2003, 02-11 Regular Meeting Minutes CITY OF SPOKANE VALLEY
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting
February 11, 2003
The regular meeting of the Spokane Valley City Council was called to order by
Mayor Michael DeVleming at 6:02 p.m.
Councilmembers present: Mayor Michael DeVleming, Deputy Mayor Diana Wilhite,
Councilmembers Dick Denenny, Mike Flanigan, Richard Munson, Gary Schimmels, and
Steve Taylor.
Staff present: Interim City Manager Lee Walton, Interim City Attorney Stanley Schwartz,
Interim Finance Director Robert Noack, Interim Planning Director James Harris, Interim
Finance Manager Dan Cenis, Interim City Clerk Ruth Muller, and Interim Administrative
Assistant Karin Bosworth.
Invocation: Pastor Gary Hebden, Valley Open Bible Church, gave the invocation.
Pledge of Allegiance: Mayor DeVleming led the pledge of allegiance.
Roll Call: Interim City Clerk called roll.
Approval of Agenda: Mayor DeVleming asked that Resolution 03-017 be added to the
agenda as Item No. 10.D).2). Interim Attorney Schwartz advised that he has received
information about comments Spokane County staff has relating to the City's stormwater
utility ordinance and requests that Ordinance No. 31-Al be removed from this agenda to give
him time to review the comments.
Deputy Mayor Wilhite moved and Councilmember Flanigan seconded that the Agenda be
approved as amended. The motion carried unanimously.
Public Comments: Tom DeGeare, 2820 South Avalon Road,reported that the name change
poll he is doing is going well. This will give the City a good idea as to what the citizens want.
He invited the Council to attend the sorting and counting of this poll at his home on March 10.
Chuck Sauter, 12013 East Main Avenue, expressed his concern regarding half-way houses,
sex offenders, and drug homes in approximation to City libraries and schools. Interim City
Attorney Stanley Schwartz replied that the Council will soon be reviewing a resolution
establishing procedures for siting essential facilities.
Council Reports: Mayor DeVleming welcomed Boy Scout Troops 405 and 424 in
attendance.
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 1 of 6
Councilmember Munson reported that the Finance Committee met, thoroughly reviewed
claims submitted and approved them for payment, with expenses still well below budget
appropriations.
Consent Agenda: Councilmember Flanigan moved and Councilmember Denenny seconded
that the Consent Agenda be approved as submitted. Mr. Noack added that one invoice from
the consulting firm is currently under discussion, but that it was paid. The motion carried
unanimously approving: (a) Special Meeting minutes from January 16 and 21, 2003; (b)
Regular Meeting minutes from January 28, 2003; and (c) Claims Obligations in the amount of
$117,571.02.
Public Hearing: Spokane Valley Interim Budget
Mayor DeVleming opened the public hearing at 6:10 p.m. for the purpose of receiving public
comment on the proposed Spokane Valley interim budget for period January 1, 2003 through
March 31, 2003.
Interim Finance Director Noack said that this is Spokane Valley's first public hearing and he
is honored to have this opportunity to provide information for public comment on the
proposed budget. Noack summarized the contents of the proposed interim budget, reporting
that to date, the City has expended $474,316.33, which is well under budget, and noting that
the public may obtain copies of this interim budget at City Hall. He thanked the Finance
Committee for their assistance in developing this budget.
There were no comments from the public on the proposed interim budget.
Mayor DeVleming closed the public hearing at 6:30 p.m.
Mayoral Appointments - Lodging Tax Advisory Committee: Mayor DeVleming
announced that he has appointed to the City's Lodging Tax Advisory Committee for a term
expiring December 31, 2003, the following: Liz Beck (Super 8 Motel), Peggy Doering
(Valley Fest), Jayne Singleton (Spokane Valley Legacy Foundation), Jeff Fox (Spokane
Valley Doubletree Hotel), and Councilmember Flanigan. Councilmember Flanigan said that it
is estimated that this tax will bring in $300,000 to $400,000 yearly to be deposited into a
special fund that is administered by this Committee.
Councilmember Munson moved and Councilmember Denenny seconded to confirm the
Mayor's appointments to the Lodging Advisory Committee.
Councilmember Taylor moved and Councilmember Denenny moved to table the motion to
the next appropriate meeting, to allow time for Council briefing on the appointees. The
motion to table carried by majority vote, with six aye votes—Mayor DeVleming,
Deputy Mayor Wilhite, Councilmembers Denenny, Munson, Schimmels, and Taylor; one nay
vote - Councilmember Flanigan.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-036,Adult Entertainment: Interim City Clerk introduced Ordinance
No. 36 by reading the title. Councilmember Taylor moved and Deputy Mayor Wilhite
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 2 of 6
seconded to advance to second reading Ordinance No. 36 Adopting by Reference Chapter
7.80 Entitled "Adult Entertainment Establishments" of the Spokane County Code. Interim
Attorney Schwartz summarized the ordinance noting that it does not regulate zoning.
Schwartz said that he will review a proposed amendment to the County code and report back
to the Council. Responding to Councilmember Munson's question, Schwartz advised that a
moratorium could be imposed on new adult entertainment establishments during this interim
period until incorporation. After the incorporation on March 31, 2003, the moratorium could
be extended for six months while the City's comprehensive plan is in development, and
extended an additional six months if certain criteria are followed. Councilmember Munson
moved and Councilmember Denenny seconded to table this motion until the interim staff has
had time to review the code. The motion carried unanimously.
Penny Lancaster, 14816 East Farwell, said she is pleased that the Council is considering the
County's ordinance. Lancaster reminds the Council of the critical nature of the adult
entertainment ordinances designed to prevent and control health, safety, welfare issues, and
neighborhood conditions around the premises of these establishments. She suggests an
amendment to County Code Section 7.8.100 G—Hours of Operation, to include Adult Retail
Use Establishments, since they are presently exempt and customers are frequenting these
businesses after 2 a.m., often time inebriated.
Kim Arrotta, 18318 East River Way,presented some information to the Council regarding
pornography bookstores. She said she has attended several City of Spokane council meetings
and heard that homeowners near these bookstores are finding adult paraphernalia in their
yards. Arrotta encouraged the Council to weigh the revenue from these establishments and the
fallout that comes from the cost to human lives. She said that the Council should serve and
protect the community, and it is important to remember moral standards as legislation is
considered.
Tom DeGeare, 2820 South Avalon Road, agrees 100%with the previous comments.
The motion to table action on Ordinance No. 36 carried unanimously.
Deputy Mayor Wilhite moved and Councilmember Munson seconded that Staff be directed to
develop a resolution imposing a moratorium on any new adult entertainment establishments
during the interim period before incorporation. The motion carried unanimously.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-037, Planning Commission: Interim City Clerk introduced
Ordinance No. 35 by reading the title. Councilmember Mike Flanigan moved and
Councilmember Munson seconded to advance to second reading Ordinance No. 35 Creating a
Planning Commission and Establishing the Duties Thereof. Interim Attorney Schwartz
summarized provisions of this ordinance. Councilmember Denenny stated that there was
agreement by Council at the study session that we wish to have a broad section of the
community represented on this commission. Deputy Mayor Wilhite added that the terms of
appointment will be staggered initially, then every three years thereafter. The motion to adopt
Ordinance No. 35 carried unanimously.
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 3 of 6
Agenda Bill No. 2003-039,2003 Interim Budget: Interim City Clerk introduced Ordinance
No. 37 by reading the title. Councilmember Munson moved and Deputy Mayor Wilhite
seconded that Ordinance No. 37 Adopting a Budget for the Period January 1, 2003 Through
March 31, 2003; Appropriation of Funds and Establishing Positions and Salary Schedule be
advanced to second reading. Interim Attorney Schwartz summarized the provisions of this
ordinance that appropriates funds generally, as required by law and includes a salary schedule
for interim staff. Interim Finance Director Noack said the budget presented includes one
revision to include Council cellular telephones for contact within the City. Following
discussion on the necessity and advisability for this revision, Interim Attorney Schwartz
suggested that the budget be adopted because state law does allow for adjustment of small
items within funds administratively. He will research this issue and advise staff.
Councilmember Munson withdrew his motion to advance Ordinance No. 37 to second
reading.
Councilmember Flanigan moved and Councilmember Denenny seconded that Council
suspend its rules for two readings of this ordinance, advance to second reading and to adopt
Ordinance No. 37 Adopting a Budget for the Period January 1, 2003 Through March 31,
2003; Appropriation of Funds and Establishing Positions and Salary Schedule.
Councilmember Denenny noted for the record that the $1 million from Spokane County is an
advance of the road tax monies that will be transferred to Spokane Valley upon incorporation.
The motion carried unanimously.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-032,Establish hotel/motel tax: Second reading of Ordinance No. 27
was made by Interim City Clerk. Councilmember Munson moved and Councilmember
Denenny seconded to adopt Ordinance No. 27 Levying a Special Excise Tax of Two Percent
on the Sale or Charge Made for the Furnishing of Lodging by any Hotel, Motel, Rooming
House, Tourist Court, or Trailer Camp; Establishing a Special Fund for the Tax; and
Providing for Other Matters Properly Related Thereto. Interim Attorney Schwartz
highlighted changes made to the ordinance from first reading that clarify provisions for the
Advisory Committee. The motion carried unanimously to adopt Ordinance No. 27.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-033 (Adopt County Road Standards): Second reading of Ordinance
No. 33 was made by Interim City Clerk. Councilmember Flanigan moved and
Councilmember Munson seconded to adopt Ordinance No. 33 Adopting by Reference the
Spokane County Standards for Road and Sewer Construction as the Interim Standards for
Road and Sewer Construction of the City. Interim City Attorney Schwartz explained the
changes to Section 4 that are in accordance with the Council governance manual. The motion
carried unanimously to adopt Ordinance No. 33.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-035, Adopt Stormwater Guidelines: Second reading of Ordinance
No. 32 was made by Interim City Clerk. Councilmember Denenny moved and
Councilmember Munson seconded to adopt Ordinance No. 32 Adopting by Reference the
Spokane County Guidelines for Stormwater Management as the Interim Guidelines for
Stormwater Management of the City. Interim Attorney Schwartz explained that Section 4 of
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 4 of 6
this ordinance was also changed to be in accordance with Council governance manual.
Responding to Councilmember Flanigan's question, Interim Attorney Schwartz said this is an
engineering ordinance rather than a control ordinance. Interim Manager Walton added that
Interim Public Works Director Dick Warren is meeting with County staff and local builders to
address the concerns about restriction on development.
Eleanor Anderson, 2805 South Needham, asked who is in charge. Interim Attorney Schwartz
answered that services will be the same, but the City would be in charge, with a different level
of accountability.
Dick Behm, 3626 South Ridgeview Drive, said he worked on the Stormwater Transition
Team, and the Council is following their recommendations.
Robert McClain, 11931 East Diana Court, asked if this ordinance covers standing water on
the pavement. Councilmember Denenny replied it did not, but that the money collected from
the Stormwater Utility presently goes for monitoring, inventorying, etc. with no capital
projects. The Council will, over time, provide funding for improvements. The motion to
adopt Ordinance No. 32 carried unanimously.
Agenda Bill No. 2003-040, expressing intent relating to fire service. Councilmember
Flanigan moved and Councilmember Denenny seconded that Resolution No. 03-016 be
adopted Stating the Intent of the City to Continue to Receive Fire Protection Services From
Spokane County Fire Protection District Nos. 1, 8 and 9. Interim Attorney Schwartz said that
this resolution gives the fire districts information as to the intent of the City relating to fire
services following incorporation. Deputy Mayor Wilhite asked about annexing into three
different districts and Schwartz indicated that the resolution doesn't address this question, but
he will research this issue. The motion to adopt Resolution 03-016 carried unanimously.
Resolution No. 03-017, Support North-South freeway: Interim Manager Walton
introduced the resolution that is presented for Council action at the request of the Washington
State Department of Transportation (WSDOT). Walton said that information was presented
to the Council at the Feb. 4, 2003 study session on this project by WSDOT, who have
indicated they would like to have support of the various cities involved along the project route
as they prepare to secure funding for the project. Councilmember Munson said that he would
like the Council to carefully look at all requests for City endorsements and be selective about
what is approved. Councilmember Denenny moved and Councilmember Munson seconded to
adopt Resolution No. 03-017 Expressing Support for Ongoing Activities in Connection with a
Multi-Modal, Limited Access, North-South Transportation Corridor.
Tom DeGeare, 2820 North Avalon, inquired if this support includes financial support.
Interim Manager Walton advised that there is no financial support,just a voice of general
support for the project.
The motion to adopt Resolution No. 03-017 carried unanimously.
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 5 of 6
New Business: Interim Attorney Schwartz said that he and attorney Cary Driskell recently
provided a memorandum to the Council summarizing state land use laws that should help
them understand the various ordinances and agreements relating to land use that will be
considered in the next 20-30 days. Interim Manager Walton added that land use documents
will be a subject for discussion at the February 20, 2003 study session, with action on
legislation and public hearings as required scheduled for the March 11, 2003 regular meeting
that will be held at the Community Center.
Interim Manager Walton said that the County Commissioners are interested in scheduling the
next joint meeting, possibly for a breakfast meeting.
Interim Finance Director Noack again thanked the Finance Committee for the careful scrutiny
of the interim budget as it was prepared. The next focus for Finance will be to start
development of the budget for April 1 through December 31, 2003.
New Business: Councilmember Schimmels requested legal comments relating to the County
decision on the Spokane Rock Products project. Councilmembers concurred that the interim
city attorney review and investigate all permits issued or to be issued on this project that may
impact Spokane Valley, and report back to the Council.
Public Comment: Tony Lazanis, 10625 East Trent, said that there is concern about the road
for this project that may not be in compliance with road standards and noise in the
summertime. He requested the Council to take steps to assure protection for the
neighborhood. Interim Attorney Schwartz explained that projects have vested rights under the
laws in existence as of the date they file a complete application, but any future permits are
subject to laws that then apply.
Adjournment: There being no further business, Councilmember Flanigan moved and
Councilmember Taylor seconded that the meeting adjourn. The motion carried unanimously.
The meeting adjourned at 7:40 p.m.
ATTEST: APPROVED:
ciszt
Interim City Clerk Mayor Michael DeVlemi g
kb
Council Minutes from February 11,2003-Approved on February 25,2003 Page 6 of 6