2004, 02-07 Special Retreat MinutesAttendance:
Councilme.mbers
Michael DeVleming, Mayor
Diana Wilhite, Deputy Mayor
Dick Denenny, Councilmember
Mike Flanigan, Councilmember
Rich Munson, Councilmember
Gary Schimmels, Councilmember
Steve Taylor, Councilmember
NOTES
SPECIAL MEETING WORKSWOP /RETREAT
SPOKANE VALLEY CITY COUNCIL
February 7, 2004
9:00 a.m. — 4:00 p.m.
Staff
Dave Mercier, City Manager
Nina Regor, Deputy City Mgr
Marina Sukup, Comm. Dev. Dir.
Ken Thompson, Finance Director.
Cary Driskell, Deputy City Attorney
Neil Kersten, Public Works Director
Mike Jackson, Parks & Recreation Director
Cal Walker, Police Chief
Tom Scholtens, Building Official
Chris Bainbridge, City Clerk
City Manager Mercier gave a brief overview of the purpose of this retreat/planning session, that it is a
time for "big picture viewing," and a time to discuss what Council wants, and how and when they want it
as council and staff discuss the trends that will affect operations for the next several years. In summary,
City Manager Mercier said this will be a brainstorming session in a relaxed atmosphere as council and
staff review the draft materials presented.
1. Review of Departmental Work Plans and Submittal Timetables:
a. Legislative and Executive Support (goals and objectives chart)
City Manager Mercier went over the 2004 Organizational Goals and City Manager Objectives, and stated
that the objectives include some tasks identified to begin to satisfy the goals of the Council; and as
indicated by the YfN, the question to consider is, is that the right objective to achieve the goal? Mr.
Mercier said we want to make sure we know the definition of Managed Competition Program and that we
can do this by checking with other entities to see how they have addressed this issue; that in connection
with the Comprehensive Plan, we need a 20 -year plan to make certain we are well acquainted with and
are meeting the requirements of the Growth Management Plan. Mr, Mercier then discussed the other
goals listed on the handout.
b. Public Works: Work Plan, Capital Projects, Key Decisions and Policy Issues
W astewater Services
Public Works Director Kersten discussed the issue of wastewater management and spoke of Spokane
County's October 14, 2003 letter regarding the development interlocal agreement; adding that it is his
hope that the draft agreement will be ready for council review by early March. Mr. Kersten also stated
that the DOE has committed for a five year NPDES permit, but that not all negotiations with the EPA
have been finalized as the EPA is not comfortable with that direction. Mr. Kersten said the EPA
considers the river a stressed body of water and has concerns with discharging into the river. Director
Kersten said that staff is attempting to schedule a meeting with the EPA to discuss their concerns, one of
which is use and attainability (UAA) concerning the TMDIL analysis. Mayor DeVleming mentioned that
we also want to project when we will run out of capacity so that deadlines can be set prior to that point;
and for staff to alert council as specific issues arise which could cause major problems. Councilmember
Munson suggested gathering more information from other jurisdictions, and obtaining alternate plans in
case what we have won't meet EPA or other mandated requirements.
Notes, February 7, 2004 Council Retreat Page 1 of 4
County En ineerin Contract
Discussion turned to the County Engineering Contract, and Director Kersten said the County provides
additional engineering services to the City of Spokane Valley, and that any changes to this document
should be accomplished by June 1, adding that he does not anticipate any further changes at this point.
Develop Six -Year Street Funding Plan
Director Kersten said that staff will be gathering data to project total costs and are working on getting the
historical numbers in order to fully understand the maintenance cost including preservation projects for
maintaining neighborhood streets. A goal is to determine cost in order to fully fund the streets, including
maintenance and capital projects, and that pavement management is also a part of that six -year plan.
Update Six Year Transportation Plan
Staff is working to bring a draft plan to council for approval consideration, which plan will include a
three -year list of projects to be funded. Director Kersten also reviewed the list of projects and activities to
be working on this year.
A question arose concerning the corridor right -of -way and Director Kersten said that staff is drafting a
letter for Council to send to the County Commissioners that address the right -of -way issue. Council then
turned their attention to the vision statement and upcoming meeting(s) with the Planning Commission. It
was determined that two groups will meet: one group will focus on the vision process for the couplet, and
the other group on the vision of the entire City. Mayor DeVleming suggested forming questions for the
survey and to get Council and the Planning Commission together perhaps on the 23 to discuss the
responses. After Director Kersten went over his remaining work plan, the group took a break at 10:45
a.m., and reconvened at 11:00 a.m.
c. Planning and Community Development.
Develop First Comprehensive Plan
Community Development Director Sukup reported that the development regulations will probably not be
quite as "on- target" as other tasks, adding that upcoming issues such as sidewalks are complex.
Councilmember Denenny said he would like to look at other communities' processes used to identify
areas of problems /challenges in an effort to help avoid those legal challenges, and to determine best
practices. City Manager Mercier added that Deputy Attorney Driskell has been looking at what
procedural problems arise as a result of the processes applied, and Director Sukup said that the Comp plan
involves various other City departments as well as outside agencies, and the concern is to make sure the
implementation regulations follow the comp plan; she also stated we need a draft of the plan before we
can decide the direction to proceed.
Improve Overall Communication
Director Sukup mentioned staff will be continuously working to improve established ordinances.
Councilmember Flanigan mentioned he would like to see in print, what we can do as a city and as a
region, to identify the tools available to accomplish what we want to accomplish, and to do that he feels
we need more specific definition of "economic development." Mayor DeVleming; added that he would
like to see what other communities in the state are doing in this regard, and then asked about the schedule
to implement public participation. Director Sukup said we will start meeting with identifiable
neighborhoods and the business community and if changes are made to the sign regulations, there will be
additional public input. Director Sukup mentioned that staff will start going out to meet some of these
civil /social groups beginning the end of the month in an attempt to get invited to their meetings also.
Mayor DeVleming added that he wants to expand council information by seeking input from fellow
councilmembers, City Manager, and Department Heads. Ms. Sukup mentioned staff will also be
conducting a citizen survey to help determine what information we need from the community. She also
asked council to send topics to her concerning areas where they want the community to give us answers,
Notes, Fcbrunry 7, 2004 Council Retreat Page 2 of 4
perhaps via a 10 -12 minute telephone survey. Councilmember Munson said that he will contact the Valley
Rotary Clubs to see if they are amenable to having Director Sukup and /or other staff discuss issues with
them.
Cross - Training: Director Sukup said staff will engage in cross training to ensure code enforcement
officers can assist in residential family code compliance. Building Official Scholtens said he spoke with
the electrical division of Labor and Industries and told them the amount of work is more than one person
could adequately handle but not enough work for two to handle; and that he feels it would be inefficient
for the City to take over the electrical program. Mr. Scholtens speculated about the possibilities of
issuing permits at our center by stationing one L &I employee in our office as we currently do with the fire
inspector, to service our customers by selling permits and to have someone in the office at a particular
time to answer questions. In response to a question about sewer permits, Mr. Scholtens said the County
handles sewer permits and there is no evidence of cooperation from the County; that the County does the
inspection up to the house, and we take the backflow valve and sewer reversal inspections, and that the
public is not happy having to go to both places. City Manager Mercier said if Council wants staff to
explore the possibility of handling sewer permits, perhaps we can extend an offer to the County that we
can extend office space and perhaps use the fire marshal space when not in use.
d. Parks and Recreation
Parks and Recreation Director Jackson said that staff hopes to have an RFQ to submit in a few weeks
regarding the Masterplan. Additionally, Director Jackson said that he hopes to get council direction on
summer programming as staff needs to start reserving space in some of the schools; that his proposal is
similar to last year but hopes to increase participation to make it economically feasible to contract with a
private bus rather than use a van; and that day camps will likely increase from 17 to about 40 participants.
in reference to sport events, Director Jackson said staff has started inventory, and it could be argued that
entities in town could cover privately what we have offered; that he could try to direct interested patrons
to others who have the service, or we could offer it ourselves, like summer camps. He said all programs
for camps are contracted, and that there is no difficulty in cost recovery for direct costs. City Manager
Mercier said that last year's direction was to expand pool use/hours and that was implemented; there were
ancillary programs started last summer and as we move forward, we seek to identify the core functions in
terms of overall recreation programs in the community; that he's noticed a large amount of adult and
youth programs available; and if those services are being offered in the community there is not
necessarily a gap to fill; so the question remains how do we engage in this process without: running afoul
of the private sector. Director Jackson said he needs to try to inventory all the extra circulator activities in
the community so we can give council information to make decisions about creating programs to meet
community needs and wants. Council agreed that Jackson should continue to gather information and
work on the master plan. Director Jackson said he feels that over 90% of the program direct costs were
recovered last year, except for the playground program which had no fee; and the pools did not fully
recover all costs, which was expected. Concerning cost of programs, scholarships were mentioned and an
idea was presented concerning giving social service organizations scholarships. Director Jackson also
said he seeks one or two councilmembers to be on the Senior Center Committee and Mayor DeVleming
asked councilmembers to let Director Jackson know of their interest. Councilmember Schimmels
indicated his interest as did Councilmember Munson, and Councilmember Munson added that if only one
councilmember is needed, that he need not participate.
e. Police Department
Police Chief Walker explained his department's work plan and discussed cost effectiveness and cost
allocation in relation to the contract, and stated he expects approximately $20,000 to be credited back to
the Police Department. Chief Walker said that the police department is getting a better handle on the
defined partnership with the county, that we identified some things that needed to happen but did not, and
that the County finalizes their budget very late in the process and he's working on how to fix some of
Notes February 7, 2004 Council Retreat Page 3 ot4
those things to get better at projecting budget for future years. Chief Walker said he wants to continue
looking at how other agencies develop their contracts and wants to spend more time putting man hours
into viable public safety issues instead of so much time into the actual contracts. City Manager Mercier
added that the City will maintain service levels equal to that in the unincorporated territory, but there is no
baseline data of service level, so the overall challenge is to define the service level in this and other areas.
Chief Walker said the number of officers per thousand population is not the driving force into bringing a
number recognized as an acceptable level; that staff did an analysis of how many people it would take to
bring us up to that acceptable level and that there is no way to measure that. Chief Walker explained that
the department tracks business on reports generated. He stated he is working on those statistics to report
type of call, area of call, and how long it took officers to arrive on the scene, and then to compile all those
pieces of data into some reasonable way to measure the level of service. City Manager Mercier said we
continue to operate in a data vacuum, making it difficult to accurately measure level of service.
A break was taken at 2: 15 p.m.; the meeting reconvened at 2:30 p.m.
f Operations and Administrative Services
Deputy City Manager Regor discussed the work plan and said staff is experimenting with a managed
competition program and hopes to present a draft program to Council in April. Program areas mentioned
to consider included the library, animal control, roads, parks, municipal court, and the jail.
Councilmember Munson said he feels we have not done well in getting the word out about who we are
and what our philosophy is, and that he hopes to be able to develop a community outreach program to
give media news releases. Ms. Regor said staff is using more of a reactive approach to media public
relations. City Manager Mercier said the media is adept at discerning issues of greater concern, and it
night be more effective to continue to have good notice of items that will be discussed by council; that
council does speak with the public as in the "conversations with the community," but that perhaps we
should look at having a regular featured article where council can address certain issues; or have council
volunteer spots in film media or other ways for council to reach out to media to inform them of upcoming
issues. Mr. Mercier added that newsletters are generally more expensive and have little impact; but that
perhaps Council could consider a column letter in the newspapers; and that all can spend some time
thinking about venues where council can go out and offer to be the noontime speaker. Mr. Mercier said
that part of the reason for the advance agenda is to inform the media of upcoming issues. The paperless
agenda option was mentioned but greeted with little enthusiasm, as many councilmembers prefer to have
paper copies upon which to make comments.
g. Finance /Budget Related issues
Finance Director Thompson discussed the draft five -year financial forecast as shown on his outline, and
said staff keeps track of all programs and how they interrelate to help determine if there is need for other
programs. Director Thompson then discussed the actual sales tax versus the estimated sales tax, the street
funds, general funds, smaller funds and projections, bonding limitations, and the five -year projected
shortfall summary. City Manager Mercier added that there is a vast amount of expense associated with
contract services, and perhaps alternate providers and /or other options could be explored. Finance
Director Thompson then briefly discussed the 2005 budget calendar.
As it was nearing 4:00 p.m., it was decided that items not covered in today's discussion (Facilities and
Contracts, and Community Involvement & Outreach) could be discussed either in study sessions or at
another retreat.
The meeting adjourned at 4:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted
Chris Bainbridge, City Clerk
Notes, February 7, 2004 Council Retreat Page 4 of 4