int, • f~lii_,_ :ii_thc nl:irc-mcnit mf r~ ;.,_uc anim. fl,. - , ~ ~ ~ 1 , Adupliun nf Anintjl--Agrec►nent ai sl,a), ur tieutcr- ~tcrility Urpusit - Forfcitureaf Anima!- Aaimal heutering Prugram ltevolving Account. Any pcr5on actopting aiq aftitrdil-+dog or catl fram 5pakiint-4_ ~~~ray AMa11ii14-.4ia1,A ':oncr.•I shQll, st the dircction of Iln+rriaEC-mt4felr;uil COW! :1n+mnl £'c,i}tri4. have said animal Spa%.d _o ~-ir neuicrecl Mior to adopeio,t N'f4hl(! f11(F2ir {40) dDtiS (1f Qdi-"ioIt. Z~£~!i{173ihiii titlil~I . ' D'uec!or or his1her designee determines jp-ft-e~cer~is.~_a-t i er discmh.°n that the stcrilizstien proacdure should F►e jrcistponed. ~~Ue co the anima!'s age. health ar ather apProPriate tutu. fn&*;mwn ttiaft a--" .nal-Gentrol I &~.cwWiom -2~I3,- - At the time af adoption af an an~~l--'sdo or cat4 G~+m Spc~lcena~'-~nty r~f?E2'i73ICeRI~i}{ l' a StC~l~l d a35ft fCC 2 ;~1C ~uL111:1~ ■ ' - - will bc clvvged in addition to other fees c.sjbhr,hrd bn ;-3-) C_The sbcrility deposH Cx collerted by ~pel~se~-6+s+mtg-~+ifnal-6e~tteel .w ;'r'S,annnsl :ortroI frum the sala a¢qgtigQof any dog or cat witl be depos'sted imo the i+"te ='AtiifvW .''_wi{#+n the Animal Csrc And Pratrctinn Rcserve Funds account of $.p~kane aun nnd_restricted fpr uSe tq reimburso vetednnij.,..a~'Qr the s,~-lneuter uf adopied das~ und c~ti ait41 jt t e discretion of t~e pitector, for treatmrrtt and cnre of initg~_ er sick: ani als im undCd 6X tm41 cO'ltr0f_ ~~LzertEfe~~re~ b} ~-~k~~e <'.-~e~tity :lsitflnl E~•r~t~F- ~.-Q. Ail }sw81►asam-e€pcrsnm scfoptinct animttls nrsm Spokane-C-oun4y-tlnif+a1 f~1Mrp1. ~~L-}~'+S;ar~~mul ~~xytr.~l which have nQt lized= will be provided with a sterility depesif-Feeai{~t vo which will contnin spacc for the signature of a licased veterinarinn who perfarms the spsying nr neutuing of die animal. [n nddition, the pumhestr will bo providai e list of lioensai veLcrinarians participating in the ~~GeuntyAnin%l ~ 5f44AA'34nimsl aarumt Ncutcring Prugrum. In orda for the pueulta5er pci'san ndoatink to hevc his a hcr ncw pet spaytd or neutered for no chargc, the purekasff ep rson must have 1 their pei sterilized within nincty 4434 duys of purcfisSe by n perticipating vticrinarian. The sterility reeeip6 youchq_shall be presentai to the partiripeting veterinarisn, who shnll sign ~ and dato it end retum it to f.+C-A-1P5animal :vntrul fQr reimburscmcnt. !f the person adu ut inA dericlcs to use a veterinarian wha cSnes nat porticipate in the Spokw►e ~ C-eemiy Animal Sk-W':rSamri,l canaml Nrutering Program, then the-pumh*wthcv wil! be responsible far all fecs chargod by the nonparticipating veterinarian. VVhethv a participating ar nonpgrticipating vcterinnrian iy used, the pct must bc suriliud within ninety i Is<<! days of punc}►ase. _Mee+pt--by -elieenWed Upon_retum-o€4tre-signed and ~irestor - or-• I:iaahade~s' rrsntbdr~anla~N-fet~: Proof that the animal hag baon spayod or owteral shall bc pcovidod to s,~ -l=entro! *r R~1f~:u~ir7isl :onuzl within ninety F~>►- days of aduption. Pruof shsll cons„t uCthc cumplctcd_ti!erility def"sit vouchcr from a vctrriitarian 11 ~ purticipating in the Spelcaf3el-4-Auntv--An+tna' w~~•:.~_ l_. •r I_\eutzring Program; ur where the animal has becn spayed or ncuterYd by a nonparticipating veterinariui, the prciof shnll wnsist of o written stntemrnt From the vderinarian or ciicvc which spuyrd or nrutertd j the animal, indieating the dnie the animal wa5 spnytd of neutcrrd i--.t Upon retum af the siizned and daicd stcrilitY vouchcr bv a licatsW (t cigatinst erian to ?~4-APiars~ni. f ~unuul. the )irector or hisiber dcsignee wi11 cause the iMuanec of a St►eck or warrmyljo the ve_tMinarinn in BCGpLdllce witi~ e then ~ sc utod reitt~buEMcnt rete. ~ t._ +-+AnY Person IIdgP&►ng-an animal who f"rtg fails to providc proof thet the animsl adaptccl by4hen has btcn epayed or neutered shall eumrndcr dtie unima) to Spekane .f- ~ C'eumv-r!!lifftal Ceati81 11-1;el L " 1.11 43 -4r+}`-~',er+-€w~~r+der` airart~~a!-~s' . II be-gWl . ~ fi c~'_~=F::•3►~~.lnimn! .•.~r,:r._,i shal traintain a41re-neutering progrum rrvolving a=urn which will canstitute a checking necnunt srt up under the ecmtrol of Uie Syoksna , 6eVftf5'-AniHWI---CartL-04 L.,nrr,l Uirrifor to fncilitate paymcnt to perticipating veterinurinns after reyuired proaf of spaying,`ncutcring gs atha yualified veterinurisn servic.es has bern submittcd. Vetcrinarians mny aIso be Rimbucsccl t}wugh the ~ cc,unty vouchcr paymcnt system. 1 1 1-: fhc ncutcring pmgrIIm revulving accnunt shull be balunca! ;uid reimbunal ..-•<,qir:~,,rrani At least mundily; rcimburscmcnt vuuchers shall have steritiry depasft vouchcr or ott1el, qunlifial vst~n~rian savirc reccipty attaChcd_ Thc rccripts will bc char¢rd to the Spaicanc Cnunty :lnimn) Neutering Progam rt-~en-c. 484.-A664s►pewn ding,-eFCsb-Nefico-ts-Oweer ef4(eeper--flcdcmpt+ae: fiWt-O"t-eeEs-pfa#3ib+Spekettc-E;-eanty-Gede;-o€-if t#e ~ac-fs-iti -A_r 4-hei,ngsas~e~ted-to e .define&"' {fs _?-E4"W-er whea-the-m-is#'o+nd-!a-be yftcl,tapimd. or dead. f ~ The-tkfllfllfl!-C-t)►}fm'i_)if8Efi3t'-othi5r!h@!'Q5i,-fl28-ttpclF!-4hC' 11111fEfttRdtttg-Afat7Rf-Atill ft'GRf , !F-0~lh&vsk-wmi-Whdf~121'-f?f-i1B~-~#l`tiBL-K-WltkEtfl~rf8ill-lielA40 teg,- {f eu-I.-M}y' 11 . the . t}fll1i . AHd O~"S~Uf~}C-8V1YtK-43F~L~@Ad-HN#~!!!-Qf-l:'°;-- if . Gerifea4-I-?ifeetar•et*ts1~-~eslgnee-~tf#~tled+aisly-frt~-t#+e-cet ~-iis-it~Se~ewReF-Of-Iree~F. i€-ii-~~-r~a~3y-~ess+~et-tc► ' !~e-aut-Es-~k4-li~sec#-ev+rteF -or- kreprr,-tha shfill irfy thevnf!s-uwnrFa-keeper-meil; A-Htrial.<' . ~jr-tt►Ie~Ho~-a-pc~enel-nc#i.-~e-t#et-~►-aa~ has bren-minpew%lwi•arrd-iv#eta-t-taayabe Fedeme: -l++~ ~~st~enta~-lt.:~+►sed e~-f~t~d pu+suan4-t~►-4#r+s-ehupter 4he11-~-I~elc# Cnf~3te-~swaef-eg-~ee~ef I:+s-rE 1ra~t;-tt-Eittti.lsr~1 i:+tntt f~-21) -I,;•~~r~; lr~.-~r;} tEra-l+trfr t~'; im~~:~:~tn:yis: 1'f~z (-~tti}~~re in un{ieen5ed-cxit-is-in be held-deprtid5 Q1t•Ehe f@FE1pernri@iif-t?Fl nirtie#+4-ii-e4.-Of !33 Any aai(s) f►et-~ede~-a I+uffwate45+ Ag-males--u€-ams-shal . (4) . i F~3 Any oet(s) impeunded pumum! !a th-s s"en-may -in . . . addition, any E63 Any--mfs - empotmded by&~e a-ef ' fir-keepWsec~ I i':t}4.46 '7.3II.I8II COA[1'Ol OfCYLl. ~ .1 _Thc Coilowing cai cuntrol regulatians are palice regulations designed to protect pubiic heulth end safety. ne owmer or kecper af a cat is strictly liable to oorttrol hisdhrr cat or eaLs as r,cquirod herem. This mcans thdt the penatty far viotatiau of thcse t+egulgticros is imposod without regnrd to zny wmngful inicntinn of the violatar. R,_It is unlawfu! For the owner or Icexper of a cat or cuts W violate any of the following rcgulations. '1'he owner or koeper af n cat or cats shel I prev-ent said cats fivm: ~ ± l+-Bcing ecccssiblc to othrr cats, while in heat. for Purposcs otlicr than contmllod or planned brerding: ! t2 -.Kunning at lerge whcn tho cat hes not been neutered or spayod, nnd the cat is six (6) months of agc or uldcr; ~ 13,}---.Not hnving a current licensc or failic►g w pcovidc proof of such lioense as providcxi for in this ocdinancx; ;4:~--- hot bcing cunendy inoculaied for rabies or failing to provide proof of such inorulntian, and the cat is si.r t." months of age or oldcr;;ktr f►r+.win -•rd-thVkcy ;5_}- _F3eing kept. hnrbored or mainwinod and known to hsve a cantagious diseaxc unicss undcr thc crcctment of 4 licensed vetrrinarian, end apprupr{ately isoluted to prutect tfie public and other animals; ~ ;b. i Bcing an privatz propertY widiaut the permissian oC the property owner or the persrm ontidai to possession of the gropetty. ~7 o Exhibiting viciauv pm__~jti' a ~$.3.Ffit~~titMMr Rlace whem food is stocrd prcaarcd ~vad,or sold to thc public or q_jMij4in2 or hnll• vruvidcd that tliis Ji4i13haR4j_aRBlv to any Cdt scrving the blind or dcaf: ocxs or bnspitats: or to cxhibitions or organizcd cnt shows. 33 _N The fQllowing dog concrol fCE,'lJliliti-Riti :ife [lt-ilicc IC~tI~.'.1fui:ti dc:ti1-T1Cd :o 41tiiicLi i:17171i.: hcalth and safety. 'i'he ow•na ar keepcr of a dog is sVictly liablc to oor►tcul his nr her dng or dogs a5 required herein. This mcans that the perwlty for violation of thcse regulations is imposcd without rtgard to any wrongful inteniion of the violatar. . . it is untawful for the vwncr ar keepcr of a dog or dogs w viUlatc any oC the tlolltw, ing rcgulatiorts. 'The owner or ketper of a dog or dags shall prevent said dogs from: ~ - 14_ Running at lergc in *~•k~j'::._:-.~it; i i!%, wlicttter licrnscd ur nut; pruvided, that this Su cctinn shall not: a) prohibit u pason from wniking or cxcrcising a dog in public when such dog is on a Iwsh, tether or chain nut to exceed eight feet in Irngsh; b) proliibit a ptrson fmm having a dog ofT lensh in an area dcsignated pursuant to Mc 5.04.045(I) as an off-lzash urea providod that the requiremcnts uf ~~i-•r. S\ N!C 5.04.045(2) are met; and, c) providod further, that this scctiun sttal) not appty to any dog serving the btirxf or dcaf; ~ +2+ - Entrring any placr whrrc food is stored, prepared, srrval or sold ti, the public or eny public building ar hall; provided, that this Eq~seciian shall nc,t apply to any dog serving the blind or dcaC; tn veterinurian affioc.a or haspitals; or dog exhibitions or cxganized dog training classes ar to dogs uscd by urmared ~..tr srrvices or luw enforcemsnt agencies; j 3_►- Bcing accessible to othcr anirmls, while in heat, tor purposes -0 -,:r chan cantrvlled or planned brrcding; ~ Aj- Chasing, running aRer tir jumping at vchicles using p4bli,: ~:<<•~:, and nllrys; ~ i5 4, Snapping, gruwlirtg. snarling, barking in a threatc❑i::q jumping upan, chxsing or othetwisc threatrning persans or animals; 46 + - l;x.hibidng victious propensitics: 17. liowling. ycUing, wh.ining or barking or nutlcing utli-,~, r;:l 11, 1.c, iil Su.:h a manaer as to disturb any person ar groups of persuns to an unrcasan4blc Jegree; ~ •8 o [3cing kcpt, herbored or maintained and {:noam t4 hnvc a contugious disearc unless undrr the trestmcnt of n Iicensed vetcrinarian nnd appnipriutely isolatcd u~ pratect the public and otfier animuts; I .9, 1 Running in pac{:s; provided, Cor the purposc of this scLtion "pACks" mcans dog-S in groups of thrcc or more; ~ .10 t t`at hnving a license ras ~a.:ti.~-~a_~ -r~4~•J..: t, ~ir#~:#-~~+rciiu~r~ i i, shis chaptcr; ~ I 1_i Nol bcing currc»tly inacutntcd for txbics or fuiling w providc proof uf sucti inneulatian, snd the dug is sir nionths ofagc or alder a.s,L ujTr:i fi~ pf.--vide&4,~F-=- ~tliis chaptcr; r 12_t Running at large whCn the dog has nnt bcrn ncuterrd or spnycd, sad the dog ic ix matuhs af age or older; ~_A dn~ dcxl:ueci kMtentiallv danur.rouy shnll riot he :ti runnine nt 1arpto ur uci the u«ner ur k"pcrs prL~crtt•. iinlc;s it i; on a Icnsh acid urnler phvsicAl restrdint o~f i . 1 .1 , :t cfoS dcilarrd a dnngcraus dLig shali nLH Fx ruruting aI Inrkc cx outiiJr a aic~_ 1Qg}tre, un~ the d2& is mgWed andttstnune~by a substemial chain at Icash and undcr nhvsical restraim of esponsiblc pcrson The murzle sball he mAd~ in n manner that will_not cause injurv to the drni er intrrtcrt with its visirq~ or respiratinti hut shal1 prrvent it fnim bitinQ anyrersi?n ~r_animal. ~=:44-:1=+- i0. !Qu Vfolacfoas as Iafncdoas-Escepdons. Failurc to pcxform nny act rcquircd bv this chentcr o or thc pcrformnncx of any act prohibited by this chapter is dcsignatcd ng an infrectit+n and may not bo classificd as a criminal offmsc, cxccpt tho following violations sltall be c1;L«ified as misdewmamms: -44A - MiSDEMEANORS: j 4a-I L. -St'%Mic•R: Mc 5.04.030(e4) end--S44:034f o~~g-te faLxlY representing dog or cat ns spuyedlnwierad ar nonspayedrnonneutued; -'--_~S~_%1!'_5 04 032f31 and 5.04.033M. rclntinA t4 Caiture tn abid b conditions itnposad nn putcntialty dannm.c3 dogs: (29) 5.04.040. ralnEing-ie theft ar misust of liccnsc tngs. --`-e"it_►+ s4',ti~C 5.04.442f71. operatinR an tt~is~tnscd comniercial kcnnel; 7], opSruing an ~lfccnsod privaE~ k~ruld; L!. ~m6n 54'Mf 5,04,04 _4,~m S~ S 04 iW512xr) a1lowln_a a doa to rxhibit darteaous or aL,emtisi%e bCh8Yl0r in a dcsiQnated nff-Ieash acoa: , &n. Mt 5.04.045(21(t) nllowina ac d4g in bcnt in mi dc4i¢nuod off-Icash arca: ~ *W. Secoxyr- Sti Nic 5.04.067(7). cats oxhibiting vicious aronrnsieies which consiituk a dengcr to nrrsons_ domcstic animais t+oultn+ or Iivesto k' ~ f~i;8. -~n•~ ~i~_ 5.04.070(6), relatin" dogs cxhibiting viciaus propensitiea which constiwte a dangcr to persons, dornestic auimals, poultry or livcstack; 49. ~.~t~n-S~,ti~r ~ oa o7a~~) oaccntial~y clan¢croug dcm at larac: {4j4j9._Gm+o+►-SV4iC 5.04.079(1),-r4stia-to fiituro to 9ign a psvmise to aPPcar. r;01 t. sre"io.n-SV_,1(' S O4.0 91 _failurc to idrntifv -txFSqn receiviagnatirt; ,l~l', -~S1'titi 5.04.0792. 1'ailute to ~y a r.er' :~:►1?. Smim-5VN1(' 544.150. dutv whrn strilcinst dom~cjiuigw with moic►C 4eh1L'lC' iild -S,-v-tir;n-S%\t(' 5.04.160. animal bitcs to bo cd (3~ Seot'an . _ , 4at4ng-w.wilfid- eppeeron a-n~t~ae8€inf~ioe~; ~ t~t il:. 11he third or subsequent violation of any provision of this chapter within a twelve-manth period. Eor putposes of this substctian, e third or subsrqueut violation kvithin a twclve-munth pzrioi is dctcmiineJ nccc~rding to ;h~ daic of tho offensc for which an infrartiun, citatian or complaint hns bccn issur.f, regnrdlexs of whethrr the coun has deemcd thc viulation to have barn Committcd provtded, thal a finding by the court thnt the prior infisi;tion was not committcd shsl I rcncler the priLn violatian not couneablt taward the third or subsequent violation; (7) Ceeiiae3.13d:1~t~}~ara~ing- t~►e~e'te1-kc+nnel; See6en ~ . , + , {14}-Svla' . . _ . o--faeL:erv-~+ ahic#e-hy , (4-1) -,,,...e_...a.,.-f8'tl.m tozc't; (},1,)i~._5 , ~ ail►irt-te-abide-by-cjen~it+~+~s-iirttx~=.r~! <m ` . . . it~leg- 39-dtA}=WhCfhng dafnN5tiL'--Etf}4ff4ilt-Wfill-iftSFi.f VC}ttr4"!!d 5.04.160. I:stink txa ar,=~et:t4 ?u?r4 1•4 tµ rr~rrrJ GROSS-„~~.DEMEA:ti'QRti. I .~-+1 ~+c,u~on-S~ %1C' 5 04.032. failur(: t.) ct,[ripir• N4ith dc►n_gen,us dog rcuuircmrnts itnp050d D~Attt,.to lhis ScCtit~n;.~fr-iu~~; _ ~sz•n S% N! t L0~4.035. failute to enmRlv with dnneerous dOR re_.i=.:.r-tic.n and owotrshi~rAquircmrijl.~,;, •-y; --=-ek~;=;.n S\ ,\!C SO4.045(2)(b). nrolubitedgain do art.: .-i•~ ~~1 c 5.04.0700a), dcui~ernus doe at tnr c; . . . 5.1)4,120(31. intrrtc,-~nce ti%ith ►aWul cu:hanA-,1,11 : Su 1`~~ tiotice uf Infraction--lssunpcc. •.11 \ -lhC An1R1$i'Genwe Dl[rl:,,• f ili•, f7.-i commissioned by the 1.~+nt}-~t~~ <<• , tu issue a nuticc ui inCr.uticn it cummitted in Dircctor's or hisfher designcc's presence or if Director or hiv1irr devignec h.i:. infqrmatior,Lto stipp9f'G_@reasonable I,-lirvr I•--.lirl !hit the ,•«i,rr ~,r L•cri:•r ~_f :tn ~ animnl has cammiucd an infraction. ~ r~i~4 _-T11CC6UTt fl]fly ISSUC iS -Ii~.' t-t ;[ii[,):,ll, tl i:jiull Ic-':j I1 V.filL:ll il .4 the ArtimeW~l Diroetar or his.TlCf SC~Igf1CC lll.ll Illl'[C 1S RtitiOlliibIc C.l115tl W bclic\,• tlt.st an infracticjn Wa4 .•(,mrnittad :~4 \oticc uf Inirartfun--I)eterminatiun [iual I ~nless, ('ountested-Fbrnt. 4~ r~ A notic,; of infraction rrpresent; a dcterminntion that an infructiLin hcis bccn „utnmittcd. I ne dctcrrninatinn \~ill I~; fin~l <<n1c~5 roiiite.ted a. pnovir}cd in t}ii5 ch;~pter i r; l t=•:~. Thc nocice of infraction shall incluc3c the folluwing: ~ 1-A siaternrnt chat ths noticc rcprcsents a dctetminatian tfiat ::n !~,~:tion hns born comrnrtied by the ptrson named in the notice and thnt the inination shall be fins) unless comested as providcd in this chapter: A:--- A stasrmcat that an iafraction is e nancriminal offen~c iar 'xhicti =-entjail may rtat be imposed as u sanction; __-A ststcrnrnt otthc specific infiaction far whieh the ncaicc w,t; 1,•.ucL9; - A staterttrnt of the rnaneiary prnalty cstnbtishai for the infrnctiun: --A sintemrnt af the agtiarts providcd in this che{stcr for respandinu t,, ~ t,c naticc and the proccdures neccssary to exercisc chesc optioas; ik, _ A statrmeni that at any hearing to contcst tlic ddcrminatian. 0i': has the UwYIen of proving, by n pcepoaderance uf the evidence, that il.c ~;traction was armmittcd; and that the persan mey subpoena witnesses tnclwlinb U.L Aicrr wtio issucd the natice of infraction; 1#47. -A statcmcnt that ut aoy hearing rcyucsted far the purposa -_z_ kplnining mitigating circuenslnnces surraunding dse wmmission of t}se infrarei, An, ;he persott will be dcemed to havc crtnmitted the infracsion and may not subpacn.s itttcsscs; -448 - A statemcr►t thst the persan must respond w the notiac as provictixt ;i ~ I, i s chaptcr wittun fiRccn w7 t days; i,) A stntement which the perwn shull sign thut the person promisc7 t~, ;:~,pond to the tmtice of infraction in one of the ways pro,0ded in this chapter, and Jjj . stmemen, Rum 4o 4ien :ht,Inised-is-wmsderneannr-"~ ' . . . t! _ A ststemrnt that ritilurc tv respnnd w the noticc of infracci; r n failurc to appcnr at n hearing rzqursted for the purpose of cr►nfesting ►fi, ,I.:termItation or far the purpose of explaining rtiitigating cirrumsta»ces will re:t!:e ,n s dcfiult jud}gnent against the person in the smount of the pcnaltyL_ end-t`;:, z~,~~uro-fn~ly,~e-ttltat+Fe~-4~t t#cr~~=+~e-1a~+~~s~ txt.zrney ?~;r c-r~~;rt.c!_=x.-a:r~•.etiiiti t~„ ,:tt{ l4 ResponYr lu 1'~isicc 4 liti(i-a:!i;~n 1'~aitr~.lin•ti I1:•tcr~iun.ii~•~~ I lcaring--FaUure to Respand or Aplti.:ir- ,-HA. Any person whL. I i provided in this soction witliin tittoen da; s oi the Liatc oc thc noticr I -If the persoa determined to hsve committed the inCrsciion -~„c t it~c determinntion, the persan shall respond by ccxnpleting the oppro~.+riate portian of t'- r-,;;tice of infraction and submitting it. either by mai) ar in pccsnn, to the caurt specifted , i . ihe naticr. A chnck or mnney order in the amnunt of Uie penalty presrribcd for iI !r!fraCtion must be submincd with the respanse. Whcn a respnose which ducs not :i ~ ~I.. :lctrmiistatir••l k an .~~-~*r;.~,•i:~!~ + ntcr ,I~:tll h._ ,~n!cn•,1 ;n'hr , ~rr!',, rc- . . I ..;f thc pcr•„)o dczcrrnincil :,-I 'iacc nunittoJ thc ;ntr.i, ti(, n %.,~,iict 10 ,_u1ilc.t the Jeterminuticm, the ptrson shall rrs}xmd by wmpiciing the portian uf the noticc ul infraciinn requcsting a hearing end submitting it, either by mail ar in persan, to the court sprcificd an the noticx. llte court shell notify the petsoa in writing of the time, placc and iiate af ttte hetiring, attd ttiat da;c sh.+1 I not hc 54?oner than ~c%en days from the c}ate uf thc notiLe, except by agreerncnt. ~ •-I ►1?. -If the petson dctcrauitt.;d tu 1.4vr c;immiucd :tte i11iT'JL60II Joe, not cont;.~t the deeertnination but wishes to expl,un mitigating cic-c:umstan+xs surrounding the infraction, the pman shal) respond by compfeting the portiun of the naticr of infractinn requesting a Itearing for that purExose and tiuhmittine it, cithcr by mail or in rtrson, tv the rnurt spccifir:l oR[}lC17,'. ~ hearinx_ I . lI1C ~~.•I:I: n11-.11 f .ici'1.i;I p1;-,II:i,I ,._,,C'-.,ii,l i!ll I~l.'f:':.: ~'~li.:.'.• prescribed fnr the infraMion snd may notify the prosrcuting auomey af the failurc t respond to the naticc of citil intraction nr ri) ,i~P~•.~r at a rec;ucslyd hc:irinr if per-C-i: ~ issucd n noticc of infroction: . 0 Fa1l5 'ld (o tft. !li i... . I'lif:f,_,. •il .l'- ;I1 (ir ~It of this sertion; ar Faila to anpc°r at -t fieanng rryur,~t ` 11 n I I(r.u flulcti a Pmcedures far the c(induct oF all infractiun hc:;riuu piuvidcd t„r in %Jhmpto Ii.hall lx in a,:curduner with the lnfraction Rulcs Cor Courtg aflimitcd lurisdiction. I 1nI, ; rr.,, -n •.uhirrt t•:) Pr,,cerdintis i.nJer this chapTer mzy hc rrFrc,entetl hv ~Utltl SC I . I Ileariugy-Cuutrsting I)eterminatiun thut tufriiction l:ommitlcd- :1 ppcal. ;1N A Itienring held for 2h2 F1iIfpASG ii (h:' .Si.-i7Tillfi_111w1 ?1I.!! _i!7 inf'rnrtion has bcrn committed shall F+e without a,jw; -]lie court rttay consider the iyutice ,1 n:" :_ti..n „1 1_1 j;l : ,,111C, h r.; r:1ade under oalh submittcd by the officer who issijCd dic nulicc ur Wriucti 51:►tc;n.i't wm the basis for the issuance of the notir,e in licu of the utficces pcrsunnl appenruncc at it<c hcxring_ Tho person nnmccl in the no4ce mny suhpornn witnesses, incfud:m:~hc c~{ !~ti r!i~ ti,h:t ',F,t~., r,t Icr«- ~r•„I r.:~r;i~ic ~4irr,;,.-c: {~re=•:i,1 in :nt ln the event the defendant cautLsLs any inFrai.-tion, the burdcn of prac!f is upon the tottmwC rri to establ[sh the commissian of the infractioo by a preponderancc of the cvidcncr. ~ ~4,13. -ARcr cotLSidcration of the cvidcnco and ugument the oourt shall dderminc wttether the infrnctian was cummiued. W'hae it hu5 nnt bern esisblishcd thnt the in(raction was committed. an arder dismizsing the notice shall be errtrced 'm the court's tzccxds_ Where it hus boen esWblishtd that the infi-action wus cammitteci, an sppnopriate ordcr shal) lie ~ cntrrod in the court's rcconis. ~ iii[=. -An appcal from the court's ddertninetion or ordkr shall be to the superior court The docision of the superior rnurt is subject only to discrctionary review pursuant to Rule 2.3 uf die Rulca of Ap}xllate i'rcxcdurr.. ;.4)4_-j'.:.' u Hearings-E=planatian of MiNgating Circumstanccs. ~ t4:,v f1 hearing held for the purpose of allowing n person ta explnin midgating circumstencrs surrounding the commission of nn infraciien shnll bc an informal procoeding. Tha person may not subpoenu witnesses. The dctcrminuion that an infraction has been cammitiad may not be cantestcd ut u henring hrld for the purpose of cxplaining mitigating ~ cinumstances. t2_ 0- After the court has hcard the explanation af the ciraimstsnces surrounding the commission of the infrnction, an appropriatc otder shall be ertered in the court's rr=rds. ~ r~+C '[bece rnay bc nu appeal fram the cnun'x deteKminxtion or anirr at a hearing cm miugatian, ;.,µ,b=}1-.30 Order of Court--Civp Naturr--Waivcr. Roduction Suspensiop of Pcn~lty--t ~tetu~r'tt}~•.;c~t~r f~.,f-l~~a~~.. ( ;-4,1 -M order ettteced after the receipt of a mponse which dacs not contcsi the dctcnninstion ur after it has bem cstablishod at a hcaring tttat the infractian was committed, ~ or after a hearing for ihc purposc of explaining mitigating cin:umstances is civil in naiurc. ~ -'Ihc court moy inciude in the ordcr the imposition of any pennlty euthorizod hy the provisiorts of this chapter for the annmissian of an infradion. Tho caurt mny, in its discrctian. waive, reduce, or suspend the monetary prnnlty pracribed for the infraction. t1t t~e-~eqsee*~~*e4uest,-t~►e-ceurt msri~~er€~nnce~a€$-fw~f:~4+€'~~•mmw►i!y qige-iiiinimurtt wega per hatx ;0.2 _;0 Nuticc uf Failure to signr*oe:ppeerseer-Fsilurc tu satisfy prn:ilty. ~ (t is a misdcmc.+n„r irr ;tny pcrlon ',Oo ha; bc,_n pcr::~n:ill}' •.vith a notice of civil infraccion, us proti-idrJ by tipoF;nnc Coutity Uistrict l:ourt ntlr, as it prrscn'~-, exists or us rtuy bc hcrcinafler amendcd, to rcfuse to sign a writtcn promise w rcspon•_i the notirc . , , -A*y-person-wiffully-vielating hig-otherws'tElert&ne!-sig►+ed-prc•ntiisa-te-a~.~:: +n ~ i +sr-pelty ef a Fnis~rm eanor, ukifneie-dispos. 'on-me), be oempiiefi wtt#-by-en ~eentnee.`~S3`e~sns~~: A pcrson who willfuily fails to prty n monctary pcnalty t.. !•-~==r=:. :-~v;u~~~ m~~tas required by a court under thi-; -',:~s~:cr r;~:,y ~•L• t;_.~in,i in ;•i\ if uf couci as pravidcd fnr in k( A< <-I;:;+rr 7.21 K1 • ~~i+-i.!+~•~ 1"'_~+~._.~> Pcrsva receiving aoticc-IdcnNfication and detentiuri. -A person who is to receive a notice of infractiun under-Sezuan--5.0 !.07_i 3+ crimit►al citntion odff tttis cha~ter ~:r chapirr-y 16.52 or,t¢154-kc- 1is rzyuircd w idrntify himsclf or hersclf tn thc t~'+e~ef eircctor or hisrher dgz~r a~i.~.±~s~~-'~•~ rn,"k,r:cFurn; ..{ticc_by giyin~' his or her tame, address. and datc Qf birth .gLU11pon tHc rrqucst oflt#►e-o~errt~a-pers-►t sha{1 produce rrxsonable idrntification, including a driver's lic,erise or identicnrd. f-?iB -A pemon wha is unusble or unwiUing tu rmsunubly identify himself or ceisclf to ~ the Dirccto,rQr hislhcr designer. oLa _:iforccmcnt 011JLcr msy bc detaincd far u ptriod uf time nut longer ihan is reason,~`,;y nectssary tn ldrnti!'y t!e pdwn fot purposes oC issuing a nMice of infrflction or cilation. ~~(L illiul fallure to identify. followin¢ a lawful reaueg undrr this saction u.i misdcmcanor. f-31 ~t~~-C~i~#~+~nel-~x►tf~~l ;hQEI a~L+M ntlrs±t+-i~e+#tifit:r4ion-er.d detrritiett -D€ Rc~rwctit~ c.+flr~nt6{i+t~~+~il i~fracEie►►~: 4 ~ • - Failurc to Obc~ In,trtictionc nf an O(Ticcr A per5gr2 is reguired to sfop when teuucsted or si a1~:1_tt~ d±, ;u 1fy tiie te:~E e:'mp1y--witl►-inswiet3cms-e{' sir-Ankywl-6entral Directur or hiOier cksignee, or ef a-h~•. i> - •l••jy~f~~,]~~ Cf1iC'P:~^n; nt : 1'!.~t II1 tIC tilfOi'CCIitCllt Of tlIIS C}in(ItGr or Jliir}ItF i-l-:-4-+ert-4'pc•::. tl<<~t~r~Rk'%~' 16.08. IG ~2 or 16_5•1 n.-Ll--~! '{i€~y-t~+t~eF~u} er--of his.4herepu4y-iR-ths e} . ,fs , ! G.(1K, 16: i 2 .=r-lf+.*4Rt-'W Anv pcr:nn ~4 hu wiflFillv viol,str~ thic ~cctinn i; euilty af,i misdrmC.i=ii, r , ~z.".4.+4Ea°.30_24; Mimxl Coutrol Director or hisiher Uesfgocc-Issuaacc of Criminal Citatloe. The Animel-6et+Nei Dirxtor or his)ficr desigrtoe shall be spctially commissionad by the _,•urT=y 4,efiE:rin f',3icc_C'hiqf esa 4r{4is%+ tor thc purposc of cnforcinq i, swei )orkoe~fg3-e~er+in~e!'•whioh~-+n-aie{ation-o€any provision af tfiis chaptar c-fohef4" ~-~?.~31r~-t+p•-~~nr<=:KU~t~ t~~?c;oc kc ~l ~•~c~j 6.Q$. 16.52 ar 16.54 , I Cet~e~-AineceFeFhiOa-designee~-p~sa~ree;-p.we~; i Orpt-W 5.12 , n++n~l-~ontral- ' . '~eeteP~~++siher das+gnee dW' a-iso he speowly Gemmission~y--'S.--1-~ - nncl shall huve the . . -'l nuthority to issuc citations and makc artrsts whcrc thc Diroctor or hisrlicr dcsi¢ncr hns infocmaliun to su rt a reasonable belief thnt the uwncr. hnndla or kecoer of thc animal iS in v►4lntion.917 an secti on5_ fa"ioleEiens o4'-QhWer-S_ 12-a€-Jie -fi;►eit 16,08 nd--16.5? RCW; constiluting a misdcttuanur or gruss misdcmcanor. ~ 4.=14:41477.30?=0 lZcdcmptioo Procedures. Any dog impounded pursunnt to thc prnti•isions uf t}iis cltdnt__r i~r - = _~.•~--t~ ~c ttc~r±~ 16.08. l6 52 or I~:'4 ~1-+~ seatier~-S:A-±i.~ i" ' - ' dwough 4:131.13A may, when all canditian4 havc bqmmt for rcJease. be redxmed upon paymcnt Qf tte Mtces and nrnaltics due and owinv- anv rocoverable expen;Vs iqqurrrd bv. ~ - t=KAPSantmnl ci,~mr,!-frdentpt►on-fea$s-pwttde~is-saeEIen xnd praof of p current licenst: attd, oroOf oC 8 Curtrrit rahirs ti•accinntinn or writren igrecment _to ttrescnt svch within 30 d31`s, 'i'hz r~icm ticm fcc t~~r n d~~~ -,1a11 bc [uiion uFthe citv :ourzil Pruvidrd furthcr, the Ar:inwl C'ontra4 Uirrctor or hiv'her designce for good cause ut hislhrr discrrtiom may %vnive anci'or reduce the ~ redemptinn fee. 0? Any eai impuundexd punuarrt to the pruvisionti cif tllis_ehster ~it I(i.U$. 16.ti2 or 16.';.s i ?~c~i+.K►-i~►-+:~1SS? {I (:}{._.~}ri~-. .~~-=.1.U :P..i\_•.~~ic'; .::Ij =-;li{~1,."1, 1!.t% L: hiill :i;c'! Ti. ~~C<:~ _ ~~C C~~CCiili•,~ .i~,. paymcnt of the mv foes and en:s ties duc tttid ukviqj, _4p}' recuverablc expetiscs incttrred b,•_ 1nim31 c.~nvn! ►e~c#eeAptie"-feo--a~fxo and pn.~of of currer,t ljcensc and rabia vaccination pLvwnte . lle rulemption frc i'or a cat J1,ll I,c :-S?Abltshcd hti IIImc fCS,j Uo:3 .il Ih[ cj*t Lvu'1~1(r',t:rii-ht furtlicr, thz .1rtErnal-E-ential Director or his,'hor designee for gond cuuse nt hivher discretion , may waive and !or reducc thc ralemption fee. _Recovernble er~e.n_~es inturred include bse M-Ic hc lici,itrLl t0_ i ri, (cci_ ~;t.t}~Ilbi:c.3 •.cp,~ni:e rc=.~:iulicl~ 'fic '~T~ - , 1 reavnab~ terinaar expcnst~s irtcurred bv_•r-'r' = AII_fces and sxtcnsel_pV a61c unJcr this sectiQp shall bo macle a ab So animul ~-•,.t c'~;-• 10.2155 Ucstrnctioa uf vicious and Dnn en wti Iok,. +t Any dog having viciuus propcnsitIcs L Jcti~cd u t:i,. n~s; .~r~crrd wmtd ovcr to di ~={~_-t~?F,..•un,ei ~ort:ol shcltcr for disposal b; nieans of cu[hanasia by the district cirrrt upon !hc o«iicr's nr kcrRirrq nonviciion of ar; I violutionofSVMC~--,~.h-fi5.04.07t10~ i 3 At1Y dug dcclarcd a ciap~:.,,.,. ,f 'I '.i,'-_-A rc.tiistrntiixt shall be euthttnizcd as pruv)de.1 t'or in + t 5.04.032{4} and 1; i (33 !"iepasel- , ~ {-t~+fa-=I•,• Ix~- ensiEies--shell-chereafter btkept-on-a-Jea4;-t . Of-ohitift At_v~-fence~-ifte~t ' L~[lS! owner or keegg oL4 defz to be destroycd A tl►e ani by meanx of euthanasin undrr this .uid ~~e,.•~ trr•• k? ( t1 16.08. 1¢~52, and 16S4:tFU- wwens t#ia okito-au, 11a; tweniy-fuur hours from notification tlwi%uw€-e-ef-ihe~ oau►c-arcier tu turn thr doc; i~vir l0 If1C tti4fffiiiJ-4 i}fltfi-I ~ • ~ '.-i _ . , ~i1L'lIC( j~,r d15po5:1l fl)' mCi7Rti O1 l? cuthnnasia: willFul intcrfScgmc wi flLtho lawful disposal of a dov~,oursuant to this scction is n gross misdemcwo W -`n5'persenrwhs.rs +elaies~tn) ef d ' c-ikn-4tal1-l.e--gWry o#' fl nt3sdewteenr4: 4.4 3+.~7_.iU.2wi Pcnaltics i--1A_-'1bt maximurri penalty fur thc t ic;!:uirm of am pto% isun u1 11;1'ti chaptet' rortslituting ntt infraction mher than - 5.0•1.030 dn!-5:0-3-8?-~ rclatirit w failuro to abcain animal ficrns~.•s ~hall hc - - ~ • r - i.itTlIlllIltiJ %%ilI11t1 a twclvo-mottth rrrirhl. 1i< <ithlitiou, ;h4 may imposc f1I1y llpPI1i;71bIC statutury asscssmencs. j=4H. --Anr-pcft.9-:In addition co any othct pcnaJtics pruvidod by this cltapter. Cound in violatinn of atty provisions ar any arnendmcnts thertto which arc dcsignntecl us misdcmcanors shell bo punishcd by a~tne of nut moto tlwn one thousand dollnts or by ~ imprisonmcnt in the counry jail for not more thnn ninety 04-days or by both such tine and imprisonroait; or iCdcsioaied as a erom-rnisdcmcanar shell be punlshed bv a fine of nnt morc than five thousan~,dQjJars +-~~:+~+!+~:~:~~+or bv imprisonment in the ccwnt~jait_for noc more _thnn 365 divs or 6v both fne and imprisonm~~. tltcr 0. 31 31 :=tC_` Thc pcnatties Cor violntion of S% `,!c-►ck~;-~s 5.04.030 and• .4 than ',~ftxri~nS VNlc' S.44.030(a, asd-SeL4ion--S:04.431 e,ti_li ,b% scparai- .c~ilutio:t t't thr ~it% 011TA Provided, howevcr, the district court judgcs by IcKal wurt rule or gencral orcier may allow for a teduction in said sum hy wiy of mitigation ur tivhcrc a licrnse is obtainad or rcnewc-d within tcn calcndsr da) s uftlir issuancr of an infr<action. ~ &.oJ43t V;n+sfien *9 tensfifi ~ S -tff-aes~-prattsh~t~s -c+i~~is-c-ltttpfer-~hall ecx'-'ttttc-a-p+~1~ls~ tttt~at~e and muy ba abaMc4 in-unytteu+teJ-h"4;W Chu{}Ear: 7.49 •t ~ of fces not othervvise cs1$6lishcd reasanably rzlatod tn fW€uihflg fWfilling ics responsibiliucs unu_ ihis chapta. Thi9 shall be construcd cunsisttrtdy with afl local Spokane Counry district caurt tul, and geneW order as on the subjcct invalving thr failurr to liecnsa dogs ur cats as set fo:th i;. 5.04.030 nnd 5.04.031 hervof. Fee scbSdulcs stwll Ix nosted nt the R. • 11rO_b altcr and on thc,.ri!r-,;:l -,r;iz_ot -l-e~ •#ir web sita. ~ Uuty Whea Striking qomestlc Animgl witb 111otor Vehiclc. Any person wfio, whilc opcr.iting a molor vehicle, stn'kes n doroesuc iwi.iI i, s_'4_:.3rwy shall siop at oncc. rcnder reasanablc sssistanct, and shall immeciiatcly m{n:rl su:ti injury or dentli tn the animal's owner. in the cvrnt the ow= of said nnimal cannot h,.- ertninrd and loc:atui, such pcrson shnll at onae report the arcidcnt to shcenif"ai•eenimi-authefii~ asc '11iis scction shall in no way bc cunstruei as requiring the pctson strikin Ehc animal with a motur vehicle tn be financinlly respnn,it,!,- '',,r ;n:i:r: •r f~•:~~(~ ;:f A ptrsam who willfullv vinlalcx this section chn!I bc cci .4 4# 7.30.27 5 Animul Bites to be Reporte, i. Every animal which bites a percro shell hc p: ;:_,1 . . ; c~aft"} ?+t~_,.wr,l snd sh$11 tFterrupan bc sccurcly qunrant'tncd nt thc dircctinn ~ ~~aflaGwnty-AflimaFC-enifol 34RAPSamn,a1 ,,ncr_~ l far a period aCtcn days. At the discreei, ,,i ~kat~a-E: j►CR,j_i?~snimal _oirrol, such querantine may be an :h premiscs of the owner ar keepcr, at the %~po+kme Co*mt.- -tir4ffal.1nicndl ~oncrol ?~3hcltcr, ur at tl,, ciwrter's nr keeper's option and expense, in avrterinary liospitnl of the owner's ur keeper's choicc. [n the caus of animals whnsc ownctship is not known, such qunrnntina shall bc at the .!iin ~.trol ~4.~ 4•:uf,-'r -\f=T:,4--.hc1ter ar u veterinary hospitsl. If the animal is ckuarantined at thc nnimnl cQntrol she1ter~~1,t•1-!,- . z-~~a:-~+=~f=--,~ the uwner or keeou nf the animal sha!I ~ bc charwd .u; .iim.uni :u r•tjbii.);c;1 b% -:co.iratc rr101 _ n .11 ,l:c :ih . Any nwner or keeper nf an animal who knowinulv,, iolatrs this sation shal) bc guifty nt'.i miti1tc•nicannr. ~Q.N.i:l fH7.3(1..8U Spuyiag and ncutcriog Sen ice.. - nree dollass r}~ if every dog and c! 11. r[1 ~•,~:.f~~ .ci usrd solely foc the puiposc of impleitieneing u sp:+yins anil r}eutcring progracn uf ]i4cn;. d dngs and cals rrsiding within the unincarp2pird arcns af Spokana Cotmty-qnd nn . juri<dldioRg urtdcr ctm[ract fof1Y~~i.i~r~l .•-~r~_I--ef 1hs,l Ma:-e-u~~tr.-:. Spakana-C-au y--AatiinaI-Guntra1 Direcior shall dcvolop and inaint~in a s(tnyirg tstul ftcutcr=~_ , ;,•r .~!i;,_h I~~:U ,;.r~• ~ht• ,~q~~ren,.rt; I -!i ,triliiv to l~arti•.~patr_ in thc ~ Spaying and ncuterir►g ot li:cns«I dogs and caLs undcr this utititmi tihall be voluntary ;th thc nnimal's owna or keeper. • 4 4Aii Se+-erabil+tt, r-H--ts- . 4"-kdee14Fld- , -shB!-Aef-~ afthis - ~G a.~,¢}$ ~R A~1Sf1f1~'~lSt~ _ .}HIttNl-.-~--~tE - _ '2._~Q( _}f~; £$5!''i-~~9f1~ e amee . a4l . . . C-impur 5.0 21---VQ3-+N 1101 a=fH'Allear-esfiWand aeWAti_I~pliarto*'-he f ft-~x'+EliSR--{~Q~-B~-~-u't• " . - • 8`ri~i'?ct~td-ri@f"!g ,..s.t..m~ -.,~`1;--<itee~. c~:1i8~8. ~-=a~:~--fi~-l~~:,n~?r,r.:► dS CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY - Request for Council Action Meeting Date: April 3, 2007 City Manager Sign-off: Item: Check all that apply: ❑ consent ❑ old business new business ❑ public hearing ❑ information X admin. report ❑ pending legislation AGENDA ITEM TITLE: Ordinance amending logo code provisions. GOVERNING LEGISLATION: SVMC 1.06.030(A)(6) PREVIOUS COUNCIL ACTION TAKEN: Adoption of Spokane Valley Ordinance 06-013. BACKGROUND: The City adopted provisions relating to City logo usage in 2006. In doing so, the Code identifies at SVMC 1.06.030(A)(6) that Purrfect Logos is approved by Council for producing logo wear clothing at the request of the City. Staff now recommends removing any reference to a specific business that is authorized to produce such merchandise. Instead, staff recommends that SVMC 1.06.030(A)(6) be amended to identify that the City Manager has authority to choose an entity to produce such merchandise. ~ OPTIONS: Leave the code provision as is; make additional changes. RECOMMENDED ACTION OR MOTION: Council consensus to place this ordinance on the next Council agenda for a first reading. BUDGET/FINANCIAL IMPACTS: N/A STAFF CONTACT: Cary Driskell, Deputy City Attorney ATTACHMENTS: Proposed Ordinance 07-0'"" Amending Logo Ordinance DRAFT C1TX OH" SPnKr1NE VALLEY • . SPOK.ANT:. COUNTY, WASHWGTON ORDLNANCE NO. 07- - AN QRDINANCE UF i'.Hk: C:17'Y nF SPpKANE VALLLY, SPOKAi\TE COUNTY, WASIII3\GTO\°, AMEN1)rNC REGULATIONS On° THE USF, OF THF, OFFTCIAL CITY LOCO QF TWE CITY OF SPOICAiVE VALTaFY, WASFIIiVGTON. WHER-EAS, thE City Council established by 7'rademark, thc Cify of Spol-aane Valley Logo, which depiccs a mountsin and riverwith the name oCthe City of Sqokane Valley. The Trademark was filecf with thc Seeretary of State for the State of Washington on June 23, 2003; and `'JT-T.l?.:RFA S, the City established provisions in the City Code for those uses of the logo that are alloNved ; and WI-IEREAS, it is necesstiq Erom time-to-timc to amend Code provisions; and WI-IEREAS, it is the desire of the City Council to amend Spokane Valley Municipal Code chapter 1.06.030(A)(6) relating to authorized uses for use of the logo fnr apparel. I`TOW, TNERF-FOftE, the City Council of the City of SpAkane Valley ordains as follows: Section 1.. f.ntent. Tt is the intent of the City Council to amend SVMC 1.06.030(A)(6) to remove reference to an_y specific private business entity for production of apparel featuring the Cily loso. Secciun 2. Amenclment. Title 1; Section 06, Subscction 030(A); is hereby ainended to remUve any reference to as follows Official Use. Use of t-he City logo sltall be for official purposes a-s specifically set forth Uelow. A. The following uses have been explicitly a.nd expressl}' approved wit:hoiat t]ie neecl for furt}ier City cansent: 1. Use of logo on any ofticial City of Spokane V311ey documenc, ir►cludinb buc not limited to stal:ionery, IetCerhead, report and ruport covers, envelopes, memorandLuns, faxes; employee and eleclecl officials' buSiness cards, name tags, and name plates, • 2. [3se of logo on student advisory council (SAC) slationery and itcros oPrecognition; 3. Use of logn by the Spnkane rlrea Economic Taevelopment Council for their ►narketing materials, on their Nvebsitc, anci in thcir printed materials that are used in recniihnent; expansion and retention efforts for mvketing for business amaction vid development:; 4. Use of logo by the C7reater Spokane Valley Charnber of Comrnerce for City of Spokane ' Valley promotion of'the mayor's State of the City Address; md fnr the City's ceneral promotion through tfie Chamber's map; 5. Use of logo by those officially involved with and for Ihe planning, promoting and clecorating connec•ted with the Mayor's Ball, including but not limited to evenc wine glasses; napkins, tickets, utvitations, and other promotional materials and decorations for the ball; ~ G. Use of logo !--4?tH+fec4~oges-bv an entitv abnroved bv the ciri, rnanaeer f'or apparel purchased by City employees and elected offeials, provideci those purchases are transaeted while thosc. employees and elected officials are still serving in their City capacit'ies; and , 7. Use of logo by those officially involved with and for the pliuining of Valleyfesf and _ accompanying parade, including but not limited to event deeorarians, promotional malerials, advertisements, posters, and temporary signs. Ordinance(17-_Amendingl.,ogpProvisions Pagel of2 nRAFr B. The logo may, kvilh City approval, be used for other specific events tllat benefit thc Cicy of Spokane Valley community and are not prohibited by subsecrion C of this section. ~ C. A.pproved use of the City logo shall also be in accnrdance wid1 die City of Spokane Valley Logo Style and Standards Guide, which shall be approved by separate resolutioll. D. The Ci1y Io~o shall not be used on or in connection wii:h any advertising or promotion for any product, business, orgarii2at:ion, service, or vticle, whethe.r offered for sale for prof t nr offered without eha.r,;e, without the express consent of the eity council. The logo shall not be used in connection with ttny election issue, or ciunpaign related thereto. E. It is a violation of this chapCer to use any symbol that imitate,e the logo or thaC is cleceptively similar in appearance ofthe Iopo, or in any mar►ner that Nvould be an improper use of the logo itself'. F. Nolhing in this chapter shall prohibit the reprocluclion of the City logo for illustrative purpqses by the news media i.f che reproduction by the news media is incidental co the publieation or the broadcast. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit a characterization ofthe City logo from being used in p0litical cartoons. Section 3. Remainder of SVMC 1.06 Uncha.uced. Thc rcmaining provisipns of SVMC 1.06 are unchanbed by this amendment. Section 4. Severzihilitv. lf v1y section; sentence, clause or phrase o.Et:his ordinance shall be held to be invalid or unconstitutional.by a cdurt of competent jurisdiction, such invalidity or uneonstituCionaliCy shall not affect the validity or constiiutionality oFany other section, sentence, clause or plirase ofthis orcJinanee. Scction S. T'fiTectivc ]aate. This Ordinance shall be in full f'oree and effect thirtY (30) days aiter publication of this Ordinance or A summary thereof in the official newspaper of the City. PASS.F.D by the City Cauncil this day of .2007. Diana Wilhite, Msyqr AT'iTST: Christine 13itinbridge; City Clerk Approvcd as to Form: Oftice of die City Attorney Date of Publieation: Effective Date: i Ordinancc d7-_ Miendin~ Logo Provisions Page 2 of 2 ~ . ~}7TY ~ SPOKANE , '~~`-~~'3 Nv~'~~E•' r`. ~ ~ ~ 0 ' ~ ~ ~'a~~ •`'b 1 • ~ . i ~ ~ ~ SFOKANE . . COUNTY +w„~,~• , , ~ ~ 1111,AND P1iPIRE ' . tAPHQ C0MlAYY 'q.szzha uur 141l. NIE•MORANTnU1~I Ol+ AGftEE1VIENT REGARIaT.l\TC TOUNllATlOn'Ai., CONCEPTS, M.r111TAGLD 1MPLEn7ENTATiOV k'LAN, t1i\TD D1SSOLVED OYYGEN TA'IDL FQR '1':EM Sk'OKANE RIVER - 1I C1S VTEMORANDLJn!t QF AGIZEEMEN"1" is entered 'uito and effective ttiis day of ' , 2007, by ancl between the VVashington State Departmeut of Ecology, Spokane County, the City of SPokane, the Liberty r.ake Sewcr and Watcr District, Kaiser Aluminum Fabricated T'roducts, LLC, and Iiiland Empire Paper Company, collectively referrecl to as "the parties." RECITALS WlIL1~AS, thc parties h~ive reached an agreement i.n principle ~~~ith i-egard to tl~e . Spokasie R.ivcr Dissolved Oxygen Ti. L, as set forth i.n t]ie docu.ment en.titlecl, "F'oundational Concepts for thc Spokane River TufDL Managed Tmplementation Plan" ("Foundational Concepts documeuY'); which is attached hereta as "Ex.hibit A," and VVHEREAS, the parties desire to enter into a Meuioi-anduin of Agreement to more formallymemorialire the Foundational Concepts doculnent. AGTtELiIENT NOVV, 7°I-1EREFORC, the parties agrec that the foundational concepts described in the Faunclacinnal Concepts document are liereby accepted by the parties and will begin guiding TMDL implementation as of the effective datc of thi.s Agrcement. The parties further agree ttiat tlie Managed Implementation Plan for the Spokane River Dissolved Oxygen TMML and the Spokane R.iver Dissolved Oxygcn TMDL will bc drafted consistent with the Foundational Concepts docucncnt. SIGNED on STATF OF VVA.SHJNGTON, 1 DEPAR7Iv1EN T OF ECULOGY , BY ' "I'itlc: DirECtor SQ~s9ass.e 1 . A.DOPTED by the Boasd of Counry Comnussioners of Spokaiie County, Washuigton this day of 120.07. % Mark f2ichard, Ghair ATTEST: Bonnie iVlager, Vicc-Chau ' 17ariiel.a Frickson ' Todd MiElke, Conlmissioner Clerk of th.e Board ' STGNED on ' - Lll3E1ZTY Lf1KE SEWER cS'z WATFR DISTRICT Tom Agnew, Presiden.t • Fi-an.k L. Boyle, Couunissioner SIGNED on CITY OF S.POKANE ' . Bv Deputy Mayor. Attest: Approved as ta form: City Clerk Assistant City Attomey . so, ssvss.6 2 , r ' - SIGiNED'on KAISER ALUIvIINTiJM FABRICATED . PR.OTaUCTS, .T_:T C By Mike 7erga Kaiser Trentwood Planl titanager SIG\jFD on INLAND EMPIRE PAPER COMPANY , By ' Wayne D. Andresen President and General Manager ` s r' , O • ' , . 50759055,6 j / t~ . . ! !i ` Foundational Concepts for the Spokane River TMDL Managed Implementation Plan - . June 30, 2006 The Spokane River does not have enough dissolved oxygen (DO) during the months of April through October to meet current Water Quality Standards. The best available science shows that excess phosphorus is the main cause of this problem. There is agreement among those who petitioned Ecology in 2004, other interested parties and Ecology that actions are needed as soon as possible to improve the River's condition, and, by assuring treatment capacity for septic tank discharges, further protect the quality of the Spokane Valley - Rathdrum Prairie Aquifer: Low dissolved oxygen also results from carbonaceous biochemical oxygen demand (CBOD) and ammonia. For the purpose of implementing the Spokane River Dissolved Oxygen TMDL, it is assumed that efforts to control phosphorus will also serve to control CBOD and ammonia. Reducing significant amounts of phosphorus in the River during the April-October season and achieving VVater Quality Standards for dissolved oxygen are the goals of the Spokane River Dissolved Oxygen TMDL Managed Implementation Plan (MIP). In the October 2004 Draft Total Maximum Daily Load to Restore and Mainfain Dissolved _ Oxygen in the Spokane River and Lake Spokane (Long Lake), Ecology estimated a reduction target of approximately 208 pounds/day of phosphorus from point sources, - .%non-point sources and other controllable sources. Most of this reduction is anticipated to come from improvements in point source wastewater treatment technology located between the Idaho state line and the Lake Spokane Dam. . The best available science conclusively demonstrates significant phosphorus reductions will improve DO in the River and Lake Spokane. How the River will respond to signficant phospho~us reductions, the full extent of the reductions necessary to alleviate DO defciencies, and the phosphorus reductions possibfe over the next 20 years are not precisely clear at this time. Hence, an aggressive, managed approach that removes phosphorus from a variety of sources through a variety of inethods and monitors and assesses the impacts on DO over the next 20 years is a reasonable way to maximize the effectiveness of the sizable invesfinents necessary to improve the-River. Capsule Summary of Approach ' Currently there is not well-established technology that can reliably treat a variety of wastewater discharges and achieve the River phosphorus (evels required to improve DO sufficiently to meet Water Quality Standards. 7here is, however, technology that significantly reduces phosphorus from effluent and that can bring current discharges much closer to the levels required by UVater Quality Sfandards. The Spokane River . Collaboration refers to the difference between what technology improvements can achieve- and the TMDL levels to meet Water Quality Standards as "the Delta." .l _ . . vz, . ~ . The MIP provides reasonable assurance that Water Quality Standards can be achieved ~ during the first ten years of MIP effort by installing the most effective feasibie ~ phosphorus removal treatment technology and completing a planned and schedufed group of actions aimed at eliminating the Delta. The foundational concepts described here will begin guiding TMDL implementation wtien accepted by Ecology and affected National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit holders. While phosphorus reductions from technology improvements and other actions can be . estimated, their true impact on DO requires actual implementation experience and . resultant measurement of DO levels in the River and Lake Spokane. The first ten years of MIP efforts need to.be in place and operational prior to their consequencss being fully assessed. A thorough assessment after the 10th year of the MIP will provide the inforrnation necessary to guide actions for a second ten year MIP period. These second period actions will include continuation of successful actions conducted in the first 10 years, such as operation of the treatment technology and other permanent phosphorous reduction efforts, and they could include new actions such as consideration of river oxygenation and/or reconsideration of Water Quality Standards applied to the River and Lake Spokane. The MIP's actions*necessary to eliminate an NPDES permit holder's Delta will be enforceable over the 20 yea~ life of the MIP and the TMDL phosphorous waste load allocation will become enforceable requirements at the end of the 20 years covered by the MIP. . During the,MlP term, the NPDES permits applicable to individual dischargers will include interim limits and other requirements as described below in the section titled "NPDES Permif Cycle." Ecology Wi!! Complete the Dissolved Oxygen TMDL Consistent with the Foundational Concepts . The foundational concepts in this document are the result of substantial deliberation by the Spokane River Collaboration. This effort placed completion of the Draft TMDL "on hold" prior to its-being made final and submitted to the Environmental Protection Agency for review. Ecology will re-draft the Draft Spokane River Dissolved Oxygen TMDL to . include a MIP consistent with the principles described here. The re-draft will be subject to the same public review process and administrative procedures used for the earlier ' Draft TMDL. As well, Ecology will continue to work on a government-to-government , basis with the Spokane Tribe of Indians to ensure compliance with downstream Tribal water quality'standards. ' ' . Waste Load A/location Targefs A TMDL requires waste load allocations (WLA) for the affected NPDES permit holders. These targets, expressed in concentrations.in the draft TMDL, will'be slightly reyised in the re-drafted TMDL to reflect upstream.permitting in Idaho and an April-October rather than June-October critical period (see the boxed table on page 24, Draft Total Maximum Dailv Load to Restore and Maintain Dissolved Oxv4en in the Saokane River and Lake Spokane. October 2004). The total phosphorus concentrations; as allocations in the TMDL rounded to the nearest microgram will remain 10pg/l.._ v21 2 In the MIP, however, the 10 pg/l total phosphorus targets will be expressed as pounds af phosphorus discharge in the River based on the discharge volume estimates , established through the Collaboration. The translation from concentration to pounds of phosphorus forms the basis for measuring success in meeting each phosphorus waste . load allocation target under the MIP. Success in meeting the pounds of phosphorus target will be achieved by the installation of the most effective feasible phosphorus removal treatment technology and implementaiion of other phosphorus reduction actions that together result in the net pounds of phosphorus discharged to the River by the dischargers being equal to or less than the target pounds. The following table shows the pounds per day phosphorus targets for each Washington State NPDES permit holder as they will be expressed in the MIP based on projected flows for 2017 and 2027 using estimates produced through the Spokane River TMDL Collaboration. • . - -d • . - -d 2017 2017 . 027 WWTP TMD D . . . Phosphorus Influent . g. bstd. . Liberty Lake 1.41 0.12 1.51 0.13 Kaiser Aluminum i 15.4 ~ 1.29 I 15.4 I 129 - Inland Empire Paper I 4.1 0.34 I 4.1 ( 0.34 City of Spokane: from City of Spokane only 36 41.77 . I - from Spokane County l 5.76 9 from Airway Heights I 0 I 0 ~ , . Total City'of Spokane I 41.76 I 3.49 50.77 4,24 I • Spokane County (new g 0.67 8 0.67 plant) NOTES: a Influent flow projections baseci upon data from Flow & Loading Work Group and dischargers b Ibs/day for point sources = Influent MGD x 10 Ng1L P x 0.0083454 ° MIP achieves Waste Load Alloca#ion by 2027 , The "(Ibs/day)" numbers listed above will be 'used as the target pounds to determine each NPDES permif ho(der's Delta. An NPDES permit holder's Delta is the actual pounds of phosphorus discharged per day minus the target pounds. NPDES permit (imits wiif be based on a seasonal average with appropriate daily, weekly, and monthly . limits that recognize the uncertainties and start-up complexities of new treatment technology. . The 2017 phasphorus targets are goals during the first ten years of the MIP. These phosphorus targets will not be binding during the first ten years so as to allow assessment of the beneficial impact on DO from al! MIP-related technology • _ improvements and phosphorus reduction actions initiated during this time, and to allow vz1 3 measurement of the actual Delta reduction by the dischargers based on experience. By the end of the 20" year, NPDES permit holders are required to be in compliance with j the phosphorus WLA in the right hand column of the chart above. Once an NPDES permit holder demonstrates reliable ability to continually meet its target, either by treatment technology or technology combined with actions to eliminate the Delta, that permit holder will have met its responsibilities for meeting waste load allocations as expressed in either the MIP or the TMDL. Aggressive efforts, initiated as quickly as possible, to reach the targets during the fir$t ten year pe.riod of the MIP are required. These efforts will include both phosphorous. removing treatment technology upgrades and a suite of other phosphorus reducing actions from the list of °target pursuit actions" described below. Some aggressive programs to meet phosphorus targets may be conducted jointly by several dischargers. These efforts need to result.in assignment of reduced pounds of phosphorus to individual dischargers because dischargers must meet individual targets. A trading program of dischargers' demonstrated surplus phosphorus may be . implemented consistent with EPA guidelines pending Ecology's verification of any surplus phosphorus offset pounds. . As part of the implementation of the MIP, each National Pollution Discharge Elimination System permit holder in Washington State covered.by the Spokane River Dissolved Oxygen TMDL,will,.in accord with the section titled "Schedule ofActivities," prepare a ~ technology selecfiion protocol and an Engineering Report with construction schedule for the treatment technology improvements the permit holder intends to install. The permit holder will also prepare a Delta elimination plan with.a schedule of target pursuit actions (see details below).that, in combination with the technology improvements, provide reasonable assurance the April-October phosphorus target will be achieved in the first 10 years of the MIP. The ways these targets and associated requirements will be reflected in each NPDES permit is explained in the section below titled "AIPDES Pe►mit Cycle." _ . ' Target Pursuit Actions Target pursuit actions are tfie steps that are either required or available for NPDES permit holders to both upgrade their technology and eliminate their Delta within the first 10 years of the iV11P in order to provide reasonable assurance of ineeting targets. The target pursuit actions may be modified as a result of the 10'h Year Assessment. Dischargers without a Delta do not need to perform target pursuit actions for Delta elimination. . Technology selection protocols and Delta-eliminating target pursuit actions will both be initiated as soon as possible, and Delta-eliminating actions will not be deferred until technology improvements are actually selected and installed. . . ` ~ vz1 4 . Enforceable terms of each NPDES permit will include the obligation to meet the interim or final effluent limit and the obligation to complete implementation of the target pursuit actions, afthough the details of the target pursuit actions may be set forth in a separate administrative order. After the 10t" year of implementation, a thorough review (see the section titled "Tenth . YearAssessment) will be conducted to determine what, if any, additional phosphorus reduction actions are necessary, what actions should be continued or discontinued, and/or whether any changes to the phosphorus reduction goal in the TNIDL or the Water Quality Standards for DO in the River and Lake Spokane are warranted. By the end of , the 20th year of the MIP, NPDES permit holders are required to be in compliance with the then current TMDL phosphorus waste load allocations (the targets may have been modified as a result of the Tenth Year Assessment) to assure applicable Water Quality Standards are being met. Reauired Actions: Required tar4et pursuit actions for each NPDES oermit holder with a Delta.are as follows: - • Technology Selection Protoco/: NPDES permit holders will prepare, and submit to Ecology for approval, a comprehensive technology selection protocol for choosing the most effective feasible technology for seasonally . removing phosphorus from their effluent with an objective of achieving a discharge with seasonal average 50Ng/I phosphorus or lower. If pilot testing is a part of the protocol, there will be appropriate provisions for quaiity _ assurance and control. The protocol will include a prefiminary schedule for construction of the treatment technology. • Delta Elimination Plan: In addition to the technology selection protocol, NPDES permit hofders will also prepare and submit for Ecology's approval a . Delta efimination pfan and schedule for other phosphorus removal actions such as conservation, efffuent re-use, source control through support of regional phosphorus reduction efforts (such as limiting use of fertilizers and dishwasher detergents), and supporting regional non-point source control efforts to be established. The plan, in combination with the phosphorus reduction from technolagy, will provide reasonable assurance of ineeting the permit holder's target in ten years. • Expedifious Decision: Ecology will expeditiously review and decide on the proposed technology selection protacol, preliminary construction schedule and Delta elimination actions. • Engineering Report: After a permit holder implements the technology _ selection protocol, the permit holder will prepare, and submit to Ecology for approval, an Engineering Report concerning the chosen technology, including any updates to the construction schedule. The Engineering Report will (if . necessary) be accompanied by amendments to the schedule and substance - of the target pursuit actions so that in combination with the Engineering vzt 5 Report on expected- technology performance, there is reasonable assurance of ineeting the target in ten years. Ecology will expeditiously review and ~decide on these submittals. . o Interim Limits: When new treatment technology is installed, Ecology will set interim phosphorus permit limits based on the engineering reports. It is recognized that, because modem phosphorus removal technology is challenging, achieving normal, and routine operation may require finro years, assuming average seasonal conditions (temperature and flow) during both years. During this period, Ecology will recognize these conditions and their effects on compliance with interim discharge limits. • Final Limits:Final limits applicable durjng the remaining term of the MIP will be set based on the actual performance of the technology installed and operated at optimum reliable efficiency (see the section titled "1VPDES Permit Cycle"). • Investment Stability: The- investment in phosphorus removal technology is recognized by Ecology as having a 20-year life, and no significant modifications or replacements of phosphorus removal facilities will be required during the term of the MIP. Modifications fo installed technology that best available data indicate would enhance phosphorus removal performance and are efficient and cost-effective may be required. ~ •Conservation: Public NPDES permit holders, in cooperation with water punieyors, will as soon as possible develop individual and regional programs that reduce flows by funding "LOTT-style" indoor conservation efforts that target 20% water conservation per household in older urban areas and 10% . water conservation per household in newer (post 1992) urban areas. These programs will have local ordinances, avoided cost investment principles and per connection expenditures similar to the LOTT program. To the extent * these actions are demonstrated as reducing phosphorus loading to the river, they will be recognized as contributing toward achieving phosphorus waste load targets. • • Class A Effluent: Each publicly owned treatment plant covered by the Spokane DO TMDL will, through their technology updates, produce effluent meeting the Stafe of Washington Class A reclaimed water quality standards in . place when the MIP takes effect. Available Actions: The followinq tarqet pursuit actions are not reauired of everv NPDES permit holder with a Delta. The non-aoint source proqram, however, needs to have sufficient participation_to achieve the TMDL-reauired phosqhorus reduction. ~ vz1 6 • Reclaimed Water: Publicly owned dischargers may seek to re-use the , Class A reclaimed water the.y produce as result of technology improvements. All reasonable efforts to re-use and/or recharge the aquifer rather than directly discharging it to the River, particularly in the April-October timeframe, are strongly encouraged consistent with circumstances and opportunities. Ecology will work with each NPDES permit holder and the Washington State Department of Health to prepare approvable permits that enable timely and successful implementation of these opportunities. Specifically, Ecology . commits to the following: - ■ Ecology will assist in permitting re-use efforts by actively coordinating ' state permitting with the Washington State Department of Health. ■ Ecology will assist dischargers proposing re-use target pursuit actions in assessing whether any water rights/qualify impairments might occur and how any impairment might be addressed. ■ Any revisions of Washington State in Class A reclaimed water guidelines or standards in place when the MIP takes effect will serve as a basis for requesting Ecology's reconsideration of an NPDES permit holder's approved target pursuit action plan that relies on re-use target pursuit actions envisioned prior to the revisions. ■ To the exterit these water re-use actions are demonstrated as reducing phosphorus loading to the river, they will be recognized as contributing . toward achieving phosphorus waste load targets. • Regional Phosphorus Reduction Programs: Privately owned treatment plants may participate with other NPDES permit holders in regional phosphorus reduction programs, such as conservation (see above) and non- point source control (see below). To the extent these actions are demonstrated as reducing phosphorus loading to the river, they will be recognized as contributing toward achieving phosphorus waste load targets. • Bio-available Phosphorus: NPDES permit holders may seek to prove to , Ecology that a certain stable fraction of their phosphorus discharge is not bio- available in the River environment for a time sufficient to consider it not . reactive and not a nutrient source. If Ecology agrees, the pounds of phosphorus that are not bio-available will be recognized as contributing - toward achieving the total phosphorus'waste load target. . • Source Control Programs: To the extent that source control actions to limit phosphorus inputs through regulation of phosphorus-containing products and • through enforced phosphorus-limiting pre-tr.eatment ordinances are demonstrated as reducing phosphorus loading to the river, they will be . recognized as contributing toward achieving dischargers' phosphorus waste `j, load targets. . vzi 7 o Regional Non-Point Source Reduction Program: Participating NPDES . --1 permit holders and Ecology will jointly fund and- implement a regional non- r_, f1 point source {NPS} phosphorus reduction program at $2 millionlyear. The - program will begin in the second year of the MIP following completion of an initial study (50% funded by Ecology) to determine the best.opportunities for , non-point phosphorus reductions. The regional non-point source program will be designed to achieve the NPS ' phosphorus reduction identified in the TMDL and to contribute to the Delta reduction efforts of the participants, as necessary. If sufficient reduction in NPS phosphorus as determined by the 10th Year Assessment has not yet ' been achieved, the jointly funded and implemented regional NPS program will . continue for the second 10 years of the MIP. The program will be closely managed by the oversight and coordination group described below, and it wilJ be monitored to routinely identify cost-effective strategies and verify actual phosphorus reductions. Resources could be shifted to other more effective actions for phosphorus reduction by mutual agreernent with Ecology. Successful phosphorus-reducing actions funded by the NPDES permit holders through the NPS program will be recognized as contributing toward achieving dischargers' phosphorus waste load targets. • Septic Tank Elimination Program: Spokane County may submit to Ecology information and calculations demonstrating the phosphorus removal impact _ on the Spokane River and Lake Spokane of its Septic Tank Elimination ~Program. Pending Ecology's expeditious review and decision regarding the ~information and calculations, the. County may, if Ecology approves, use the pounds of phosphorus prevented from reaching the River and Lake Spokane* through septic tank elimination as part of any needed offsets for the County's new treatment plant (see the section titled "IVew County Treafinent PlanY'). Oversiaht and Coordination: The above taraet qursuit actions reauire careful mbnitorinq and accountinq to assure aenuine phosahorus reductions and qroqer Delta reductian recoQnition. The followina will occur: , o Ecology and the discharger's will immediately collaborate to develop an oversight and coordination group. The intent is to form a collaborative group to oversee and.coordinate the required regional actions including, but not limited to, the NPS, monitoring, modeling, reporting and public outreach programs, however the participating entities retain their individual authorities. . Ecology and the dischargers will share in the administrative cost of #his group. o The oversight and coordination group, in cooperation with Ecology, will . manage the non-point source program described above. ~ . . ~ , ,i • v21 8 % ~ • i • The oversight and coordination group will implement a monitoring and research program for the River to routinely track and evaluate the amount of phosphorus removal, the impact of phosphorus reductions and associated improvements on dissolved oxygen levels. Also, there will be additional studies such as those concerning sediment oxygen demand, the efficacy of • river aeration/oxygenation, and bio-availa6ility of phosphorus in discharges and other areas that advance the understanding of and refine the science concerning the River's heaith. Modeling capabilities for the River will also be enhanced by gathering and including sediment oxygen demand data, noting and examining episodic events that contribute to increased phosphorus loading, and other relevant data and by considering current measurement of minimum river flow as adjusted by regulation. Ecology and the dischargers will share in the cost of implementing and operating this monitoring and research program. • Dischargers will prepare and submit annual reports to Ecology, describing each discharger's performance of the target pursuit actions and any measurable successes. For joint actions (such as the NPS Program), the dischargers may provide a joint report. - • Ecology will prepare annual performance reviews concerning the status of agreed-upon, committed target pursuit actions described above. Every two ~ years Ecology, using monitoring information, v,rill prepare and present a report and, in collaboration with the oversight and coordination group, conduct other public engagement efforts regarding the River's health and the performance and effects of the target pursuit actions described in the MIP. o Ecology will address Avista Corporation's DO responsibilities through the 401 Certification process. New Spokane County Treatment Plant A new Spokane County treatment plant will be constructed to meet its phosphorus allocation target through a combination of advanced treatment and other offsets that are . in place and accepted by Ecology as effective as the plant begins routine, normal (i.e., beyond shakedown or start up) operations. As with the engineering reports and target . pursuit action plans and schedules for NPDES permit holders, the County will submit to Ecology for approval the County's engineering report for the plant showing how the most effective, feasible phosphorus removal technology has been selected, and hbw the offsets will be timely developed. At the time the plant begins normal, routine operations, it is expected the combination of offset actions and the plant's treatment of water to be discharged in the River'will together achieve compliance with 10pg/l . , phosphorus. Consistent with NPDES requirements, the plant will be permitted by Ecology in order to enable rapid conversion of septic systems to sewers consistent with the approved septic tank elimination program prior to the completion of the County plant. The County will - vz1 9 construct.the plant within the first 6 years of the MIP as the County's offsets from the target pursuit actions are being developed and made operative. It is recognized that 'any phosphorous reduction actions selected by the County that rely on the plant ' achieving normal, routine operation for their full implementation (such as completing septic tank hookups and/or water re-use) can still contribute to the County's offsets. It is - further recognized that, because modern phosphorus removal technology is challenging, achieving normal, and routine operation rnay require two years, assuming average seasonal conditions (temperature and flow) during both years. During this , period, Ecology will recognize these conditions and their effects on compliance with interim discharge limits. . The County will also develop a comprehensive program for reclaimed water production, re-use and aquifer recharge of effluent. This re-use program will be subject to the same conditions described for other re-use target pursuit action plans described above. 10th Year Assessment Following the 10th year of the MIP there will be a major assessment of the plan's impact. A collaborative process will be used to make determinations about the relevant actions appropriate for the second 10 years of the MIP. The assessment will be a data-based, objective review designed to assess: e The amount of phosphorous removed from the River by the actions taken to date ,compared to phosphorus reduction targets. ~ • The River response to those reductions and associated changes in DO. e The necessity, if any, for further reductions in phosphorous, CBOD and ammonia in order to achieve Water Quality Standards for DO. • The likelihood of further phosphorous reductions occurring in the next 10 years of the MIP if the actions begun in the first 10 years were continued. o The set of actions that could be initiated in the next 10 years of the MIP that would more likely than not result in further phosphorous reductions, if necessary, to achieve DO Water Quality Standards for Lake Spokane. • The reasonableness of pursuing these actions and/or the reasonableness of pursuing other strategies such as Lake Spokane oxygenation and/or the . appropriateness of modifying DO Water Quality Standards if continuing existing or implementing additional phosphorous removal strategies will more likely than not fail to improve DO sufficiently to meet existing DO Water Quality Standards. ..Particular attention will be given to Lake Spokane's hypolimnion (lowest) layer where DO levels may be least likely to be significantly improved by upstream phosphorus reduction. r vz1 10 • Data and actions will be carefully reviewed to determine whether technology improvements and target pursuit actions can resuft in the hypolimnian meeting DO Water Quality Standards, whether lake oxygenation or other techniques may be effective in improving DO and/or whether modified Water Quality Standards for this layer are appropriate. These decisions will be made consistent with the MIP Decision Diagram below. I MIP Tenth Year De~tsion Diagtam Perlotmnct on~ CofTf111Mftrnb 041n+piover 40midnued ew. Dw lo MIM/ or OffwR1v~► o~v«+ ~ / Stortu• ~ ~ ~ Doira M" Acgm ConunthrArtga . /i. RMr.t or ~ Bauer vwn YW . sanownasa Doarrmt NM Ton YNn d Iu11P Are Now. Corolnw0 ot Oltif ` .rulon~ Z \ GoOsDontlvely Oenne NwM Aetlon C--Inmtlrrwft -Cansider-T1Vv~~ Aeratbn Dacument Nutl Ten Ya4n ol MiP ~ ~tst Roptnn , al+d Oarjara Pwtorrn Adam PWUonn M.f1" ~ I v2i 11 This assessment will occur following the 10th year of the MIP. The assessment may need to be extended if the timing of the installation of treatrnent technology has not resutted in operation for a long enough time to produce sufficient data about river conditions and DO response. If this occurs, the assessment would not be completed until there has been at least 3 years of operation of all heatment technolagy upgrades by all dischargers. NPDES Permlt Cycle ' Four 5-year NPDES permit cycles are expected to be covered under the MIP. CuRently, all four existing NPDES permits are under administrative extensions. Each of the existing NPDES permits will be handled somewhat differently due to varying conditions associated with each discharge. In general, the NPDES permits will follow this sequence: . The permit is issued with effluent limits adjusted based on perioRnance history. The permit will state the goal of achieving an equivalent of an effluent phosphorus concentration of 10pgl1 phosphorus by the end af the following permit cycle (i.e., in 10 years) through a cambination of phosphorus treaiment technology anci target pursuit actions. Enforceable terms of each I 2007 - 2011 NPDES permit will include the obllgation to meet the , effluent limit and the oblfgaGon to start, continue, ancl~, r complete the target pursuit actions. The details of thc target pursuit actions may be set forth in a separatu- administrative order. The permit, depending on d:,te 4, issue, may also specify dates for submitting a technoiogy selection protacol and an Engineerir.,j Report with an estimated construction schedule, all a` described in the section titled "Taroet Pursuit Actions. ' 1 V., I The petmit is issued with interim effluent limits takrng effect with the completion of technology upgrades. implemerttation of the phosphorus target pursuit actions to reduce the Delta is continued during thfs permit cycle. The permit will state the goal of achieving an equivalent of an efflueM phosphorus conc,entration of 10Ng/l phosphorus by the end of the permit cycie (i.e., in 5 years) through a combination of phosphorus treatment technology and target pursuit actions. As in the first Permit Cycle, anforceable terms of the NPOES pemiit will inctude the obligation to meet the effluent limit and the obligatlon to continue andlor comptete the target pursuit actions. The details of ihe target pursuit actions f I 2012 . 201 6 may be set forth in a separate administrative order. Ttie intenm limits will be based on the Engineering Report that provides Ecology with reasonable assurance that an equivalent of en effluent phospharus concentration of 10NglI phosphorus will be achieved by the end cf the permit cycle. It is recognized that, because modern phosphorus removal tectinolagy is challenging, achieving normal and routine operation may require two years, assumirtg average seasonal conditions (temperature and flaw) dunng both years. During this period, Ecology will recognize these conditions and their effects on compliance with interim discharge limits Operational characteristics fa tha newly installed technology witl be assessed so thai final Ilmits can be established. The permit is issued with frnal effluent Ifmits based on observed operational characteristirs. The pemnit wfil reflect results of the 10'" Year Assessment. The penrinit will state the goal of achieving an equivalent af an effiuent phosphonls concentration of 10Ng/1 phosphorus II I 2017 _?p2 1 through a cambination af phosphorus tr8atment iechnology and target pursuit actions. As in the first Permit Cycle, enforceable terms of the NPDES perr,!c will include the obligation to meet the effluent limit r, the obligation !o continue and/or complete the targ- ; pursuit actiona. The details of ihe target pursuit ar.~ - > may be set forth in a separate administrative anier. The psrmit is issued with established flnal efftuent !ir that, in combination with completed and continuing IV 2022 - 2026 target pursuit actions, meet the final waste load alfocations since they will be enforceable at the end of the MIP. A Gantt chart version of the anticipated permit cyctes for each existing NPDES permit . holder plus the permit cycie for Spokane County is incfuded for illusfrative purposes as Attachment A. V`' 13 Schedule of Activities to Initiate the MIP Based on and consisient with the principles and foundational concepts in this Agreement, several tasks need to be completed as the Spokane River TMDL and accompanying MIP are made final. These actions include the following: • Re-drafting of the TMDL, completion of the MIP by Ecology, and submittal of the final TMDL to EPA - target date 1/1/2007 • Submittal to Ecology of technology se{ection protocofs, Delta elimination plans and treatment technology fmplementation schedule by each discharger - target date 1 /1 /2007 • Creation of the oversight and caordination structure necessary to implement tfie actions that will be conducted on a regional scale such as the operation of the NPS and monitoring programs - target date 1/1/2007 Assuming the Faundational Concepts in this paper become an Agreement in Principle that is endorsed by Ecology and the dischargers this summer, and the TMDL is completed by Ecology and approved by EPA, it appears Nkely the first permitting sequence and the start af the MIP's first ten year period could begin in earty 2007. Ecology and the dischargers agree that local elected officials in the Spokane area should share the lead with Ecology in developing the appropriate oversight and coordination structure for overseeing the implementation of the MIP aI1d SeCUr1119 tf'1@ Il@CC55afy I(?1rC-;1 ,c?ncy a11d rlifid1f1C,1 C~ITlll'ii(ilt~fl~ ~ sufficient to support it. Applying the Foundatianal Concepts, Ehe Agreement in Principle does not requirt any party to engage in any future action or make any subsequent decision in violation of established rules and procedures for engaging in such actions or making such decisions. Nothing in this document changes any party's authorities or responsibilities under law or regulation. The parties embracing this Agreement recognize and supporE that this path forward is the appropriate way to establish the legally sufficient framework for completing the Spokane River DO TMDL and to quickly begin the important worlc of improving the health of the Spokane River. All parties agree to conduct themsefves over the next months and years consistent with these Foundational Concepts and resulting Agreement in Principle so that this can be successfully and efficiently accomplished. vz 1 14 . Attachment A. Draft Wastewater Treatment Facility Permitting Schedule - INCLUDED FUfl ILLUSTF{A71VF PIIRPQSES OlYLY - I ~I ' I ► ~ - l- - I I ~ ~ L I ~ ! ~ _ _ 1 - - I I+ ~ I r I Ifl ~ - - - - ~ ~ < . 14-F ~ _ - ~ - , ~ Till A - ~ - - - -I I _I _ - L - , _ ~ 1 - - - ~ ~ F.: 7i7, 1 /1 G7 7i ' II.~~~~'i~.:F: C.~ • A/ 1; 2 !r• - :2 - _ - - - 1-1--I- . 1 3{ d 's =~~~~;~~:~e.►-;.~~ ~ o , ,1s! ! j ! , - J} - V~, - 15V , v21 ~ Spokane River TMDL Oversight Committee DRAFT 3,ro;U7 Oversigtit Conimittee • Member Al-Large - Chair' • City of Spokane" • Idaho Departrnent of - Spokane County' • Executive Director Environmental Quafity • Liberty Lake Sewer and • Technical liaison • Spokane Tnbe Water District' • StaRAssistant • Stevens County • City of Spokane Valley - Voting • City of Coeur d'Alene • WA Department of Ecology • Conservation District - Non-Voting • AVISTA . • Inland Empire Paper Co. 'ExmNe eowd • Kaiser Aluminum • Environmental • otners r a ~ ~ . . ~ Non-Point Source i• i" ~DiscussioN PAPER / Spokane River TMDL Oversight Committee March S, 2007 Tlte Full Grorip Co-Clrairs, fOjIOZUtIig lliSCllSSi0nS ZV1C'Tt Cit'if Of SpOILCIYIC lli'1d'C'hC Clty Of . Spokune VaIley, prepared tlte tttrderlyirig discussiort for t.1te purpose of creatirig n Tivl.T)L UversigFrt Conn»r.ittee. 77cis paper is preseiited solelyfnr di.scussian purposes. '171-ie Fou.ndational Concepts for the Spokane River "I"MlaL Managed Implementation Plan docu.rrient speci.fies the formation of an Oversight Com.m.itl•ee to perform the followulg: Ecologlj and the ciisr.hargers zvill irlatnedint.ely collaborate to clPVelop a.n oversight aPCd coordinnt.ion _ graup. 77re irtteyit is to fornz n collaborntYve groccp to auersee rr.rid coorditTnte ttw- reqisii-ed regiortaI actioris iricliccting, ficet not linri.tee'l to, t.lie NPS, nzoriiioritzg, »rodelrrrk, reporf.rng nrcd pieGlrc ou.f.reaclt progrrtrns, hv2veuer the pnrticipatirig entities rettcirr fheir irr.dividual aut•horities. Ecology mid the disc{uirgers zuill sliare in the tdmitr.isf.ratiue cost of t1Tis grnrrp. 't he Eollowing, discussion points have been developed to advancc the design and formation ~ of an Oversig'ht Comnlittee. Each of the major el.emelits of forming an Oversight Committee listed below i.s Eor discussion purposcs only: PU1tPOSE The Oversight Committee will. have 1]iree prulcipal responsibi.li.hies: 1. Track implEmentation of the Fowldational Concept Agr.eeirent and assess ~,~rQgress on each action incJ.ud.ed thereun. 11. Dircct the implentental'ion of specific clements of the 7,"oundatianal Concepts. - The Oversighti Colnuuttee will «rork witll each of the ju.risdicdons, tlle Washington Conservation Conm.ission and the Spokane County Conscrvation District as wcll as other governmenl and non-gaveinment orga.nizaCions in thc desig-r4 f.unding anci unplementation of a nnn-paint source control prop,•am to contYOl phosphorus discharges to the Spokane River and Lake Spoka.ne tteservoir. 111. Outreach ~incl repor.t i•o the puUlic on the pr.og-ress in i.mplenZenting t}iP Foundational Concepts and TMDL. FUNCTI(7NS The OversighY ColTttn.ittee will earry out• the follnwing specific functions ta accomplish its three pruicipal responsibi.li.lies: . ~ 1. By-Laws. The Oversight Comm.ittee wi.ll develop By-L,aws for the operations of the Oversight Conzmittee, including appoi,ntment of member.s, terms of office, eligibility, and othcr relevant matters. 2. Non-point source control prog-ram. The Oversighh Conznzittee wi.l,l direct the i_m.plementakion of the non-point source control prog'ranl ulcluding but nol• limited to the [ollowing: a. Approve the scope of rvork for the Regional Non-poi.ni-5ource slud.y. b. Al.l.ocate funds conti-ibuted Erom those entides signutg the Hou_nd.ational Concepts, Mcmorandum of Affeement, to non.-point source conrrol programs. c. Coorciinate and assess propi'ess in reciucing non-pAint sources of phosphonis. d. rlIIocation of eredit to Disc.hargers fronl Nan-point source phosphorus rcdiution 3. Manitoring. Qversee the devclopment and i_mplenlentation of a monitoring pr4gracn to collect infornlaHon needed to accomplish the following: (a) assess hocv well dte River a.nd rescrvoir respond to phosphoru-s c•eductian,(b) report to the puUlic prAgi•ess in reducing phosphorus input the river and rEServoir a.nd (c) to . refine the model used Uy the Departnlent of Ecol.ogy i.n preparing its TM Dl:, report. The Ovcrsight Committee is expeeled l•o creale a mnnitoring team. or comnuttee of ' agEncy staff wha will dcvelop and manage, lhrough coopErative eifor.ts, a nlaiutoring progran. The Oversight Cocnmittee will provide approval on scopc, schedule anti budgct for the monitori.ng prog'r1in. 4. Iinplcmentation of Foundatiunal. Concepts. lhe Ovcrsight Committee will monitor the prog-i'ess of all cnHties in the implecnenladon of dElta managenient programs. The Qversighr Conuiul-tee will perioclicrilly revi.ew the proeress in iulplcm.enting actions ag•reed upon u1 the roLUldational Concepts a.nd repart progress ta the publ.ic. 5. Phosphorus tirading. The Oversight Comn-dttee will oversee the developrnenti and irnplem.entatiqn qf a phosphorus trading program or exchange progran consisl-ent with the E.nvu•oizmental Protcction Agency rules and regulations gtti.ding trading programs. . 6. Water conseivation commu.nications. "l"he Oversight Cammittce wi.l.l assure cQnuliunication of consistent wZd supportive messages regardiilg watEr conservaHon Water conscrvation will be carried ouY by t11e individual jurisclietians as independent. However, the Oversight Comnuttee will eoor.dinate ivid-i the parl7.ci.pating aetions jurisdictions to Facilitate coarciination of progracns a.nd actions to assiue a consistent message is being commu.n.icated to the public. ~ 2 7. Water reuse communication. ']'he oversight Comnuttee will act to assure ~ coatmunication of a consistent ai1d supportive mESSage regarding water re-use: Water re-usz iNill be carried out by the individual jurisdictions as independEnt actiAns. The Qversight Commilfiee ia=itl coordinatE with the parl-icipating juxisd.ichions ta facitihal•e coordination of water re-u.se programs and actions to assu_re that a consistent message is being com.mu.nicated to the public about the valuc of watcr re-use. 8. Report to the public. The Ovcrsight Committee wiII repart on a bi.-annual basis, through a major puUlic conference, actions taken and pKOgress made in reducing the discharge of phosphorus and improving the tiissolved oxygen un the Spokane IZiver and Lake Spokane Reservoir. FORNIA'rYON . The Oversight Can-Lnuttee will be formed through an I.nterloccal Cooperation Ach AgreemEnt. Thc Interlocal Agreenlent will provide for the following operating bodies of the Ovcrsight Canumittee: 1. An F.xecutive Roard wi.l.( be form.ed from the nlunieipal agencies with discharge permits to inanage the aff.ai.rs of the OvPrsiglit Con1u-uttee. The E.xeciitivE Boarci cvill be cornposed of Elec:ted OfEicial.s fronl the City of Spokane, Spokanc Cou.nty and Li.bezry L,ake Sewer and Water Disti-ict, as well as a.r.1 At-]:.argE Menzber who may serve as the Chair. . J 2. 1'echnical Committees wil.l be used to advise the OvErsight Coc.nnuttec on matters of a technical natuxe. Additional, short term, technical Conunittees wil] bc forrned as neecled and serve the Qversight Conunittee. 3. A Sta.nding Advisory Coizimittec will bc formed for the purpose of advaticing the goaLs of the Oversight• Corti.in,ittee as describc-d in the Foundational Concept 4. Special Advisory Bodies will be created to providE advice and guidance to the Oversight Camnuttee as nceded on unique or special tapics. 5. Qversighti Commiftee st:aff will be uldepcndent Pinployees of the Oversight Committee. StaFf will report to the Executive Board.. C(7N7POSlTI(7N The Oversight Conunittec will Ue ca.mposed of one member fronl tach (na.mes provided by each entity, except the At Largc Member.) of the following organizatians: 1. City of Spqkane 2. Spokane C:ounty 3. City of Spakane Valley 4. Liberiy I..akc Water and Sewer District ~ , . 3 5_ One at-large meinbcr (to be defined). A.n "At-large" menlber will be nonunated Uy the ExecutivE Committee a.ncl approved by lhe Ovcrsight CommitteE. The At- large nieniber nlay servc as the Chair of the Oversight Boarcl. 6. Washington State Uepa:rtment of Eeology The Standing F1dvisory Canwnittee shal.l consisk of approxi.mately 11 mernbers, with nonlinees suUnutted Uy Each group, and the appoint-ment rrade Up the Oversigllt Cont.m.ittee. It may be composed of representatives from l•he following organi.zations and/or ii-iterest groups: 1. Idaho Departn-ient af Environmental Quality 2. Spol:ane Tribe of tndians 3. Srevens Count), 4. city of Coeu.r d'Al.ene 5. Environnlenta1 interest groups 6. Conservation District(s) 7. Avista 8. ]nla»d Empire Paper 9. Kai:Ser Alurninunl 10. Others as may be recom.mended, a,nd approvPd by the Oversi.ghl• Cominittee ' TZepresentatives named by their respectivc organiLation and/or i.nterest group to participatP on N1e Advisory Conlnuttee will Uc expccted ta partieipat•e [ully in Advisory Comtnittee work on a tamely basis. Technical comm.i.ttees wil1 be formed by Uhe cavPrsight Comnuttce as needed to provide advice aiid g•uidance on spccial topics. 7"he tech.nicat comn-tittees will be composcci of individuals wi.th expertise and/or special l:nowledge at1d experience in the topics lo be acid ressed. Speeial advisory bodies wil.( be forrned fQr lirne liituted and dcfined topies as needed by the Oversight Comm.i.ttee. Special advisory bodies will be coniposeti of i,ndividuals wha may represent speeial. i.nteresl:S, knowledge and or experience rEgarciing khe topics to be ad.dxessed.. NUNDING The OverSight Conmuttee will be fundeci through contributions fioni d1e participawig• jurisdictions. 1. Developnlent af an Interlocal Agreenlent (ILA) to fo.rm the Oversight ComRi,ittee wTi1.1 be leaci, jointly, by the Ciry of Spokane, Spakane Cou-nty and l•he Washington Departcnene of hcology. . 4 2. Seed rnoney to fund the i.nikial 4vork of tkie Oversight Comm.ittee wi.ll be coniributed froul eadl jurisdiction, incluciing the Washi.ngton Deparhnent of. - Ecnlogy. 3. The Fxecueive Committee cvill develop an initial and an on-going funding meehanism f.or (7versighl• Conimittee responsibilities. Legal r.eview of initial fu.nd.ir.ig sourees will be done, joinlJ.y, by City of Spokane and Spakane Cou.nly. Potential funcii.ng soitrces include: a. Adnlulistralive charge to thc nan-point sou.rce conti•ol program. g•rlnts. U. Creatian of a Watershed Protecbon Aut}loriry c. Alu1ua1 assessnient to each wastewater utiliry d. Other 4. SpOIC1Ile COLLIlty will servE as the Fiscal Agen.t f.or i,nitial grant fund.ing and admi.n.istration af the ILA until such time as thc Oversight Committee is establishEd and operating wi.th proper authority and praCCdures ut-place ta function indepEndently. . ~ . 5 ~ . . . • ' ver.3.7.07 ~Spokane River Dissolved Oxvaen TMDL* Schedule - 2007 DATE ACTION February 14 EPA issues draft Idaho water quality permits for 60-day public review March 7 Partnership finalizes the TMDL Collaborative Pracess March 15 Ecology convenes the TMDL Advisorv Committee to review the revised draft DO TMDL April 14 EPA's public comment period closes on draft Idaho water quality permits ~ May 11 Ecology DO TMDL public meetinq to initiate a 30 public comment period May 25 Ecology DO TMDL workshop and public hearinq May 30 Ecology draft NPDES permit public meetinq . May 31 EPA issues final Idaho water quality permits - June 30 Ecology submits final Spokane River DO TMDL to EPA for approval July 31 Ecology reissues Washington water quality permits TMDL = Total Maximum Daily Load or Water Quality Improvement Plan ° Snokane River TMDL Collaboration ~ Munitoring Aetivitics and Structurc 1. Activities The Oversight Committee will: ' ' • "Irnplement a monitoring and research program for the River to routinely track and evaluate the amount of phosphorus removal, the impact of phosphorus reduclions and . associated iniprovements on dissolved oxygen levels." Data Oualitv Assuraiice: Ecology's Water Quality Data Act Yolicy reqi.ures that cach cnvironrnental study' . conducted by or for the Washington State Department oF Ecology must have an approved . Quality Assuraiice (QA) Project Plan.llie QA Project Plan describes the objectives nf . . the study. and the procedures to bc followed to achicve thosE objECtivcs. The QA Project . Plan is a product of a systematic planning process. . A QA k'roject Plan . 11 •.Lists the goals and objeetives of a study . . • Identities the type anci quality of data needed : • Describes the sampling and mcasurcment procedures necded to acquire ttiose data • Describes the QC and assessment procedures needed to ensure that the study ' obj ectives are met Corc `'Vater Oualitv Monitoring Assess current conditions and trends in water quality as improvements in wasteNvater treatment aud uuti ;ation of non-point sources occur over tiuie. There are current]y- four ambicnt morutoring stations wfuch have been satnplecl regularly for the past 10 years. Six . additional core monitoring stations are being considered. Sbecial Sludies • Sediment oxygen demand - • Efficacy of river acration/oxygenation • Bio-availability of phosphorus. Water Oualitv Modelino- • . ' , Modeling vf the Spokane .River will conlinue to be an integral part of managing Spokanc i River «+ater quality. The CE QUAI. W2 niodel will be used to: . ` - • Evaluate potential effects of planned implemcntation measures J • Assess the effectiveness oEcompleted implementatinn acticans • Tdcntify where additional dala coUection would aid decision-making Modcling will integrate the data gathered from core monitorinD and special studies aud is fui essential element of adaplive managcment. Revortinf'! Ecology will prepare annual perf'ormance reviews concerning the status oPagreEd-upon target pursuit actions (ee. steps requirzd to upgrade technologies and eluninate delta) . Every twa years Ecolog}y, usuig rnonitoruig uiformation, will prepare and present a report to the coixununity regarding the Rivcr's hcaltii and the performauce and effects of the target pursuit actions. . 2. vionitoring Committee The Oversight Committee is expected to creatc a monitoring team or committee af agency staff who -Mll develop and manage, through coopcrative efforts, a monitoring program. "1'he Oversight Conunittee will provide approval on scope, schedule and budgel • For the monitoring pragram 1 MI7L Collaboration Monitoring Work Group City of Spokane Spokane County Ecology . Spokane Counry Conservation District City of Coeur d'Alene Aviska . , Sierra Club i I MONITGRINC, WokKcpC)liF DkAF i REPGKi 3 0 3 6 Mibs M%Mmmmi N 'Nashington tdat}o A t umI 4Orra RAW Lau ~ Colt~r 7 AI~M Lace (~4J CuOd Rl.t 11117 ! dty ot Gow 0'luW* l Lowv use Aw'Ta parnr roM 1a7 T Jii spOkiA! OWf: 70 RT.'!f 4lu I2.s r 1Va~r.r.~~i~~fo rfie0 E=rtr PspW S3~~I,1e KV 4E a OOUt!! ' CAIt1Qart1~ ITiYP ; rrN ~f► ~~m Itl t d2,t 57A1 ltLt iT.4 ~ Dw 54A7 2 Cm" KaWAImInum c7ay a cost faM DOT► / rmTp R ~Z. ~ uea-C NtA 100.5~ ~ y W51Cin AIl~ S81bfC dGitO 1~IV Rl~R iQL~.7 ~ OActive Station , ~~T ~'a ' t.xan cr#ac (Ii~nQrt~ Cr~ek) MProposed Station 5 r ~ Novemner LZ, 'LUU7 Figure 1. Ecology's active Spokane River ambient monitoring stations and proposed new station locations. Technologv,Selection Protocol (TS1') ~ t'1t nthiiiiiuui. wi acGCF ~4 table 1`eshn€~lo'~e1c~ti~an ~'rc~tacol rnust ~cIu~ie ~sr ~+~res,~ Lhe tc~llr~'w~+in g itcrns: 1. Goalsc Thc. '['SP rriust clearly idexit~f~ lhe gvals for the wwwwater LTOUunenr techn~~logy°, including, but aot liniited to: a. Pruvide a complete list of established)identiiied goal (i.e. <50 uglL ) b. Timel i~e,% or timc coru(raints for e~.~c;l~ goa1 NKART": The `~SP o-nust speak to ILow AKART is being addressed for each iiidividuat lechnolop- conMaereil in Ihis evaluratioti 3. Process. `l'he TSP mus# describe Lmd detaii the pr'ocesses use~ eva:Mr.ate an+d e1Srninate individua1 wasii:w-a#er treatinent tecluiol~gies 4. Recomrnenda#iuti: The TSP mu:;[ recommen:d either a singlc wastewater rrcataieat tech,nolagy, or a combination of ~~a-qs;wa[er tmatrnent techno1~gies, wZd ijfcludet but not be limiteci to: a.. Tirtiing of implemtntation of selectc;d tecLiolcegy b. Desc:riplion of t~ow ths: r"ommerided tec1nology v%ill ~cwevc trea#.meni go~fls Delt7 Ellnliileitli}II PlaII (D~P) At rninimurn, an acc~~~able DeIta Llinsinaiion Ylan must include or address the fo[lowirag items: ~ ~ i. Goals. 'I'he I7EP mu.st ~le-arly identiCy establisheci goa1s including, but isot liiniked to: a. Define DEP, irtcluding how it is determirtedlcalculaled for Lhe sndividual eittit~~ ~ function of TNtDL goals and wastcNvater treatment effectiveness ts. Timelines c,r time constraints tor DEP unplementation. Process: The DI;P rnust idenlit`v, describe and detail the p€assibre C3E1' projects or acfivitaes under conszderution. b}+ the res~~ctivc eniity ii7c[uding, but nat limited to: a. [.ist of all identi#ieci rx)"ible DF_.F pr~~ect or activitirs b. Estirnationlproaection oi` amourtt ansJ t9Ming O£ P011LLtant (:{delta") reduction of each, uncluding supporting cab:ulations, m#erunces, etc 3. Recommendationt '1`he 17EP anust rt-co rn.mend one or mone projects or a,cti vities capahle of achi evir,g DEP goals ine luding, but not be limited xo: a. Pravrifizalion ofa31 identifieci pec~jects or activities b. Timing oI'implema:niationof each c. Dtncripxion of~ow tI7e recommenderf projccts or activitics will ac,hieve goals TfP & DEP Togekher, the Technolagy SeIeclion Protocol and Utlta Elftnination I'Ian iirust w-idi reasonabp~ assur~~e clearly c~emsanstrate lhe aIailily of llle clisclaarger at:hieve t~~ finaI goaI.s of d1e T"l+ML. For phosplycrus, ihat meat~s -a "hlended" loading. resivtiflg from both TEP and L)E P. ol` tica mtit`e tbn 1~ U&T,_ ~ µwrh 6• 2001 Numbar ot 2m T"k Task Tttie ss..s wW End DaRe Days Nov r~L „w rED wA APR wY x,. A:L t 2 3 t~ ] a 1 7• 1 7) a~ 11 4 7/4 t 1 3 4 I? 7 a 13 4 1.10.00 S kane Rtvei DO TMDL 1,1001 Fhal modeMna tune comnlatn I I?12W007 1.10.02 IRevise draR DO TMOL ~ 3110007 1 31150007 14 1.10.03 IMod" wcxft raua rvrriew d re+rtsed dran 00 TMOI ~Ut5f2061 I 3f30f'2DOl I 1.10.04 lAdvfatxv Cpmtnlltee rdlvfew, ol revlsod draN TMOI ~ 3/15rl007 I 313(Y20(17 I 1.10.05 Finet rovlelona lo dreh DO TlrlOL I 4i1fm7 ~ 411/2001 ~ u 1.1D.06 I al teom revlew d rt" dref! DO TMDL ' 4J7l2007 ~4121/?OQ7 14 revlaw (Don Manuu'Leurle Mann): notlly ECY PID d upcartriV 1 I I .1 D.Q7 wblia oomrteocN ne►iod 4r11 R00T 1130R007 n 1.10.08 In te EP/l aomf►sMVrocn►nmetxialloru: lnlomel rewmv 5+1!'407 ~ 5f112007 ~ 6 110.08 1 PuAUcmeetuxr 911/2001I 1 110.10 130-dav DuW1c oommenl oenod d rovwed dreR TMDL 911 l7p()7 6f1112007 ~ 31 110.11 IPubllc heorin4 ~ 5051007 ~ t 1.10.12 I Incorparate pubhc oortmients irtlo finel DO TMDL 9/11f20d7 I 6l15l2007 I 4 110.13 ~lntemel taem rwlaw al Mul DO TMDL ~ fi/tfil20D7 ~ 506r2007 ~ 1:1 110.14 ISubmq flnal DO TMDL to EPA ~ 613{1I2007 I t 1.20.00 [Area IYPDES Permlts 12mine d NPDES nemHl nndiralktns xe uc+-tu4eto I 1111.5l2c108~ 1_20.02 (DevWots droN NPDES awmits ~ 9712008 1115r2Q07 ~ 171o 1.20.03 IntAmd tan nrvlewr d WaTI NPOES twumits I tI td12Q07 I 2120f1007 I 35 1.20. W Faduat review af dnN NPDES oermd~ ~ 22f1r2007 ~ 5I100U0'1 ~ 79 1.20.05 3048tDUbYC review d drnfl NPDES twrmita I 5J111'1007 I 6f11/1007 I 31 1.20.06 kb6c meapnQ fnr " NPDE3 ioortn4a 5r302087 ~ t 1_28_07 ~Respprnl tq ooomienta tscelved on " NPpES c*xffmts Bri 212007 ~ 813d1100 I .8 120.011 Isaue Rnd FfPOES oermMs I 8130/2007 I t I 1.24.09 ~Eflar.Uve dalo d NPOES oertMts 711f2047 ~ t 1_ L \ • Spokane River Forum Development Framework ' Mission . The Spokane River Forum sseks to preserve and enhance the value of the Spokane River for ali segmsnts . of society by increasing and deepening public awareness, engagemertt and interacaon with the rivers environrrtental, cultural and economic resaurces. . ' • Background and Need , ' - • The Spokane Rfver is often referred to as °Spokane's signature," its "prernfer community asset,° or "lacal . treasure." The river"can be seen as the blue ribbon bf the chambers "Near Nature, Near Perfect° campaign to draw busfnesses, talent and tourism to the region. The Spokane River Forum provides a tool to inspire decision makers, stakeholder groups and the public to find pathways tav,rard a clean and healthy Spokane River watershed that is an asset 4o all segments of the : comrnunity. , Goals and Objectives , . . The Spokane River Forum has five fnterconnected goals and objectives: : ' 1) Leadership: The Forum will be recagnized by federal, tribal, state and local suthorities, non- • govemment organizations, and the general pubfic as fhe key ooordinating bady/clearinghouse for Spokane River informaHon. • ' 2} Coordination: Tfie Forum will foster interagency oommunication regarding pubtic awareness needs and iniNaNves. Further, the Forum will work across agencies and entities to ooordinate public . information and engagement regarcling ecanomlc, environmental and cultural issues affecting the ' Spofcane River, induding how decisions and objectives in one area may affect another. In short, a platform evill be developed to help agencies promote public awareness (of?) across several issues. 3) Public InformatioQ: In understandable, easily accessibla tenns, the Forum will educa(e fndividuais ' and groups about challenges facing the river, protection and clean-up efforts, and the potential benefits and oosis of proposed regulations, restoration and/ar cleanup efforts. Information tviU- include: - • Roles and responsibilities of agenaes and• groups ' . • Overviews and inventory of ecaonomic, environmental and cuitural issues affecting the r(ver . Proposed studies ' • CurrenVexisting study data and information - Altemative strategies for i-egulation, protecbon, cleanup actions andlor issue resolution . Timing af decisions and public comment periods • . Opportunitizs to become involved in one or more issuss 4) Puhllc Enaaaement: The Forum.wifl host and promote specific activities to facilitate dirECt - interaction with scientists, natural resource managers, decision makers and others concQmed vrith mrer issues. Such opportunities twill enable the public to: . 8ecome directty invotved in one or more issues , • Encourage mutual gains decisfon making and coliaboration . • Promote individual, group and arganizational behavioral change to address specific needs • 5) Student/TeacherQutreach: The Forum will dsvelop specific materials and resources that students ' and teachers can use to connect Spokane River issues and experiences to mastery of Washington . ' State Essential Leaming Requirements,. Washington state grade-level expectabons, and university requirements. I'dlaterials and activities may include: • Print and/or on-line resources • Teact►er woricshops . • Classroom field trips • Intemships • I ~ fJ ' . Principles • . Specific organizational principles include: • - • A non-hierarchical, oollaborative organization design • Actfvities that promote public infarmation and engagement, but do not develop policies _ . ' or policy recommendatfons • Outcomes of organization decisions do not usurp or diminish the statutory autharity, legal mandates, or Treaty rights given to govemment . _ • Outreach and engagement efforfs maximize administrative etficiency, minimize conflicting public messages, and leverage opportuniGes for funding Thesa principles, taken togett►er, the mission, goals and objeckives, will facilitate creating an environment t;hat: . . , ' •places a premium on aollaborative effort . , • is entrepreneurial and futuristic in nature • thinks holistically • is incJusive of all individuais and groups . • facilitates development of posifive, trust-based relationships • cates transparency via access to people, rssaurvss and informational data Gases . h reonors the needs of all participants by providing information resources that are timely, understandable'and easy to access • fostzrs winaprin outoomes by encouraging mutual gains for all partiapants helps to coorciinate and unify public messages. . Such an environmsnt maximizes the community's ability to act collectively to support the highest good for the Spokane River watershed. . • , . . ~ i • . • ` ~ ~ Spokane TMDL Capital Budpet - Proviso from the 2006 supplemental capital budget page 28 of Bill S-5878 "$1,150,000 of the state building construction account--state appropriation is provided solely for activities required to determine the total daily maximum load (TMDLS) for the ' Spokane River." . All of the money must be under contract by 6-30-07. We will lose these funds if they'are not under contract by 6-30-07. There is no match requirement. . Monitarina and Niodelina ($150,000 per year) fund additional and continued river monitoring to verify the condition of the river and how it responds to changes in phosphorus ' inputs and flows, and collect additional information and conduct modeling related to bottom sediments and aeration proposals. As per I'u91P, local dischargers will share in the cost of . implementing and operating the monitoring and research program. • Reuse & Aauifer Recharoe ($250,000) - provide grant funding to local sewer utilities (City of Spokane, Spokane Co. and Liberty Lake Sewer and Water Dist.) to revise facility plans to include aggressive water reuse and aquifer recharge elements, including initial facility plans. . V'Vater Conservation ($100,000) provide grants to local sewer utilities to begin a program to provide vouchers or rebates for the installation of iR-house water conservation flxtures (low • flow toileh, sho%werheads, washing machines, etc.) ~ • Non-point Source Pollution Prooram ($500,000 per year) - provide grants to begin implementing the Little Spokane R. and Latah Cr. TMDLs (these tributaries provide high levels of nutrients to the Spokane R.). As per MIP, the local dischargers will jointly fund this program. . Public education & outreach and TMDL administration ($150,000 per year) - provide funds to establish an education and outreach program'for the TMDL and to provide administration and oversighit of the TMDL Managed Implementation Plan. This could be funding to ' establish an "office" or program jointly with the local govemments. Spokane River Forum Proposal? . , Not included: • • Watershed Oversight and Coordination Committee Funding • Treatment Technology - grants or loans for upgrading and constructing sewage treatment facilities to implement tfie TMDL. Local governments will spend the next year . ' or so running pilot plants and determining the most appropriate type and cost of treatment technology to be installed. 1JVe do not have facility plans or cost estimates yet, but they are likely to be very big hundreds of millions). About 3 or 4 years ago Spokane County estimated iYs costs for a ne`v advanced wastewater treatment plant to , be $73 million. It's not knoWm what their plant will cost with additional phosphorus removal, but it's sure to be more plus inflation. Costs to the City of Spokane and Liberty Lake are not known either, but the City had already planned on spending about $100 million on upgrades. Not all of these costs are due to the TMDL, much is simply to add • capacity to serve population growth in the area. The TMDL will add significant ~ incremental costs, however. FINAL DFtAVI' - SCQPT OF WOltlC ' BI-STATE NQN-POIiNT SQURCF STUI)Y=1'HASL 1 . SPOKAniE RTVFR DiSSQLVTaD OXXGEn' TMllL • INTRODUCTIOri The Spokane River Uissolved O:cygcn (17U) rotal Ma.Yimiun Daily I.:oad (TtifDi...) proccss has cstablished a phosphonis target of 10 µg/L, which is expected lo reduce e.YCe_ssivc algal productivity that causes DO conce.ncrations to i~aU below the tivater quality _ . standard. Thc Foundational Concepts for the Spokane River Ta0 TMDL %vill begi.n guiding TMT)L implementation, and meeting the phbsphorus target will reyuire a cembination of improved poiut source wastewater treatinent technology xiid reduced non- pouit source (NJ-f'S) pollutant loads. Treatment technology currently canno/ reliably meet lhe waste laad largel of 10 µg/i.,, ' . and the difference between what current technology can aclueve and the waste load target is r.ef.err.ed to as "the Taelta." The Foundational Concepts requires that National Pollutant T.)ischarge Eliinination System (NPDES) permit holders develop A Delta Eliuiuiabon Plan, and states that they may participate in a regional NPS program. If that pactiGipation demonstrates NTPS phosphorus load reductions to the river, 'NTPDES pemiit holders will be recogiuzed as contributing toward achievuig phosphorus waste load targets. As such, tlus Bi-Statc NYS study is a necessary first step towards deuionstratitig Nl'S phosphorus load ~ reductions. , The Spokaue River and Lake Spokane have been listed on a 303 (d) list for iuipairment or dissolved oxygen (b0). Modeling iudicates that the inain cause of the DO depletion is algae in thc water bodies. The algac growti is primarily caused by e:cccssive nutricnts, with phosphorus being the largest nutrient contributor. ThE DO I'otal Ma.Yimuin 17aily Load (T'MDL) study rccommcndcd that both point . sotirces and NPSs of phosphonis bc identified and mitieatEd. `1 he purpose of this prap4sed shidy, whicll will be conductcd in phascs, is to idcntify and quantify vF'Ss into the Spnkauie Ttiver and Lake Spokiuie, to icientify best inanagement practices (BMf's) to zddress the Nl'Ss; to evaluate the cost-effectiveness and longevity of the identified BMYs, aild to prepare an implementation plan for reduction of NPS based on the selecteci BMPs. . .'1'hE study area of the Phase 1N-PS study uicludes the watersheds associa.ted vvitli Coeur. , d'A1cnc Lal:c, the Spokane 1't.iver ajid its tributaries liangman/Latah Creek and Little . Spokaiie River, and Lake Spokane. The study area is shoNvn on the attached Figure l. As the NPS study progresscs; thc study area may bc reviscd as appropriate. Initial grant fiindin ; of appro:timately $248,800 has beeii provided by the Uiuted States Congress, to be administe.red through the Environmental Protection Agency (E.PA) for this projECt. This grant funding was a direct result of efforts by the Spokane Renional ~ Chanlber of Conunerce, Representative Butch Olter, R.epresentative Cathy R~icMorris, and Senators Patty Murray, vlaria Cantwell; Lany Craig, aiid Mike Crapo. NFS Scope Final [7raft 030207 (2) 1 It has been estimAted that the full cost tc> perforni NI'S sriidics throuch completion of the - , implEmentation plan could be ui the range of $750,000 to $1,000;000. 1"herefore, it is ~ anticipated that the projECt Nvill be divided 'uito two or tluee distinct phases. The scope of work proPoseci herein is fQr Phase 1 only. 1'he scope pre_senteci below for future Phases 2. and 3 is preliniinary i.n nature and is presented only to illustratc the general directiou of the prnject from start lo final completion. 'I'hc scopc for Phases 2 and 3 may be retined and adjustecl ciuring the completion of Phase 1. Spokane County has agreed co be the grant recipient and lead agency for this reeional _ NT'S Study. As part of the effort fa initiate the Project ancl establish the grant; the Caunry has invited participatiou by a. nwnber of agencies and interested parties from Tdaho and Washington. '1°wo mcEtings have been held to discuss the scope ancl budget for the project. A list of the participating agencics and intcrestcd partiES, identificd as the I4PS . • Advispry Committee, is attached (Attachment A). tldditional mcmbers may bc addcd to the NPS Acivisory Committee as appropriate. This group will continue as the Advisory Committee for this NPS Stuciy and subsequcnt phases. ' Additionally, the Spokanc Rivcr 170 'Y IvIL7L Watershed Uversight Cornmittec; eurrcntly proposed as part of the Foundational Concepts for the Spokanc River DO TMDL, will bc included an the Advisory Committcc. vPS Scone of ~,~Vork lt is anticipated that due to fiinding, workload tiining, and subcontractor needs, this will ~ bc a rnulti-phasc project. "1'lus Scope of Work descrihes three (3) phases; however, the ' currcnt fiindins (S248,300) is linuted to Phase 1 activities only. lt is atrticipated that several siguficant studies will be needed to quantafy the non-poi_nt loading to the Spokane River; thus, fundinD needed f.'or later phase.s (Phases 2 and 3) ~vill greatly exceed the $245,800 currently available. If sufficient f'uture funding is avai]aUle folloxvuig completion of E'hase 1; 1'hases 2 and 3 could be performed as one phase to complete the overall \TPS Study ArojecC. Phase 1. Data Collection and Asscssment ("I'o hc fundcd bv the currentlv availablc :I::I:'A Grant) Compilation of existing ciata, data evaluation - daia gap identification, arld nurSuit pf • early action data collection efforts. Tiine allotted for cornplction of Phasc 1: 12 - 18 months aftcr grant approval Task 1-1. Identify potential NTPSs; Task 1-la. llevelop list and identify sources for eYisting/available data & iVl'S stuciies: F_.stimated F3udget $14,000 ' - I NPS Scope Final Drati 030207 (2) 2 . ]?otential NASS include, buC may not be limited to: • Agricultural acliviiies in the Hangman/Lalah Creek watershed in Iciaho and Washington, • Agriculhiral and residential activities in the Little Spokane River watcrshed, •Agricullural; residential and other development activities in the Coeur - • d'Alene Lake watershed and along the Spokanc River ui 1dalio In-direct storniwater dispnsal, examples include but are not limited to ' . ' drywells, sNvales, and otlier areas where storniwater intiltration occlirs; • Spokanc Vallcy Rathdnun 1'rairie Aquifer recharge, . • On-siie ciomestic waste disposal systems • Residential lawn fertilizers • Logs on the bottom of,Lake Cocur d'Alene and tlroughout ihe Coeur d'Alene watershed. ' T'ask 1-16. Collect available NTPS data and NPS stuciies; consultant evaluates data: Estimated Budget $60,000 . Evaluate collected data coiisistent with the Wa.shingtQn State Water Quality 17ata Act and Waslun;ton Department o.f.'Fcolhgy Credible Data . Policy. Identify crcdible fuld non-credible data. Identi.ky data gaps. These ~ are identified potential NPSs with littlc or uo esisting credible data necessary to quantify NAS loads and the impacts of BiVlPs. Action Items: • Meetings with agcncy staff to identify lcnown and potential sources/problems • Public workshop/meeting to inform stakeholders and broaden base for . sourceJPrablem identification (includcd as part of Task 1-5) • 12ctaui consultant to evaluale data. • Consultant data collection and evaluation '!'ask 1-2. Asscss and prioritize relative eontribulion of NIPSs: Estimatcd Budget $40,000 '1"ask 1-2a. Prioritize identifed potenli-al sources in terms of 1' loadirig based ou cYisting credibJe data and professianal judgment ' `l'ask 1-2b. Tdentif-y early action data collection efforts - high-priority sources with inadequate creclible clata constitutc early action data collection efl'orts Task 1-2c. Technical Memo 1-Stunmarize existuig studies arid available existing data;, suinnlarize adequacy of existing studies and cxisting data; ranking of sources; identif catipn of and recommendations for early action data collection ~ efforts. ' NPS Scopt: Final Drafi 030207 (2) 3 Action Items: . . ~ • Meetin~s behveen 'agency ar►d consultant staff to rcvie~v adequacy of data sets • Staffreview of identified early action items to assure conclu-rence ~ Public workshop/meetuig to infonn stakehoiders (included as parl of Task 1-5) Task 1-3: Develop a priority (or siudies io fill data gaps; develop scopes for early action data collection studies deenied feasible under available budget, collect early action data: . Estimated Budget. $60,000 . . ' ~ Task 1-3a. Develop scopc for carly action data collcction shidics Task 1-3b. To the extent funding is available; initiate early action data collection studies ' Task 1-3c. Prioritize remaining data gap completipn aclions Task 1-3d. R.esults o('early action stuclies; recommendatican and prioricization t'or fuiure studies . Action Itenis: • Establish work grotips of agcncy/citizcns with knowlcdgc of data gaps/sotirccs/problcros • Work groups meet tn develop study plmls • Acquire contractor services for early action data collection studies deemed ~ fundable in Phase 1. Farly action items preliminarily identif ed b}* the Advisory Group include phpsphoru.s loading to T ake Spokaile from on-sile waste disposal sysiems and phpspharus relea.se f'rom sedimenCS. • 1'repare Quality Assurasice Pa•oject Plaii for early action studies • Public Nvorkshop/meetuiE to inform stakcholders (includcd as part of "1"ask 1-5) Task 1-4. Project Management: Phase 1: Fstimated F3udget $30,000 Task 1-4a. Contract management:.FPA and subcvntractors ' Task. 1-4b: Develop ptoject zPeeirc Quality Assuraizce Project Plan(s) Action Items: , • Couiplete and subiuit timely progress reports and requests for reimbursemcnt • Conduct work group meetings (uicluded in Task 1-3) on an as- needed basis '1"ask 1-5. Public Education and lnformation: Phase 1: Lstimated Budgct $48,800 Task 1.5a. Conduct three public worl:'shop/meelings during Phase 1 ~ ' Task l.Sb. Other inforination dissetiunation as deemed necessary NF'S Scope I'inal 17nft 03 0247 (2) 4 ~ Action ltems: • Retain independent facilitator to conduct work group scssions (see Task 1- 3) and.public workshops/mectings. ' . • Conduct a public meeti_ng early in tre prop•am to provide informatioii to the public an the goals and approach nf the prnject, conduct a second . meeting follnvving completinn of Task 1-2 and a third meeting near ttie end of the Phase 1 fundina cycle. vleetings will be held 'ui central- locatioris v6tlun the watershed to better reach stakeholders in ldaho aiid ' Washington. Phase 2. Comnlete iNPS CharactcrizaNon (if ncedcd). Identifv and Evaluate Ri1~II's ' (Future Scope, Budeet, and Fundina) , The 1•inal Scope oF Work for Phase 2 will be completed following completion of Phase 1. For the purposes of this Scope ot' V✓ork, a preliminary scoge for Phase 2 is presenled below. This sc•ope will be reiined based on the funding anci progress in Fhase l. Tasks to he completed in-Phase 2 include: • Coinplete data collection and data assessment (if needed), • Characteri°r„e NPS loading by sources; and prepare non-point sourcc loading ~ reports, • Idcntify and evalti ate BNIPs to address NPS areas Task 2-1. Conduct Additional llata Collection (if needed) Task 2-1 a. Conduct needed additional ficld Nvork; data analysis, characterization of individual NPS loadiug, and report preparation . Action Items: ' Task 2-2. Identify and 23-valuate I'otential Best Managcment I'racticcs to control priority Non Point Sources Task 2-2a. Tdentif'y and correlate BMPs appropriate to each problem source Sludied, Task 2-2b. Evaluate cost-effcctivcncss and longcvity of idcntified BMll's. . -Develop effectiveness moiutoring plans for selected BIMPs, employ monitoring on pilot projects to assess effectiveness, , Task 2-2c. Prepare summary report of NIPS areas; including evaluation of cost- - effectiveness and longevit}, of identified BvI.Ps and moniforing plans, ~ NF'S Scopc Final Drsft 030207 (2) 5 Action ltems: ~ E-stablish work groups (from Task 1-3) to identify 13NQs , • Tncorporate effectiveness monitoring into proposcd BiVIP projeet scopcs whcrc possible • Prepare Summar.y R.eport Task 2-3. 1'roject Maiiagement Task 2-3a. Conlract management: P.PA and subcontractors Task 2-3b. Develop PrOject sPecific Quality Assurwice Prnject Plan(s) Action Items: . a Ncgotiate contracts witli selected contractors; (from 'T'ask 2-1) . • SuPervise contractor work. •Complete and submit cimely progress reports and requests fpr reimbursemcnt . • Conduct wor.k group meetings on an as needed basis • Conduct 1'ublic workshops at least aiuiually diuing thc grant pcriod, in • addition to those proposed in Pfiase 1. Phasc 3. Develop NPS implemcntation Plan (Futurc Sconc, Rudgct, and Fundina) T}l E.' C T1. ' , r' S ope oi~ `71~0 for Phase 3 will be prepared follc~~~mv ~ comple.tion of Phase 1 and Phase 2. A preliininary, eoncepiual scope is presented below. . Taslc 3-1. Develop a BMP Implementation Plan Action items: • Develop macrix matching best management pract.ices vvitll problem areas • Identify funding sources and ]ead agencies for impleinenting each practice • Icientify actaptive manageuient elements xvliere appropriate to elements and defining monilorinj trigge•rs fpr changing management Task 3-2. Project Managcment Task 3-2a. Contract mana-gement: EPA and subcontractors °1"ask 3-2b. 17cvclop projcct spccific Quality Assurance Yroject Plan(s) _ . Action Items: • Completc and submit timely progress rcports and requests for reimbursement ~ • Conduct Tecluucal Coi-tuiiittee meetiiigs on azi as necded basis • Conduct Public workshops at least an.nually durin; t,he grant period NPS Scope Final Draft 030207 (2) 6 ~ Attachment A Non Pouit Source Advisory Committce Participants United States Lnviroiunental•1'rotectiou Ageilcy Washingtan Departmcnt of Ecology Spokane County • Spokane County Conservation District . . . City of Spokatic City of Spokanc Vallcy Libcrty Lakc \Vatcr and Sewer 17istrict Spokane Tribc Idaho Dcpt. of Environmental Quality Kootenai Loiurty Panhancllc Hcalth llistrict City of Coeur ci'Alene ' City of Post Falls . ~ Coeur d'Alene Tribe . . - , Spokane 1Ziver ll0 TMDL Watershed Oversigllt Coninuttee Sierea Club - Center for Justice T ands Council ~ , NPS Scopc Final Draft 030207 (2) 7 DRAFT ADVANCL AGENDA For Planning laiscussion Ytirposcs Only as Uf viarch 29,2007 8:45 a.m. Flease uote this is a work in Progress; iteius are tcntative To: Council R Staff From: City Managee Re: Draft Schec[ule for Upcoming Council Vfeetings - A.oril 10. 2007, Kcaular NleetinR, 6:00 n.m. [due date Monday, Aprii 21 Proclanintiort: Child Ahuse Freventivn 1llatrth 1. PU13LiC HEARING: 1'roposed Amended T3udgeC - Ken Thompsnn _ [10 minutes] 2. Consent Agenda: Claims, Payroll, Minutes; SAC Bylaws [5 minutes:l 3. Second EZeading Yroposed Public Record Ordinance - Mike Connelly [10 minutCS] 4. Second Reading Proposecl Purchasing Ordinaiice - Cary Iariskell [15 minutes] 5. first 17eading Prqposed Ordinance Amending Logo Provisions - Cary Driskell [10 minutes] 6. First lteading Ordinance Amcnding 2007 Budget-Ken Thompson [10 minutesJ 7. First Reading Amendment to Animal Coritrol Orclinanee - Cary l7riskell [10 minutes] 8. Proposed Rcsolution Supporting 1 VIDL Process - Councilmember D-enenny [10 minutcs] 9. Motion Consideration: Snow Plowing Level of Service - John Mohnian/Neil Kersten [10 minutes] 10. Mokion ConsidEration: Authorizing 'Negotiation of Street Maintenance Contract - Neil I<ersten [20 rtiinutes] [estiRiated meeting: 110 minules] Wediresclcrv, Anril 11, 2007-Mcnjor's State ofthe Citv Adrlress Mirabcau Hotel Aari117. 2007, 6:00 n.m. Studv Sessian [due date Monday April 91 1. N irst Quarter CenterPlace Rentals - Mike Jackson (30 minutes) 2. Bzirker Raad Bridge Update = Steve Worley (15 minut:es) 3. Waste Management Pick iap - Cary llriskell (20 minutes) 4. Lncal Redevrelopment Authority - laave Mercier (20 minutes) 5. Advanee Agenda Additions - Nlayor VVilhite (5 minut:es) 6. Council Check-in -iMayor Wilhite (5 minutes) 7. City Managcr Comments - llave Niercier (S rninutcs) TOTAL A-1CNUTLS: 100 minutes Anril 24, 2007, Reiular I17ceting, 6:00 n.m. [duc date Monday, April 161 Proclamation: Aqrirticipal Clerk's Week 1. Cansent Agenda: I'ayToll, Claints, Minutes [5 minutes] 2. Second Reading Proposcd Ordinance Amending Logo Provisions - Cary [ariskell [10 minutes] 3. Sccond Readins Ainendmenl to Animal Control Ordinance - Cwy Driskell [ 10 minuCes] 4. Second Reading Qrdinance Amending 2007 $udget - I{en1-hornpsAn [5 minutes] 5. Prqrosed Resoluxion A.mendi.ng 2007 'I [E' - Steve Worlcy (10 minut:es) 6. Viotipn Considerat.idn: Contract Approval for Street Maintcnance - l\Teil hersten [20 minul:es] 7. Sidewalks - iVlike Connelly [20 minutes] 8. Information Only: T)epart:menC ReporCS [esl•imated mecting: 95 mi»utes] Mav 1, 2007, 6:00 ».rn. Sliecial MeetinLt/StudY Session [due dxtc Monday, April 231 Joint M.eerin2 Nvith County Commissioncrs for Item #1.: 1. Wastewater'Creattttent Financial Planning, rates Study - Bruce Rawls (60 min) R.eaular Shidv Session for Ctiuncil for remainder items: 2, City Inclieat'ors - Patrick Jones (20 minutes) O 3. Proposecl 2008-2013 '1'lly - Steve Worley (20 minutes) 4. Advance Agertda. Flddi[ions - Mayor VVilhite (S minutes) 5. Council Check-in-Mayor `Vilhite . (5 minutes) 6. City iti!lanager Comrncrits - Dave Mercier (5 minutes) TOTt1L MINI3TFS: 115 rninutt:s Draft rldvancc Agcnda 3/29C2007 8:40 Ai~~t Page 1 of 2 May 8, 2007, Tteeular Meeting, 6:00 n.m. [due date Monday, Apri130] 1. Consent A.Denda: Payroll, Claims, Minutes [5 minutes] 2. Admin f7eport: T'aperless Agcndas, Cost Comparisons - Chris Bainbricl;e 1*20 minutesJ May 15,2007, 6:00 n•m. Studv Session [due date Monday, 1VIay 7] l. Discussion: 1'olicy Issues in Planning Commission Recommendecl UL7C Tit.les (90 rninutes) Mav 22. 2L107, l7cLyular A'IeetinL,, 6:00 u.m. (duc date 1VTond.iy, May 141 1. PUIi.LT(,: FIE ARING: E'ropnsed 2003-2013 TIl' - Steve VVorley' (10 minutes) 2. [nforniatian Only: Depar[mcnt R.eport.s Vi9y 29, 2007 - DAY AFTER NTENiQRIr1L D:1Y - NU ML ETfiNG Saturdxv, June 2, 2007 - CounciVStaff Retreat, 9 a.ni. - 3 p.m. Councilmember Denennv's Cabin. 29897 i.lsle View Road. Snirit Lake. ldaho 83869 Tenlulive AgC1TCIQ T1C'mG': F1l7PdJt2g Upf1077Si Bond issttes, 2008 Gouls (P!ulley CD13C PrvbTranr); COIl7lC1I tYE'FICUSts .Tunc 5, 2007, Sueci:iCA'lecting' 6:00 D.M. (due date;Tuesday; Nia,y 29, 2007} L Consent ADenda: Payroll, Claims, [vtinutes [S minutes] 2. Administrative Report: U17C Titles - Marina Sukup 1:20 minute,s] Tuesdav, June 12, 2007 - No Mecting or Studv Session {June 12-15: A4VC Cities Conference, Tacoma) JOlA'TMrrafjN'c w1rtr.SPC)I'►AiN'E COUNTYCOrYTitifISSIOIVERS: f'nssihle rlutes include: Morrday, Jurre ls at 1: 30 al !he Cornity,,- aY FYedriesday, June 21, !!I II7B 1I10Yl1!!7g June .1.9, 2007, 6:00 o.m. Studv Session [duc date A-londay, Juue 11] June 26. 2007, Reaulsr NIecdng, 6:00 p.m. [due d.ite Mondst}', .Iune 181 1. CUnsent Agend3: Payroll, Claims, Ivtinutes [5 miniites] 2. Proposed Resolution Adopcing 2008-2013 11Y - SCevc Worley (10 minutes] 3. Inforniation Only: i7epaitment Reports :Julv 3. 2007 = nAY REFn.RF 4"' 0r :ITJLY - trn mee'tiiie. ,Tulv 10, 2007. I2c:eular Mccting, G:UU D.m. [duc date A-Ionday, July 2] 1. CUnsent Aaenda: Payroll, Claims, Minutes [5 minutes] OTIi1;K F.CNDIN(". ANU/O12 Ul'COtii1NG TSSITESnIEEE17WGS: Work Force Development, In-Service De.finicions AdoptiUn of 2008 Budget - Oeloher 30, 2007 [..odging Grants CDBG Review estima[ed meeting cime does not include time for public Noise Qrdinancc (Construction Activity) comments] Modi .fied Crime CheclJGime Reporting Central Vsllcy School Districc [rnpact I=ee IZcquest , Sewer Collectinn SySLems - \ieil Ker5len ' . Site Locator Sepc 27-29, 2007: NLC, Energy, Environment R. \Tatural ResOurces Sesering Comrnittec Fall Meetin;: CenterE'lace Accident Stzti3tics alonD Broadway -(7ceober 2007 T)raR .Advance Agenda 3/'29f2007 8-40 AIM Pagc 2 of 2 Spc'TI~oka00'0'~ .ne Va11ey 11707 E Sprague Ave Suite 106 ♦ Spokane Valley WA 99206 509.921.1000 ♦ Fax: 509.921.1008 ♦ cityhall@spokanevalley.org Informational Memo To: David Mercier, City Manager and City Council Members From: Neil Kersten, Public Wor1cs Director Steve Worley, Senior Engineer- Capital ProJects CC: Nina Regor, Deputy City Manager Date: March 21, 2007 Re: 44`h Avenue Pathway ProJect - February 28, 2007 Open House Yroject Background Since 2004 the City has received letters from the Central Valley School District requestulg safe pedestrian facilities for studEnts walking along 44"' Avenue. These rcqucsts have becn mostly focused on new cievelopments proposed wcst of Schafer Road buC also include 44a` Avenue east of Schafer Road. Attached are severalletters from the school district rega,rding their concerns. As a result of thcsE concerns, the City developed a grant request for 44`h Avenuc pathway bctwcen Woodruff Roaci and Sands Road. There are currently bike lanes on the widened shoulders of Schafer Road ancl Sands Road and ail asphalt pathway along WoodruffR.oad to Ponderosa Elemcntary School. Additionally, the Poncierosa PUD on the west end of 44`h Avenue has been canditioned for the construction of a pathway on 44th Avenue fram the develnpment to Woodruff Road. Proviciing pedestrian and bike access on 44U' Avenue froni Woodruff Road to Sands Rnad would coinplctc bikE access on all the Ponderosa arterials (see attached Map 3.2, Bike and Pedestrian System, from the adopled Cnmprehensive Plan). In 2006 the City received a Federal S'1'P Enhanccmeni grant in the amount of $16,500 f'pr the design phase of a 10 foot wide asphalt sharcd-use pathway alang the north side of 44`h Avenue from Woodruff R.oad to Sailds Road. A survey cnnsultant, David Evaiis & Associates, was selecteci last fall from the City's consultant roster, and the topographic and right-of-way survey work was completed on January 22, 2007. Qn Wednesday, Nebruary 28t' 2007, aii open house was hEld at Ponderosa Elementary School from 3:301'M to 6:OOPVi. A preliininary layout of the proposed ` ' pathway was clisplayed for discussion purposes. Approximately 35 to 40 people Informational Memo March 21, 2007 44"' AvEnuc 1'athway Projcct - February 28, 2007 Open House Page 2 attended the ope_n house. f11so ui attendanee was Valerie Putnam, a correspondent for . the Spokesman Review. On Saturday, March 3, 2007 the Spokesman Rcview published Valerie Putnam's article on the projecC and the open house. A copy of that ai-ticle is actaehed for review. Also aCtached is a copy of the informational handout clistributed at the open house. Public lnput and Feedback Feedback received af the open house was generally mixed, with those supporting the pathway appro:cimately equal to ttlose expre.ssing concerns. Below is a summary of the gcneral concerns expressed at the npen house along ~vith staff s resPonses to those conccrns. TtiE PATHWAY D0E5 N'OT CO\T1ECT TO ANYTI•II\~G OR GO AN1'WHERE. fihe prvposed patlnntry along 44`k .Avenue Will prOvicle a cvnnection to the existirrg a.sphalt pcrtlnwc~y ulong the lvest side oJ'Woacli°ar f Routl. 7his existrng pathwcry on Woodrttff Road cvr2linues north to Fonderosa Elemeratury Sclrool. 7'he intent of the Pr•oposed projects is to irraprvve sufety fof• the general public untl for tivalk-ing sturlents not only to Ponderosa Elementary bru ulso for middle and d2igh sehoa1 students that catch scl2aol huses along 441h Avenue. 1 HE PA'CHWAY tiVIL[. RESULT 1N Tl-LE EI.IM1NATiO~I OF TREES. . Orre of'the goals for this project is to clesign and corrstruct a patynvay tllat will fit trt lvith the surrounding neighborhovri by mecrnderirag uround exi.rtirig trees in an ef "oY1 to suve a.s many of the Pvrrderusci Pines us posstble. However, ir is recognzzed tFtat svme existing trees will rieed !a be removed to fit the putFnvuy tivitlzin the existiyig r•rg111-of-tivay. Oize residertt livirrg ori 44`k Avenue expres.red support for the remnval of a tree in front of his house. THE PATHWAY SHOUi.D BE CONS'I'RUC"TEI7 ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF 44" AVL'NUE, 1N ~ QRDER TO ELIMINATF TFE CROSSMG OI' SCHAPER ROAD. THIS INTERSECTION [S ' CUE2.RE11TLY UNSAFE. . I he norrll ,ricle of 44ff' Avenue lvcrs chosen for the puthwrry becuuse Fhere is more rig3rt-vf-tvay utiailable rtortlr of the existing roudway than on the south side. Wi1h tlzis udditional right-of-tivay, impacts to exisiing trees and other improvernerilS I S' )IIIY111121ZG'CI. SIg71RgG' Q12CI CPpS.,nvulk striping will be included us purt of the project tn ulert clt•ivers of pedestrians crnssing Schafer Ruucl. THE PATHWAY SHOULD BL- CONS7'RUCTED AI,ONG SCHAFER RO.AD INSTEAD. Schafer Road currerilly hus widened asphalt shoirlders which are iriceridedfor u.se by both pcclestrian,s und bicyclists. Because44c6r Avenue currently ha,s no ' bicycle or pedestrian facilities this project had u signircantly better opportacnity of beirrg funded based on the federul grun1 criter-iu. VERY NEW PEQPLE CURREiNTLY WALK Oft BI.K.F'. ON 44TH AVENUE. We agree thar ciurifig the lvinter months there are fe}v people walkirrg or bicycli,ig on 44t'' Avenue. HaweveY, there hrrve been several requests from the ' Central Valley Scheol Dislrrct to provide a safe, hard-surfaced palh for Informational Ivleino March 21, 2007 44"' Avenue Pathway Project - February 28, 2007 Open HousE Page 3 ~ . - walking sludents. As the weather ivar»is up more chilciren und aclults tivill be tivalking or bikrr:g ulong 44`h Avenue as eviderrced hy the existink drrt puth currently on the rrvrth sicle. We also believe that if a pathway wer e constr•ucted, even more folks ivould use it. As a side note, each time staff visitecl the siie, pedestrians and bicyclists tivere observed along 44'~ Avenue. tiVe ulso understand the Uriiversiry Higii School cross-country teain (boys and gir•!s) uses this area as part of their trurnrng route. PL"OPIdF 1VALKING ALONG 44'C}-I AV_"NUh HAV-E GREATED THEIR OWN ll1RT E'A7'1-IWAY. The exiscing dirt pathtivrry is not corrsiderecl a sufe walking environment for students. Irr rnany pluces ihis dirt pathwcry is inadequale tivilh lurge partions rrot having enough rooin, thus forcing pedestrians and bicyclisls vul onto the existing nar-row roadway. Also, the dirt pathwuy only exisFs on a very short , section nf 44'i' A venue ftom Schafer Road tv University Road. A SECO\iDr1RY ACCESS l'0 `I'I•IF PpNDEROSA SHOULD BE A HIGrfER I'ItlOltl"CY. We ugree that access to and fronr tlre Porxderosa neighborhood is an irnpor'lunt i_ssue. flowever, the propnsed pathtivuy project untl tlze grant ftinding assaciated with it have no relationship to Pondervsu'.5 UCC8.5'S 1SSUes. The federal enhartcenrenr grant that ficnds the puthtivay project foctises ori projecla• such as developing facilities far peclestriurrs and hicycles, acquisition of scenic easemenl.s ancl .scenic or Izistoric sites, scenic vr 62istoric higynvuy pro,grams, landscaping and other scenic beuutifccation, and preservatiorr af uhuncloned raillvay corridors. `VHO WILL MA[NTAIN THL•' Pr1Tl-IWAY fN TERMS OF SNOW AND DEBEt[S REIv10VAL? It is not ihe intent of thisproject to creute u respon.srbility to udjoining property awnet-s for snow and/or debris re»ipval un the puthwuy. At this time ' tlre Ciry tloes jiot propose to remove snow vr debris ftonn the puthlvuy. However, thi.s ia'sue us it relutes to sidelvalks is currenlly uncler corisiderution 6y Council and legal staff. HOw Wl(,I.. THE CURRENT DftACNIAGE ISSIJES F3F ADDRESSBD ALONG THE PATHWAY? SIciff will look at the drairzage issue as purt nf the puthway design process. The pathlajay will be designed to mirrintiae impacts tn existing,features as much asPo.ssible. Son:e niodifrcations of existirrg cirairaage facilities tivithin the public right-of-wuy will be required. 1S THTS PROJECT BEHNG D0iNE 7'O E\`NANCE TNE YO\zDEROSA PUD DEVGLOPA9E\''I' TO TI-[E WEST7 The Ciry's prapasetl pathway project has no relationship iwith arry developn7ent.s existing orpropvsed in Ifre Ponderosa at-ea. 7he Czry's proposed pathivay and tlte putlrtivuy requu•ed us a condition of the Pvnderosu PUU project sirnply recogriizes the need for the development af saf~ tivulk:ing and biking facilities for .students and other residents of the Ponderosu rreighborhood. 1nFormational Memo March 21, 2007 44`t' Avenue Path4vay Pro.ject - February 28, 2007 Opcn House . Page 4 It seemed the majority of concerns were expressed hy folks living adjacent to the proposed pathway. I-lowever, there was also soine support for the pathway by a few of the residcnts adjacent to the proposed pathway. FtccommendaYions We proposc to continue developing plans for the pathway bascd on many of the comments received at the Open House. We also proposc to dcvclop a seeoncl alternative dcsien to accommodatc bicyclists and pedcstrians along 40' Avenue. We will also dcvc_lop a postcard survey of thc Pondcrosa residcnts to measure the amount nf support for lhis pr4ject. A sccond Open House will be scheduled mid to latc April lo present the two alternatives and bathcr fiirther comments. Staff will then provide a suiiimary of i.he project to Council at a Shidy Session, whieh will include a discussion on whether or not to proceed with the project. *We anliciPate the nexC oppnr[unity td apply .f.or federal fund'ui; for thc consiruciion phase of tlus project w-ill be in vlay, 2007. 't ~ • ~ kr\N i9307 EASY CATAlDO SPOKAkE VALLEY, NJA 99016 - f5091228-5400 . CEiNT[tALUALLEY • SCMOOL OISTRICT 135E sooz 9 'f Nnr June7, 2006 Neil Kersten • City of Spokane Valley 11707 East Sprague, Suite 106 Spokane Valley, WA 99206 Dear Neil: ' - Thank you for your April 18 e-mail seelcing mare information about Centraf Valley School Distdct's postura ooncernlnq additional housing in the Ponderosa area. We wyelcome the chance to vrork with the city in wJnatevzr ways are appropriate to be sure that students who may reside in this housing~are safe as they ' travel to and from school. . . I have spoken vrith Gharlie Hollen, the school districYs Safety Resource Offccer, about student travel to and from the proposed neighborhood. Qur first concern is that students walking to and frqm Ponderosp Elementary have a safe route of travel. Enclosed as Attachment A is a map shavving the one-mile vrafk radius from Ponderosa Elementary. We do ~ y not offier 6us stops for regular elementary students who live within one radius mile af their school. We expect that many elementary scF►ool students res9ding vuithin the newfy proposed Ponderasa development will walk to Ponderosa ElEmentary. , A second concern is that students being bused firorri the new devefopment, primarily to Honzon Middle • School and to University High School, have a safe place to baard the school bus. We understand that roadways within the Proposed development will be private. If that is the case, we vriU be unable to operate schoof buses within boundaries of the new neighborhood. We envision a bus stop on tfie nearest public roadaray = 4e Avenue - to serve bused students. We ask that a tumout be provided for tfiis stop to improve ' safety of boarding students and so that the buses witl hot impede trafFic when loading or unloading. Both topics, w9lkvrays and bus traffic, have been 'addr€ssed on foUr accastons, starting in July 2004, via correspondence to the ciEy. Copies of this correspondence are enclosed as Attachment B. Yaur April 18 e-mail menUons the Federal Transportation Enhancement Grant for design of a pathway along . 40 Avenue. VUe expect that this path vri(I improve safety for walking studerits. We weicome ttte opportunity to communicate with your staff in dssign of this vralkway. Please aontact me when discussian abput this project, or about additional grant funding, is appropriate. Sincerely, • . , Dave Jadcman Director, Atailiary Services . Enclosure . ~ 1 - , . Ciiy af Spokefte VNley - PorudErosa . ~ Attachment A ; ~ ' ~`r'S ~1st ~ • I s- st `111-~ Ponderosa Zoo, , /I~~~nd~er ~a=r-t~e:~- 5::~ L n3rdi . • , . . ~ . . ~ . 35th 36tn "I - ~ ~ m ' . J~ . - • ~ ~ ~ t at a ~ . . . . . , ; _ £ .f ~ ~ . - . , . . . . . . ~ ' c - - ' • ~ . ' ra ~ oi",~ ki[ . • ' `•a:: _`'"f y . . . , 42~ • / ~",I.y 1` r d ~ Q:' / ~ 2 d 4~' ~ t\~ 3 .431 . , . .~s~ ~ ~ ^ .~t:t.; ~ ~ ~r s~aw. ~ ~ 44,dea: ~:-~~:s•r • f • . . • . • _ _ • ' . +1~~U ~ . '`~~1•~ Ki,.~;~- .!~'=*yhs'~' ~'.t3~: 4: s ~ . . • t~ _ . . • . . . ~ . . .Ci • , a~ - :.y:•~ • i . , • : , _ • . . ~I00 4 W .F jj • • ' . „~r ~;1 -y t~''~:~' , , `_m~ ~ ' ~ „ •Ta., ~ ~t.. , . , , . , , • . t~..~. ~.~~t~ a,~a? • . ~ cc ~.:0 ~ ' , ..~1 ` . . +~n~;~ ' • ' - . ' : , : ' • ' ' . . 1j% :f , ,1~' . . , , • . . ~ : 1 z-.i„~.: :.y:~~~~ ~~T.' •i. . . U - ' • • - ~ ' ~(Y• ~ • ~ ~ • • st • .i.. ~ :~Ri~' .~~'t~`~' ~ : ~ . • '~•J,•;+•. :1 . . , . . . . ~ 'i- . ~C~... _ a • :iy~y . ~,c`. . ' ••~Q~.~„~~.~1~` • • . , I~,•'• .r.~~ 4~~ti.W =i^iHf~= . .,or: ~ . . - . ~ . . . n • ; ~ ~'s~~'''~~t~ ~ Y ~ ' ' ' • • ' ' ~ rJ . ' • . , . ~ • ,•~ri.r:~. li~$}ii~}~ , . _ . . . „ . - • • - ~ . ~ ,Gb`~~'.r - ' • . ~ . ~ ~ . ~ r . . ' . ' ~ ' ~ ' i ~ • ,"J.3:'!. . . ' , , ' - . . • . ' ' - . : fti~tL. b• . ' . ' • . ' • • ' . t r ' • ' - . ' .;~li': ~ . ~ ' ~ , • ' ' , • . ~ . , • - ' ' • ' . . . . • i . . • . • , , . . ~ . . • ~ ' . ~ . . . . - ' • ~l ~ • . By ~ i i ~ c , i f ~ p • y 1, , ~ . - Attachment B- ~ , . Ju(y 9, 2004 Micki Harnois, Associata Planner City af Spokane Valley. 11707 E. Sprague - Suite 106 Spokane Valiey, WA 99206 . Dear Ms. Hamois: Central Valley School District i$ aware of the proposed SUB-07-04/PUD 0404 residential development We understand that this development proposes approximately 82 sing(e-family homes on a 16.95 acre site within Central Valley School District. Central Valley School District currently has capacity to senre students expected.to reside within thi's residential development The district would offer school transpartation to grade 6-12 . students from public roadways on the perimeter of the proposed development. Central VclIley School District is interested in this developmenYs impact oh Ponderosa Elementary School. The development is located within the schaoi's walking distance. Our major concems surround pedestrian safery, including: o Sidewalks • Safe student crossings o Traffic control near the elementary school Another matter that shoulii be considered•is vehicle access to Ponderosa Elementary School. .We do not expect that direct access to the school woufd be adversely affected during the construction period. Due to the riumber of new residences proposed, however, we expect that traffic conge,stion on and near the Ponderosa Elementary site will be increa$ed as parents deliver and pick up students. • We note that this checklist appears to address only 16.95 acres, while the proposal states that the development will include 27.70 acres west of the 16.95 acres. Sincerely, Dave Jackman ~ Director, Auxiliary Services . .i SUB-47-04 P~7c1d Hamois ~ I : I . ~ • ~ • 19307 EAST CATALDO S?OKANE VAlIcY, WA 99016 ` - - (509) 228-5400 CENTRALUALLEY sedooto1srnlcirIse r.i August 18, 2004 ~•r 0 Micki Harnois, Associate Planner City of Spokane Valiey 11707 E. Sprague, Suite 106 , Spokane, Valiey, WA 99206 Subject: Comment: SUB-07-04-04lPUD 04-04 Dear Ms. Hamois: , Thank you for allowing Central Valley School District 4356 (the °District") to comment on the above application. We have reviewed the proposed Ponderosa PUD and have the following comments: 1. Authoritv to Impose Mitiqation Measures There are two bases for the District's review of impacts created by the proposed Ponderosa PUD: The State Environmental Policy Act (°SEPA°) requires that any impacts upon schools be reviewed to determine whether those impacts rise to the level of a probably significant adverse impact. Under SEPA, any signific~ant impacts to the District created by the Development must be mitigated in orderfor the City of Spokane Valley (City) to issue a Mitigated Determination of Non-Significanoe. The sevond basis for imposition of conditions to mitigate the significant impacts to the District is the State Subdivision Act. In RCW 58.17.110 the Act states: (2) A proposed subdivision and dedication shall not be approved unless the city, town, or c4unty legislative body makes awritten findings that: (a)-Appropriate provisions are made for the public health, safety, and general welfare and for... schaols and school grounds and all other retevant facts, including sidewafks and other planning features tfiat assure safe walking conditions for students vrho only v,ralk to and from school; and (b) the public use and interest will be served by the platting of such subdivision and dedicatfon. Wit finds that the proposed subdivision and dedication make such appropriate provisions and that the public user and interest will be senred, then the _ legislative body shall approve the proposed subdivision and dedication. Vl/ithout findings of fact and mitigatng conditions either under SEPA or as a cortdition of plat approval providing for mitigation of the impacts, the Gity cannot make a determination fhat the probably significant adverse impacts to the District have been adequately mitigated or make the required findings under the Subdivision Act that appropriate provisions for schools and student safety have - ~ been made. . r- . Ftnal M_Hamois 5UB-07-04- PUD 04-04 . • . 8oth of these statutory provisions are supported by policies and goals sQt forth in the Spokane CouMy Comprehensive Plan. Specifically, the Comprzhensive Plan provides: Chapter 2- Urban Land Use: Streets, pedestrian paths and bike paths should rontribute tv a system of fully connected routes. UL2.14 - Separated sidewalks shail be required on public roads in all new residential subdivision. UL7.11 - Establish zoning and subdivision regulations that require residential developments to provide the following improvements: a) Paved streets (and al{eys if appropriate,) curbs, and sidewalks, paths and intemal walkways, when appropriate. c) Street lighting ' Consistent with the Growth Management Act, intzrpretation of the county's development regulations must be consistent wit'ti the above-identified poficies and goals which provide a basis for imposi►ion of mitigation of identified impacts. II. Impacts and Proposed Mitiqation This proposal falls within the Ponderosa Elementary School, Horizon Middle School and University High School attendance boundaries. The District anticipates fhat it will be able to house students ' residing within the proposed development. Based upon the City's and County's stated policles and goals under their respective Comprehensive _ Plans, the requirements under SEPA and the State Subdivision Act, the District requests the folfowing measures to promote safety of students walking or befng transported betwesn Ponderosa PUD and public schools. o Sidewalks be provided along traffic lanes within the proposed development. The sidewalks will provide for the safety of students walking to school or waiting for the school bus. • Hard surfaced area be provided at the parameter of the development to serve as off-street waifing area for students waiting to board a school bus. • That area- lights be provided at areas designated by the district as potential school bus stops. e Assuming that roadways within the proposed development are to be private, that school buses have adequate roadway width andJor tuming radii to safely serve students living in this development from public streets at the parameter of the deveEopment. . Please provide the District with a copy of the City's proposed determination under SEPA as well as a copy of the Staff Report in advance of a public hearing scheduled for this Development. If you have questions, please contact me. Sincerely, D ve ac a Directo~, Auxili Services . Final Nf.Hatno(s SU&07-04- PUD 04-04 ~ ~ . , • ' ~!•a~ ~ri Ij'f~l~ . ~ C BS . ` kfN,\, 19307 @A5T CATALOO SPOKAh1E VALLEY, VJA 99016 (so9) us-saoo cENITRALuALLEY scNOnloisrucTUlse June 13, 2005 Micki Harnois City of Spokane Valley . ' 11707 East Sprague Suite 106 ' Spokane, Valley, WA 99206 Dear Ms. Hamois: On August 18, 2004, I offered comrnents in behalf of Central Valley School District concerning Ponderosa PUD. ~ ' My August 18 letter failed to specifically mention the school distri cYs conoern for safety of students walking along 44'h Avenue betnreen Woodruff Read and the Ponderosa PUD (now known as Ponderosa Ridge) on their way to and from Ponderosa Elementary School. Central Valley Schoai District requests that the city consider either a curbed sidewalk or -a hard-surfaced walking path along 40 Avenue befinreen Woodruff Road and the Ponderosa Ridge development as a condition of approval of tfiat portion of Ponderosa Ridge lying within the City of Spokane Valley. Sincerely, ave ck n Dire or, Aux 'ary Services ` - CiEy oi Spokano Valley, A9ic9ci Hemols 06-O5 > > ' ' 19307 EAST CATkLDO / SPOKANE VALLEY, WA 99016 (509) 228-5400 GENTRAL VALLEY scxooL oissaicruse I ~ I March 29, 2006 Neil Kersten Director, Public Works . City of Spokafle Valley ~ • 11707' East Sprague Suite 106 Spokane, Valley, WA 99206 Re: Ponderasa Area Housing Proposais Dear Mr. Kersten: • ' For several months, Central Vailey School District has followed proRosals for addifional housing in the Ponderosa area. We have previously corresponded oonceming safety for elementary students walking to and from school within the Ponderosa neighborhood. We have also asked tfiat . provision be made for safe'waiting and bus boarding for secondary students who would be bussed to schools in other areas of the district. In addition to these conoems, Central Valley School District urges the City of Spokane Valley to evaluate adequacy of Ponderosa area raadways for ingress, egress and traffic associated with Ponderosa Elementary School when cansidering additional housing in the Ponderosa neighbofiood. . Sincerely, Dave ackma Dire tor, Auxil ary Services / - Gity of Spotcane Valtey - Roadways - Ponderosa ' ~ Map 3.2 4 Bike and Pedestrian System . r ~ ' I_ . ~ ~ , r«, . • - ~p- a': " .,'r ~ Y f1M~~1• Y i~ ' - ~t ^ -i ` ~ ~\11r~.4.{., i1..L~1 ~ ~.e.~J .__~•v. ~ J'~ y;' - / t.ege„d ~ i1e. ~ ^ _~c'"~~'„~r ~ ~ - •IMM, ftul ~ I k~~:wnp Eli►r Lu.xs : I rmt,v.aa sihe Lbnet r__L_ ~ . rw. Z" _ --.T k 'u.i~..a'~ PrA '•l ~ l - - i ws"+'~~ 4wra! Ur PMb , r Ou r J , ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ _ ~ T ►~..t.. - - r.n ; ~ - ! ~:s~ie~ PcdestrInn Pah MM Nl+..n ' - \ 1 , _ _ . T~..,,, -~':L. 'r.n• ; ~ \ r ~f i~ _ c'~ 'ut i`°~r~far~r.,i, ~ 7 t, .4i Hra i rr f ~ _ _ : ll~~ _ : y ~ . ~ ~ ~ I -s~- Uk! }i~ ~.~'.,P■,c u~,J. • _ • ; ' ~ - r '_'_~s~ l ~ . , Intmepc - . ~i. • 90 - - i. ' " ~''i' _ ~ _ ^ ,,r.~ • _ 5` ~ , ~ ..;......7»..«..tir.,.~...»..• ! I ~ rxhw4 ~ • 'Ir ~ .-IdlSa.DR~L.~ ~ _ : { ~1^V' ~AV(Oi1~ rMt~ Ot6v Muninpnlu;u cty ocspa►wor ~ „1r. W. ~ -s}......~ . ; - y - ~n 3.-_~--~-"'~1 . ~ _ t ! ,L-.. -I";. 's~ a' ~ ~ _ •~l ~ ~ ~!r~naGtuNtlifuca ~ ~ id ~t . "~C_t - ~ ---~-,w~ r~-'~• ~-.y ~ ~ _ - ~ui~ wwuEluesto ~ . - Li j . ' . ~ . . , _ - ~ _ ~ ~ ~ _ ; " ~ • _ 'ir~mrt► r' 41 7 . _..~j~ ..IR=~~'I. ♦ ~ ~ ~V ~ ~`'y _ ~ ~ - • ~ ~ ~...1~..~ ~'~1~. .:.t.. ~ ~i ~ i..'l. l_ ~ l,.ry~ ` • i _ ~ ' . ~ ' 1 . ~M { V . ~ ___T ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~r •~,~-'~r_ ~ ~ ~ ~ n _ ~ a , ~ ~ ~ ~ Iblr 4AIA4 . ~ T'~ _ _1* _ _ ~ ~~i ~l- ~ j ~ iT. Yal ~ - I . , ' ~ .i { ~ ~ ~ A7 ~ry'! I ` ' i~•'1 - i l.r ~ A~~►l W~tM11Wa~1~NN~/MI~i~NCI~~ r ~ , 1 ~qF ~Y A/i}~A K AY~1l1 R~tllwa r1► i. ~I w'-. h~Ar Amm.~ fmur.u~r renrYf.w~y+rrm~tdrI-Iwy]rrr~ eru-~ i . ~yly _ Llrnii~e~AMreaL~'+w.I/9~+a..~d9iV.•!~ SpaKEsMuNREVIIEw.cow Pathway planned Ponderosa residents voicc concerns ovcr proposc~tl traii Valcric Putnam Patha•ay dcsign CuRCSpondent March 3, 2007 "Me city plans to post dic tinal pathwuy design on its V~'eb sitc, Safery, draicage, trail maintenance and landscape integrity were aftec it is c~mpleceti, at sume of the concerns voiccd Wednesday by residcnts during an NvN,.W=5P_o "nevalley.org. If informal npen housc at t'onderasa Elcmcntary. , anyonc has any questions or ' conc-erns call Stevc Stamatoplo5 Thc city of Spokane Vallcy is proposing a community pathway on at 688-0022 or c-mail 44t1 AYenue from Woodruffto qinds rnad,;, qlilff:llllj C'itv Cntincil t.rTi,~;'~i~}`"~j.:,~;`,} •~~~r1 ~r • members presented canceptual _ ,lbout 40 residents showed up. , 1 wOUId he 3rfo(loTlc!1' It II 11:11~ }oRlcrkSi'. n_-t'.'t'fli ~;1Ct~ll.• ~~I Ily; i';' ~ i.. i'• I I: .i , CILhCT Slu_ . ' subdivision wcst of Waodruff. The propuscd trail would be a!0-foot-wide a.5phalt path and more tlian a mile lunb un llie nurth sidc 44U1. 'MC CIIPT':`1`.t r!::n fr:i!ur~;ti t{1C (';i?)t IIIz-;?lldt fl(1S* (l1?vIlLfl Iflc !1c'i'ti ;lF?d tcrr;mn t}tc n3thr , I.iberty nltwon'tbc.11]`icl IL: I, li.~ ~t .iJ. ter.hnician. "CJur goa) is to savc ns many of the trees as possiblc.' "It would be a rea) shame to ruin the integrity of the way it flows nox. .'Aonderosa nsidcnt said. "I dai't believe it will have the samc rural Ceel "We are in despcrate need far an envance and exit in the Ponderasa arc.:, Ponderosa resident since 1974. "We shuuld be focusing on that which is a repl safety issue i , rathcr than the puthway." Stiltncr, along with cither residents, also questions the rationalc behind the pathway along 44th. In their opinion. Schafer road is the hcavier pedesvian traffic area. "Wc erttlly need a pathway for safety concerns cqiming do%Nri tr+lm thc 5chuul tti Schafcr." Stiltner tiaid. "Therc is no whcrti far the kids to safely walk." The Public Works Dcpartment identified 44th Avenue as having same contiguration issues along the I roadway to hinder safery for pedestnans. Tlie safeiy issues matched the critena for a grant offered by the redernl Highways Association tlu-ough the 'Cransportation F?.quity Act in 2005. ; The ciCy received a$16,500 grant in 2006 to cover the design phase of tlle project. Before drawing preliminary conceptual plans, the city hire.d David Evans and Associates to do a topographical and right- of-way survey. The city received its survey findings in January. "The big concem is proximity of pedestrians to vehicle traffic," Slamatoplos said. "Schafer has an established wide shoulder on both sides of the ro3d that can be used right now. Fourty-founh has it in places but in other places there is literally no shoulder on the roacl." Residents also voiced concern of having the pathway cross ai the corner vf 44th and Schafer, a thrce- way stop. "They need to fir 44th and Schafer with a linht or sornethinj ~~isttal," said Diane Gross, who lives on the east corner of 44th 1nd Schafer. "I've seen a number of penple run it. They don't cvcn stop, and thars not safe for the kids walkinc." lsermanent wa.rning signs and stripinj at each intersectian is planned and possible at every driveway where line of sight is an issue. "Our intent is not to create a situation where il's unsafe for kids," said Steve Worley, city senior engineer. "We want to create a sitiiation thaYs safe. If ihere was any indication that this was going to create a dangerous situation, we wouldn't do it." Snme 44th Avenue residents report flooding as already an issue for their yards and driveway and are conccrned with how the city will alleviate the water when the pathway goes over some drain fields. "We do recognize that is an issue here and we need to fgure out how we can accommodate that," Worley said. The propercy owners who live along 44th Avenue asked for clear guiclelines as to who is responsible for snow removal, and general upkeep of the pathway. "It is not our intent on this project ro make it the homeowner's responsibi lity." Worley said. "There is no regulation at this point in time that says anyone is responsible," Stamatoplos said. "We have a need to ha<<e a poliey citywide ancl thc council has begun to look at that situation. "I"hey saw it (this pathway) for the first time in an informacional briefinc durinL last night's city council meeting." The next step is design. Armed with concerns from the neighborhood, a final clesign should be completed to meet the early May deadline for the C'ederal I-lighways Administration grant to cover the construction phase. The estimated construction value is $222;500. If the city can't secure federal funding, it wil) need to laak for alternate funding sources. "What funds we receivc will shape what the final project is going to look like," Stamatoplos said. (-~l After funding, the projecl goes out to bid with an estimated completion date of summer 2008. "If there; was a huge opinion in the Ponderosa neighbnrhood that• said they don't want it," Worley said. "Then we're not going to foree it on anybody." SCpokane : - . Valley~ 11707 E Sprague Ave Suite 106 ♦ Spokane Valley WA 99206 509.921.1000 ♦ Fax: 509.921.1008 ♦ cityhall@spokanevalley.org ~ _ . . . . . . - . • , . . . • ~ wELcoME TO 44TH AVENUE PATHWAY PROJIECT OPEN HOUSE Fehruary 28, 2007 '1`he City of Spokane Valley would like to thaiilc you for your interesf in this project. `C'his Open House is intended to inform citizens about the 44th Avenue Pathway Project and provide a sctting wliere questions and concerns can be adclressed. Please review the exhibits and the information below. City Staff are hcrc to try to answer any additional questions you may have. Should you thinl: of mare questions aftcr this Upen riouse, we have provided at the end of tllis document a City Staff contact witli e-mail address ajld phone numbcr for your r.eference. COM.NION QUTSTTpNS AND COVCERNS What docs the nroject consist of? The proposecl projcet is to construct a 10-f.oot-wide asphalt shared-usc pathway along the north side of 44th AvenuE from Woodruff Road to Sands R.oad. The paehway will be dcsigncd to nunimi~.e impacts to the adjaccnt properties and save as mwly krees as possible. Why is this pathway being proposcd on the North side of 44th Avenue? ' The north side of 44th was chosen becausc, in gcneral, there is inore public R.ight-of way available and fewer existing improvements to accouunodate than on the south side. There is also a fairly well definecl dirt pathway currently in use on die nort11 side. Will there be Right-nf-Way acquisitions? The City does not anticipate the need lo acquire additional TZight-of-way for tliis project. The City inay need temporary construction easemenis in order lo tie the pathway slopes into the adjaccnt properties ul areas requiring cuts or fills. NVhy was Schafer not the site for the proposed pathway? Schafer Road currently has aNvidened asphalt shoulder that can be used by pedestriar►s; 44th Avenue does not. A pathway on 44th Avenue had a better chauce oF being fundecl , based nn t11e Federal graut criteria. ~ ( ~ How will the drainage ditches and other improvement5 alnng the Nc~rth side of 44th - be affected? The pathway will be ciesigned to minimize impacts to existingfeatures as much as possiblc. However, soine modifications within the public Rigtrt-of-way may be needed to construct the pathway. i7ctailS will be worked out as the clESign progresscs, taking uito consideration thc fccdback received from the public. Once constructed, who would be respousible f'or maintaining the pathway? The City will repair any daaiagc to the pathway if rcquired. T.he City does not currently providc snow removal for sideNvalks and pattiways. This issue will be reviewed by Council in the near fiiturc. When will construction of the project begin? The City of Spokane Valley has only received Federal Ptuids for the design phase of this project. Once a design is completcd, an additional grant aPplication will be submitted for construction ftindinj. If tlus applicatiUn is successfiil, Nve anlicipate construetion to begin iu 2008. For questions contact: ~ Steve Stamatoplos 688-0022 sstamatoplosoaspokanevalley.org